You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 22 2026 1.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rhian Brewster (rumour) (LOCKED)


Page 2 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
mattteo Flag 18 Aug 20 9.11pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Surely £20 million will secure him ? Maddison and Maupay went for that previously. Nothing seems to of changed, including us seeming to dick about to secure these type of players.

Edited by Booted Eagle (18 Aug 2020 8.49pm)

I think 18 million would secure him, cause that's the clause, but it's a question of salary bidding between a few Premier League clubs.

However, 18 million seems huge to me for a Championship player. Patrik Schick is playing in a Champions League semifinal tonight, is the same age as Watkins, and costs 22 million.

As a comparison, you don't even need to look further than a wikipedia page.

Schick has 35 goals in 122 matches in the top leagues in Italy, Germany and for the national team.

[Link]

Watkins has 45 goals in 132 matches at secondary level for Brentford.

[Link]

Edited by mattteo (18 Aug 2020 9.46pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Aug 20 10.59am

Originally posted by mattteo

I think 18 million would secure him, cause that's the clause, but it's a question of salary bidding between a few Premier League clubs.

However, 18 million seems huge to me for a Championship player. Patrik Schick is playing in a Champions League semifinal tonight, is the same age as Watkins, and costs 22 million.

As a comparison, you don't even need to look further than a wikipedia page.

Schick has 35 goals in 122 matches in the top leagues in Italy, Germany and for the national team.

[Link]

Watkins has 45 goals in 132 matches at secondary level for Brentford.

[Link]

Edited by mattteo (18 Aug 2020 9.46pm)

Why would someone who is currently playing for Champions League semi finalists come and sign for us?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Aug 20 11.09am

Yes, that was my question

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 19 Aug 20 11.09am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Why would someone who is currently playing for Champions League semi finalists come and sign for us?

Is the correct question to ask

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 19 Aug 20 11.33am

Originally posted by mattteo


Thanks. But something is not correct about Zaha. They probably have an error or didn't count the entire seasons and stopped somewhere. You can see Zaha's data misses a lot from Fraser's.

He definitely had more than 2 clearances the entire season, he played in almost every match and defended at every set piece.


No, Sofascore have it about the same. [Link]

They say he made 0.1 clearances per game which, over 38 games, would make 3.8 (give or take). That would tally with the 4 combined clearances on the PL website. They actually have his season heatmap on there as well and, as you can see, he barely entered our box so it's unsurprising really.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 07 Sep 20 4.32pm

Could be on the market for sale. 20m in the telegraph. I would actually like to see us go for someone like this. Would not be on silly money and could be good for us. Did well for Swansea, however would be a gamble.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 07 Sep 20 10.10pm

Not as safe a bet as Batshuayi - but I would be delighted with Brewster. Could be a superstar in the making and the most instinctive goal scorer we’ve been linked with imo. Amazed if Liverpool do actually sell him,

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Sep 20 10.14pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

Not as safe a bet as Batshuayi - but I would be delighted with Brewster. Could be a superstar in the making and the most instinctive goal scorer we’ve been linked with imo. Amazed if Liverpool do actually sell him,

There must be a catch if Liverpool have gone from “ we don’t want to loan him as we want him in 1st team squad” to “ he is yours for 20m” doesn’t ring true

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 07 Sep 20 11.02pm

Personally I’d prefer someone different from either Bats or Brewster. Bats is perhaps the player most likely to be ready to play at his peak so I’d prefer him and he also has proven he can score at this level. Brewster still has a lot to prove at this level. Be a huge gamble to pay 20m for him. Loan would be great.

Either way I’d be more excited if we were after someone around 24 and already having played and scored in a top league.

 

mattteo Flag 07 Sep 20 11.29pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

There must be a catch if Liverpool have gone from “ we don’t want to loan him as we want him in 1st team squad” to “ he is yours for 20m” doesn’t ring true

20 million for someone at his age ckming from a team like Liverpool is not a huge fee. I also think something is wrong here.

I mean, they were asking 28-30 million for 23 year old Harry Wilson a few months ago and wouldn't even think about selling Ben Woodburn. Why Brewster?

