You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Captain?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 11 Mar 19 1.16am

Well Casual, how can you come up with such a ridiculous post to start with?
Beyond me! And I am more than happy with our present captain any given matchday!

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Mar 19 6.15am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Well Casual, how can you come up with such a ridiculous post to start with?
Beyond me! And I am more than happy with our present captain any given matchday!


Don’t mind him as a player, but we lacked guts on Saturday and he just let the game and occasasion pass him by. Needed someone to sort everyone out and he never.

 

Master Coin Flag 11 Mar 19 10.02am

Originally posted by Casual

Is he. When he took a corner did he get the ball and raise his hands up to get the Palace fans going ? Did he f*ck.
he put his head down, no interaction with the fans and chipped in a corner with back spin aiming at no one..
He’s good enough to be in the eleven , never a leader.

This is a poorly executed screengrab of Luka geeing up the fans after his penalty. Since you seem to insist he plays cheerleader as well as leading by example and showing passion (which he clearly does). Not only am I seething at the nonsense in this thread you’ve now made we have to go back through “highlights” to illustrate a point.

6396B621-9056-41BE-A97D-8F61D574EBB4.png Attachment: 6396B621-9056-41BE-A97D-8F61D574EBB4.png (10,579.23Kb)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Mar 19 10.21am

Have to say that Luka is one of my favourite players atm. I thought he has proved such a coup since he came here.

He's a 6"+ serbian, playing holding midefield, he's a technically good player, can read the game well and of course he can take a penalty and score on top of that. I don't have any concerns about him as a player apart from his set pieces being poor this season (I'm sure he can do better) and earlier on in the season where he kept getting caught in possession, often leading to goal scoring opportunities if not goals (he seems to have become more aware of that and it has become a rarity).

I was happy when he was named captain, I think he leads by example and is probably our most intelligent footballer.However I honestly think Luka is a very likeable player and that is not what we needed on Saturday and I think what some people are getting at here.

You need someone who's a bit of a cvnt sometimes: who opposition fans hate, who hits players hard and sometimes dirtily, hassles the referee, winds up the opposition and who screams at team-mates, not Luka's style at all. I've always hated the 'he'll f@€king murder ya' chant, simply because it doesn't fit!

We could either have a captain like Luka, or a cvnt captain in the mould of Keane, Deeney or someone like that. Either of those types can play captain, just some days suit them better than others.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Loz83 Flag Crawley 11 Mar 19 10.23am

The only criticism of this team is they can be a bit nice, a lot of other teams leave a foot in, time waste and look aggressive and manage to get away with it so why don’t we? Luka is a decent captain but we could do better.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Mar 19 10.57am

Originally posted by Master Coin

This is a poorly executed screengrab of Luka geeing up the fans after his penalty. Since you seem to insist he plays cheerleader as well as leading by example and showing passion (which he clearly does). Not only am I seething at the nonsense in this thread you’ve now made we have to go back through “highlights” to illustrate a point.

Looks like he’s celebrating a well taken penalty to me

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Mar 19 11.19am

I don't want to give an opinion on Luka - who is an exceptional player - as a Captain. It's hard to tell

What I would say is we never properly replaced Jedi. We definitely need an enforcer, that has been clear for a couple of years. Sometimes it looks like that could be Sakho. But from where do we get the next Shaun Derry?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 19 11.24am

At three point park
As away teams now know we are awsomely w***.
Not only is RH going for the worst home record award hes also going for the team fair play award.
" lads dont be too tough as you might get a yellow and not be my favourite to guarentee a start even if you are playing like dogsh ite"
Ffs take this issue of toughness to the top as thats where it sits.
What would bfs have said after that to ffs brighton at home.
He would have told them to go home and not come back with a display like that.
I reckon roy went for a point. A bloody point.
Why leave max and K on the bench and use DM.
More points than any other season at this point i know.
But the points in those seasons were infront of us, the fans at selhurst.
Pissed right off as a minimum.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Mar 19 11.28am

Originally posted by cryrst

At three point park
As away teams now know we are awsomely w***.
Not only is RH going for the worst home record award hes also going for the team fair play award.
" lads dont be too tough as you might get a yellow and not be my favourite to guarentee a start even if you are playing like dogsh ite"
Ffs take this issue of toughness to the top as thats where it sits.
What would bfs have said after that to ffs brighton at home.
He would have told them to go home and not come back with a display like that.
I reckon roy went for a point. A bloody point.
Why leave max and K on the bench and use DM.
More points than any other season at this point i know.
But the points in those seasons were infront of us, the fans at selhurst.
Pissed right off as a minimum.

I agree on Kouyate but not Meyer. An impact sub. Would have been owned by the Brighton midfield.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Mar 19 3.42pm

The original post is harsh on Luka. Currently there is no one else suited for captaincy.
Sometimes hollering and screaming has the opposite effect. Tactics like rotational fouling must surely come from the management, if RH was to decide that this was a valid ploy then the players would adopt it. I'd like to see it, due retribution on one of the opposition who has brutally hacked one of our players.
I would like Luka to be talking to the ref more - doesn't need to be overly aggressive, but confident and firm.

 

GreenwichEagle Flag Greenwich 11 Mar 19 5.06pm

Absolute nonsense post. Utter bilge.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 11 Mar 19 7.22pm

We lost the game, because we didn’t want it as much as them. Jimmy Mac was awful as he has been most of the season. They had 2 chances which they took brilliantly, no complaints from me, Luka has been our most consistent performer in my eyes and I can’t see another suitable person to take the arm band...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 11 Mar 19 7.26pm

Originally posted by Casual

Agree. He’s a defensive midfielder, and not a bad one.
What are the other midfielders doing, and as captain why isn’t he telling them what to do ?

What like?

Jeff be creative.
Cabaye - don’t leave.

He can’t make players be creative!

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 11 Mar 19 7.41pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

We lost the game, because we didn’t want it as much as them. Jimmy Mac was awful as he has been most of the season. They had 2 chances which they took brilliantly, no complaints from me, Luka has been our most consistent performer in my eyes and I can’t see another suitable person to take the arm band...

Tactically they nullified us, conditions helped them for the 1st goal coupled with poor defending, 2nd was a great hit coupled again with suspect defending. Both managers knew exactly how the other team was going to play. Roy failed to grasp the initiative by changing up our formation. First goal was crucial, if we had scored first early on we might well of won. Even when we were level, giving Roy another chance to throw something different at them he didn't do this. Not sure that I have seen the Weed play any different this season so there is really no excuses for not being ready with a good game plan to take them on in this set up. Now the Udders will do exactly the same so we really need to be throwing something different at them.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 19 7.45pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Tactically they nullified us, conditions helped them for the 1st goal coupled with poor defending, 2nd was a great hit coupled again with suspect defending. Both managers knew exactly how the other team was going to play. Roy failed to grasp the initiative by changing up our formation. First goal was crucial, if we had scored first early on we might well of won. Even when we were level, giving Roy another chance to throw something different at them he didn't do this. Not sure that I have seen the Weed play any different this season so there is really no excuses for not being ready with a good game plan to take them on in this set up. Now the Udders will do exactly the same so we really need to be throwing something different at them.

Dream on
No chance as roy knows no other way.
Cardiff away.
Thats our get out.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Mar 19 7.57pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

What like?

Jeff be creative.
Cabaye - don’t leave.

He can’t make players be creative!

Wish he could , might be able to tell Benteke to score a goal

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 11 Mar 19 8.56pm

I think he's our best current choice but I completely agree he's not a true leader of men. it's a quiet team, lacking grit.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Uphill Flag Bedford 12 Mar 19 2.32pm

Where was he when Zaha went mental at Southampton?

Tough being a captain but keeping tempers cooled is one of the main requisites.

If he'd jumped straight in and ushered Zaha away might have saved a red card and two match ban.

 

JohnB Flag 12 Mar 19 4.18pm

I'm not sure there are many teams in the league with a genuine old school leader anymore.

Vincent Kompany at a push, outside of that I can't think of anyone that comes across as a real leader.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 12 Mar 19 8.39pm

Originally posted by JohnB

I'm not sure there are many teams in the league with a genuine old school leader anymore.

Vincent Kompany at a push, outside of that I can't think of anyone that comes across as a real leader.

Deeney, Noble. Both hated by opposition fans and only really have a career on passion rather than ability.

Edited by Casual (12 Mar 2019 8.39pm)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain?