You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew v Hodgson
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew v Hodgson


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Apr 19 4.23pm

This would not be the best undercard at the next Joshua fight.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Cy Bais Flag Minneapolis MN 07 Apr 19 9.31pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Pardew's first year in charge was excellent, but eventually showed that he had no idea how to organise a team. We were an absolute shambles towards the end, especially defensively.

Hodgson has the opposite problem - overly rigid, inflexible, and cautious. Still, given a choice between the two, Hodgson will get you just enough to stay up whereas with Pardew it's a complete gamble.

^^ Wish we can mix the two traits in one. That would be my perfect manager. From what i remember, Pardew didn't know when to park the bus to protect a lead or secure a point. Whereas, Roy would be too defensive at times when the occasion calls for the opposite. :-)

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 08 Apr 19 10.14am

Pardew got rid of Murray as thought he was past his sell by date. A mistake that has cost the club millions of £££ ... pretty sure Roy would never have done that!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Apr 19 11.43am

Originally posted by KAOS

Pardew got rid of Murray as thought he was past his sell by date. A mistake that has cost the club millions of £££ ... pretty sure Roy would never have done that!

This Murray thing has gone on for far too long. When we sold him the vast majority of Palace fans including those on these boards thought he was past his best and that the money we received was fantastic for an aging forward. You simply cannot run a football club on hindsight so whilst it has turned out that he has had a wonderful twilight to his career, you cannot say that another manager would have known this was going to happen.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 08 Apr 19 11.52am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

This Murray thing has gone on for far too long. When we sold him the vast majority of Palace fans including those on these boards thought he was past his best and that the money we received was fantastic for an aging forward. You simply cannot run a football club on hindsight so whilst it has turned out that he has had a wonderful twilight to his career, you cannot say that another manager would have known this was going to happen.


Never sell a striker that scores goals consistently whatever his age. Just common sense ...

 

si_1967 Flag Surrey 08 Apr 19 12.07pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


This Murray thing has gone on for far too long. When we sold him the vast majority of Palace fans including those on these boards thought he was past his best and that the money we received was fantastic for an aging forward. You simply cannot run a football club on hindsight so whilst it has turned out that he has had a wonderful twilight to his career, you cannot say that another manager would have known this was going to happen.

Most people on here thought it was ridiculous to get rid of Murray and that is why we can't forgive Pards.
He also treated Speroni abominambly whilst Wayne was going through his rough patch refusing to play him.
He also got rid of Jedinak and replaced him with Flamini.

Okay he got us some results to start with but ultimately his arrogance shone through and showed him up to be the complete tosser he really is.

 


... what

RyWa Flag Beckenham 08 Apr 19 12.31pm

Originally posted by si_1967

Most people on here thought it was ridiculous to get rid of Murray and that is why we can't forgive Pards.
He also treated Speroni abominambly whilst Wayne was going through his rough patch refusing to play him.
He also got rid of Jedinak and replaced him with Flamini.

Okay he got us some results to start with but ultimately his arrogance shone through and showed him up to be the complete tosser he really is.

The Jedinak argument is nearly as bad as the Murray one. Jedinak was very poor his last season with us, he was too slow and too sloppy and the fans were getting frustrated. hes a club legend but Jedinak went at the right time, he simply wasn't good enough.

Murray has in-fact come good, I must admit I was gutted to see him leave but not many people were confident he'd start banging them in again (me included), just like the board didn't know Benteke would be a flop after the first season.. on paper Benteke for Murray was a huge upgrade and step in the right direction for Palace.
Everything is easier to judge in hindsight.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Apr 19 12.53pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

This Murray thing has gone on for far too long. When we sold him the vast majority of Palace fans including those on these boards thought he was past his best and that the money we received was fantastic for an aging forward. You simply cannot run a football club on hindsight so whilst it has turned out that he has had a wonderful twilight to his career, you cannot say that another manager would have known this was going to happen.

Totally agree.

My understanding of the situation is that it wasn't Pardew's decision to sell. It was Steve Parish who had been advised that Murray was past his best and should be sold if the right offer came in. Whatever, it's done.

Be interesting to see how Brighton cope next year as I can't see Murray replicating this season's form...but then again !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Apr 19 1.04pm

Originally posted by KAOS


Never sell a striker that scores goals consistently whatever his age. Just common sense ...

Easy thing to say but Defoe had 8 different clubs, Kevin Phillips 9, Peter Crouch had 13! Were all those managers so wrong, because these guys have consistently put the ball away throughout their careers?

I think the issue is more that different managers have their favourites and sometimes they also think, rightly or wrongly, the grass is greener.

 

VKR1888 Flag London 08 Apr 19 1.26pm

I was always a Pardew fan. The cup run was amazing, as was some of the football.

I couldn't really argue when he was given the sack though, he was actually given more time than usual given what he had done before.

Roy is proving to be not the answer though, not if we want to push on. I would argue we are not getting the best out of the current squad.

 

Jefroc Flag Crete 08 Apr 19 2.30pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Totally agree.

My understanding of the situation is that it wasn't Pardew's decision to sell. It was Steve Parish who had been advised that Murray was past his best and should be sold if the right offer came in. Whatever, it's done.

Be interesting to see how Brighton cope next year as I can't see Murray replicating this season's form...but then again !


And Parish says the worst decision he ever made was allowing Pardew to persuade him to sell Murray.

The best front three we have had since the Wright/Bright day’s was Zaha, Murray, Bolasie. They terrorized defenders because of talent and so importantly mutual understanding. Since that was broken up we largely have depended on the individual skills of Wilf and Andros. .

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

si_1967 Flag Surrey 08 Apr 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by RyWa

The Jedinak argument is nearly as bad as the Murray one. Jedinak was very poor his last season with us, he was too slow and too sloppy and the fans were getting frustrated. hes a club legend but Jedinak went at the right time, he simply wasn't good enough.

Murray has in-fact come good, I must admit I was gutted to see him leave but not many people were confident he'd start banging them in again (me included), just like the board didn't know Benteke would be a flop after the first season.. on paper Benteke for Murray was a huge upgrade and step in the right direction for Palace.
Everything is easier to judge in hindsight.


I think you miss the point on Jedinak though, he was a club legend and the time to move him on was probably right. BUT, Flamini!!!!
As for Murray He scored 7 goals in 17 games in that second half of the season before we moved him on.
So those saying the time to move on from the Glenn saga are right, but it is relevant still when discussing the pros and cons of Pardew. And I still stand by the point that Pards was an arrogant tosser and Hodgson would never treat star players so badly

 


... what

si_1967 Flag Surrey 08 Apr 19 2.45pm

Also, we didn't get Benteke as a replacement it was Connor Wickham, very much as sideways move really!!

 


... what

RyWa Flag Beckenham 08 Apr 19 3.08pm

We signed Benteke and Wickham within 10 months of Murray leaving, I accept Benteke being at the the latter end of that time period, but he certainly filled the void nonetheless which had only been done by Gayle to an extent since Murray's injury.

Flamini had some solid sub performances for us,though lets be honest, Flamini only started 3 games, simply because we had better players like Cabaye, Mcarthur and Ledley at the time.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Apr 19 6.05pm

Originally posted by Jefroc


And Parish says the worst decision he ever made was allowing Pardew to persuade him to sell Murray.

The best front three we have had since the Wright/Bright day’s was Zaha, Murray, Bolasie. They terrorized defenders because of talent and so importantly mutual understanding. Since that was broken up we largely have depended on the individual skills of Wilf and Andros. .

Someone's telling porkys then !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Loz83 Flag Crawley 09 Apr 19 10.21am

to be fair pardew had a poorer squad to choose from, having a players like sakho, luka for a start. the end of last season under hodgson was some of the best football ive ever seen us play!

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 09 Apr 19 10.43am

Originally posted by Loz83

to be fair pardew had a poorer squad to choose from, having a players like sakho, luka for a start.
the end of last season under hodgson was some of the best football ive ever seen us play!

Neither Sakho nor Luka played under Pardew.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

The Dolphin Flag 09 Apr 19 10.59am

I disliked Pardew for more reasons that I have time to write about today.
He damaged CPFC very badly during his tenure and should have gone after the FA Cup Final.
Murray - should have stayed and I said so at the time and Jedi should have been offered a way to stay at the club - I have no doubt he will be back in some capacity soon!
Pardew was a chancer.
So Hodgson for me every time by comparison.
Whether I like his football makes no difference - he is a Gentleman and doesn't use excuses when we lose.
When Pardew won it was down to him and when we lost it was someone else's fault.
Pardew won't get another job higher than League One ever again in my opinion.
He is toxic!

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 09 Apr 19 11.28am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I disliked Pardew for more reasons that I have time to write about today.
He damaged CPFC very badly during his tenure and should have gone after the FA Cup Final.
Murray - should have stayed and I said so at the time and Jedi should have been offered a way to stay at the club - I have no doubt he will be back in some capacity soon!
Pardew was a chancer.
So Hodgson for me every time by comparison.
Whether I like his football makes no difference - he is a Gentleman and doesn't use excuses when we lose.
When Pardew won it was down to him and when we lost it was someone else's fault.
Pardew won't get another job higher than League One ever again in my opinion.
He is toxic!

Very good summary. I agree entirely.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 09 Apr 19 12.18pm

Yes Pardew has damaged the club....maybe Parish is the root cause of the issues a lot of managers have had to put up with recently...a mate put me onto this 17mins from the end is where it gets interesting

[Link]

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew v Hodgson