This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
agree too. had a great 1st season - now suffereing 2nd Season syndrome. has offered no evidence that he will succeed as a PL manager. on a related note - any idea what's happened to David Wagner since he did the same for Huddersfield? One PL Season doth not a good PL manager make. Wagner went on to manage Schalke in the Bundesliga but was relieved of his duties after about a year and a quarter due to poor results. At Huddersfield, in their first season in the PL he took them to 16th place.In their 2nd season he was sacked after 22 games with the team bottom of the table. Edited by Willo (12 Mar 2021 2.47pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Think I might be missing something here. Wilder has done a good job at Sheffield United. I would think there are plenty of good managers who would have fancied their chances of getting a club that size out of league 1, though fair play to Wilder for actually doing it, and for then achieving a very impressive promotion to the big league. Credit too for keeping them up with what was partly the league 1 squad he started with. Thereafter he couldn't do anything to arrest a massive, humiliating, season long capitulation. They have literally been in the running to be record breakers. He hasn't been able to overhaul the team that did so well for him in the lower leagues, despite buying and borrowing some highly rated players. The list of managers to get clubs promoted into the premier league isn't exactly short, but the list of those to do well once in that league is. Wilder has earned his place on the first list, but not on the second. What exactly has he done to make him the right man to build a new team, on a relatively limited budget, at a club who have hit the glass ceiling in the top flight? Does he have any obvious track record of developing young players? Has he integrated new signings into a side with success? Shouldn't think he'll have to wait too long before a good championship club makes him an offer, but I genuinely can't see why he'd be suitable for us. Edited by TheBigToePunt (12 Mar 2021 2.18pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Think I might be missing something here. Wilder has done a good job at Sheffield United. I would think there are plenty of good managers who would have fancied their chances of getting a club that size out of league 1, though fair play to Wilder for actually doing it, and for then achieving a very impressive promotion to the big league. Credit too for keeping them up with what was partly the league 1 squad he started with. Thereafter he couldn't do anything to arrest a massive, humiliating, season long capitulation. They have literally been in the running to be record breakers. He hasn't been able to overhaul the team that did so well for him in the lower leagues, despite buying and borrowing some highly rated players. The list of managers to get clubs promoted into the premier league isn't exactly short, but the list of those to do well once in that league is. Wilder has earned his place on the first list, but not on the second. What exactly has he done to make him the right man to build a new team, on a relatively limited budget, at a club who have hit the glass ceiling in the top flight? Does he have any obvious track record of developing young players? Has he integrated new signings into a side with success? Shouldn't think he'll have to wait too long before a good championship club makes him an offer, but I genuinely can't see why he'd be suitable for us.
Every manager is a risk, but Wilder's managerial record up until this season has been largely on an upward trajectory. Obviously he has only two years experience in the PL, one in which they massively overachieved and one in which they have achieved largely the opposite. If he was to be considered I imagine Parish and the board would vet him on how he felt he could improve the team and take the club forward. Although not PL clubs, he does appear to have improved the teams he has managed throughout his career and in the case of Sheffield Utd implemented a long-term strategy rather than doing a simple job of plugging holes, which culminated in their unique approach to the game that was so lauded last season. This season the centre-backs who made that system possible have often been missing through injury and with a lack of squad depth or support in the January window has meant they've sunk lower and lower. Any manager is a risk, especially as we have gone through the list of seemingly sure bets (Hodgson, Allardyce and Pulis). Of those not already employed, the rest of the field are mainly either managers with no PL experience, managers with no experience of managing a smaller PL team, or managers who were sacked from their PL club. Howe is one of the few exceptions, but there are as many question marks over him as there are over Wilder, I would say. Dyche looks like the best fit in terms of ensuring PL football, but Burnley can generally be as hard to watch as us. Several managers have spoken about how Wilder is a 'student of the game' and he certainly seems willing to change tactics to try and fix things. We arguably have better players than Sheffield Utd and with a few additions I think he may be our best hope of finding a way of playing more entertaining football without being rinsed by the PL's big clubs. If he could find a strong working relationship with Parish and Freedman he could thrive, but that, as I said earlier, could be the biggest sticking point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
Mark Hughes once walked out on Fulham to make himself available for the Villa job, but they didn't come calling. Wonder if Wilder is putting his hat in our ring (if you pardon the expression). Apparently Parish wanted Hughes for Palace but (thankfully) he turned us down.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
Mark Hughes once walked out on Fulham to make himself available for the Villa job, but they didn't come calling. Wonder if Wilder is putting his hat in our ring (if you pardon the expression). If he had a hat, he would undoubtedly doff it. To coin a phrase.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Pierre
Not sure Chris Wilder would want to come running to us if the opportunity even arises. With an ageing squad, lots of players at end of contracts, renewal of contract discussions with some of them not with all by the end of this season. Also would he end up with any more input into transfers as we already have a director of Football at CPFC and apparently SUFC wanting to appoint one was rumoured to be one of the sticking points he didn't like? I would be very careful what we wish for! Re the players out of contract. Is roy too familiar to actually make the correct call. A new manager may be better to do this. Not necessarily wilder but one who has no affinity. Anyone on here with a business must know how hard it is to get rid of long termers. Not the politics but the emotion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
So lets get this right, peeps on here want Roy, who has kept us in the prem, out I think it’s more a case of IF he doesn’t have his contract renewed, who comes in. I certainly wouldn’t be ditching Roy for someone like Wilder.
|
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
So lets get this right, peeps on here want Roy, who has kept us in the prem, out Zzzzzz
|
|
|
No way, One trick pony. Has now been found out. Cant change his system. Has signed rubbish. Going down and as much his fault as anyones at SU. No thanks
|
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
A depressing assesment of his abilty, he was in total control of who they bought, so if they have a poor squad its down to him. The reason he is leaving Utd is he wont work with a Director pf Football, who the owner wants to put on place.
|
|
|
I'm torn on this. Part of me thinks that he's quite a good manager. The other part says he's a dour northerner who thinks he's Brian Clough. Nowhere near.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.