This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
The new stand is the very obvious answer to increasing revenue but it hasn’t progressed much at all. There does seem to be something going on there. The planning permission will expire at this rate. I wonder if the business plan is not quite so convincing now that they've seen the club up close, but ultimately if you wanted to increase the value of the asset you wanted to sell, building the stand makes long term sense. I do wonder sometimes if the board are nervous about putting £100m into a project which will only pay back if we stay up, and which otherwise could be a massive millstone around the neck of a championship club. If we had five or six players under 24 who would command good Premier league transfer fees then there would be some security against the event of relegation, but we all know it hasn't worked that way. I've made the point before in relation to other subjects, but I'll repeat it here: I trust Parish, and if there is something he is leaving unsaid it's for good reason. There is no doubt whatsoever that when it comes to the stand more and more is being left unsaid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Your first point is what we were all told when the Americans came on board and £100m was supposedly ringfenced for stadium redevelopment which as time goes on seems to be more and more unlikely. Your second point is also true. Your third point is the difficult one to answer as the accounts are so convoluted with shareholdings disappearing into the mist that no-one really knows what is going on there Very true but why do they use such opaque structures if there is nothing to hide? No doubt to extract money in a 'tax efficient,' way. Whilst you can only follow the money so far, the gaps are perhaps more telling than anything else.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
Yes, Tim, I know, I know, I did get it, but, apart from McDonalds What else have the Americans done to grow our beloved Palace. It still seems to me, having started this and reading the responses so far, we don't properly know. Thing is. Are we or are we not getting value for money? Blame culture? That's definitely their fault.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Great scene and dialogue. ‘’You long streak of paralysed p1ss’’ is a highlight. Pierce Brosnan from the IRA points a gun at him at the end in his chauffeured car they hijacked after Helen Mirren gets taken away for her probable execution in another car. At the start Pierce Brosnan kills Belach from ‘Raiders of The Lost Ark’ playing a London firm gangster after a swim in what he thought was about to be a casual homosexual encounter in the changing area. Not Colin!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Not Colin! What? The caterpillar. Surely not?
|
|
|
Originally posted by HolmesdaleUpper
Yes, I too had similar thoughts. We're going to have an interesting summer one way or another.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Very true but why do they use such opaque structures if there is nothing to hide? No doubt to extract money in a 'tax efficient,' way. Whilst you can only follow the money so far, the gaps are perhaps more telling than anything else. The full ownership of the club is shrouded by exactly the kind of mysterious dead end paper trails that should possibly be banned in every walk of life, though we do know that the main owners are Parsh and the two Americans followed by a bunch of far smaller shareholders. Parish and the Yanks have the majority and so are defacto owners. Parish takes a wage as he runs it day to day. It is true that the Americans could extract money from the club somehow I'm sure, but it seems highly unlikely that is their intention. The rate of return would be so very, very low compared to what they have plainly put in, that they could literally leave the same money in a bank account and make more. On the available evidence, they aren't here to rip anyone off, have plainly helped us out when we needed it to the tune of tens of millions on more than one occasion, but at the same time have not yet done that which they were most widely expected to do and make significant investments in infrastructure (or Selhurst anyway).
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The full ownership of the club is shrouded by exactly the kind of mysterious dead end paper trails that should possibly be banned in every walk of life, though we do know that the main owners are Parsh and the two Americans followed by a bunch of far smaller shareholders. Parish and the Yanks have the majority and so are defacto owners. Parish takes a wage as he runs it day to day. It is true that the Americans could extract money from the club somehow I'm sure, but it seems highly unlikely that is their intention. The rate of return would be so very, very low compared to what they have plainly put in, that they could literally leave the same money in a bank account and make more. On the available evidence, they aren't here to rip anyone off, have plainly helped us out when we needed it to the tune of tens of millions on more than one occasion, but at the same time have not yet done that which they were most widely expected to do and make significant investments in infrastructure (or Selhurst anyway). Thanks BTP. Best responses so far. Maybe now the Academy has been completed and we're in the PL for another year, we'll see some progress with the stadium. Like you, I trust Mr Parish to do what he believes to be the right thing for our club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The full ownership of the club is shrouded by exactly the kind of mysterious dead end paper trails that should possibly be banned in every walk of life, though we do know that the main owners are Parsh and the two Americans followed by a bunch of far smaller shareholders. Parish and the Yanks have the majority and so are defacto owners. Parish takes a wage as he runs it day to day. It is true that the Americans could extract money from the club somehow I'm sure, but it seems highly unlikely that is their intention. The rate of return would be so very, very low compared to what they have plainly put in, that they could literally leave the same money in a bank account and make more. On the available evidence, they aren't here to rip anyone off, have plainly helped us out when we needed it to the tune of tens of millions on more than one occasion, but at the same time have not yet done that which they were most widely expected to do and make significant investments in infrastructure (or Selhurst anyway). Not strictly true it is very easy to extract value. They have loaned money which is inserted into the structure at a number of levels and through structures such as the Delaware LLP's which are not obliged to file accounts. These loans attract interest at a far higher rate that is paid by the banks - as no bank would lend that money on a simple risk analysis and so a lot of money is simply servicing debt. Parish also takes a lot more than his salary as he controls a number of the service companies used in the structure which charge a healthy rate for their services. These structures are pretty standard in the affairs of wealthy individuals. These people are not philanthropists.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
When Harris and Blitzer bought their share they said: “We couldn’t be more excited to be joining the Crystal Palace family. We were drawn to the club’s rich history, exciting brand of football, strong leadership and, above all, its passionate fans." At the time of signing the deal we were riding high sixth in the table. I wonder if the excitement has died down yet Add that to the fact it was reported in 2019 that they had enlisted a law firm to try and sell their share and it suggests they perhaps expected to get a bigger return on investment. COVID probably put an end to any hopes of an immediate sale. All the things that have appeared in the press since they came on board gives me the feeling they may have underestimated just how competitive the PL is. It may also be partly behind the hold-up in development plans. Thankfully in Parish we have a man who I believe genuinely has the club's best interests at heart. The Americans didn't come on board as a gesture of goodwill, so I don't feel we owe them any huge amount of gratitude. They saw what they thought was an opportunity to turn a decent profit and possibly now realise they can't and want out and I hope they get their wishes. I feel no animosity towards them, it is just the way these things are, but we certainly don't need reluctant investors running the club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Not strictly true it is very easy to extract value. They have loaned money which is inserted into the structure at a number of levels and through structures such as the Delaware LLP's which are not obliged to file accounts. These loans attract interest at a far higher rate that is paid by the banks - as no bank would lend that money on a simple risk analysis and so a lot of money is simply servicing debt. Parish also takes a lot more than his salary as he controls a number of the service companies used in the structure which charge a healthy rate for their services. These structures are pretty standard in the affairs of wealthy individuals. These people are not philanthropists. Yes, Parish has a firm which is (I think literally) called 'Smoke and Mirrors' which hires services to the club, but it's all shown in the accounts and is for fairly small beans in the grand scheme of things - if he wanted another 100k a year I'm sure he could just give himself a pay rise - so it's hardly suspicious. I'm sure you are right that there is some clever way to get a higher rate of return on what is probably about £100 - £150m(?) that the Americans have put in by now (if you include the purchase price) than they'd literally get in interest from a bank, but I still don't think there is any evidence to suggest they are looking to cream off of the club. If they depleted it, even bit at a time, then their investment goes sour, and they lose a huge amount more than they would ever gain through all the little nibbles they might be able to take along the way. Plus, if they were looking to extract more than they put in, why would they keep coughing up tens of millions when we need it? Agreed that we are not dealing with philanthropists, but I wouldn't expect to be. I certainly don't begrudge Parish his salary (high as it is), nor do I begrudge the Americans a fairly quick buck if they redevelop Selhurst and sell their shares to some other billionaires. All seems fair enough to me. There is some obscurity in the structure, set up and investment plan, but none of that makes any of them dodgy, which I think is the conclusion one's mind can wander to in the ongoing absence of total clarity on this issue. Them not telling us exactly what they are up to isn't the same as them doing something they shouldn't.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Yes, Parish has a firm which is (I think literally) called 'Smoke and Mirrors' which hires services to the club, but it's all shown in the accounts and is for fairly small beans in the grand scheme of things - if he wanted another 100k a year I'm sure he could just give himself a pay rise - so it's hardly suspicious. I'm sure you are right that there is some clever way to get a higher rate of return on what is probably about £100 - £150m(?) that the Americans have put in by now (if you include the purchase price) than they'd literally get in interest from a bank, but I still don't think there is any evidence to suggest they are looking to cream off of the club. If they depleted it, even bit at a time, then their investment goes sour, and they lose a huge amount more than they would ever gain through all the little nibbles they might be able to take along the way. Plus, if they were looking to extract more than they put in, why would they keep coughing up tens of millions when we need it? Agreed that we are not dealing with philanthropists, but I wouldn't expect to be. I certainly don't begrudge Parish his salary (high as it is), nor do I begrudge the Americans a fairly quick buck if they redevelop Selhurst and sell their shares to some other billionaires. All seems fair enough to me. There is some obscurity in the structure, set up and investment plan, but none of that makes any of them dodgy, which I think is the conclusion one's mind can wander to in the ongoing absence of total clarity on this issue. Them not telling us exactly what they are up to isn't the same as them doing something they shouldn't. I am merely suggesting that like any international investor they structure their investments in a way that offers them an opportunity to maximise their income. View of that what you will. Not suggesting anything illegal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
I am merely suggesting that like any international investor they structure their investments in a way that offers them an opportunity to maximise their income. View of that what you will. Not suggesting anything illegal. I wasn't suggesting you were accusing anyone of illegal activities! I think the issue is whether one feels the Americans are here to build Palace up to be bigger and better (even if only slightly) than it was before, or whether they are here to take whatever they can get, or whether it's actually some point in between. To me, the basic facts as I understand them suggested they've put their hands in their pockets plenty, but yet the headline reason they were sold a share in the club seems to have gone cold for no obvious, insurmountable reason.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I wasn't suggesting you were accusing anyone of illegal activities! I think the issue is whether one feels the Americans are here to build Palace up to be bigger and better (even if only slightly) than it was before, or whether they are here to take whatever they can get, or whether it's actually some point in between. To me, the basic facts as I understand them suggested they've put their hands in their pockets plenty, but yet the headline reason they were sold a share in the club seems to have gone cold for no obvious, insurmountable reason. Its a difficult one isn't it? I think the American model in most sports where you buy what is often in effect a franchise does possibly not lend itself to emotional investment. So guess we will never really know. My concern is that the signals are increasingly that money is not there - with a lack of recent investment on the pitch and the lack of redevelopment on the ground. If you stand still in this league you are probably in reality going backwards. I am also suspicious of any opaque ownership structures as they are well, opaque.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.