This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Allardyce, Bruce and Dowie are all exactly the same as Pulis. Two bob chancers who took the piss out of us as a club and thought the grass was greener elsewhere and lied to get out of their contracts. I don't care how good a manager any of them are, even if we were in dire straits nearing relegation, Palace would lose any credibility it has, if any of them were considered by the club.
Edit: other than Allardyce. I think he would have stayed if him and Parish were on the same hymn sheet. Not that I'm criticising Parish. If Big Sam couldn't operated within his framework then that's fair dos. Edited by ChrisGC (10 Jun 2019 3.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Allardyce, Bruce and Dowie are all exactly the same as Pulis. Two bob chancers who took the piss out of us as a club and thought the grass was greener elsewhere and lied to get out of their contracts. I don't care how good a manager any of them are, even if we were in dire straits nearing relegation, Palace would lose any credibility it has, if any of them were considered by the club. I don’t think Allardyce took the p1ss out of us. He wanted to get out of his contract because he didn’t want to cover for Parish’s previous mistakes in the transfer market which have effectively hamstrung is since. Just look at how little we’ve spent on transfers since and will do until we sell one of our prized assets. We took Sakho on which was big but he was in the team on loan before the perm signing, and Kouyate. Nothing else of note on the field. FWIW I do think the £45 mil we spent was necessary. If we bought a left back 6 months before then we may not have bought pva and schlupp and conserved £10 mil and £40k of part of one their £60k wages by waiting and/or scouting more thoroughly instead of at high cost out of the Panini album again. Most of our successful managers are required to paper over our poor scouting, transfer policy and inflated wage bill, which is why I accept the current football while I try to keep my eyes open and to not start snoring. Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Jun 2019 9.27am)
COYP |
|
|
I wanted him to stay, thought he suited the club very well and was looking forward to a few years of stability. Roy's given us that now though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I'm not sure whether you are correct or not but there was definitely something going on that we don't know about. Sam hinted that his relationship with Parish wasn't all rosy but wouldn't expand on it. Yet another case where we will have to wait for the autobiography to come out
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I don’t think Allardyce took the p1ss out of us. He wanted to get out of his contract because he didn’t want to cover for Parish’s previous mistakes in the transfer market which have effectively hamstrung is since. Just look at how little we’ve spent on transfers since and will do until we sell one of our prized assets. We took Sakho on which was big but he was in the team on loan before the perm signing, and Kouyate. Nothing else of note on the field. FWIW I do think the £45 mil we spent was necessary. If we bought a left back 6 months before then we may not have bought pva and schlupp and conserved £10 mil and £40k of part of one their £60k wages by waiting and/or scouting more thoroughly instead of at high cost out of the Panini album again. Most of our successful managers are required to paper over our poor scouting, transfer policy and inflated wage bill, which is why I accept the current football while I try to keep my eyes open and to not start snoring. Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Jun 2019 9.27am) Did Allardyce lie about why he wanted to leave or not, it’s quite simple without made up theories.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Did Allardyce lie about why he wanted to leave or not, it’s quite simple without made up theories. He left as soon as the window ended without breaking any terms in his contract. I don’t know what anyone’s problem with that is. He didn’t even buy any cloggers or one trick pony long ball merchants. It’s not his fault Parish is how he is and what’s happened for so long with player and squad management. I’d have a beer with Allardyce instead of being an idiot over it and him probably laughing at anyone who would be, like he did at pathetic divers when be was stood in his technical area. I liked the exaggerated one at one player.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I thought we played some of our best football under Allardyce. We played Arsenal off the park in a 3-0 win, beat Liverpool 2-1 at Anfield, beat Chelsea 2-1. He spent a fair bit of money but I think the majority of his signings have been a success and still doing it for us today. He was the best manager for getting the best out of Benteke. I'd have him back in a heartbeat if he was committed to staying at the club for a more longterm project. I also think his repuatation of defensive hoofball is unfair when you think back to teams like his Bolton team of JayJay, Campo, Djorkaeff etc. where they played some great football at times. You make some good points, most of which I agree with but in the end Allardyce is a mercenary. He 'retired' to wriggle out of any commitments to Palace, hoping a bigger job would come up. It did at Everton but they hated him.
|
|
|
2 places higher, 40m poorer.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
we saw with both Pulis and Sam that their perceived image is way off the reality, both have used direct football when it was the most workable option but their decisions re tactics and personnel with us showed their astuteness and sophistication as coaches - Everton fans were grossly unfair to Sam, was at Goodison when his Everton played us off the park last season (we had RLC and Wilf missing tbf), Freedman was off the mark when he described West Ham's football as 'long ball' when Sam was in charge there - Sam got the funds to keep us up, the fact that he knew there wouldn't be much more money coming was no doubt a big part of his decision to leave regardless of his relationship with Parrish, if he were still here I think we'd be in roughly the same place, maybe a place or two higher but it's irrelevant to speculate because we would have quite a different squad, I don't think Jimmy Mac would still be here for example. Totally agree, both terrific managers, played great football under both if them, its a miracle pulis kept us up that season. surprised a prem team hasnt snapped him up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Unlike Sam, not all managers pack their bags and scuttle off in a huff because of the inability of the board to spend money. Benitez and Ashley spring immediately to mind. Allardyce is greedy, pure and simple. He just bounces around from team to team, uses ‘brand Allardyce style football’ which lasts about 18 months before being found out and then moves on to save another team for another big payday. He is ambitious but ultimately I don’t believe he is that talented. Roy has done as good a job with less resources and as a result we have found some stability albeit at the expense of some dire play at times. Would we have done better with Sam still at the club? No I don’t think so, we would still finish exactly where we deserve to be which is mid table. Sam was found out as soon as he went to a club that demands better than average results ie: Everton. Spending money has got nothing to do with the relationship between manager and chairman, it is to do with the accounts. Clearly ours aren’t great at the moment which is why SP needed a manager who could manage without spending a bundle (enter Roy). Where we have gone wrong however is wasting money on players like Mutch Jach, Erdal and Sorloth and quite a few others I have thankfully forgotten about. So, in a nutshell it’s how we spend our limited resources that needs improvement at our club and now we just need to know whether that is Dougie, Roy or SP’s responsibility so we can direct our angst accordingly! You’d be right if the evidence wasn’t there that our scouting has been poor for a long time, so not only do we pay lots for well known players but we have to pay them loads to come to little Palace with the embarrassingly small changing rooms and showers. You can also include chopping and changing football strategy back and forth and thus having to fire managers in December, again partly because the summer preparation and transfers have been disappointing and not researched.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
You’d be right if the evidence wasn’t there that our scouting has been poor for a long time, so not only do we pay lots for well known players but we have to pay them loads to come to little Palace with the embarrassingly small changing rooms and showers. You can also include chopping and changing football strategy back and forth and thus having to fire managers in December, again partly because the summer preparation and transfers have been disappointing and not researched. Yes Rudi, agreed, hence my last paragraph. We quite clearly have limited resources, spending them wisely is of paramount importance but that is what we probably do worst as a club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Unlike Sam, not all managers pack their bags and scuttle off in a huff because of the inability of the board to spend money. Benitez and Ashley spring immediately to mind. Allardyce is greedy, pure and simple. He just bounces around from team to team, uses ‘brand Allardyce style football’ which lasts about 18 months before being found out and then moves on to save another team for another big payday. You haven't a shred of evidence that anything you've said is true
|
|
|
What if my father had never met my mother !!!! great thread
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
You haven't a shred of evidence that anything you've said is true
Edited by Dman Palace (11 Jun 2019 2.50pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dman Palace
And most posters make it fairly obvious that they are expressing opinions by the way they phrase their posts whereas Eaglecoops phrased his post as if it were confirmed facts and not a rather biased opinion that was probably incorrect anyway
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
And most posters make it fairly obvious that they are expressing opinions by the way they phrase their posts whereas Eaglecoops phrased his post as if it were confirmed facts and not a rather biased opinion that was probably incorrect anyway ME you do spout some tosh at times. There is not a shred of evidence within my post to say it it was anything other than my opinion. So, do you complain to all the national newspapers after they write complete garbage like AWB wants to leave Palace or Zaha is unhappy at Palace even though there is not a jot of truth in what is said? No I didn’t think so. You just accept it as opinion even if you think it is completely wrong. I don’t really give a damn if you agree with my opinion but when it comes to big fat Sam, what I have written is what it is.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.