You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hennessey


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 17 Oct 20 7.19pm

Originally posted by Swindy

The biggest problem for Wayne Hennessey has been that he is not Guaita or Speroni. A large chunk of the fanbase fail to notice Guaita making mistakes which have cost a significant number of points, particularly in recent home games. There were a lot also who watched Speroni's final games through rose-tinted specs, great clubman, blah blah blah etc etc, but past his best, flapping at good number of balls, often worth a goal to the opposition.
Similar mistakes which Hennessey was and would be completely crucified for on here. He could though teach the other two a thing or two about kicking properly.

And in exchange the other two could teach him how to save the ball.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 17 Oct 20 7.54pm

Wayne is better than Butland no question

 

Robk Flag 17 Oct 20 8.43pm

You ARE joking of course...&#128515;

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Oct 20 11.40pm

Originally posted by Swindy

The biggest problem for Wayne Hennessey has been that he is not Guaita or Speroni. A large chunk of the fanbase fail to notice Guaita making mistakes which have cost a significant number of points, particularly in recent home games. There were a lot also who watched Speroni's final games through rose-tinted specs, great clubman, blah blah blah etc etc, but past his best, flapping at good number of balls, often worth a goal to the opposition.
Similar mistakes which Hennessey was and would be completely crucified for on here. He could though teach the other two a thing or two about kicking properly.

All keepers make mistakes the difference is how many games the good ones like Guaita win you. I can only think of Sheffield Utd and the dead rubbers against Burnley and Leicester last season.


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Oct 20 1.18am

Originally posted by Swindy

The biggest problem for Wayne Hennessey has been that he is not Guaita or Speroni. A large chunk of the fanbase fail to notice Guaita making mistakes which have cost a significant number of points, particularly in recent home games. There were a lot also who watched Speroni's final games through rose-tinted specs, great clubman, blah blah blah etc etc, but past his best, flapping at good number of balls, often worth a goal to the opposition.
Similar mistakes which Hennessey was and would be completely crucified for on here. He could though teach the other two a thing or two about kicking properly.

His kicking is outstanding and is a big plus. For a big chap I’ve never felt he controls his box enough but he is a good keeper. Far better than Butland at the moment but then poor Jack isn’t what he was. Maybe he will grow back into a special keeper but I believe it will take time. I hope Guaita can avoid injury for many months.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 18 Oct 20 7.21am

Originally posted by Swindy

The biggest problem for Wayne Hennessey has been that he is not Guaita or Speroni. A large chunk of the fanbase fail to notice Guaita making mistakes which have cost a significant number of points, particularly in recent home games. There were a lot also who watched Speroni's final games through rose-tinted specs, great clubman, blah blah blah etc etc, but past his best, flapping at good number of balls, often worth a goal to the opposition.
Similar mistakes which Hennessey was and would be completely crucified for on here. He could though teach the other two a thing or two about kicking properly.

The keeper also instills confidence in his defence.
Much as vincente has made mistakes the defence appear to have more confidence in him than Wayne.
Didnt help against Chelsea ok but that was a one man issue who had a really unluckily bad day.
Ability wise both have different traits but my point stands, imo.

 

saveloy Flag carmarthen 18 Oct 20 9.54am

Hennessey for a big bloke doesn't have any bottle.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 18 Oct 20 12.06pm

We certainly needed an upgrade on Wayne. Hopefully Butland is the answer.

 

VSEagle215 Flag New York 20 Oct 20 5.24pm

Not in current 25.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Oct 20 6.10pm

Originally posted by VSEagle215

Not in current 25.


Didn't expect him to be since he is unlikely to be back from injury until the New Year. Why waste a space?

 

Casual Flag Orpington 20 Oct 20 7.39pm

Originally posted by doombear


Didn't expect him to be since he is unlikely to be back from injury until the New Year. Why waste a space?

Waste a space/ waste of space

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 21 Oct 20 7.31am

He-Nazi

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 25 Oct 20 11.30am

The fact that Jack Butland has come in and been given Speronis old number 1 shirt speaks volumes.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 25 Oct 20 12.04pm

In the last season before Guaita came along and took over the position, Wayne had played well and made fewer errors than previously, and was a bit unfortunate to lose his place, although I accept that Guaita has earned being first choice.

Unfortunately people like to hang on to their perceptions and prejudices and Hennessey has been tagged by them as being a blunder waiting to happen, and ever more shall be so.

 

jeeagles Flag 25 Oct 20 12.10pm

For all the stick he gets, he was a £3m signing to play understudy for Speroni in 2014.

Going back to 2004. We've managed to get incredible value out of our goal keepers.

Vessen - Loan
Kilray - Free
Speroni - £1m
Hennessey - £3m
Mandanda - Free
Guiata - Free
Butland - £1m

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 25 Oct 20 12.19pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

For all the stick he gets, he was a £3m signing to play understudy for Speroni in 2014.

Going back to 2004. We've managed to get incredible value out of our goal keepers.

Vessen - Loan
Kilray - Free
Speroni - £1m
Hennessey - £3m
Mandanda - Free
Guiata - Free
Butland - £1m

We have indeed, although it’s rather ironic that Wayne is the most expensive keeper we’ve ever signed

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 25 Oct 20 12.24pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

For all the stick he gets, he was a £3m signing to play understudy for Speroni in 2014.

Going back to 2004. We've managed to get incredible value out of our goal keepers.

Vessen - Loan
Kilray - Free
Speroni - £1m
Hennessey - £3m
Mandanda - Free
Guiata - Free
Butland - £1m

We have indeed, although it’s rather ironic that Wayne is the most expensive keeper we’ve ever signed

Edit....cancel that, a quick bit of research and it looks like we paid more for Alex McCarthy (£4.41m from QPR - Transfer market)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 25 Oct 20 12.52pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

For all the stick he gets, he was a £3m signing to play understudy for Speroni in 2014.

Going back to 2004. We've managed to get incredible value out of our goal keepers.

Vessen - Loan
Kilray - Free
Speroni - £1m
Hennessey - £3m
Mandanda - Free
Guiata - Free
Butland - £1m

A million for Nigel Martyn was pretty good too.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 25 Oct 20 12.58pm

Originally posted by chris123

A million for Nigel Martyn was pretty good too.

Think you’ll find that was a record fee for a goalkeeper at the time..!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 20 1.04pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle


Think you’ll find that was a record fee for a goalkeeper at the time..!!

Martyn was the first £Million pound goalkeeper in English football.
It seems a relative pittance now but he was signed in 1989 pre-PL days.
I was present at his debut when we were defeated 3-2 by Tottenham at Selhurst Park.
We sold him to Leeds, when George Graham was their manager, for just shy of £2.5 Mill.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey