You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 10.20pm

Originally posted by blackheatheagle

This incident has reminded me one of my favourite caricature.

So called religious beliefs full of hate and their demand from people to be respectful about their beliefs


Edited by blackheatheagle (17 Apr 2019 9.09pm)

Yes, there's certainly an irony to that. Is it 'just a belief' if you're publicly condemning a group of people to what you believe is the pit of hell. He's conveying an extreme view and it's the most forthright attack on a group of people that can be made from a religious perspective short of physical harm. It's going to get a public reaction because it's a hateful outlier view and if your boss sees it as a distraction and you keep doing it, you can expect action to be taken.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Apr 19 10.28pm

This is one of those very tricky moral conundrums.

I loathe religious dogma and the persecution of others that might result from it but I find it difficult to understand how one can reasonably condemn a person for expressing religious convictions when the religion itself is accepted.
How much can we blame people who have been indoctrinated with backward hogwash from childhood and how far do we go with limiting expression of free opinion to avoid offending even if that opinion is based on fantasy?


My answer would be not at all until that belief conflicts with the law or when it is a direct cause of harm to others. Then we have to say that protection of others comes before personal conviction.

If we want people to stop believing in religious nonsense then we need to discourage the spread of religion and the indoctrination of the young.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 10.55pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

As the years have gone by on some things I seem to have become more socially conservative, perhaps that is in reaction to society's increasing liberalisation or just something natural that happens to aging males....or both.

I tend to agree with those who say 'why upset people' for no reason. For example while I'm quite the anti Islamic I kind of agree with the idea that you don't draw pictures just to upset people. But then again..... on the other hand I'd kind of like the liberty to do so. When it turns out that I'm required to bend my knee on it.....I suddenly discover that I've lost all flexibility in my knees.

Nowadays, I react when I find that what can be a perfectly reasonable request for civilised behaviour then moves on from a desire for respect to a requirement for it.....Where people get sacked if they say stuff like I'm not for this or not for that.....I find myself remembering those Muhammad Ali days and I know what's being lost.

It seems a disfigurement of the kind of tolerance I wanted when I was younger.....Now I'm just a cynic. I realise that it's ...'meet the new boss, it's the same as the old boss'.

Same puritans, just different rules.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Apr 2019 9.04pm)

Yes, as they say 'the more things change the more they stay the same'. The configuration shifts from time to time but the game remains the same.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 17 Apr 19 11.08pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is one of those very tricky moral conundrums.

I loathe religious dogma and the persecution of others that might result from it but I find it difficult to understand how one can reasonably condemn a person for expressing religious convictions when the religion itself is accepted.
How much can we blame people who have been indoctrinated with backward hogwash from childhood and how far do we go with limiting expression of free opinion to avoid offending even if that opinion is based on fantasy?


My answer would be not at all until that belief conflicts with the law or when it is a direct cause of harm to others. Then we have to say that protection of others comes before personal conviction.

If we want people to stop believing in religious nonsense then we need to discourage the spread of religion and the indoctrination of the young.

That's a good point. It's like the abused becomes abuser argument. He's parroting what he's been told. The conundrum being that he wants to propagate views that vilify and condemn and yet in holding him to account will that embolden others? I don't think there are clear answers which is why my view fell more to it impacting the team dynamic and his habit of ignoring requests from management.

To use a religious sensitivity raised earlier, if a high profile Muslim rugby player said that anyone drawing Mohammed deserves retribution and eternal damnation, and that escalated into a tit for tat that resulted in harm, would his role in that be acceptable? If not, at what point are we supposed to act.

Ultimately there's plenty of dodgy stuff that could be and is justified by its presence in religious texts. Maybe we all follow our own religion of sorts, even if there's no God attached, in that we each form a view of life that we settle on. At least outside of actual religion though, ideas can be explained or debated, rather than just saying 'God said so'.

Edited by dollardays (17 Apr 2019 11.09pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Apr 19 11.28pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Yes, as they say 'the more things change the more they stay the same'. The configuration shifts from time to time but the game remains the same.

Ain't that the truth.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 10.30am

Originally posted by dollardays

Child marriage appears to align in a rather unfortunate manner with some religions. If a player was in the team posting pictures of young girls on Instagram and saying 'If only I could marry this one' and more concerning comments, would you support that too? It's the same principle. Religious texts, including Christianity, contain all kind of beliefs that are either considered extreme or shocking in the modern world. Are you saying that anything written within these books is perfectly legitimate just because it's based on religious belief?

