This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
At this point I genuinely don't understand why we're not putting most of our eggs in the academy basket seeing as we clearly don't want to spend any money. I've looked enviously at Chelsea this season who have integrated three academy prospects into their first team and watched them score every one of their league goals so far. Granted they had little option due to their transfer ban but we've pretty much had a self-imposed ban for the last couple of seasons. Instead of spunking another £30m on a Benteke, imagine what you could do to the academy for half of that money and the rewards it could potentially reap. Our best two players in the last ten years have both been academy products and will eventually be sold for a combined fee of £130m+. We must have one of the oldest average first teams in the league and it really feels stale at times. There are definitely positions (forward, wings, full backs) where we need reinforcements so I really don't see the harm in testing some academy products there. Unfortunately, I feel it would take a manager who isn't scared to try them there unless his hand is forced (AWB). Don't know about you lot but I would be far more forgiving about us losing games if there were enthusiastic youngsters in the team giving it a go. People always go on about the incredible size of our catchment area, time to test it. Money is being invested into the Academy so that it can achieve Category 1 status. Having better facilities doesn’t come with any guarantees but will at least get the club closer to competitors for young players. You reference Zaha and AWB as examples of what an academy can produce. But then look at the time elapsed between the two - nearly ten years apart ! My point being that there are no guarantees or quick fixes here. Moses and Clyne also graduated of course but in times where the route to the first team was more quickly achievable . You are advocating sticking youngsters into the first team for the sake of it. Not factoring in whether they are ready , good enough or better than the senior pros being selected. That’s just unrealistic at this level. Or even further down the leagues , look at Bolton - forced into playing kids that aren’t really up to it . Yes, Chelsea have got three former youth team players in their side currently but that club has formerly been no friend of developing young talent and indeed their transfer ban is in relation to breaking rules involving signing young foreign players under the age of eighteen.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
A guy I work with is semi pro and in his mid 20's - He is of the opinion that there are hundreds of young players good enough to play in the Premier League (himself included - I don't believe him), but they simply don't get a chance. He played against AWB in a pre season friendly at the start of last season and claims to have bossed him and won a penalty off him. My point is that I believe him to an extent and AWB is an example of someone who got a game due a freak injury list and 18 months later was bought for £50m by one of the biggest clubs in the world. If Ward didn't get injured he'd probably be in the academy still or loan to a league 1 club. I remember seeing Hirem Boateng come on near the end away at Swansea about 3 years ago and thought he was awesome, but we never really saw him again. I can't think of any youngster at Palace who's played in the first team and really looked out of their depth. We're established now and are not realistic relegation candidates. Its about time we stopped buying journeymen on high salaries like McCarthy and Cahill (played well to be fair) and started to promote some youth into the first team. There’s a world of difference between getting a chance in the first team and actually holding down a regular place. Yes, Boateng looked decent when he came on.....where is he now ? How about John Bostock.....looked to have it all but had his head turned.... It is harder than ever for a player to come though the ranks into the first team, not just at Palace. But if they are good enough and their coaches - the likes of Richard Shaw - push the Manager - then they may just get a chance. From reading the interview with Shaw it appears that in his view he doesn’t have a player that he can put forward for first team consideration
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
Gary Borrowdale Gary Stebbing too
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
There’s a world of difference between getting a chance in the first team and actually holding down a regular place. Yes, Boateng looked decent when he came on.....where is he now ? How about John Bostock.....looked to have it all but had his head turned.... It is harder than ever for a player to come though the ranks into the first team, not just at Palace. But if they are good enough and their coaches - the likes of Richard Shaw - push the Manager - then they may just get a chance. From reading the interview with Shaw it appears that in his view he doesn’t have a player that he can put forward for first team consideration This is exactly my point - he didn't get a run in the team which is why he's now out on loan at a lower league team. It's no good giving someone 20 minutes, they need at least 5/6 games to see if they can swim. All Premier League teams would rather pay big bucks for an unknown foreign player then risk a youngster. Hence why all our decent youngsters are now playing in the Bundesliga. Bostock would have made it if he'd stayed at Palace rather than stunting his growth chasing the big money at Spurs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
This is exactly my point - he didn't get a run in the team which is why he's now out on loan at a lower league team. It's no good giving someone 20 minutes, they need at least 5/6 games to see if they can swim. All Premier League teams would rather pay big bucks for an unknown foreign player then risk a youngster. Hence why all our decent youngsters are now playing in the Bundesliga. Bostock would have made it if he'd stayed at Palace rather than stunting his growth chasing the big money at Spurs. My point is that Boateng didn’t do enough to justify that run. A decent 20 minute cameo is not enough. He went to Plymouth where after making a good initial impression, he struggled. You said it yourself - PL teams see it as a risk playing young players making it harder for them to break through but I would argue that the financial stakes are higher than the Budesliga hence the reluctance. And come on, it’s not ALL of our decent youngsters. I’d love to see a Palace team built around home grown talent but the way football is at the moment it’s hard to see that happening and not necessarily the fault of the club or the manager.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
This is exactly my point - he didn't get a run in the team which is why he's now out on loan at a lower league team. It's no good giving someone 20 minutes, they need at least 5/6 games to see if they can swim. If I remember rightly Hiram Boateng was released a couple of seasons ago and joined Exeter
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
If I remember rightly Hiram Boateng was released a couple of seasons ago and joined Exeter Exactly. If he was so good how come he hasn't pulled up trees at a lower club where he would get playing time. We get this a lot complaints that young players don't get a chance at a PL club get released and then drift out of football. Football is not just about skill you also need determination or sheer bloodymindedness. Vinnie Jones was never a great player but he had those qualities. If you get released or transferred the correct response is to show them on the pitch they were wrong and if this means you drop down to a lower standard so be it.
One more point |
|
|
Hi, know I'm a few days late here but I was at this media event at the academy so might be able to shed some light on the quotes (was myself from the SLP, the Standard, Football London and the Athletic). That quote was meant in the context that - statistically - the reality is that young players are unlikely to make it at the club. It was a kind of "go and prove me wrong" type thing. It's not that he has completely written off their chances of ever playing football. To add to what someone else said, yeah Shaw always comes across really well. I've done a few interviews with him before and he's really interesting on a range of subjects. Originally posted by Bangell
"The harsh reality is, the guys that are here now are not going to make it at Crystal Palace, they are not going to make it in the Premier League. It is tough, it is hard. They might make it in League One, Two or the National League." Absolutely extraordinary to read this. I do hope he meant to say "most of them aren't going to make it", not that he has no hope in any of his current players being of any value to our club in the PL.
[Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Kian Flanagan was outspoken but made some really important points about U23 football. I wrote a piece slightly different to the Standard and included a few more quotes from Lewis Bryon, Nya Kirby and Gio McGregor. Bryon spoke about the U23 "bubble" and the sense that you can become too comfortable if you are not getting out on loan. You can find that here: [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by smitherscpfc
Kian Flanagan was outspoken but made some really important points about U23 football. I wrote a piece slightly different to the Standard and included a few more quotes from Lewis Bryon, Nya Kirby and Gio McGregor. Bryon spoke about the U23 "bubble" and the sense that you can become too comfortable if you are not getting out on loan. You can find that here: [Link] That's a really good piece. Well done. it makes sense now Flanagan talking about 'we'. in another article with the same quotes, it talked only about him...Which made it seem like he was discussing the royal we. The club needs to be far more proactive and creative about giving these players the experiences they need. We should buy a little club in Europe and ship them off there for 1st team football.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
That's a really good piece. Well done. it makes sense now Flanagan talking about 'we'. in another article with the same quotes, it talked only about him...Which made it seem like he was discussing the royal we. The club needs to be far more proactive and creative about giving these players the experiences they need. We should buy a little club in Europe and ship them off there for 1st team football. Thanks! Kian was the most vocal so perhaps the temptation among other organisations was to just go with his quotes. The problem with that is his use of 'we', while not mentioning the fact that there were six of them sat there, make him sound arrogant. I can vouch for the fact that he was the complete opposite and just clearly had something he wanted to get off his chest. On your final point, the topic of the club having a feeder to whom they can send players on loan came up but quotes are embargoed until the October international break.
[Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
You wonder if AWB was one who "wont make it here" first you have to be good enough to train and stand out with the first team squad, you have to earn the right. when your a prem club the youngsters need to be exceptionall. hopefully the new set up can attract better young players.
|
|
|
So why don't Palace send them out on loan after complaining about it??
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
So why don't Palace send them out on loan after complaining about it?? Bare in mind that you can't SEND players out on loan, whey have to be wants by another club, and also agree to go.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
The idea that AWB fluked his way into the first team and Roy "was forced" to take a chance on him is really funny. Most young players get their chance when a senior player gets injured. Bear in mind Roy had been at the club about 6 mths at the time and he didn't feature in de Boer's total football revolution. This. Also, AWB had made the bench as long ago as under Allardyce and played in the Asia Trophy under De Boer. He was always extremely highly rated. Most players who play for the first team have played several seasons of U23 football (see also: Woods and Dreher), AWB had been around that environment and the first team environment for a few years before he debuted. The idea that he came from absolutely nowhere is wrong.
[Tweet Link]
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.