Still, at 20 million and rather similar age to Josh Maja, I think I'd rather go for the latter. But Brewster deserves a close inspection. If only this position weren't the most important one at Palace...then we could have patience with a 20 year old to develop. But the club desperately needs a proven center forwardm

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 08 Sep 20 6.18am

Aston Villa now interested in signing Brewster with Manager, Dean Smith , having already reportedly approached Liverpool FC: [Link]

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Sep 20 8.03am

Originally posted by mattteo

20 million for someone at his age ckming from a team like Liverpool is not a huge fee. I also think something is wrong here.

I mean, they were asking 28-30 million for 23 year old Harry Wilson a few months ago and wouldn't even think about selling Ben Woodburn. Why Brewster?

Still, at 20 million and rather similar age to Josh Maja, I think I'd rather go for the latter. But Brewster deserves a close inspection. If only this position weren't the most important one at Palace...then we could have patience with a 20 year old to develop. But the club desperately needs a proven center forwardm


Exactly - the conundrum, we'd love a young CF that has potential but NEED a proven goal scorer. When Premier league survival is at stake, I daren't look beyond the proven one.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Sep 20 8.03am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Aston Villa now interested in signing Brewster with Manager, Dean Smith , having already reportedly approached Liverpool FC: [Link]


They're as desperate as us!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Sep 20 8.21am

Originally posted by mattteo

20 million for someone at his age ckming from a team like Liverpool is not a huge fee. I also think something is wrong here.

I mean, they were asking 28-30 million for 23 year old Harry Wilson a few months ago and wouldn't even think about selling Ben Woodburn. Why Brewster?

Still, at 20 million and rather similar age to Josh Maja, I think I'd rather go for the latter. But Brewster deserves a close inspection. If only this position weren't the most important one at Palace...then we could have patience with a 20 year old to develop. But the club desperately needs a proven center forwardm

Me too

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 08 Sep 20 8.46am

I agree with most of what’s been said here. But for a young striker coming into Palace he has to be aware that he can’t fail to be better than what we already have (or rather don’t have) so even a modest return in his first season would see us lot full of appreciation and must fill his m with confidence. I think he’d be terrific for us but am myself suspiciously thinking “what’s the catch”?

I agree that Maja would also be a good choice and (shrewd piece of business) he is the type of player we used to pick up for peanuts from the periphery of other clubs and turn into household names, (Armstrong, Morrison, AJ etc). I think he’d do very well for us and has proven track record at different levels and leagues.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Sep 20 8.59am

The 20m fee could just be made up by someone, as it is not a figure directly quoted from a Liverpool source. They see him day in, day out against PL players, so there is also the possibility they don't think he is quite good enough; they do have a history of getting good fees for young players who do not match the bill (Solanke and Ibe come to mind). However, I think most likely is they don't want to sell him and he'll go out on loan, probably to Villa.

 

jeeagles Flag 08 Sep 20 10.55am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Me too

Every game in front of an empty stadium probably costs them around £2m to £3m per game.

Big clubs might have to change their loan policies to make up for the short term losses.

 

elky30 Flag Clapham 08 Sep 20 1.50pm

Liverpool are considering letting him leave permanetly

[Link]

Surely this is the exact kind of striker we should be going for, young, quick, great finisher.
Dont like the idea of a buy back clause but if you put it at double of what you buy for i would be happy.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 08 Sep 20 2.10pm

Originally posted by elky30

Liverpool are considering letting him leave permanetly

[Link]

Surely this is the exact kind of striker we should be going for, young, quick, great finisher.
Dont like the idea of a buy back clause but if you put it at double of what you buy for i would be happy.

That is proper sneaky. So Liverpool sell him for £20m and get the money in to fund other players. Yet, if Brewster hits it big time then they get to buy him back......probably at fee nowhere near the market value if he has really succeed.

You would have to be a mug to go for that kind of deal.

Wait for an incoming Palace bid then.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Sep 20 6.08am

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear


That is proper sneaky. So Liverpool sell him for £20m and get the money in to fund other players. Yet, if Brewster hits it big time then they get to buy him back......probably at fee nowhere near the market value if he has really succeed.

Isn't what we are trying to do with Sorloth equally sneaky?

 

Page 2 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic