You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sensible write up on Roy and our season
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sensible write up on Roy and our season


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 11 Apr 19 12.03am

This is the situation - Parish couldn't back Roy, as he should have done this summer, to allow him to have two years doing it his way, to fully steady the ship and hand us over a mid table club..

Too many mistakes in the past are still being paid for, literally.

So, whilst Roy is doing a great job considering he is expected to finish 17th with what he has, we are not seeing the best of Roy.

This summer, i really feel we need to give Roy an extension, one year so that summer 2021 is time for a new manager to come in, with a similar vision and ethos to carry on with the club.

Last Jan, Roy was stubborn and was making statements on the pitch with players, showing that we needed signings - he asked and stated we needed up to 7 new bodies in. That never happened, not even close. There are articles out there stating this, any one reading up on us at the time will have seen this.
So, what happens, Parish lays it out to him and a year later, Roy has a different story, playing along with the poor us narrative Parish wants. It's not poor us, it's broke us.

Thing is, i don't think it's fair on Roy as we aren't seeing the best of him, which is why i feel, cash in on AWB, Meyer, spend that cash on 4 players Roy does want, built around Zaha and capable of plan b. Let Roy do his thing and i am confident we reach 40 points quicker next season and quicker again.

 


This was once a quality forum....

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 11 Apr 19 1.55am

Does anybody have our home vs away stats since promotion.

My sense is that we would have better away form and the lack of points at home this year is not a new thing

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 11 Apr 19 1.46pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So, what are you saying, is there no middle ground between Pardew and Hodgson where we defend soundly but play more entertaining football? It doesn’t just have to be one or the other and I also think you underestimate the abilities of the players in our squad.

I would agree with your comments about underestimating the abilities. I think the big difference between good and bad has been the tempo. First half generallay pedestrian and second half, much much quicker. The only problem has been that in some games, by the time the tempo increases, we have ben a goal down ( Brighton, Southampton, W Ham as examples) and only thanks to Guita we weren't 0-2 down to Huddersfiled (again).

Its by and large the same players on the pitch (after all the delays in subs is well documented) so why so so so slow in build up early in the games as there is clearly that ability to play a a faster game.? Clearly they won't go tearing into Citeh early on ,but as somebody else has said we treat the poorer teams exactly the same as the big 6 at home.

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Apr 19 2.39pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Does anybody have our home vs away stats since promotion.

My sense is that we would have better away form and the lack of points at home this year is not a new thing

2013-14 Home 11th 27 pts Away 12th 18 pts
2014-15 Home 16th 21 pts Away 5th 27 pts
2015-16 Home 18th 21 pts Away 13th 21 pts
2016-17 Home 18th 20 pts Away 8th 21 pts
2017-18 Home 13th 26 pts Away 9th 18 pts
2018-19 Home 18th 16 pts Away 7th 23 pts


 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 11 Apr 19 10.33pm

Couldn't load the link, but in summary of the facts, if it didn't include:

Plan A or bust.
75th minute like for like subs.
Dropped too many points against s*** teams.
Couldn't finish our dinner.
Terrible at home.
Mid-table by default.

Then it's inaccurate.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 11 Apr 19 10.52pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Couldn't load the link, but in summary of the facts, if it didn't include:

Plan A or bust.
75th minute like for like subs.
Dropped too many points against s*** teams.
Couldn't finish our dinner.
Terrible at home.
Mid-table by default.

Then it's inaccurate.

Two s*** teams in league, seven points out of nine with an away game to come ..can easily be ten out of twelve, how's that dropping points then?
Silly billy

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 11 Apr 19 11.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

2013-14 Home 11th 27 pts Away 12th 18 pts
2014-15 Home 16th 21 pts Away 5th 27 pts
2015-16 Home 18th 21 pts Away 13th 21 pts
2016-17 Home 18th 20 pts Away 8th 21 pts
2017-18 Home 13th 26 pts Away 9th 18 pts
2018-19 Home 18th 16 pts Away 7th 23 pts


Which gives us an average of a 12th place finish every season....

