You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bewildered
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bewildered


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 01 Mar 21 11.50am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yes, relying on the opposition not taking their chances as opposed to creating and scoring yourself is not really a sound football strategy.

It is the exact opposite.
Defending and destroying opposition play is MUCH easier and less phisical demanding than attacking and building your own play.
An Italian Serie A manager some time ago told me, attacking wins you matches, defending wins you trophies.

Edited by Ian-VI (01 Mar 2021 11.50am)

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 01 Mar 21 11.54am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

In your time supporting the club, you've witnessed the utter dross served up by Trevor Francis and Peter Taylor. Now that was unenjoyable. This is still the most successful period in the club's entire history and I'd far rather witness this period where we're an established Premier League side going through a temporary issue involving squad age and depth. There have been far more unenjoyable periods than this.

There have also been far more enjoyable periods than this.

This isn’t our most successful period ever, that was the Wright/Bright era (now that was exciting) This is our longest period in top flight football. Whilst the shareholders may be happy with us limping over the line each year to stay in the division, it doesn’t mean us fans enjoy it.

I’m a long time season ticket holder but I’m not even sure I want to renew to watch this rubbish.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 01 Mar 21 11.58am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Whilst I accept your point, there always seems to be an excuse for our shocking play that we are expected to accept. I reckon we have only played well maybe 7 or 8 times this season despite winning 9 and drawing 6.

I don't think anyone will disagree with you that we've been served up turgid bollocks for a wee while. It's just no fun at the moment. However, I can see why it's being played that way, and if the overriding business strategy and intention is to stay in the Premiership (which I'm pretty certain it is), then it's been successful. The decisions made in the close-season are going to define our future, probably for the next decade.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 21 11.59am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Let me explain. We have a relatively small squad and we have topped the injuries list for half the season. Fulham have found very good form in recent weeks, and virtually a full squad, averaging 2 points per game. Fulham played really well on the day and I would be surprised if they could have played a lot better.

Accepting we didn't play well, we did have a couple of chances but didn't find the man or hit the target and Guita only had to make one good save. I point was much better for us, in our position in the table, than it was for them.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Mar 21 12.03pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI

It is the exact opposite.
Defending and destroying opposition play is MUCH easier and less phisical demanding than attacking and building your own play.
An Italian Serie A manager some time ago told me, attacking wins you matches, defending wins you trophies.

Edited by Ian-VI (01 Mar 2021 11.50am)

You won’t win anything if your sole intention is a 0-0 outcome. We all remember the George Graham, Jose Mourinho and as we are seeing Roy Hodgson style of football from the past and it is has become outmoded. Knick a goal and park the bus has been the Italian way for years, but it’s no longer the way successful teams play football.

I suppose you are suggesting as those who continue to support Hodgson that it is the only style of football we can ever play, whereas I see that style as the only way Hodgson knows how to play.

 

si_1967 Flag Surrey 01 Mar 21 12.05pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I've always respected Roy's interviews as he tells it straight, but he's had a few shockers recently, including yesterday.

I know we have injuries, but we were dire. Zero shots at home against a team in the relegation zone is unacceptable. Perhaps it would have been different with a crowd to urge them forward. The only positive was the result which was totally undeserved.

If they performed like that in front of a full stadium, they would have been booed off.

I like Roy and on the whole he has been terrific, but things are starting to sour. We've done enough to survive this season, but I can't imagine he'll be offered a new contract.


However, the form table over the last 8 games has them in 11th two places above us and only 1 defeat!
But, I don't disagree with all of what you've said above.

