You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Does the Club have a clear strategy?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Does the Club have a clear strategy?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
AERO Flag 02 Feb 21 2.03pm

The ground is obviously the major issue for many reasons .Revenue being the major one as most clubs certainly premiership and most championship clubs have new or more updated stadia .

 

mileend Flag East London 02 Feb 21 2.47pm

Maybe Parish is happy to have all those out of contract players because he thinks it is likely he'll want a new manager next season and that is going to be an attractive proposition for a new boss to get the players they want in - or at least suit their system.

That always seems an issue at Palace where the core squad that get the results play only one way. Typically without the ball for most of the game.

There will be financial constraints but we are going to have a lot of wages freed up so we should be able to compete well for the out of contract players who are not at the very top level.

If Zaha goes then that will mean enough funds to pay some transfer fees.

If there is no manager available that fits the bill then I expect we will see some contract extensions come through and one more year for Hodgson and similar approach again.

 

AERO Flag 02 Feb 21 4.47pm

Makes some sense, new manager ,new players brought in to his liking. No point getting players in and new manager not wanting them .ie Mayer

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 Feb 21 5.00pm

Originally posted by Knightstar

I’ve been a Palace supporter for over 50 years and although I rarely find time to attend matches these days, I follow the club’s activities very closely and am fully committed to seeing the club becoming the best it possibly can be.

So my numerous thoughts and concerns about the club can be summed up by the title of this thread. Unlike some posters I respect what Steve Parish and co have done for the club and are hopefully still planning to do. However, if the club has a clear strategy, I’m not aware of them having shared it with us fans and I think it would be beneficial if they were to do so.

For me, a strategy has to be driven by a compelling vision and I think we can see elements of it in some of the things the club are doing. For example, I really like the slogan ‘South London and Proud’, as we should be aiming to ensure we are THE top team in South London, which I think is already the case but the key requirement is to ensure that we always will be and that means continually building the club and taking it forward. Over time one would hope that as the premier team in South London we will start to compete more evenly with our other Premier League rivals within London.

Distilling this strategy down to some key points, I’d like to suggest the following:

Mission Statement:

To become an established top-ten Premier League team and one of the top teams in London.

Striving to achieve such a mission should also make it possible for us to aspire to play in the European competitions but there is much to do before that becomes a realistic prospect.

Medium-Long term Goals:

To have a top-quality stadium with a minimum 35,000 seating capacity.

Parish said recently that now we have achieved Category 1 status for our Academy and the related building project will soon be completed, the Club will turn its attention to developing the ground. This must happen as quickly as possible and in an ideal world I think we’d be better off moving to the Crystal Palace park and building an even more impressive stadium but that is probably one for the future.

To have one of the top Football Academies in the country.

To his credit Parish has recognised the importance of building this facility and achieving Category 1 status was a big step forward. The challenge now is to build the reputation of the Academy and that will require them producing some top, young talent that can feed through into the senior team.

To attract additional major investment through new owners.

In order to achieve the necessary ground improvements and investment in the team, we desperately need to attract new owners who will invest in the potential of the club. We have a large chunk of South London and the South East as our catchment area and that means a decent-sized fan base and potentially a great pool of young talent to feed into our Academy. Parish needs to sell this vision to owners who want to exploit this potential.

Short-term Goals:

To maintain our Premier League status.

This is essential as it is an obvious source of revenue and unlike some posters, I do not think there is any benefit in being relegated to the Championship with a view to rebuilding, even if it means playing unattractive football in the short-term, in order to survive.

I personally think that Roy Hodgson has done a pretty good job under difficult circumstances and I’d like to see him working to ensure our survival this season and then I think he should retire with full credit.

That means I think that Parish needs to start lining up a new Manager to take over during the summer break, so that he can oversee the rebuilding of the team. Hopefully Parish has already had appropriate discussions with Roy and is already having some tentative conversations with suitable contenders, such as Eddie Howe.

To rebuild the First team squad.

With an ageing squad and so many players soon to be out of contract, the next 12 months is going to be a critical period for the club.

We should see the departure of Wickham, Benteke and Sakho as quickly as possible.

I think we urgently need to add the following:

• a creative midfielder to boost our attacking threat in the Cabaye or Ross Barkley mould
• a young defensive midfielder who can start to replace Macca or Luka
• a proper right winger to replace Townsend
• a young centre back to start to replace Dann or Cahill

Our long-standing need for a reliable striker naturally remains important, although we may have an answer there with Mateta but that remains to be seen. I’m also not sure whether Batshuyai has a future with us or not, as he hasn’t had much of a chance this season.

Anyway, I think as a Club we have some major challenges ahead and I hope that Parish sees them as part of a coherent strategy and I’d like to hear more from him about how he sees these things coming together. I appreciate it is difficult for him to be open about some of these matters but I think it would be good to share a vision and get us all excited about what we’re trying to do.

Great post - all very sensible.

May i add another medium term goal - to reduce the wage bill to c60 -65% of total revenue.
At present i think we are at c78%, which is the highest % in the premier league.
By having such a high wage bill it means the transfer budget is limited and also makes selling players very difficult as few clubs can afford to pay a similar level of wage (e.g. Benteke when WBA showed an interest, or why Meyer was never going to leave without his contract being paid up).

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 02 Feb 21 8.39pm

Interesting topic. Thank you for it. You're almost as old as I am (first Palace match 1965).
There has been much talk recently around the issue of whether CPFC is doing as well as it could. On the one hand, you have varieties of 'We could still be stuck in Third Division South.' The most recent iteration of this is; 'Be Careful What You Wish For'. Such arguments play out as varieties of: 'Compared with where we've come from, we've done really well.' Don't rock the boat, or we'll be back in the brown stuff.' Curiously, posters in this camp tend to regard people who suggest things could be better still as pessimists: 'you're always moaning about something...' The point of course is exactly the opposite: that the 'moaners' are actually the optimists, because they (we) dare to suggest that it is possible to 'Believe in Better' to quote the nauseating jingle.
Palace is unlikely to be a top ten Premiership club because it doesn't have the economic power to get there and stay there. At the end of the season, you are looking by and large at a list from of economic power. You know that Liverpool, the two Manchesters, Arsenal, Chelsea and Spurs will be there. Leicester is an economic over-achiever, but it's got a good manager and is excellent at recruitment and trading. Newcastle, in terms of the home gate, should really be in the top ten although it is a mis-managed entity. With Ancelloti, Everton is probably top ten and I think under Moyes and a Board that is prepared to spend (and how!) so is West Ham. Southampton (no particular economic recommendation) for next best? Villa?
Of course, in terms of economic potential, the likes of former European Cup winner, Nottingham Forest, might be there too. But that's another story.
Judged in this context, Palace is indeed doing well to have survived seven consecutive seasons in the top flight: unprecedented for us. The point about the south London hinterland and a 35,000 stadium offers hope. Actually, 35,000 isn't enough for top ten status, but if we committed to a policy of recruitment to the first team from the Academy, then that is a real outlier. This, under the present managerial regime is unlikely. Wan-Bissaka and Mitchell excepted, they just don't come through, not least because getting to 38 points is such an effort every season, there is never time to 'blood' them.
So maybe we just settle for season after season of surviving in the Premiership. The Chairman saved the club in 2010 so criticism of him is in bad taste, but I do think of him as someone who is happy with 38 points per year. He should probably sell the club on if he can find a buyer. That said, he's Palace through and through and there's absolutely no guarantee that could be said of whoever might come in.
So: could we be doing better? Yes and no. For what it's worth, I'd rather watch really exciting football in the Championship played by youngsters who have come through our ranks than plod on with this turgid survivalism. For me, the 1978-9 season will always be the yardstick. Of course, that came unstuck. But the objections to that view are obvious. Best of all: exciting football in the Premiership. That just isn't going to happen under the present regime as we have opted for 'Safety First'. It's by no means inevitable that that will work.

