You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players were released that proved decent!
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Which players were released that proved decent!


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 07 Jan 21 4.05pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

That's a good point. We've done pretty well out of players being released by other clubs in recent years.

Clyne was on the scrap heap. Cahill was without a club, McCarthy was either free or near enough and Everton certainly wanted shot of him. Ayew was also unwanted at Swansea.

Going back to Collymore, I thought we paid about £150k for him, sold him to Southend after he didn't make it here, and they sold him to Forest for something close to a record at the time - maybe over £2m? I also refuse to do the research.

I have clear memories of Collymore at Palace. Nobody could make sense of him as he seemed far too tall to be a poacher like Wright, and so surely had to be a target man, like Bright, but he was crap in the air. He also had a few games on the wing, but had no final ball at all, much to the disapproval of Messers Bright and (I think still) Wright.

When given a chance to play up front he would often burst through two or three defenders in spectacular fashion before blasting the ball over the top of the Whitehorse lane end.

Somehow at Southend he forced himself to place his shots low into the corners, and almost overnight he was a very valuable asset. The rest is history.

Southend also did well by getting Chris Powell off us for a song I think?

Collymore was bought from non league for a cool £100k so to sell him after Wright had left for only £150k seemed a strange decision to me. 6 months later he was sold to Forest for over £2m.

We did get 12.5% of sell ons though so got money out of that move and also when he moved on to Liverpool (as Southend had a % clause too)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Jan 21 4.19pm

At least we haven't got rid of pure diamonds like Chelski have!

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 07 Jan 21 4.54pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

Didnt Collymore go to Southend for around a 100.000 did well and they sold him to forest for around a million

I'm sure it was 2 million - not Alan Smith's finest hour, he reckons you could not reasonably have predicted Collymore's rise based on what he saw at Palace. But Collymore used to light the place up every time he came on, was often a sub to Wright and Bright, this is the biggest one to have got away by a long way

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 07 Jan 21 5.03pm

do remember collymore steaming down the left wing then falling over when he went to cross and kicked the ball into sainsburys -.-' -.-' he wasnt released i seem to recall he went to southend as the story was everyone took the p**s out of him in the team

Edited by thegreatlardino (07 Jan 2021 5.05pm)

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

esox lucius Flag Deal 07 Jan 21 5.11pm

Lewis Grabban is one we let go, he has a very good goal scoring history with several clubs outside the premier league.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 07 Jan 21 5.28pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

do remember collymore steaming down the left wing then falling over when he went to cross and kicked the ball into sainsburys -.-' -.-' he wasnt released i seem to recall he went to southend as the story was everyone took the p**s out of him in the team

Edited by thegreatlardino (07 Jan 2021 5.05pm)

Yeah I've heard Collymore in conversation with Wright on a podcast talking about how, socially speaking, Collymore was a real fish out of water at Palace at the time.

It's easy to see Collymore leaving when he could have taken over from Wright as a sliding doors moment (whatever that means, never actually seen the film), but he probably needed to be a bigger fish at a smaller club to develop his confidence as much as his ability, and probably neither would have happened at Palace.

If Coppell and Smith didn't think much of him at that stage, that'll do for me.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 07 Jan 21 5.36pm

As I recall Stan was constantly on our bench, and regularly came on during the Wright/Bright era. However in our esteemed wisdom, we did not want to pay an instalment to Stafford Rangers based on his appearances so we decided to sell him to Southend. Wrighty went and we replaced him with Marco Gabbiadini!

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

Didnt Collymore go to Southend for around a 100.000 did well and they sold him to forest for around a million

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 07 Jan 21 5.48pm

Think we made more on the 2 sell on fees, Southend to Forest, Forest to Liverpool . Than the actual original transfer fee.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 07 Jan 21 5.52pm

We might of got a sell on free from Southend to Forest but don't think we would have got one from Forest to Liverpool.

Originally posted by esox lucius

Think we made more on the 2 sell on fees, Southend to Forest, Forest to Liverpool . Than the actual original transfer fee.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 07 Jan 21 7.26pm

"When given a chance to play up front he would often burst through two or three defenders in spectacular fashion before blasting the ball over the top of the Whitehorse lane end."

I always remember Stan at Palace, ran with head down, with a strong shop, if only I used to to think, if only he look up before he shot but at Southend he got the coaching he needed.

Name another player thats recently gone via Southend is now doing well///


Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

That's a good point. We've done pretty well out of players being released by other clubs in recent years.

Clyne was on the scrap heap. Cahill was without a club, McCarthy was either free or near enough and Everton certainly wanted shot of him. Ayew was also unwanted at Swansea.

Going back to Collymore, I thought we paid about £150k for him, sold him to Southend after he didn't make it here, and they sold him to Forest for something close to a record at the time - maybe over £2m? I also refuse to do the research.

I have clear memories of Collymore at Palace. Nobody could make sense of him as he seemed far too tall to be a poacher like Wright, and so surely had to be a target man, like Bright, but he was crap in the air. He also had a few games on the wing, but had no final ball at all, much to the disapproval of Messers Bright and (I think still) Wright.

When given a chance to play up front he would often burst through two or three defenders in spectacular fashion before blasting the ball over the top of the Whitehorse lane end.

Somehow at Southend he forced himself to place his shots low into the corners, and almost overnight he was a very valuable asset. The rest is history.

Southend also did well by getting Chris Powell off us for a song I think?

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 07 Jan 21 8.54pm

Back to the original question, I'm really interested who we let go who went on to do really well.

At the top end of the scale clearly Ian Wright and Kenny Samson went on to do great things.

Long time ago I remember Birchenall left us to do a good few years in the top division with Leicester.(random)

But really, struggling to think of any more youngsters, than those already posted, that we let go who have turned up in the top flight.

 

saveloy Flag carmarthen 07 Jan 21 9.25pm

Steve Mackenzie

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 07 Jan 21 10.45pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Alan Devonshire

Never knew he was on our books, just had to look it up but you are quite correct.

Massive mistake, one of the best players I have ever seen play live. No idea why he never played more games for England. Remember my mum buying me tickets for England v Wales for my tenth birthday in 1980, Devonshire played that game and I couldn’t believe even at that age how good he was.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Bekken Flag 07 Jan 21 10.55pm


Andy Johnson, scrap heap at Birmingham.
Valerian Ismael, purchased by us, flopped, had a great career.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 07 Jan 21 10.56pm

Originally posted by Bekken


Andy Johnson, scrap heap at Birmingham.
Valerian Ismael, purchased by us, flopped, had a great career.

I think AJ is the opposite of what the threads about

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Jan 21 11.08pm


Terry Fenwick?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 21 11.24pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Alan Devonshire

He has been manager of Maidenhead Utd for a few years.
They were 6th in the 'National League' before the season was suspended due to Lockdown.
Wolves signed Max Kilman from the club.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 07 Jan 21 11.25pm

Originally posted by Bekken


Andy Johnson, scrap heap at Birmingham.
Valerian Ismael, purchased by us, flopped, had a great career.

Ismael had a good career, but maybe not a great one. He went back to France after leaving us and knocked about in their top flight for several mid sized clubs, then did well enough at a couple of mid table German sides to get a move to bayern Munich, but he wasn't there very long and didn't play very much.

He has, however, played for Bayern Munich far more times than I have, so I'll pipe down. He certainly did well enough to go on the list alongside Collymore and Powell.

Whilst plenty of players have moved on to greater things from Palace, very few indeed have done so having been undervalued or dumped by us, which is what I think the op was asking.

Perhaps they do know what they're doing after all...

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 21 11.34pm

Stephen Hunt went on to play in over 400 games after he left us, including those in the PL.

Steve Coppell signed him for both Brentford and Reading.

Edited by Willo (07 Jan 2021 11.36pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 07 Jan 21 11.34pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

Lewis Grabban is one we let go, he has a very good goal scoring history with several clubs outside the premier league.

We wanted to keep him apparently. He was waiting for a break behind AJ, Morrison, and Freedman?

But Grabban was too impatient and went to Millwall.

Seems a shame as just after he left we had some injuries and he would have got a chance.

Didn't come across well on Sunderland til I die.

Stephen Hunt... remember him coming on as a 17 year old against Fulham away and getting booked.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players were released that proved decent!