You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Myth that we are better than we are
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Myth that we are better than we are


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Mar 19 9.20am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I can't think of one, off hand, that fits all of those critera (end of game, 11 defenders in 18 yard box, opposition score on break); which examples were you thinking of?

I get the feeling you don't like me.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Mar 19 9.29am

Roy Hodgson has a brilliant record in coaching players and getting the best out of them, his record over Europe is second to none so why should his performances with this suddenly be awful with our players, makes no sense to even bring it up.

If I'm proved to be wrong then fair enough.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Mar 19 9.31am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I can't think of one, off hand, that fits all of those critera (end of game, 11 defenders in 18 yard box, opposition score on break); which examples were you thinking of?

If you overplay a corner you will experience big problems, keeping players back and organised results in them being overrated.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Mar 19 9.36am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Roy Hodgson has a brilliant record in coaching players and getting the best out of them, his record over Europe is second to none so why should his performances with this suddenly be awful with our players, makes no sense to even bring it up.

If I'm proved to be wrong then fair enough.

Well, this is a bold statement which statistics don't support I'm afraid.

A third of the total of all his career management victories came with Malmö. His time there ended in 1989.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 18 Mar 19 9.39am

I don't have huge complaints about the league position - it's just the uninspired, apparently uncaring performances and dreadful home form.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Mar 19 9.59am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

One of the Aussie commentators last week wheeled out the old "This squad should be further up the league line" Craig Foster, always to be relied upon for an honest assessment, disagreed. He said the two centre backs (Dann and Tomkins) were ordinary at best, the only two players he rated were Zaha and Luca. Obi Wan was good but still very young.

When you think about it he has a point. Which of our players apart from the ones mentioned are wanted by clubs further up. Townsend maybe but not by anyone in the top 8. The rest are about at their level with the squad players (Kelly, Ward) perhaps ready for the championship. Ayew was on the bench this weekend but I doubt anyone at the club wants him, Reidewald doesnt even get used, Wickham the same and Benteke outscores most other PL centre forwards but only in the number of post dedicated to his uselessness.
We just might be overachieving!


We have a Top 10 squad...no more no less...but it's simply not consistent enough at the minute...partly due to the tactics being employed by the Pragmatic and cautious Mr Hodgson....

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Painter Flag Croydon 18 Mar 19 10.19am


Originally posted by ChrisGC

Correction:

"You seem to think we're better than I think we are"

I explained my opinion. You justified yours by saying you accept the status quo, which can be analysed on merit of each season to tell an overall story of either over or underachievement, which I would say isn't relevant to where we are today.

Where we finish is relevant as to how good the team is. We aren’t as good as you think, the facts don’t lie. Over or under achieving is a matter of opinion, just because you spend a lot of money, it doesn’t guarantee improvement, ask Fulham supporters.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 18 Mar 19 10.26am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Well, this is a bold statement which statistics don't support I'm afraid.

A third of the total of all his career management victories came with Malmö. His time there ended in 1989.

A huge success at Malmo where he is still revered,
Took tiny Switzerland to heir first ever World cup and reached the last 16 plus qualification for European Nations Fina.
Guided Finland to their highest ever FIFA rankings.
Took Inter Milan to a EUFA Cup Final, only losing on penalties.
Saved Fulham from relegation and took them to a Europa Cup Final.
Took WBA to 10th in PL,their highest ever finish.
Came to Palace after the RdB fiasco and with us rock bottom P7 W0 D0 L7 and no goals with every pundit in the land saying were 100% certain to go down saved us.

If you are going to blame him solely for our home record this season then ergo he must also be solely responsible for our wins at Man City, Wolves, Fulham, Huddersfield, Leicester, Burnley and a draw at Man Utd.
Evn at Anfield where our two keepers were injured we scored three goals and gave them a fright.

Not a shabby record as a Manager.

Edited by PZ Eagle (18 Mar 2019 10.28am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Mar 19 10.48am

Originally posted by Painter


Where we finish is relevant as to how good the team is. We aren’t as good as you think, the facts don’t lie. Over or under achieving is a matter of opinion, just because you spend a lot of money, it doesn’t guarantee improvement, ask Fulham supporters.

Fulham supporters aren't relevant to our success.

Where we finish is relevant to how the team performs, not how good it is. Teams with better ability than us have been relegated before.

Over or under achieving in seasons past isn't relevant to today, nor is it solely an opinion. Our finish in the first season was an overachievement given expectation, squad ability and position at Christmas.


We are underperforming and underachieving this season. It's not as if we're playing at 100 miles an hour, chasing every ball, showing tactical flexibility is it?

The same 11 players (baring injury) are going out week after week and playing the same way and expecting different results.

It's the physical manifestation of the definition of madness.

I think we are capable of being better than we are playing. You don't.

Edited by ChrisGC (18 Mar 2019 10.51am)

 

harrowhorn Flag 18 Mar 19 10.56am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Have to disagree.

