This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Johng
Nobody has said they hate anybody. These are the weekly wages for the following. Are they really providing value for money. These salaries are a massive drain on the club's finances. Max Meyer £125,000 Edited by Johng (09 Mar 2020 10.54am) they are not providing VFM (i would include Wilf and his 130k in that list too) With our high wages and ageing squad it will take 2 years or so to make significant changes. It doesn't help when SP gives Wickham, Takkers and Tomkins early new contracts too. Why not wait a little?? This end of season i can see Dann being released but there are not many others out of contract. Edited by palace99 (09 Mar 2020 4.03pm)
|
|
|
well said, I always stood up for Ayew as I do for benteke, its just about reading the players, being with a coach like mind and think what can we do to improve this player. Ayew admitted hes given a free reign, how many saw he was playing almost right back in first half, if was so the watford defender was unsure when to pick him up... Originally posted by Fatherken
here we go again
|
|
|
Originally posted by A1969Eagle
well said, I always stood up for Ayew as I do for benteke, its just about reading the players, being with a coach like mind and think what can we do to improve this player. Ayew admitted hes given a free reign, how many saw he was playing almost right back in first half, if was so the watford defender was unsure when to pick him up... Ayew has admitted he was overweight last season and that's why he wasn't great (which he wasn't). Bentenke would need to score 25 goals next season or be an assist machine of de Bruyne levels to make his cost seem even close to good value; nevertheless, I have always maintained there is a good player still in there but I don't think you can blame the coaches that this player has been unable to show himself for the best part of two years. On Peter Crouch's podcast he talked about how Pulis only really coached the defensive part of the game and essentially left the creative players to do their thing. You get the feeling this is probably also true of Roy to an extent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Johng
I'd be interested to see what people think on this subject. For me it would be. Benteke (form and wages) Oh and Wilf, of course (he's going anyway) Edited by Johng (08 Mar 2020 10.49pm) I’d keep Luka for the time being (unless Everton want to offer us £20 Million again) but I agree with you about the rest. Too much money being paid in wages to keep persevering with Benteke, Sakho & Meyer and Hennessey just not good enough and I too would take an up and coming youngster like MUFC have unearthed with Dean Henderson.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Max Meyer's alleged wages have been brought up quite a few times as no-one seems to know where this figure has come from. My understanding is that it's about half of what you quoted. Why is that your understanding? I have seen many claims that it is 125.000 and none that it is 60.000.
No buying fee, but 6.5 million on 4 years, making a total cost of 26 million!! Not played for this money.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Why is that your understanding? I have seen many claims that it is 125.000 and none that it is 60.000.
No buying fee, but 6.5 million on 4 years, making a total cost of 26 million!! Not played for this money. Other claims say £60k. Not much point in arguing about it if we don’t actually know.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
For me the jury is out on Bentenke. If he can play like has in the last few games then he is worth keeping around for one more year. Sakho just seems unable to stay fit and so I would reluctantly listen to offers given his age. Personally I think if Meyer is happy to stay then I can still see him having a future at the club, but he may not have that patience now that Roy will be with us for another year. Luka looked better in 20 minutes on Saturday than he has looked for a long time, so maybe he just needed a break and some competition to shake the cobwebs off. He is still probably the best long passer of the ball and on his day is probably our best central midfielder. Like a number of players it's all about whether he can get back to his old self. A year ago most of us would have happily accepted Riedewald leaving, but now many of us want him to get more of a chance. Like Meyer it may all come down to patience. Wayne is fine as number two. We're too small a club to attract a better GK to sit on the bench in my opinion. To be honest, there is no one I'd be happy to see leave, especially given how small our squad is. A big factor will be who we bring in. I agree with this and the other posts which worry about who is coming in if we are offloading. I would avoid clearing out too many even when bringing in replacements as without some sort of handover you get a bit of a void. The older heads are worth having on their way out to keep the club culture and spirit etc. That said, I would probably reluctantly agree with not renewing Sakho's contract at the end and listening to offers, but we really would need to get some cbs of the future lined up as ours are all towards the end of their lifespan. Of course goes without saying Wickham and Sorloth are dead wood and it would make almost no difference to the club if they ceased to exist so they can go if you can find anyone mad enough to take them off our hands, although I guess with Sorloth we do have potential bidders.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
The squad is small so I wouldn't want to lose too many. The centre backs as a whole are getting pretty old - there's a good chance we could lose Cahill and Dann summer after this when they'll be 34 and 35 by which point Tomkins will be 32 so you'd want to get a younger centre half in to that group this summer. Sakho makes most sense to go - paid the most, plays the least, and you'll get a club take him just for the name. Shame because he's clearly so talented, but he's a (barely) walking injury. The Max Meyer square peg thing is obvious, you'd likely get some money for him. He is one of the younger ones in a fairly old midfield group though which makes me reluctant. Would actually keep WH. He's no Guaita but he's looked alright when he's stepped in this season and was good competition last. Getting a young keeper in is all well and good but for every 1 Henderson there's 20 Scott Flinders. Can't see anyone stumping up the cash for Wilf. Could well be Wickham's summer if we can get another forward in and I don't expect to see Sorloth again. Then bringing in you're looking at, ideally all under the age of 26, - CB (Need) That'd be a great summer. The squad is also old in football terms with the following players currently in their 30s or will be later this year : Ward,Cahill,Tomkins,Dann,Kouyate,McArthur,Sakho,Benteke,McCarthy,Kelly,Van Aanholt. I think the club will try to offload some of the older players from the list above and also Wickham.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Johng
Max Meyer £125,000 Edited by Johng (09 Mar 2020 10.54am) Out of these three, I'm embarrassed to say that I would keep Benteke ahead of Meyer and Sakho. Sakho is injured 90% of the time. Meyer rarely plays, and when he does, he isn't very good. Benteke isn't good, but at least he's always healthy.
2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Out of these three, I'm embarrassed to say that I would keep Benteke ahead of Meyer and Sakho. Sakho is injured 90% of the time. Meyer rarely plays, and when he does, he isn't very good. Benteke isn't good, but at least he's always healthy. Challenge that. Most times he's come on I think he's picked up the energy, got on the ball and made things happen. Wilf certainly perks up when Meyer comes on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Rubbish. Hennessy a quality prem keeper and a great option at #2. Meyer gives something different and changed the game regularly when he enters the fray. Sakho our most talented defender when fit. Needs a chance to get back to that. Luka. Doesn't even deserve a reply. Benteke - starting to show some great form.
Only people i'd consider moving on are Dann and Townsend. Love them both, but they need to be playing. I agree with most of what you say except Meyer. I would go as far as saying he shouldnt even be in the squad. He has done absolutely nothing for us since he has arrived. I am shocked at how poor he has been. Im not sure how long is left on Dann's contract but id like to see him stay longer. Townsend- I really like him but I don't think he would be massively missed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Rubbish. Hennessy a quality prem keeper and a great option at #2. hahahahahahahah He is a good player in my opinion, however he doesn't fit into Hodgesdon's style of playing, I think he was added to the squad to play the deep role that Cabaye Played so well, so if you compare him to Cabaye you see his short comings in that position.
Cahill is head and shoulders above any other defender at the club. Sakho when fit is good cover for Tomkins nothing else. Luka. Doesn't even deserve a reply. Have you watched his performances this season ? He has been savagely average at best all season and got torn a new one by Moy at home to the weed. Pace is letting him down, and to a certain degree McArthur is mopping up his errors. Benteke - starting to show some great form. Agreed, the withdrawn number 9 role suits him better.
Only if it betters what we have Only people i'd consider moving on are Dann and Townsend. Love them both, but they need to be playing. Dann and Townsend are you actually mental sorry mate but that's crazy talk.
|
|
|
We shouldn’t offload any we’re going to need a big squad for the Champions League next season 🤪
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dannyh.V2
Dann and Townsend are you actually mental sorry mate but that's crazy talk. I can see us selling Dann because we’d get some money for him before getting nothing for him. I can see this happening for virtually all our players as long as the powers that be feel the price is okay, and they can work with what they have or get new faces in with what they have. Unfortunately I wouldn’t be confident of us doing that or being able to do it well enough anyway. Cahill fell in our lap remember. He knew Roy but if he didn’t want to stay down south where I expect his children are at school and growing up he might be elsewhere. We are just not bringing any money in and they’re not going to turn offers down from now on imo. They probably look at Luca and wish they courted the £20 mil Everton interest. The sooner fans get used to accounts, spreadsheets and Freedman, who doesn’t appear to work in harmony with Roy, deciding transfers and the squad, the better for their anger levels come deadline day. I wouldn’t go as far as asset stripping but a lot of decisions will be financially based. There has been attempts to sign younger players to slowly turn the squad age into a more sustainable one long term so at least they realise it before addressing it. I doubt we’ll see any of our academy stars now Parish is removing the barrier to them getting in the team lol. What does he take us for?
COYP |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I can see us selling Dann because we’d get some money for him before getting nothing for him. I can see this happening for virtually all our players as long as the powers that be feel the price is okay, and they can work with what they have or get new faces in with what they have. Unfortunately I wouldn’t be confident of us doing that or being able to do it well enough anyway. Cahill fell in our lap remember. He knew Roy but if he didn’t want to stay down south where I expect his children are at school and growing up he might be elsewhere. We are just not bringing any money in and they’re not going to turn offers down from now on imo. They probably look at Luca and wish they courted the £20 mil Everton interest. The sooner fans get used to accounts, spreadsheets and Freedman, who doesn’t appear to work in harmony with Roy, deciding transfers and the squad, the better for their anger levels come deadline day. I wouldn’t go as far as asset stripping but a lot of decisions will be financially based. There has been attempts to sign younger players to slowly turn the squad age into a more sustainable one long term so at least they realise it before addressing it. I doubt we’ll see any of our academy stars now Parish is removing the barrier to them getting in the team lol. What does he take us for?
About 10 players are out of contract in 2021
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
About 10 players are out of contract in 2021
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.