This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Why not read the article properly if you want to have a rant as it says quite clearly that "The youngster harbours concerns about what opportunities lie ahead at Palace with competition particularly fierce in the wing and attacking midfield positions." Why not blame Parish as it was him that bought Eze who is probably the one blocking his path to the first team With Zaha playing as a striker now and Townsend getting on, there is only Eze which is hardly ‘fierce’ competition seeing as there are two wings. No idea who are our attacking midfielders are. The article is a worry if this is how he feels. I’m sure he’s not the only one. Now is the perfect time to try out a youngster or two. If they’re not ready, it will be a good experience and help their development. It at least shows the others that it’s possible to get to the first team and will keep them motivated. We know from previous seasons that Roy will stick with his usual lineup. Apart from about £2m in prize money which really is small fry, it makes no difference if we finish 9th or 15th. Blooding youngsters is a better long term investment.
|
|
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
One of our brightest prospects from this brilliant under 18's team we currently have might turn down a professional contract from us to instead go to Germany. Apparently he is worried he may not be able to break into the first team quickly under dinosaur Hodgson. I'm sick and tired of the Roy in brigade. Lets have another couple of years with snooze fest Roy ball, not bringing any youngsters through, but hey ho why not give another contract to that crock Wickham!!! who won't play for another two years!!! I tell you something, if Hodgson gets another year, i'm done with football until he retires. just because he has good record at U18 level does not mean he is going to be top PL player and he will only break in to the first team when and if he is ready. He sounds like he is acting like a spoilt brat!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
So what is the point of paying loads of money out to create an academy if it is unlikely any of the players will ever play for us? Because it is not going to happen to every youth player, some will make the choice that their development is best served by going somewhere they are more likely to get first team experience, gutting for us but their decision. Going to Germany seems popular at the moment but not every player is going that way. To be honest if you are an up and coming star at Millwall or Charlton academy and you get an offer at the Cat 1 Palace you are likely to take it , but rising starlet seek future in Beckenham isn’t going to make a great story except for the South London Press, we will nick players as well and the cat 1 academy makes us more attractive.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
So what is the point of paying loads of money out to create an academy if it is unlikely any of the players will ever play for us? The gulf between reserves and first team, is enormous there is no guarantee that this lad will make it. We pinched the lad from Chelsea so he has no loyalty to us and will do what he thinks is best for himself. Some clubs have dropped their academies as they don't think they are worth it. Another poster (maybe different thread) has pointed out that our players currently on loan are not distinguishing themselves (yet) in the lower leagues. A while ago I posted an article about the youngest players to debut for each PL club. From memory most of them either flopped or had careers at lower league clubs so it's not a Palace problem as such. Sometimes you just have to bite the bullet and accept that you will lose players just like PVA who will walk out on us at the end of the season. Edited by Badger11 (17 Mar 2021 7.49am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
With Zaha playing as a striker now and Townsend getting on, there is only Eze which is hardly ‘fierce’ competition seeing as there are two wings. No idea who are our attacking midfielders are. The article is a worry if this is how he feels. I’m sure he’s not the only one. Now is the perfect time to try out a youngster or two. If they’re not ready, it will be a good experience and help their development. It at least shows the others that it’s possible to get to the first team and will keep them motivated. We know from previous seasons that Roy will stick with his usual lineup. Apart from about £2m in prize money which really is small fry, it makes no difference if we finish 9th or 15th. Blooding youngsters is a better long term investment. I agree with you on this I'd rather see us play Metata and come 14th then play Beneteke and come 9th. In a usual season if would be good even just for expereince and to help get a reputation for playing youth.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Because it is not going to happen to every youth player, some will make the choice that their development is best served by going somewhere they are more likely to get first team experience, gutting for us but their decision. Going to Germany seems popular at the moment but not every player is going that way. To be honest if you are an up and coming star at Millwall or Charlton academy and you get an offer at the Cat 1 Palace you are likely to take it , but rising starlet seek future in Beckenham isn’t going to make a great story except for the South London Press, we will nick players as well and the cat 1 academy makes us more attractive. Your last sentence sums it up. Many are saying the academy is everything, our future, whereas in reality it might not produce anyone that we will actually play because we have a plethora of 30 year olds who are a ‘safe pair of hands’ and we can’t risk playing youngsters. It’s a sad indictment of the mindset the club are in where they must, at all costs, stay in the PL which inevitably dictates the line up of the team. Having a first class academy is all well and good but if there is no clearly visible pathway from youth to the first team or if the player simply refuses to sign a professional contract, then they will be free to leave and the most Palace will get is a training compensation fee of I think around £150,000/£175,000. So these players will only start to create decent income for us if we can filter them into the team and start to showcase them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The gulf between reserves and first team, is enormous there is no guarantee that this lad will make it. We pinched the lad from Chelsea so he has no loyalty to us and will do what he thinks is best for himself. Some clubs have dropped their academies as they don't think they are worth it. Another poster (maybe different thread) has pointed out that our players currently on loan are not distinguishing themselves (yet) in the lower leagues. A while ago I posted an article about the youngest players to debut for each PL club. From memory most of them either flopped or had careers at lower league clubs so it's not a Palace problem as such.