We can field a starting 11, when fit, that is better than the starting 11 of 12 other premier League teams in my opinion. Perhaps it's true that we have only Zaha and AWB who are top 4 quality, but that's 2 more than Watford, Brighton, Burnley, Newcastle etc, and one more than WHU, Liecester, Everton. I think we should be realistically competing for top 8 and would consider Luka, Kouyate, Sakho, Tomkins, Townshend of being worthy of that quality.

Squad depth is a problem, but that's true of at least ten other teams: who do Bournemouth, Everton, Watford have on the bench? When injuries hit you look for the incoming players to be 20% better then they actually are as they're playing for a place and the rest of the team to come together so that the machine as a whole can be better than the sum of its parts. Do you honestly believe Dann, Ward, Kelly are that far off the standard when they have to deputise occasionally against the likes of Brighton or Huddersfield? I don't.
We're where we are because of poor management. Corners at both ends are a massive problem, yet we have proven capability. This is coaching. We have fit strikers since January and choices of positive central mids like Kouyate and Meyer or defensive options like Macca and Schlupp which can be used as subs or to start. They are usually negative options: This is poor management.

PVA has been very bad for a while and is capable of better. He should have been dropped for Schlupp after Bournemouth away. We wasn't. This is bad management.

I'll end by saying that I wouldn't consider Craig Foster an authority on the matter. He was on high wages and reportedly refused to leave when we were in financial difficulty. He was a waste of a shirt, not even bang average on his day. If we applied his attitude and ability across the squad we'd already be relegated.

Edited by ChrisGC (18 Mar 2019 7.36am)

Edited by ChrisGC (18 Mar 2019 7.48am)

Sorry, you are saying Watford have NO players that a top club would want? Foster would be a shoo-in for England if he hadn't said he's not interested. Doucouré? Pereyra? Deulefeo? Holebas who is actually our player of the year this year, most assists by a defender equal with Robertson.

Who do Watford have on the bench? Gomes; Cleverley (England caps); Chalobah (England caps at all levels); Kabasele (Belgium); Prodl (Austria); Britos (Uruguay); Penaranda (Columbia); Sema (Sweden); Success (Nigeria); Quina (Portugal U21) Gray (Luton);

Not giving it the biggun, cos it's probable that the other clubs you mention could also reel off a list of names but perhaps you should not use your lack of knowledge to make you think you are better than you are.

Anyway, good game Saturday, bad luck, I think we can probably call it quits now and forget any bogus rivalry going forward.

 

Master Coin Flag 18 Mar 19 11.33am

We are better than our league position. For certain. And to say “we only have two decent players in Luka and Wilf” - how many did Leicester have when they won the league? That team has hardly been picked apart. The only top players there were Mahrez, Kante and Vardy and the rest was on coaching and optimising the squads skill set.

Can you honestly say that our home form is maximising what our squad can achieve?

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 18 Mar 19 11.38am

Originally posted by harrowhorn

Sorry, you are saying Watford have NO players that a top club would want? Foster would be a shoo-in for England if he hadn't said he's not interested. Doucouré? Pereyra? Deulefeo? Holebas who is actually our player of the year this year, most assists by a defender equal with Robertson.

Who do Watford have on the bench? Gomes; Cleverley (England caps); Chalobah (England caps at all levels); Kabasele (Belgium); Prodl (Austria); Britos (Uruguay); Penaranda (Columbia); Sema (Sweden); Success (Nigeria); Quina (Portugal U21) Gray (Luton);

Not giving it the biggun, cos it's probable that the other clubs you mention could also reel off a list of names but perhaps you should not use your lack of knowledge to make you think you are better than you are.

Anyway, good game Saturday, bad luck, I think we can probably call it quits now and forget any bogus rivalry going forward.

No, I didn't say that. I said we had 2 players arguably capable of playing for top 4 teams whereas you don't. Foster is having the season of his life and I like Success. The rest are absolutely punching.

I'm happy that Watford refrained by in large from kicking f*** out of their betters on Saturday, as is their usual tactics, and deserved to go through having shown more want for the win.

As for bogus rivalry? I just don't like Deeney etc behaving thuggishly on and off the pitch. It's like watching Wimbledon of the 90s.
Enjoy the season. You'll finish 8th in the league and runners up in the cup before dropping off next season. A bit like Burnley.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 18 Mar 19 12.47pm

A goalscorer would have us roughly six places higher in this division. it's that simple.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 18 Mar 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Bangell

I don't have huge complaints about the league position - it's just the uninspired, apparently uncaring performances and dreadful home form.

This as well although sometimes i would not use the apparently bit.
Home form is where the fans gain or lose their mojo.
Wow mines a bit lacking.
I will go to the remaining ones but am indecisive about a ST next year.
Im done with this crappy defensive respect a point or a 1-0 defeat crap.
One day we will go down.
At least if you go down playing attacking football with the tactics for defending alongside you can start the next season firing to try to get back up.
Look swansea WBA and stoke.
Went down with our current philisophy and none coming back up.

