This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
How very dare you ! I bet we go and sign a centre back now! 🤣
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
If the West Brom rumour is true, then I would sell him. He's a very good player, but as we know, injury prone. Sometimes transfers are all about the timing, and if Allardyce is interested we can probably get a better price for him next month than after the end of the season. Remember Glen and Jedi Looked like good business at the time and almost relegated us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
Fat Sam can sign him in the Summer once WBA are relegated... He won't be there by then...
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
|
Originally posted by Elwissthebest
I can't see the point of getting rid of our best CB, but there's no point his sitting on the bench. He certainly stays injured a long time, but then again, so do all our CBs. Probably something to do with age. Hodgson doesn't rate him as highly as Allardyce, that's for sure. Presumably he is fit again, so why not play him? If he's not going to make the starting XI, then 'cash in'. I put it in inverted commas because the strange logic of the transfer means that he is worth more than whatever we sell him for, i.e. if we got £10m for him, we could not buy a player as good as he is for that money. I hope we keep James Tomkins and play him: brave, able and totally committed in a way I feel Sakho isn't (the committed bit). I'd be surprised if anyone offers £10m for him, but if they did, I would snap their hands off. He's a good player but he's 31 and has missed a lot of football due to injury. We have a plethora of CB's and you can't turn down that much money for someone of his age.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
It'd certainly be tempting to accept that kind of bid, and on paper we do have a lot of centre halves at the club. However, where I would respectfully diagree with you is that what we actually have is a plethora of injury-prone, old centre backs, three of whom (not including Tompkins) are out of contract at the end of this season. I mention this for two reasons: 1. We probably need four or five senior CBs on the books just to be able to field two in any one game, as they are all so prone to injury. Though we have plenty of cover when they are all fit, they never are, so reducing the overall number is risky. 2. We might be six months away from Tompkins being the only senior centre back at the club if terms aren't agreed with Cahill, Dann, and/or Sakho. Even if we have enough CBs for this season, losing Tompkins might be risky in the longer term. Personally I'd take good money for JT only if we have a suitable replacement secured. Otherwise it's no dice. Edited by TheBigToePunt (18 Dec 2020 1.21pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
We would be mad to sell any players in this window. With injuries and suspensions we are only a couple more cases of being down to the bare bones again. Sorry fat Sam you will have to look elsewhere.... We have a German midfielder, who could be the answer to their goal scoring problems, they can have cheap.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
We have a German midfielder, who could be the answer to their goal scoring problems, they can have cheap. Is their problem that they score too many then?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The centre of defence is clearly an area where we need to strengthen, but we can hardly sell anyone until we are buying replacements. Cahill is old, Dann is too slow, Sakho is too unreliable and both he and Tomkins are injury prone to say the least. Something must happen in the Summer. Yes and I always reserve judgement on players going until players have come in. Remember the Ambrose and Scannell meltdown?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The centre of defence is clearly an area where we need to strengthen but we can hardly sell anyone until we are buying replacements. Cahill is old, Dann is too slow, Sakho is too unreliable and both he and Tomkins are injury prone to say the least. Something must happen in the Summer. To my mind, it’s the second last area I’d strengthen after goalkeepers. But there you go, game of opinions as they say.
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
To my mind, it’s the second last area I’d strengthen after goalkeepers. But there you go, game of opinions as they say. Problem is CB is a problem area creeping up on us a bit faster than the players playing there and selling assets while you still can is a consideration.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Problem is CB is a problem area creeping up on us a bit faster than the players playing there and selling assets while you still can is a consideration. Agreed. First port of call is to renew contracts, I’d suggest we should let Sakho go though. Tompkins is a good player. I think we’d need at least £10m to consider selling, it’s a seller’s market in January. Otherwise keep him on.
Vive le Roy! |
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I can’t imagine we will be looking to sell Tomkins but he will find it hard to dislodge Kouyate from that position. Tomkins is a better defender but Kouyate offers us a lot more in that position. Oh yes? He offers a lot more? He is a 'commanding presence', true but has little guile and his passing is on a par with (again) Luka.
|
|
|
Originally posted by the.universal
To my mind, it’s the second last area I’d strengthen after goalkeepers. But there you go, game of opinions as they say. We need to strengthen all over but this thread was about a central defender.
|
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
Think he is back tomorrow, feel happier with him in the team than Cahill
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
Think he is back tomorrow, feel happier with him in the team than Cahill In central defence our options are players who are all in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers,players who have suffered recent injuries,players who are out of favour and players whose pace and mobility is reflected in the advancement of their years.Not forgetting Kouyate who is another aged player who has spent most of his career in midfield.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In central defence our options are players who are all in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers,players who have suffered recent injuries,players who are out of favour and players whose pace and mobility is reflected in the advancement of their years.Not forgetting Kouyate who is another aged player who has spent most of his career in midfield. Agreed - I would feel more comfortable with the team with Kouyate in midfield and Tomkins and Dann in the middle of the defence tomorrow. Would have said Tomkins and Cahill if he had been fit. But we need to get back to a more stable defence even if it’s aging with Ward at right back as well. Not so bothered with PVA at left back provided we have 3 in midfield helping the back four rather than the 2 of recent times. If that means Zaha over Eze then so be it as I don’t believe playing them both helps the balance / defensive side of the team? Personally I would play Schlupp in place of Eze at the moment with Benteke and Zaha up front allowing MacArthur, Luka and Kouyate behind them. If we play as open as last week we are in for another big defeat in my opinion?
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Agreed - I would feel more comfortable with the team with Kouyate in midfield and Tomkins and Dann in the middle of the defence tomorrow. Would have said Tomkins and Cahill if he had been fit. But we need to get back to a more stable defence even if it’s aging with Ward at right back as well. Not so bothered with PVA at left back provided we have 3 in midfield helping the back four rather than the 2 of recent times. If that means Zaha over Eze then so be it as I don’t believe playing them both helps the balance / defensive side of the team? Personally I would play Schlupp in place of Eze at the moment with Benteke and Zaha up front allowing MacArthur, Luka and Kouyate behind them. If we play as open as last week we are in for another big defeat in my opinion? MacArthur is 33 and in that midfield 'Engine room' he has played in 12 of the 14 PL games,including the last 7 games.At the stage of his career he simply cannot be expected to play to this extent and he will need a rest. Luka has been very disappointing, lack of pace and mobility and seemingly all he offers these days is to break up the play at times whilst collecting his customary card.The fact that he scored free kicks and penalties glossed over his deficiencies but he did use to offer more than he does at the present time. Edited by Willo (25 Dec 2020 11.21pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.