 


... what

since1953 Flag Maidenhead 01 Mar 21 12.10pm

Looking at the playing personnel available to us at the moment I think we are the weakest team in the whole of the prem. Until we get a full squad back (or most of it) we shall have to adopt the Dunkirk spirit because there is no way we shall be able to adopt an adventurous style of play without getting slaughtered.
I have been a supporter since 1953 (but can only remember matches from the late 50s) and have seen many ups and downs, and would say that Roy is playing a blinder with the hand he has been dealt with. Bodies are being put on the line and he recognises this, and if he compliments the performances then we should be realistic in our criticism of his achievement.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Mar 21 12.34pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yes, relying on the opposition not taking their chances as opposed to creating and scoring yourself is not really a sound football strategy. The most we could have scored in that match was nil. In fact our most dangerous moment was from their defender, “passing” it back to the goalkeeper.

good point - v Leeds and Burnley both scored early so essentially it was game over after 5 minutes.

Also regarding injuries , i'm not having it. Yes Zaha is clearly a loss but of the others who is a nailed on regular?
Tomkins when fully fit.
Possibly Jeff and Jimmy Mac, but if anyone thinks we will be more creative with these 2 you are deluded. They are the hard working types Roy loves.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Mar 21 1.09pm

Originally posted by palace99

good point - v Leeds and Burnley both scored early so essentially it was game over after 5 minutes.

Also regarding injuries , i'm not having it. Yes Zaha is clearly a loss but of the others who is a nailed on regular?
Tomkins when fully fit.
Possibly Jeff and Jimmy Mac, but if anyone thinks we will be more creative with these 2 you are deluded. They are the hard working types Roy loves.

It’s having the pick of players and having options from the bench. We don’t have that at the moment.

So Tomkins, Schlupp, Jimmy Mac, Zaha, Kelly , Sakho. All these players would feature in the first 11 or from the bench, that’s a fact.

And you don’t think there is a problem, you named 4 yourself and one of them is our top scorer. Who’s deluded?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Mar 21 1.16pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

It’s having the pick of players and having options from the bench. We don’t have that at the moment.

So Tomkins, Schlupp, Jimmy Mac, Zaha, Kelly , Sakho. All these players would feature in the first 11 or from the bench, that’s a fact.

And you don’t think there is a problem, you named 4 yourself and one of them is our top scorer. Who’s deluded?

Kelly has been fit for weeks but never made it onto the pitch, not quite sure why as he has always done a good job. Sakho will probably never play for us again.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Mar 21 1.20pm

Originally posted by palace99

good point - v Leeds and Burnley both scored early so essentially it was game over after 5 minutes.

Also regarding injuries , i'm not having it. Yes Zaha is clearly a loss but of the others who is a nailed on regular?
Tomkins when fully fit.
Possibly Jeff and Jimmy Mac, but if anyone thinks we willy are the hard working types Roy loves.

Newcastle scored first so why wasn't that game over as soon as they scored? We won that one remember?

Injuries have been horrendous this season and don't tell me that it hasn't made any difference. Ask any Manager if they would prefer a settled team rather than having to make changes all the time. If you think they don't make a difference look at Liverpool, they lost VvD to a season ending injury and haven't been the same since.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Mar 21 1.26pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Newcastle scored first so why wasn't that game over as soon as they scored? We won that one remember?

Injuries have been horrendous this season and don't tell me that it hasn't made any difference. Ask any Manager if they would prefer a settled team rather than having to make changes all the time. If you think they don't make a difference look at Liverpool, they lost VvD to a season ending injury and haven't been the same since.

We have the worst record in the PL this season with 161 games missed by players through injury and illness.By contrast, the total for Fulham is 46 games.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 01 Mar 21 1.30pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You won’t win anything if your sole intention is a 0-0 outcome. We all remember the George Graham, Jose Mourinho and as we are seeing Roy Hodgson style of football from the past and it is has become outmoded. Knick a goal and park the bus has been the Italian way for years, but it’s no longer the way successful teams play football.

I suppose you are suggesting as those who continue to support Hodgson that it is the only style of football we can ever play, whereas I see that style as the only way Hodgson knows how to play.

