You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hate Speech
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hate Speech


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Invalid user 2019 Flag 01 Sep 19 5.32pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Freedom of speech should be the cornerstone of any democracy providing it does not advocate violence.

That does not mean that the MSM or even social media have to broadcast every idiot's opinion but if someone wants to stand on a soapbox and rail against whatever they should have that right. The rest of us don't have to listen.

Where you draw the line is always a bone of contention but right now I think it has gone to far. I look forward to a future government bringing a bill of rights and the arguments about how far we allow freedom of speech.

Sounds about right to me. People should be able to say whatever they want without legal consequence, unless it's a serious threat of violence or designed to cause mass panic.. like a bomb threat at an airport for example. It's a self policing system. If people act like pr!cks, they are typically recognised as such by others. I don't agree with any government involvement in that feedback loop.

Freedom of speech and expression should be non negotiable. We see from various governments left and right world over that they aren't, and if we find ourselves clapping like seals over any infringement upon others personal freedoms just because we disagree with them or their politics ultimately we only succeed in making a rod for our own backs.

Governments seek control over populations any way they can get it. They aren't 'working for us', and will routinely pit people against one another if it succeeds in that aim.

Edited by dollardays (01 Sep 2019 5.56pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 19 5.58pm

Originally posted by cryrst

What about being fat, having a big nose or ears.
That doesnt hurt then if someone abuses you about it.

Of course it might. I don't get your point, if indeed there is one!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 19 6.06pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Sounds about right to me. People should be able to say whatever they want without legal consequence, unless it's a serious threat of violence or designed to cause mass panic.. like a bomb threat at an airport for example. It's a self policing system. If people act like pr!cks, they are typically recognised as such by others. I don't agree with any government involvement in that feedback loop.

Freedom of speech and expression should be non negotiable. We see from various governments left and right world over that they aren't, and if we find ourselves clapping like seals over any infringement upon others personal freedoms just because we disagree with them or their politics ultimately we only succeed in making a rod for our own backs.

Governments seek control over populations any way they can get it. They aren't 'working for us', and will routinely pit people against one another if it succeeds in that aim.

Edited by dollardays (01 Sep 2019 5.56pm)

"Abusive or threatening speech or writing that expresses prejudice against a particular group, especially on the basis of race, religion, or sexual orientation."

So you prefer that people have the freedom to abuse or threaten people because of their prejudices against others?

Not just express rational, reasoned arguments! Abuse or threaten! It is not be sufficient for someone to simply feel offended. It is necessary to prove abuse or threats.

Is that really what we want in our society?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Sep 19 6.14pm

No one has ever been concerned with protecting inoffensive speech.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 01 Sep 19 6.34pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

"Abusive or threatening speech or writing that expresses prejudice against a particular group, especially on the basis of race, religion, or sexual orientation."

So you prefer that people have the freedom to abuse or threaten people because of their prejudices against others?

Not just express rational, reasoned arguments! Abuse or threaten! It is not be sufficient for someone to simply feel offended. It is necessary to prove abuse or threats.

Is that really what we want in our society?

Well, as stated I don't believe that people should be able to issue threats. Abuse is a very different matter. We shouldn't have police knocking on people's doors over racist tweets and so on. That's a waste of both time and resources as these platforms and the tools they offer to both block and report users should be enough. We don't need to run to the authorities over obnoxious or crudely stated communications.

As for 'the real world', if someone in a workplace is reeling off slurs at fellow employees they may find themselves out of a job before long. Hateful behaviour at others within a social circle may result in a reconfiguration of it. In none of these cases do we need a 'bobby on the beat' or authorities to step in. Society is by on large self policing, because the majority of people engage in cooperation and reciprocation with others. There's very little in life that we truly need to turn to government for, and when we believe otherwise our reliance on them sooner or later comes at a cost.

Edited by dollardays (01 Sep 2019 7.17pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 19 7.34pm

Originally posted by dollardays

Well, as stated I don't believe that people should be able to issue threats. Abuse is a very different matter. We shouldn't have police knocking on people's doors over racist tweets and so on. That's a waste of both time and resources as these platforms and the tools they offer to block should be enough. We don't need to run to the authorities over obnoxious or crudely stated communications.

As for 'the real world', if someone in a workplace is reeling off slurs at fellow employees they may find themselves out of a job before long. Hateful behaviour at others within a social circle may result in a reconfiguration of it. In none of these cases do we need a 'bobby on the beat' or authorities to step in. Society is by on large self policing, because the majority of people engage in cooperation and reciprocation with others. There's very little in life that we truly need to turn to government for, and when we forget that our reliance on them sooner or later comes at a cost.

Edited by dollardays (01 Sep 2019 6.35pm)

So threats ought to be banned but abuse is OK?

It's surely not down to the "bobby on the beat" but a Court to decide if an offence has been committed. The Police will only investigate and prosecute if there is something really serious and persistent happening. They won't get involved with anything minor or petty. They have far too much else to do.

We cannot rely on society self policing, or the social media platforms themselves. It's our own responsibility to set limits and guidelines so everyone knows where they stand. One workplace may indeed sack those who mistreat others whilst another will tolerate it. "May be dealt with" isn't good enough.

That's why we have laws.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Invalid user 2019 Flag 01 Sep 19 7.46pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

So threats ought to be banned but abuse is OK?

It's surely not down to the "bobby on the beat" but a Court to decide if an offence has been committed. The Police will only investigate and prosecute if there is something really serious and persistent happening. They won't get involved with anything minor or petty. They have far too much else to do.

We cannot rely on society self policing, or the social media platforms themselves. It's our own responsibility to set limits and guidelines so everyone knows where they stand. One workplace may indeed sack those who mistreat others whilst another will tolerate it. "May be dealt with" isn't good enough.

That's why we have laws.

I do appreciate that my view may well align me with some that aren't honest actors. As in some people with a dislike of certain demographics, who would use government against these groups at the drop of a hat given the chance. But that's the price of viewing society in a more holistic, workable and stable sense really. And to me that is a reason to enshrine freedoms of speech and expression, rather than tailoring them around the politics of the day.

People having more reliance and accountability to one another, with a healthy suspicion of government, is preferable to a society where people are at loggerheads and attempt to use the government to embody their own ideology writ large. The latter is good when the going's good, but political tides always turn, so the former approach makes more sense to me.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 19 10.30pm

Originally posted by dollardays

I do appreciate that my view may well align me with some that aren't honest actors. As in some people with a dislike of certain demographics, who would use government against these groups at the drop of a hat given the chance. But that's the price of viewing society in a more holistic, workable and stable sense really. And to me that is a reason to enshrine freedoms of speech and expression, rather than tailoring them around the politics of the day.

People having more reliance and accountability to one another, with a healthy suspicion of government, is preferable to a society where people are at loggerheads and attempt to use the government to embody their own ideology writ large. The latter is good when the going's good, but political tides always turn, so the former approach makes more sense to me.

All sensible stuff and, despite the rather ridiculous claims of some posters, is actually what normally really happens.

The law exists as a framework but most cases either go unreported or are dealt with outside of the Courts. 76% of hate crime relates to race and there was a clear spike in reported cases at the time of the referendum.

You can draw whatever conclusion you wish from that.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Invalid user 2019 Flag 01 Sep 19 11.16pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All sensible stuff and, despite the rather ridiculous claims of some posters, is actually what normally really happens.

The law exists as a framework but most cases either go unreported or are dealt with outside of the Courts. 76% of hate crime relates to race and there was a clear spike in reported cases at the time of the referendum.

You can draw whatever conclusion you wish from that.

Certainly there are those backward enough to let skin colour interfere with them relating to others, but they're few and far between. Though let's also remember that racism can ultimately affect people of absolutely all races, black, white, asian depending on the demographics of their area. If we're to relate it to Brexit though I don't personally think that the vast, vast majority of voters in either direction tick such a box.

Crime figures will ebb and flow for various reasons, but I'd much rather know exactly what people think and are all about than have them silenced by government fear of stating their view. No matter who's on the receiving end, all forms of bigotry and cruelty look increasingly ludicrous the more light is shone upon them. Never deprive people of their time on the soapbox because most of the population regardless of their politics are sensible, considerate and decent and will react accordingly. Don't let outliers or the hyper politicised make you think otherwise.

Edited by dollardays (01 Sep 2019 11.32pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Sep 19 1.10am

Some old fashioned offence:

And warning....some of these jokes in the second link I personally found offensive so for some their heads might explode.

[Link]

[Link]


Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Sep 2019 1.22am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 02 Sep 19 11.52am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

All sensible stuff and, despite the rather ridiculous claims of some posters, is actually what normally really happens.

The law exists as a framework but most cases either go unreported or are dealt with outside of the Courts. 76% of hate crime relates to race and there was a clear spike in reported cases at the time of the referendum.

You can draw whatever conclusion you wish from that.

"Hate crime" has always been manipulative and insidious since it was introduced. There have been laws against discrimination for years. It's a way of suppressing the negative effects of mass immigration and large scale social engineering (e.g. the continued assault on the traditional family unit). The definition of "hate" and the way these statistics are collected can be changed at will to suit whatever narrative you want.

People fall for this because they are not rational beings but believe what they are told. Very few are even prepared top read below a headline these days let alone check on the facts behind what they are being told.

I know as that used to be me. Realizing you were being conned all of your life is not a pleasant experience but a necessary one.

Look up "Gated Institutional Narrative" if you want to know more.

[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Sep 19 12.04pm

Originally posted by W12

"Hate crime" has always been manipulative and insidious since it was introduced. There have been laws against discrimination for years. It's a way of suppressing the negative effects of mass immigration and large scale social engineering (e.g. the continued assault on the traditional family unit). The definition of "hate" and the way these statistics are collected can be changed at will to suit whatever narrative you want.

People fall for this because they are not rational beings but believe what they are told. Very few are even prepared top read below a headline these days let alone check on the facts behind what they are being told.

I know as that used to be me. Realizing you were being conned all of your life is not a pleasant experience but a necessary one.

Look up "Gated Institutional Narrative" if you want to know more.

[Link]

Just read that articled well argued. It sums up how I feel as I am on the right of centre of politics but I do not like being lumped in with the far right. Just because I oppose open door immigration does not make me a racist. Some people rarely bother to listen further that I am in favour of controlled immigration based on job skills, no they have already decided I am against immigration full stop.


Edited by Badger11 (02 Sep 2019 12.05pm)

 


One more point

dannyboy1978 Flag 02 Sep 19 1.06pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Just read that articled well argued. It sums up how I feel as I am on the right of centre of politics but I do not like being lumped in with the far right. Just because I oppose open door immigration does not make me a racist. Some people rarely bother to listen further that I am in favour of controlled immigration based on job skills, no they have already decided I am against immigration full stop.


Edited by Badger11 (02 Sep 2019 12.05pm)

Well put. Basically to much of a good thing is not good for anyone. The left don't understand this and go straight for the "your just a rascist "

 

W12 02 Sep 19 1.34pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Just read that articled well argued. It sums up how I feel as I am on the right of centre of politics but I do not like being lumped in with the far right. Just because I oppose open door immigration does not make me a racist. Some people rarely bother to listen further that I am in favour of controlled immigration based on job skills, no they have already decided I am against immigration full stop.


Edited by Badger11 (02 Sep 2019 12.05pm)

On the subject of immigration it's just complete taboo to even discuss this in either the MSM or even in daily life. You are immediately in trouble with the thought police twitter mob, headline writers, femi-nazi presenters etc.

I don't want to subvert this thread but nobody can seem to answer the relevant questions related to this.

1. What happens to those immigrants when the welfare state collapses or are you expecting the tax burden or public borrowing just to increase forever?

2. Are you happy to import people only to be used as wage slaves in the gig economy?

3. What happens when these jobs are automated (they are low hanging fruit for this).

4. Are you happy to import people from the 3rd world that have skills that are important in their country of origin (e.g. doctors and nurses, engineers).

5. How is mass immigration help with your current perceived environment/emissions crisis? Bearing in mind people from the 3rd world will have a carbon footprint at least 10x on average less and earn possibly 20x of what they do in their country of origin just sitting on UK welfare.

6. What does "diversity is our strength" mean? We are not and never were a "nation of immigrants".

By the way, ignore the figures because categorizing an immigrant as an EU citizen no longer means they ride a bicycle and are called Pierre. If you use your own eyes in our major cities you can see where these people are coming from.

The statistics are cooked, the social and economic impact is ignored and actively surpressed and like the EU (Maastricht, Lisbon) nobody ever voted for it.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Sep 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by W12

On the subject of immigration it's just complete taboo to even discuss this in either the MSM or even in daily life. You are immediately in trouble with the thought police twitter mob, headline writers, femi-nazi presenters etc.

I don't want to subvert this thread but nobody can seem to answer the relevant questions related to this.

1. What happens to those immigrants when the welfare state collapses or are you expecting the tax burden or public borrowing just to increase forever?

2. Are you happy to import people only to be used as wage slaves in the gig economy?

3. What happens when these jobs are automated (they are low hanging fruit for this).

4. Are you happy to import people from the 3rd world that have skills that are important in their country of origin (e.g. doctors and nurses, engineers).

5. How is mass immigration help with your current perceived environment/emissions crisis? Bearing in mind people from the 3rd world will have a carbon footprint at least 10x on average less and earn possibly 20x of what they do in their country of origin just sitting on UK welfare.

6. What does "diversity is our strength" mean? We are not and never were a "nation of immigrants".

By the way, ignore the figures because categorizing an immigrant as an EU citizen no longer means they ride a bicycle and are called Pierre. If you use your own eyes in our major cities you can see where these people are coming from.

The statistics are cooked, the social and economic impact is ignored and actively surpressed and like the EU (Maastricht, Lisbon) nobody ever voted for it.

One of my current concerns. I am happy to invite high skilled workers to the UK although as you correctly say we are robbing other countries. Low skilled workers are not what we need we have enough of our own and as automation kicks in they are going to be out of a job.

However I am not dogmatic about this if sectors of the economy can show that they need foreign workers and that they are prepared to financially support them rather than the taxpayer I would be okay with that. I don't believe that the taxpayer should be subsiding McCoffee jobs just so those companies can make a big profits which they book in the Cayman Islands.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Sep 19 3.41pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Just read that articled well argued. It sums up how I feel as I am on the right of centre of politics but I do not like being lumped in with the far right. Just because I oppose open door immigration does not make me a racist. Some people rarely bother to listen further that I am in favour of controlled immigration based on job skills, no they have already decided I am against immigration full stop.


Edited by Badger11 (02 Sep 2019 12.05pm)

What do you regard as 'racist'? Self interest isn't 'racist'....That's the language and thought processes of the left, which exist nowhere else in the world.

'Controlled immigration' ends up with the same result with just a bit more delay built in.

Unless you have an immigration policy like Japan's.....Which essentially refuses citizenship to foreigners.....Then all you are doing is waving goodbye to European hegemony within European lands with an egg timer attached.....Powell was right.

A hundred years ago Japan looked Japanese....Now it looks Japanese. In another hundred years it will still be Japanese.....No external based terror attacks or 'feminism' or concerns about 'racism'......You know why....the communists were sidelined in Japan after the war...rather violently as it happens and their pro immigration stance has meant they have never made headway.

It's the 'controlled immigration' myths which have already done for this country.....The birth rates and previous immigration rates have already set replacement in stone.

In the meantime you don't like being called a 'racist'.

I'm sure your great grandchildren will really be concerned about that one.


Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Sep 2019 3.49pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Sep 19 7.02pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

What do you regard as 'racist'? Self interest isn't 'racist'....That's the language and thought processes of the left, which exist nowhere else in the world.

'Controlled immigration' ends up with the same result with just a bit more delay built in.

Unless you have an immigration policy like Japan's.....Which essentially refuses citizenship to foreigners.....Then all you are doing is waving goodbye to European hegemony within European lands with an egg timer attached.....Powell was right.

A hundred years ago Japan looked Japanese....Now it looks Japanese. In another hundred years it will still be Japanese.....No external based terror attacks or 'feminism' or concerns about 'racism'......You know why....the communists were sidelined in Japan after the war...rather violently as it happens and their pro immigration stance has meant they have never made headway.

It's the 'controlled immigration' myths which have already done for this country.....The birth rates and previous immigration rates have already set replacement in stone.

In the meantime you don't like being called a 'racist'.

I'm sure your great grandchildren will really be concerned about that one.


Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Sep 2019 3.49pm)

Come on danh.
Put your 3 words on this.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Sep 19 7.12pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Come on danh.
Put your 3 words on this.

He's reclining back in his armchair listening to his Stormzy album in his stab proof vest and 'F Boris' slippers.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Sep 2019 7.13pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 03 Sep 19 3.29pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Just read that articled well argued. It sums up how I feel as I am on the right of centre of politics but I do not like being lumped in with the far right. Just because I oppose open door immigration does not make me a racist. Some people rarely bother to listen further that I am in favour of controlled immigration based on job skills, no they have already decided I am against immigration full stop.


Edited by Badger11 (02 Sep 2019 12.05pm)

Well said. It's a very common view. Most people aren't averse to 'some' immigration as long as it's needed in specific industries. Beyond that, there seems to be this idea in some quarters that if you're non white and are born here, you've been given some kind of special access to a club and should be eternally grateful for it. No, if you're born here and see this as your country then this is your home as much as it is mine. If you happen to be non white that's a total irrelevance.

And leading on from that, I agree, that if we need vacancies filled because we don't have the talent in this area or that, yes bring in individuals talented enough to fill those roles. Ideally as a nation we'd have structures and training in place to ensure that we don't even have to do that, so that can be done in tandem, but if all we care about in the decision making process is a person's race rather than their abilities and character, then I don't see that as a positive by any means.

Where I do diverge slightly, is that I don't really prescribe to an opinion that the economy has to endlessly grow and grow anyway. That will always benefit corporations and be their goal, but won't really make much difference to the average man on the streets life. So from that perspective, I don't think we ever 'need' much immigration anyway. Issues like the housing crisis and indeed those caused by mass immigration in the first place could possibly benefit from something approaching a pause in immigration. With possible exceptions in areas of real need, where training is currently lagging.

Edited by dollardays (03 Sep 2019 3.55pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Sep 19 4.21pm

We have to deal with reality in terms of immigration.....Not acceptance or agreement perhaps but reality.

Replacement to minority status for whites in England and then onto the wider UK is set in stone. This will mean gradual 'frog in the water' but still huge and permanent cultural and hegemonic shifts in power as we move forward.....first in England as we already see in our cities and then onto the UK and Ireland at large. Birth rates mean that it is only a matter of time.

There is power....those that have it and those that don't. The only demographic in the world that is particularly tolerant of minorities is European.....altruism in a global world ultimately leads to the disappearance of your own group genetics....The East Asians were intelligent enough to understand this.

The only European demographics not concerned for the future are 'normies' who think that elites have their backs....or those who don't value the European identity or those wealthy enough to ultimately move to where the going is always the best.....their kids won't have to deal with the higher crime and violence rates and the social incohesion and rising anti white culture that will emerge.

Lots of people want to know what they can do about this and what the best steps are to take if they aren't looking forward to the nitty gritty of what this actually entails......Not the warm worded, philosophical, head in the clouds 'nothing to see here' that some will sell you.

The way I see it....unless something dramatic happens...which I don't foresee, this country is already lost. I saw an interview with Peter Hitchens the other day and his advice to anyone under thirty was to get out of the country.

That's something I see happening and quickening in pace as we move forward. White flight will move less from UK population areas and more to leaving the country.....as the brain drain occurs the competing for lowering resources isn't going to be pretty...hope that your kids don't stick around for that.

As to where?

Again...unless there is a change in direction...due to EU politics this will also happen all over Europe....apart from hold out countries. Still, once some critical loss has been reached there will at some point there will be a European state, which like Israel and East Asian countries will have real and maintained rules to protect the hegemony of that population. When that time comes that's the future.....But I don't see it until around 2050 personally.

But I very much doubt that the left will be welcome.

In the meantime, it's just try to live as far away from the cities as is economically possible.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Sep 2019 4.36pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hate Speech