Child marriage is against the law in general. However, even on our own doorstep we have special marriage licenses given out to Travellers and Gypsies who are underage - as they are a recognised ethnicity. You probably were not aware of this.
Also posting pictures of underage girls online would be peodophilia - especially with sexual commentary.
Stating that homosexuals go to hell is hardly the same. For a start it's a possibly fictional afterlife. And it is his genuine belief. If someone wants to believe in these things I say let them. I don't believe in these things at all personally - just to state my position.
I don't think Folau is openly going to attack homosexuals - he believes it is wrong and has stated that.
As another poster said - I believe this is a save face knee jerk reaction from rugby. But there are wider consequences. On another thread about Wayne I provided a tongue in cheek list about what we can joke about.
Perhaps now we need a list about what we can have an opinion on. I don't like religion - any of them. I particularly dislike some of the teachings of Islam and Christianity. Am I allowed to talk about that? To be honest, I would be fired if I gave my true opinion on Social Media. My main job is as a Public Servant. That is the real debate.

 


Red and Blue Army!

chris123 Flag hove actually 18 Apr 19 11.32am

Free speech trumps everything in my view.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 11.48am

Originally posted by chris123

Free speech trumps everything in my view.

Free speech is part of the US Constitution. Even then, for example, people were not free to espouse communist views, for example.
In Britain there has always been limits on free speech - unless you want to stand on a soap-box at speaker's corner. Even that is probably curtailed these days - in case you offend someone or group of people.
So, frankly, there is no free speech but enough people seem to have been fooled into the idea that there is.
Folau is paying the price for his 'free' speech and freedom of expression. At least, there have been no criminal charges against him yet.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 18 Apr 19 12.07pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Child marriage is against the law in general. However, even on our own doorstep we have special marriage licenses given out to Travellers and Gypsies who are underage - as they are a recognised ethnicity. You probably were not aware of this.
Also posting pictures of underage girls online would be peodophilia - especially with sexual commentary.
Stating that homosexuals go to hell is hardly the same. For a start it's a possibly fictional afterlife. And it is his genuine belief. If someone wants to believe in these things I say let them. I don't believe in these things at all personally - just to state my position.
I don't think Folau is openly going to attack homosexuals - he believes it is wrong and has stated that.
As another poster said - I believe this is a save face knee jerk reaction from rugby. But there are wider consequences. On another thread about Wayne I provided a tongue in cheek list about what we can joke about.
Perhaps now we need a list about what we can have an opinion on. I don't like religion - any of them. I particularly dislike some of the teachings of Islam and Christianity. Am I allowed to talk about that? To be honest, I would be fired if I gave my true opinion on Social Media. My main job is as a Public Servant. That is the real debate.

You ought try to your stick to your own argument

"- surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? " you said.

I'm choosing examples of 'beliefs' that society rightly takes issue with. By your own logic you would have to support a player stating these creepy beliefs too if they were based on his genuine religious beliefs. My view instead is that to some extent it clearly depends on what the belief is, and if indeed it does depend on what the view is, then it's a matter of interpretation or nuance.

Believe what you like, but if you say "- surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? " make up your mind about whether you actually believe it before you type it.

Edited by dollardays (18 Apr 2019 12.11pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 12.20pm

Originally posted by dollardays

You ought try to your stick to your own argument

"- surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? " you said.

I'm choosing examples of 'beliefs' that society rightly takes issue with. By your own logic you would have to support a player stating these creepy beliefs too if they were based on his genuine religious beliefs. My view instead is that to some extent it clearly depends on what the belief is, and if indeed it does depend on what the view is, then it's a matter of interpretation or nuance.

Believe what you like, but if you say "- surely it is wrongful dismissal to be sacked for expressing religious beliefs? " make up your mind about whether you actually believe it before you type it.

Edited by dollardays (18 Apr 2019 12.11pm)

There is actually no contradiction in my argument. I don't support or believe in what Folau said.
However, he seems to have been sacked for expressing his religious beliefs. I believe this is wrongful dismissal due to employment law. Having quite a bit of experience with it here and in Britain - I believe a legal case could be taken that demonstrates he has been dismissed wrongfully on the grounds of his religion.
I am stating a legal case - not one where it has anything to do with me agreeing with him or not.
There is no contradiction in that.
What I don't like are the thought police watching everything that's said and getting rid of people when they don't like what's said.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 18 Apr 19 12.40pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

There is actually no contradiction in my argument. I don't support or believe in what Folau said.
However, he seems to have been sacked for expressing his religious beliefs. I believe this is wrongful dismissal due to employment law. Having quite a bit of experience with it here and in Britain - I believe a legal case could be taken that demonstrates he has been dismissed wrongfully on the grounds of his religion.
I am stating a legal case - not one where it has anything to do with me agreeing with him or not.
There is no contradiction in that.
What I don't like are the thought police watching everything that's said and getting rid of people when they don't like what's said.

I've not said that you agree with anything he says. I'm saying that you either believe that it's wrong to dismiss someone for expressing all and any religious beliefs, as you professed, or you don't. No matter how far those views differ from those held by the modern world or what religion they are.

As stated, by your own logic, you'd be there defending a rugby player repeatedly publicly declaring a love of very young girls "because it's his genuinely held religous belief" and "okay with his god". I seriously doubt you'd be doing that. I would find those views repellent and they lead to real world harm to others. I also to an extent believe that about Folaus views. It's not 'just a view' just because you personally don't care about what he's saying. There are real life consequences through hate spread through religion and this is an example of it.

And what if a player is essentially telling another team member that they're going to hell? Great for the team dynamic. Or there are two muslim players and one leaves the religion, I think we all know what the islamic view of Apostasy is. It becomes absurd to give an endless stamp of approval within a team dynamic of any and all bizarre religious prattlings when they impact the team, take the focus away from it, and continue despite being previously warned. I don't much care if they are "genuinely held beliefs". It's fantasy and beyond a point if people believe things that are either dangerous, damaging, counter to the society they're within, or against commercial interests that will get factored in as it was here.

Edited by dollardays (18 Apr 2019 1.31pm)

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 18 Apr 19 12.40pm

As a side note, my son was at school with the Vinipola boys.
He said he went round there house one morning,and the brothers where having breakfast out of what could only be described as washing up bowls.
Well known family in my area, and very well thought of.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 18 Apr 19 12.44pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

As a side note, my son was at school with the Vinipola boys.
He said he went round there house one morning,and the brothers where having breakfast out of what could only be described as washing up bowls.
Well known family in my area, and very well thought of.

Start as you mean to go on, haha

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 18 Apr 19 1.33pm

Originally posted by chris123

Free speech trumps everything in my view.

There is no such thing, nor should there be.

Unless you want paedo instruction manuals on your newsagents walls detailing how to groom and abduct small children.

There is a line.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 2.02pm

Originally posted by dollardays

I've not said that you agree with anything he says. I'm saying that you either believe that it's wrong to dismiss someone for expressing all and any religious beliefs, as you professed, or you don't. No matter how far those views differ from those held by the modern world or what religion they are.

As stated, by your own logic, you'd be there defending a rugby player repeatedly publicly declaring a love of very young girls "because it's his genuinely held religous belief" and "okay with his god". I seriously doubt you'd be doing that. I would find those views repellent and they lead to real world harm to others. I also to an extent believe that about Folaus views. It's not 'just a view' just because you personally don't care about what he's saying. There are real life consequences through hate spread through religion and this is an example of it.

And what if a player is essentially telling another team member that they're going to hell? Great for the team dynamic. Or there are two muslim players and one leaves the religion, I think we all know what the islamic view of Apostasy is. It becomes absurd to give an endless stamp of approval within a team dynamic of any and all bizarre religious prattlings when they impact the team, take the focus away from it, and continue despite being previously warned. I don't much care if they are "genuinely held beliefs". It's fantasy and beyond a point if people believe things that are either dangerous, damaging, counter to the society they're within, or against commercial interests that will get factored in as it was here.

Edited by dollardays (18 Apr 2019 1.31pm)

Fair enough. Believe me I can see your point. I don't really see the connection with protecting Peados though. Peadophiles is rightly a crime in our society.
Is stating that homosexuality is not supported by God - according to his teachings - the same? I don't think you genuinely believe that.
Where exactly is the line drawn. I could extrapolate your argument further and say all hard line Christians and then all Muslims are basically wrong - and should be sacked for the beliefs they have. Whilst I don't agree with religion, is that my or society's place to say?
I agree largely with what you say about team and management and obviously you should respect certain codes of conduct when representing one's country. But there is a whole can of worms here.
This is quite a difficult argument for all sides of the political spectrum. What can we say and what can't we say?
Folau could have pleaded complete ignorance like Wayne and said he knew nothing of the treatment of homosexuals. However, it is quite interesting that he appears hell-bent (!) on sticking to his religious beliefs.
My best advice to sporting teams is to ban players from social media in their contract. Then have club/national employees posting uncontentious player's tweets/ posts. Essentially gagging their right to freedom of expression.

Edited by ASCPFC (18 Apr 2019 2.03pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 2.08pm

Originally posted by chris123

Free speech trumps everything in my view.

This is a great line for demonstrating the power of punctuation.
We could have a great laugh with:

Free speech: Trump's everything in my view.

Sorry Chris - not meaning to say that is your view. Just thought this funny.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Invalid user 2019 Flag 18 Apr 19 2.24pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Fair enough. Believe me I can see your point. I don't really see the connection with protecting Peados though. Peadophiles is rightly a crime in our society.
Is stating that homosexuality is not supported by God - according to his teachings - the same? I don't think you genuinely believe that.
Where exactly is the line drawn. I could extrapolate your argument further and say all hard line Christians and then all Muslims are basically wrong - and should be sacked for the beliefs they have. Whilst I don't agree with religion, is that my or society's place to say?
I agree largely with what you say about team and management and obviously you should respect certain codes of conduct when representing one's country. But there is a whole can if worms here.
This is quite a difficult argument for all sides of the political spectrum. What can we say and what can't we say?
Folau could have pleaded complete ignorance like Wayne and said he knew nothing of the treatment of homosexuals. However, it is quite interesting that he appears hell-bent (s******) on sticking to his religious beliefs.
My best advice to sporting teams is to ban players from social media in their contract. Then have club/national employees posting uncontentious player's tweets/ posts. Essentially gagging their right to freedom of expression.

Yes, I do get where you're coming from on this.

The connection is that we're talking about speech and belief, not activity. Whether support for something that is a genuinely held religious belief but out of sync with the modern world, trumps that of the society it falls within. Where the line is as you say, that kind of thing.

I posted in the Wayne thread the other day supporting him, on the understanding that personally I believe that humour, even very offensive humour is a very good way for society to thrash things out. That's why legal action like that nazi pug b0llocks was entirely absurd and many rightly came out to condemn it.

Within team dynamics though, and in line with advice from employers, I think a person publicly admired and playing for their nation should be mindful of their conduct and responsibilities. I don't elevate genuine beliefs on account that they are said to be delivered from intergalactic beings seeking to punish entire demographics or telling the individual that it's fine to this or that. If what they feel it's telling them is roughly in line with the society they live in no-one cares, if it isn't, it causes problems. Not to target a specific religion, but has the hands off approach on hardcore islamic beliefs in this country really helped anyone or just caused endless problems for all?

I feel that a cultural take on religion that is at least partially aligned with basic understandings of others can certainly be of benefit to a person. Just spouting off and offending people and expecting no reaction to that, not so much.

Edited by dollardays (18 Apr 2019 2.27pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 18 Apr 19 2.25pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

This is a great line for demonstrating the power of punctuation.
We could have a great laugh with:

Free speech: Trump's everything in my view.

Sorry Chris - not meaning to say that is your view. Just thought this funny.

Comma after everything! Let's eat Grandma, while we're at it.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 19 2.45pm

Originally posted by chris123

Comma after everything! Let's eat Grandma, while we're at it.

I thought Eats, shoots and leaves was going to be a good relationship advice book. In the end, I got divorced because I kept correcting my wife's language.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 18 Apr 19 2.46pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

There is no such thing, nor should there be.

Unless you want paedo instruction manuals on your newsagents walls detailing how to groom and abduct small children.

There is a line.

What a weird example to give, which is a crime and not free speech.

But the main issue is who decides where the line is. An authoritarian government? A Twitter hate mob?

Free speech is a classical liberal view. Shame the left disowned these social liberties a while ago.

Edited by Penge Eagle (18 Apr 2019 2.47pm)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billy Vunipola and Isreal Folau