You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players to keep...in your opinion ?
November 16 2026 4.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Which players to keep...in your opinion ?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 23 May 21 9.10am

Originally posted by daven

Players in contract;
Zaha 2023
Kouyate 2022
Tomkins 2022
Luka 2023
McCarthy 2022
Eze 2025
Butland 2023
Ayew 2022
Guiata 2024
Reidewald 2024
Mitchell 2025
Anyone else will have to compete with other players from other clubs also out of contract.

In addition to these players I'd resign Clyne(& hope NF actually gets fit) promote Webber up from U23's, Cahill, Kelly, promote Hannam from U23's, Townsend, we have Mateta for next season on loan Shlupp, also hope some of the kids come good ie Rak-Sakyi.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 May 21 9.35am

Originally posted by daven

The players that are out of contract in the summer cease to become our players, so they are all free agents.
The club will use this to reduce the wage bill as it will become a market where the players without contracts will be worried about their futures.
I would be very surprised if we paid any transfer fees this summer because there will be a pool of players from the other clubs who need a contract.
Players who have performed well will take the best offer from whatever club and we could lose players that we want to keep because they have been offered better contracts elsewhere.
So except for Zaha and a few others with contracts I expect that we could start next season unrecognisable to todays team. Which underlines the reason why the timing of Roys departure was ineviatable.
So the only players that I would keep are the ones with contracts.


They types of clubs likely to want our out-of-contract players are unlikely to be offering anything like what we might offer given that we currently overpay those players. Benteke, given his current form, might attract serious attention elsewhere, but he knows that he's the no. 1 striker here and the club are unlikely to be forking out for a replacement. Interesting times ahead, though.

 

Arthur Waite Flag Portsmouth 23 May 21 10.21am

RELEASE:

Sakho- always injured; now slow and not effective

Ward- great servant but now a defensive liability

McCarthy- injured a lot- doesn't influence the game enough

Dann - now absolutely awful- very slow

Hennessey - not used and a third choice now

Wickham - who is he?

Kelly- hasn't had a good run due to injuries


RETAIN:

Benteke- has improved

Schlupp- key player

PVA- skilful going forward

McArthur- work rate excellent

Cahill- experienced - we need that, even though he can't play every game

Townsend- we will need him as Eze is injured for quite a while

Mateta- not had a proper run, but he does look slow

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 May 21 12.15pm

while i love Cahill, i reckon he will now only be effective for 65 minutes per game, or to come on later as a Sub.

at nearly 36, he is the oldest man in our squad.

and to echo the silence of everybody above, Luka is now only a shadow of his former self.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 May 2021 12.20pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 May 21 12.46pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

while i love Cahill, i reckon he will now only be effective for 65 minutes per game, or to come on later as a Sub.

at nearly 36, he is the oldest man in our squad.

and to echo the silence of everybody above, Luka is now only a shadow of his former self.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 May 2021 12.20pm)


Fernandinho is already 36 and is negotiating another year with Citeh. It's really about fitness (think Jimmy Anderson and cricket). Unfortunately, