This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by doombear
So of those ten players, two aren't even in our 25 man squad so don't need replacing, one is a loan and of the other seven, I can see thee going (Wickham, Sakho and Hennessey). As for the other four, it could go either way. Obviously, if all four were to go then we would have a major shake-up. But will they? Then there is the question of which of our senior Academy players out on loan might do well enough to be replacements? For example, if Woods, Pierrick and Kirby improve, they may well become full squad players next season. Edited by doombear (04 Feb 2021 10.55am) Right DB you originally stated that "there might be one or two new faces but I would be surprised if there is a major shake out". Now you appear to be saying that there might be one if players don't re-sign. 10 players might go but 2 aren't in the 25 man squad so they don't count? Their combined wages are c£80k a week and are only not in it due to injuries. You agree that Sakho will go and Bats' after his loan finishes. PVA will go - he's turned down a contract. Undecided - Townsend, Mitchell, McCarthy, Clyne, Ward, Cahill, Tekkers and Dann. So it's 13 players, not 10, and 7 are undecided. We may offer contracts to all 7 (unlikely IMHO) but maybe on reduced terms or pay as you play deals. Then the other factor is that they are out of contract so can negotiate with other clubs or just retire. I reckon Cahill at 35 may decide to retire (i think i'd prefer him to Dann), McCarthy may decide to play for his boyhood club, Celtic. So of the 13, 6 will go and 7 are undecided. If we say 4 of those 7 stay then that's 9 departures in total. As we usually release 1 or 2 senior players a year and 1 or 2 get sold, i'd say 9 departures is quite a shake up. You clearly disagree. Edited by palace99 (04 Feb 2021 5.00pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
I think that any decision wouldn't be taken until we have seen whether the 6ft 3 replacement is any good in the Premier League
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I think that any decision wouldn't be taken until we have seen whether the 6ft 3 replacement is any good in the Premier League If his legs move when he sees an opportunity occurring then the competition is over.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Palace 99, rather than repeat your post here's my reply. Firstly, 'mea culpa' but I didn't count the number of players in your list. Secondly, I don't believe that every outgoing player will be replaced unless the Board (i.e. our US investors) have a sudden Santa spirit and make lots of cash available. I'm not expecting that. Thirdly, my reference to '1 or 2', on reflection, should probably have read 'a few'. Fourthly, given the revelation of Hodgson's comments concerning his future which are linked to his wanting the board to sort out the expiring player contracts before discussing his own situation, we simply don't know who will be in charge next season. Fifthly, if too many players choose not to renew contracts offered to them, it will be a question of whether the board will (reluctantly) put their hands in their pockets for a major overhaul or tell the manager (whoever) to work with what they've got (plus a few new players) with any balance of the first team squad vacancies being filled from the U23s/U18s. It's no coincidence, in my view, that so many of our youngsters went out on loan in the last week of the recent transfer window. In short I see a major overhaul as a last resort. You may, of course, be right and I'll have to eat humble pie. Time will tell. Meanwhile let's enjoy the rest of the season in the growing likelihood of another season in the PL. Blimey it's like an autopsy with you two, jesting of course
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
So of those ten players, two aren't even in our 25 man squad so don't need replacing, one is a loan and of the other seven, I can see thee going (Wickham, Sakho and Hennessey). As for the other four, it could go either way. Obviously, if all four were to go then we would have a major shake-up. But will they? Then there is the question of which of our senior Academy players out on loan might do well enough to be replacements? For example, if Woods, Pierrick and Kirby improve, they may well become full squad players next season. Edited by doombear (04 Feb 2021 10.55am) I doubt if more than 4 leave in the summer. Its cheaper to give them extended contract on slightly enhanced wages, than buy in new players. As the contracts are ending they are free to leave with no fee. Unless Freeman pulls many rabbits out of the hat and finds 6 of more bargin buys from somewhere, we are going to be stuck having to give current players new contracts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
So of those ten players, two aren't even in our 25 man squad so don't need replacing, one is a loan and of the other seven, I can see thee going (Wickham, Sakho and Hennessey). As for the other four, it could go either way. Obviously, if all four were to go then we would have a major shake-up. But will they? Then there is the question of which of our senior Academy players out on loan might do well enough to be replacements? For example, if Woods, Pierrick and Kirby improve, they may well become full squad players next season. Edited by doombear (04 Feb 2021 10.55am) Wickham and Hennessey are both in our 25 man squad....
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Wickham and Hennessey are both in our 25 man squad....
|
|
|
Originally posted by kevlee
I would be happier with Lampard over both Howe and Dyche. However, Dyche in a way would be like Roy. Shoestring, always just trying to stay up. Dunkirk spirit. can i please ask, what has lampard done to warrant getting the job as manager of cpfc? i like frank btw, just not sure he is ready for the job.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Yes they were.....
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Yes they were..... Henderson isn't in the new list of 25 but he WAS in the previous list. So who in the current list wasn't in the previous list? (Mateta has taken Meyer's spot). Hennessey got seriously injured before the first list was sent in and Butland came in to take his place. Hennessey was, therefore, left out.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Henderson isn't in the new list of 25 but he WAS in the previous list. So who in the current list wasn't in the previous list? (Mateta has taken Meyer's spot). Hennessey got seriously injured before the first list was sent in and Butland came in to take his place. Hennessey was, therefore, left out. I stand corrected and apologise. When you look at the article stating our 25 man squad, I didn't notice the column saying if they were in the squad or not...
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I think that any decision wouldn't be taken until we have seen whether the 6ft 3 replacement is any good in the Premier League Based on your logic then ME, maybe we'll be offering Wickham another extension too. At some point you have to cut your losses and move on. I'd much prefer a young, hungry lower league striker. Surely, that's the Palace way until Pardew got into SP's head and told him we could win the league
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Based on your logic then ME, maybe we'll be offering Wickham another extension too. At some point you have to cut your losses and move on. I'd much prefer a young, hungry lower league striker. Surely, that's the Palace way until Pardew got into SP's head and told him we could win the league ..by outscoring our opponents without the services of the great Glen Murray who he weirdly didn't want and promptly allowed to leave to join Reading, he went on to score another fifty eight goals for Bournewmouth and Brighton over one hundred and seven appearances, if he'd kept him then I'm quite sure we'd been able to continue outscoring teams enough to not be sacked for being an idiot.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.