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 03 Feb 21 8.14am

Thanks You make some good points and I agree with a lot of what you say. One area of difference though is that I do not wish us to be back in the Championship under any circumstances. If we are to progress as I imagine we would all like to see, we need to be in the Premier League. You also make a good case explaining the major challenge we face in becoming an established top ten Premier League side, which as you rightly say is strongly linked to economic success. That is why I believe we desperately need inward investment, ideally from new owners. The Academy is indeed a potential outlier and really could help us to bridge that economic gap but again you are right to highlight the problem we have with the current management. I have been impressed with a lot of what Roy has done for us but he clearly can't go on for a lot longer and nor should he. We need a new, younger manager who will help to take us forward and that must be one of Steve Parish's top priorities right now. So let's hope we see action on this over the coming months.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Knightstar

Thanks You make some good points and I agree with a lot of what you say. One area of difference though is that I do not wish us to be back in the Championship under any circumstances. If we are to progress as I imagine we would all like to see, we need to be in the Premier League. You also make a good case explaining the major challenge we face in becoming an established top ten Premier League side, which as you rightly say is strongly linked to economic success. That is why I believe we desperately need inward investment, ideally from new owners. The Academy is indeed a potential outlier and really could help us to bridge that economic gap but again you are right to highlight the problem we have with the current management. I have been impressed with a lot of what Roy has done for us but he clearly can't go on for a lot longer and nor should he. We need a new, younger manager who will help to take us forward and that must be one of Steve Parish's top priorities right now. So let's hope we see action on this over the coming months.


I suspect that won't be the case. Few PL managers stay long. They either get sacked or move to pastures new.
- 10 of the current PL managers have been in post LESS than 2 years.
- Hodgson's tenure at Palace makes him the 6th longest serving manager at the current club (behind Dyche, Klopp, Wilder, Guardiola and Espirito Santo).
- When asked about a new contract last night, Hodgson, with a smile on his face, said he wasn't bothered about that, which might mean he's not fussed whether he gets a new contract or not, or that he's been assured that a contract extension will be available once the club feel we're safe. The latter seems more likely to me given Hodgson has also said in recent times that he wants to carry on as long as he can.

I expect he'll still be here next season.

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 03 Feb 21 2.06pm

Well if you are right it will be interesting to see how we progress on rebuilding the team because it has to be overhauled. We clearly need to get rid of some of those whose contracts are about to expire eg Wickham, Sakho, Benteke plus two or three others and that means we need to bring in younger replacements. I hope Roy works with Steve and Dougie and they all get on the same wavelength. Although I'd much rather see a new manager at the helm.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Feb 21 2.21pm

Originally posted by doombear


I suspect that won't be the case. Few PL managers stay long. They either get sacked or move to pastures new.
- 10 of the current PL managers have been in post LESS than 2 years.
- Hodgson's tenure at Palace makes him the 6th longest serving manager at the current club (behind Dyche, Klopp, Wilder, Guardiola and Espirito Santo).
- When asked about a new contract last night, Hodgson, with a smile on his face, said he wasn't bothered about that, which might mean he's not fussed whether he gets a new contract or not, or that he's been assured that a contract extension will be available once the club feel we're safe. The latter seems more likely to me given Hodgson has also said in recent times that he wants to carry on as long as he can.

I expect he'll still be here next season.

Should we avoid the dreaded drop, Mr Hodgson will have ensured our survival for 4 seasons on a limited spend.

Should by some chance the club decides to move in a different direction against his wishes,there will an array of people outside our club with whom I am in contact,who will be totally dumbfounded by the decision.

Edited by Willo (03 Feb 2021 2.24pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 21 2.28pm

Originally posted by Knightstar

Well if you are right it will be interesting to see how we progress on rebuilding the team because it has to be overhauled. We clearly need to get rid of some of those whose contracts are about to expire eg Wickham, Sakho, Benteke plus two or three others and that means we need to bring in younger replacements. I hope Roy works with Steve and Dougie and they all get on the same wavelength. Although I'd much rather see a new manager at the helm.


Probably not as quickly as we fans would like. It's the finances issue. I expect most of those whose contracts expire in the summer will get extension offers. Hopefully, at least Wickham and Sakho will depart. I suspect Hennessey will go now we've got both Guaita and Butland on longer deals. Whether or not Benteke goes may well depend on how Mateta shapes up (I expect him to feature significantly soon). There is then the question of how those we've loaned out do during the rest of the season and whether any of them will have done well enough to be considered as possible first team players who will do more than sit on the bench next year). Some will need more development, but Woods, Pierrick and Kirby might be nearly ready when they return. As I write I see Jairo 's contract has been extended till 2024.

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Feb 21 2.31pm

The strategy has always been there. It just gets harder to implement the higher up you go.

2011) Pull a squad of players together. Survive in the Championship.
2012 to 2013) Start building around youth, see if we can get some decent players on the cheap. End up with surprise promotions.
2014 to 2015) See if we can survive a couple of years in the premiership without breaking the bank.
2015 to 2017) Sign a few marquee players to signal the intent of wanting more than just survival.
2018 to 2020) Pad out the rest of the squad with experienced premiership players. Invest in infrastructure.
2021) Start to supplement the experienced players with younger ones to try and look to break into the top 10 in the next few years.

We've also got a targeted, low turnover approach to transfers.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 21 2.37pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The strategy has always been there. It just gets harder to implement the higher up you go.

2011) Pull a squad of players together. Survive in the Championship.
2012 to 2013) Start building around youth, see if we can get some decent players on the cheap. End up with surprise promotions.
2014 to 2015) See if we can survive a couple of years in the premiership without breaking the bank.
2015 to 2017) Sign a few marquee players to signal the intent of wanting more than just survival.
2018 to 2020) Pad out the rest of the squad with experienced premiership players. Invest in infrastructure.
2021) Start to supplement the experienced players with younger ones to try and look to break into the top 10 in the next few years.

We've also got a targeted, low turnover approach to transfers.


Sounds about right to me.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Feb 21 2.58pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The strategy has always been there. It just gets harder to implement the higher up you go.

2011) Pull a squad of players together. Survive in the Championship.
2012 to 2013) Start building around youth, see if we can get some decent players on the cheap. End up with surprise promotions.
2014 to 2015) See if we can survive a couple of years in the premiership without breaking the bank.
2015 to 2017) Sign a few marquee players to signal the intent of wanting more than just survival.
2018 to 2020) Pad out the rest of the squad with experienced premiership players. Invest in infrastructure.
2021) Start to supplement the experienced players with younger ones to try and look to break into the top 10 in the next few years.

We've also got a targeted, low turnover approach to transfers.

You forgot one thing - employ dull but safe manager to hold the fort while transformation takes place

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 10 Feb 21 8.01am

Well I think it's clear that Parish must act urgently on appointing a new, younger manager who will oversee the rebuilding of the squad. I think Roy can finish the season but a new manager needs to be lined up immediately and discussions about squad replacements should begin so we can hit the ground running during the summer window. This must be Parish's top priority right now.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Feb 21 10.28am

Originally posted by Knightstar

Well I think it's clear that Parish must act urgently on appointing a new, younger manager who will oversee the rebuilding of the squad. I think Roy can finish the season but a new manager needs to be lined up immediately and discussions about squad replacements should begin so we can hit the ground running during the summer window. This must be Parish's top priority right now.


Fine, but once again, I ask, where's the money coming from? I don't see the Americans putting up any more than the bare minimum to keep us in the PL.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Feb 21 10.36am

Originally posted by doombear


Fine, but once again, I ask, where's the money coming from? I don't see the Americans putting up any more than the bare minimum to keep us in the PL.

Valid point we don't know what the Americans have told Parish. It's even possible that they have said they wont fund the new stadium and so Parish is not pushing Sainsbury or the other issues too hard for that reason.

 


One more point

AERO Flag 10 Feb 21 10.45am

If they are not funding stadium, what is there purpose ?

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 10 Feb 21 10.47am

According to an item in the Mail this morning Palace have losses of around £20m and 'certain figures' at the club feel that extending Roy's contract is the best option.

Status Quo looks likely if that's the case.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Feb 21 11.02am

The 'stately ornament' that is Steve Parish is not only a gentleman of articulacy and personal charm he possesses a razor-sharp clear strategical mind and is a perspicacious chappie to boot.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 10 Feb 21 11.20am

Originally posted by Willo

The 'stately ornament' that is Steve Parish is not only a gentleman of articulacy and personal charm he possesses a razor-sharp clear strategical mind and is a perspicacious chappie to boot.

Blimey, I think you're right!

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Does the Club have a clear strategy?