 


Pro USA & Israel

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 12 Apr 19 12.59am

Originally posted by Willo

2013-14 Home 11th 27 pts Away 12th 18 pts
2014-15 Home 16th 21 pts Away 5th 27 pts
2015-16 Home 18th 21 pts Away 13th 21 pts
2016-17 Home 18th 20 pts Away 8th 21 pts
2017-18 Home 13th 26 pts Away 9th 18 pts
2018-19 Home 18th 16 pts Away 7th 23 pts


Fortress Selhurst and so glad we caved in to the HF.

 


This was once a quality forum....

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 12 Apr 19 7.36am

Will be interesting to see where we’re are after this season...

[Link]


 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 12 Apr 19 7.46am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Two s*** teams in league, seven points out of nine with an away game to come ..can easily be ten out of twelve, how's that dropping points then?
Silly billy

We got beaten by Brighton twice and drew with Newcastle and Cardiff at home of the top of my head.
Without mentioning Bournemouth away or the triple done over us by Watford.
How's that not dropping too many points against s*** teams?
Facetious Fred.

 

leejaneagles Flag 12 Apr 19 8.57am

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 12 Apr 19 10.05am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)


Great post.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 12 Apr 19 10.23am

I agree with the sentiment but still not convinced that BFS ever really fancied life in SE25. In his eyes we're to small, unfashionable and in the wrong part of TOWN. we gave him a chance after his England debacle and he grabbed it with both hands but, IMO, always had hopes of a 'bigger' role somewhere else.

He's not to be trusted ... kinda fella who looks over your shoulder when you're speaking to him. Always distracted by the lights.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 12 Apr 19 10.31am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)

My opinion is the Roy is the middle ground between Allardyce and Pardew. I am not aware of a more defensive , we must not lose , concede a goal minded manager than Allerdyce .

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Apr 19 11.03am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

We got beaten by Brighton twice and drew with Newcastle and Cardiff at home of the top of my head.
Without mentioning Bournemouth away or the triple done over us by Watford.
How's that not dropping too many points against s*** teams?
Facetious Fred.

Brighton, Newcastle, Cardiff, Bournemouth and Watford are not shit teams ..any team able to compete and still be able to survive this league with about seven games to go is far from crap, home or away.
All our players are not quite as competent as you think they are, opposing teams know who will make the most mistakes and we make far too many of them, Mr Hodgson is doing a fantastic brilliant job with them ..it must be extremely frustrating for him.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Apr 19 11.05am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)

Sooooo many holes, I cannot even begin.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Apr 19 11.16am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)

Sam brought in Jeffrey Schlupp and Patrick van Aanholt they are our weakest link with passing to another player ...say's everything you need to know about Sam.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 12 Apr 19 11.55am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Brighton, Newcastle, Cardiff, Bournemouth and Watford are not shit teams ..any team able to compete and still be able to survive this league with about seven games to go is far from crap, home or away.
All our players are not quite as competent as you think they are, opposing teams know who will make the most mistakes and we make far too many of them, Mr Hodgson is doing a fantastic brilliant job with them ..it must be extremely frustrating for him.

Cardiff, Brighton and Newcastle not s***?
Shows what you know. What a ridiculous thing to say.
Bournemouth and Watford also s*** in my opinion, but would have listened to sensible arguments for why they we're justified in dropping points Vs them.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 12 Apr 19 6.37pm

If you swapped our home form for our away form, the mood would be different.

Those saying Allardyce, absolute rubbish. Most overrated manager we've had that I can remember.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 12 Apr 19 7.09pm

Originally posted by TomThePalaceFanatic

If you swapped our home form for our away form, the mood would be different.

Those saying Allardyce, absolute rubbish. Most overrated manager we've had that I can remember.

Of course it would ... we've seen mostly $hite live football this season. It's NOT entertaining to watch and NOT what I travel in or want to pay for. If others are content then so be it but I'm not happy.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sensible write up on Roy and our season