Sometimes you just have to bite the bullet and accept that you will lose players just like PVA who will walk out on us at the end of the season. Edited by Badger11 (17 Mar 2021 7.49am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Your last sentence sums it up. Many are saying the academy is everything, our future, whereas in reality it might not produce anyone that we will actually play because we have a plethora of 30 year olds who are a ‘safe pair of hands’ and we can’t risk playing youngsters. It’s a sad indictment of the mindset the club are in where they must, at all costs, stay in the PL which inevitably dictates the line up of the team. Having a first class academy is all well and good but if there is no clearly visible pathway from youth to the first team or if the player simply refuses to sign a professional contract, then they will be free to leave and the most Palace will get is a training compensation fee of I think around £150,000/£175,000. So these players will only start to create decent income for us if we can filter them into the team and start to showcase them. Just having a first class Academy is a step in the right direction. It's better to have an academy and not use it - selling on the prospects if there's no way through here. at Some point we'll use it, and they'll be there. If it pays for itself, whats the harm?
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Perhaps he should have chat with a certain Mr Bostock about what can happen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Let's imagine for a moment that the academy has been running for a few years, and has a mix of average, decent, and potentially exceptional talent. Let's also imagine that the first team is also settled. It becomes obvious that not every academy player is going to break through. this is how academies work.If you have 1 or 2 world class left backs in your first team, and then another coming through the academy... He has to be something special at 18, or something horrific happen to the players standing in his way for him to get a chance at your club. so regardless of how good he might be, they will likely move on. you need to be The right talent at the right time.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by BelfastEagle
Perhaps he should have chat with a certain Mr Bostock about what can happen. I don't hold to the myth that if Bostock had stayed with us he would have become a regular first team player and possibly even a great player. It didn't work out at Spurs but he had plenty of opportunities elsewhere and has never been more than a 2nd or 3rd tier player. Yes maybe he would have knuckled down we will never know. Patrick Bamford is a good example of a player who failed at Palace and Norwich but he found his way at boro and Leeds and has proved his point. Bostock could have done that but didn't. Edited by Badger11 (17 Mar 2021 10.08am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
One of our brightest prospects from this brilliant under 18's team we currently have might turn down a professional contract from us to instead go to Germany. Apparently he is worried he may not be able to break into the first team quickly under dinosaur Hodgson. I'm sick and tired of the Roy in brigade. Lets have another couple of years with snooze fest Roy ball, not bringing any youngsters through, but hey ho why not give another contract to that crock Wickham!!! who won't play for another two years!!! I tell you something, if Hodgson gets another year, i'm done with football until he retires. Have a day off will you
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Your last sentence sums it up. Many are saying the academy is everything, our future, whereas in reality it might not produce anyone that we will actually play because we have a plethora of 30 year olds who are a ‘safe pair of hands’ and we can’t risk playing youngsters. It’s a sad indictment of the mindset the club are in where they must, at all costs, stay in the PL which inevitably dictates the line up of the team. Having a first class academy is all well and good but if there is no clearly visible pathway from youth to the first team or if the player simply refuses to sign a professional contract, then they will be free to leave and the most Palace will get is a training compensation fee of I think around £150,000/£175,000. So these players will only start to create decent income for us if we can filter them into the team and start to showcase them. Of course it is not guaranteed, not much in football can be guaranteed. You could spend £50m and get Rhian Brewster and Aaron Ramsdale and the sack.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Of course it is not guaranteed, not much in football can be guaranteed. You could spend £50m and get Rhian Brewster and Aaron Ramsdale and the sack. Whilst i agree with the jist of your post, the bit in red makes it fall down(imo). We have currently on our books 2 players that were PL proven, High Fees & High Wages . . . Benteke & Sakho
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Can I just point out before we start on the Hodgson wont play youth thread again how well the 4 players out on loan are doing, the ones dinosaur Hodgson won’t play. Kirby started two matches at Tranmere and seems to have been taken off at half time in both, similar with Pierick who is been kept out of the Kilmarnock first team by the talent of Kyle Lafferty. Sam Woods has been a sub for Plymouth and Scott Banks seems to be doing ok in the Scottish championship . Hopefully ,they are all learning from the experience hopefully they will all come good but let’s not kid ourself these are premier league ready players. We have only just got the top grade academy and the young players are simple not there to play but hopefully they will come through over the next few years. A pal I used to work with (former Palace academy player, now playing non league) told me previously that in his opinion, often the difference between Premier League and League 2 is luck and getting the opportunity. His general frustration is that a lot of youngsters don't get a chance over a foreign import or more established player. If we look at AWB, he would never have got a sniff it it wasn't for an injury crisis. He could be on loan at somewhere like Oldham now if he didn't get the lucky break. I think back to watching Hiram Boeteng coming on as a sub away at Swansea a few years ago and thought he was great. I don't think he ever got the chance again. Often you've just got to throw a kid in to see how they cope, will they sink or swim. Some will thrive and take their game up a notch to a new level. Now is the risk free time of the season to take this sort of gamble.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Whilst i agree with the jist of your post, the bit in red makes it fall down(imo). We have currently on our books 2 players that were PL proven, High Fees & High Wages . . . Benteke & Sakho Aright I might be pushing it a bit, we did in the early years make some ‘marque’ signings Cabaye, Beneteke and Sakho, but in this context of this argument about buying players with proven ability over taking a risk on potential they fit the bill of proven premier league players who were over looked for one reason or another . Beneteke had played 130 games at Villa and Liverpool and scored 51 goals ,Klopp wanted shot of him. Sakho was similar, a proven player who had played a few season at Liverpool which had been limited due his knee injuries, how they have worked out is a different matter.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.