Of course we shouldn't play like that too often but in the circumstances, the team we put out on the pitch did ok and a getting a point and denying Fulham 3 points was very important in staying in the division.

 

Palace BANANA Flag Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 01 Mar 21 1.34pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

It’s having the pick of players and having options from the bench. We don’t have that at the moment.

So Tomkins, Schlupp, Jimmy Mac, Zaha, Kelly , Sakho. All these players would feature in the first 11 or from the bench, that’s a fact.

And you don’t think there is a problem, you named 4 yourself and one of them is our top scorer. Who’s deluded?

Even if we did have a full squad and a full bench Roy isn't particularly good with substitutions.. even when it's clear players are knackered and need to be substituted he only usually brings on fresh legs with minutes to spare, if at all, which rarely, if ever, makes a difference.. and as Eaglecoops said, Kelly has been fit for weeks, on the bench and a good defender on his day, why hasn't he been brought on to help our negative/defensive tactics when we've been up against it and give a rest to one of our players..

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 01 Mar 21 1.43pm


Are we including the Wickham/Ferguson factor of +76 in the equation ?

Edited by Booted Eagle (01 Mar 2021 1.44pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Mar 21 1.46pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Of course we shouldn't play like that too often but in the circumstances, the team we put out on the pitch did ok and a getting a point and denying Fulham 3 points was very important in staying in the division.

I can’t argue with that, it was a very tough watch though.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 01 Mar 21 1.50pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Newcastle scored first so why wasn't that game over as soon as they scored? We won that one remember?

Injuries have been horrendous this season and don't tell me that it hasn't made any difference. Ask any Manager if they would prefer a settled team rather than having to make changes all the time. If you think they don't make a difference look at Liverpool, they lost VvD to a season ending injury and haven't been the same since


Exactly, we’ve started shipping goals this season because we haven’t had a settled defence, that’s no coincidence.

Edited by monkey (01 Mar 2021 1.51pm)

 

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 01 Mar 21 2.26pm

Originally posted by Osvaldo

Even the BBC pundits were bored out of their minds.
Couldn't quite believe they were watching Premiership teams.
Fulham outplayed us. Never had a shot on goal.
Yes, we've got injuries but this was a half decent team with Cahill and the GK outstanding.
The Cottagers closed us down and all we could do was boot the ball forward and hope it arrived at a Palace player.
There was no strategy or plan. It looked as though Fulham were playing at home. How we got 4 points from last 2 games beggars belief.
Why not add some fresh legs with 20 mins to go.
No good Roy saying we played well. Let's face it, if they had taken their chances we could have lost 3-0!

A tactic used when you realise your midfield has been over run.

 

Mstrobez Flag 01 Mar 21 2.36pm

Originally posted by gaz1959

Just read Roys comment's after todays game ???? Did he see the same dross that was on the BBC ?

I watched his post match interview and he clearly stated that he was happy with a return of 4 points against teams who are younger & more expensive than us, whilst we have key players out injured, but would still like to see us do more in possession.

If you'd rather us lose matches for the sake of appeasing the whingers, it's a good job you're not in charge of the club.

Roy works with what he has at his disposal. What he has at his disposal isn't too great.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 01 Mar 21 4.02pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

In your time supporting the club, you've witnessed the utter dross served up by Trevor Francis and Peter Taylor. Now that was unenjoyable. This is still the most successful period in the club's entire history and I'd far rather witness this period where we're an established Premier League side going through a temporary issue involving squad age and depth. There have been far more unenjoyable periods than this.

I agree they were periods of dross, as was the George Burley era, but it at least felt like the games mattered. We never seem to be near the relegation zone or Europe and there is no desire to go for a cup run.

I am aware that it is a successful period for the club but mid table mediocrity playing dour football is taking its toll. I've never been so disinterested in Palace as I am now.

Either way, there should be big changes this summer with so many players out of contract and Roy probably retiring. It could be a boom or bust - both of which are better than what we are going through now.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bewildered