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 18 Mar 19 1.13pm

What didn't help was us Palace fans saying pre season that we were good enough to finish 7th or 8th this season based on a good end to last season. In fact it wasn't just Palace fans saying this it was also the likes of Neville and Carragher and even fans from other clubs.

If Roy had allowed us to start the season in an attacking fashion and got several wins in our first 10 games then this could have happened but he went back to safety first football. By the end of the Southampton home game which was just our 4th match of the season I knew then that it was going to be another long slog.

In terms of the thread title I think our squad is not as good as Everton, Leicester, West Ham or Watford but better than Newcastle and Bournemouth who are both above us. We have good players in AWB, Sakho, Tomkins, Luka, Kouyate, Zaha, Meyer as an impact sub and Michy even though he is not our player. The rest are average including Townsend who works hard and apart from one purple patch a season delivers little. Players like PVA, McArthur, Kelly and Dann have been good in the past but are on the decline.

Big changes are needed in the summer across all aspects of the club but somehow I don't see it happening.

 

JacksonEagle Flag Croydon 18 Mar 19 1.33pm

I think a lot of it is Roy simply isn't a good match for the players/squad we have. He's clearly a very good manager, but his approach is relatively conservative, we have some really exciting players, some of the most exciting i've seen in my 20/25 years supporting palace and i'm not sure he's the right man to get them reach their full potential, again not because hes a bad manager just not the right manager, who is? no idea, which is the main problem.

Also would like to stress that im not saying we should be playing pure football like city, barca, just think our approach isn't correct for the current squad. Agree with what a couple of others have said that our position isn't a major concern just the performances.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 18 Mar 19 1.58pm

I'm massively pro Roy. People are just looking at grass in yonder field. Nobody mourned Glenn Murray, most folks wanted Benteke. Sometimes, a good, simple, slightly boring option -- that you have -- is just fine.

He's not perfect by any stretch, but he's a dream for Palace given where we are at today.

Personally, I hope we are considering who will replace him if he chooses to retire this summer, but I hope he doesn't.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 18 Mar 19 2.00pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

No, I didn't say that. I said we had 2 players arguably capable of playing for top 4 teams whereas you don't. Foster is having the season of his life and I like Success. The rest are absolutely punching.

I'm happy that Watford refrained by in large from kicking f*** out of their betters on Saturday, as is their usual tactics, and deserved to go through having shown more want for the win.

As for bogus rivalry? I just don't like Deeney etc behaving thuggishly on and off the pitch. It's like watching Wimbledon of the 90s.
Enjoy the season. You'll finish 8th in the league and runners up in the cup before dropping off next season. A bit like Burnley.

Their betters? They've beaton us 3 times this season and have assembled a very good team. I would say their players are better than ours at the moment.

 

HOLden Flag Grays: Essex 18 Mar 19 2.16pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'awb & pa1ace ' by bexleydave

Just wanna talk about entitlements & expectations!

We seem to either, downer the size of the club, due to our history, not expected or entitled to be in the European places, cause (never mind the other clubs fans thoughts on that) OUR own supporters don’t believe in that somewhat ridiculous thought!

Does that mentality & attitude need to change?
Cause if the fello CPFC fans don’t believe, why should the players?

The flipside is, we expect to beat the Uddersfields & t***fords of this league, WHY? When last week I thought, we are a small club, that’s punching above our weight!

Next season will be Our SE7ENTH Premiership Season! Look how far we’ve come & achieved! Been to New Wembley, more times with PlayOff, Cup Finals & Yids Away, than ever before!

Lastly on, Aaron Wan~Bissaka!
Yes, he should of, been one of the first names for the senior ENG1AND team, especially as Sarfgate, is one of our own! BUT!! To those that say we are a small club, that are not entitled to anything... why should AWB be expected to be called straight into the national team? What’s the difference?
IMHO, Townsend should be also called up as well!

By the way, my expectations are, middish table finishes & trips towards the semi’s @ Wembley, in the Cups! Be like a Leicester/nEverton sorta club, but in Our own unique rollercoaster PA1ACE way!

Thoughts?

 


................E
C' mon U GLAZIERS
................G
................L
................E$$ex by birth,
................Selhurst Park by the grace of god!
F0110w...@paulholden84

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 18 Mar 19 3.12pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

The ability of some of our players to pass to another who is only about four feet away is down to Mr Hodgson then is it?

And therein lies, I believe, one of the reasons we are not higher in the table.

The thing that always hits me is our haphazard passing. Yes, every so often we will string a few passes together and create a chance, and even a goal.

But,all too often we give the ball away when trying to break out of defence, or, likewise, give the ball away by sloppy passing when trying to mount an attack.

So many other sides seem to have players who can play a fast accurate passing game with quick movement and one touch football. Instead we have a rather laborious build up that entails numerous sideways and backwards passing (particularly at home). If we do try and speed things up we tend to give the ball away. Until we have players who can pass the ball with a high percentage of accuracy then we are not likely to trouble the top half of the table.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Myth that we are better than we are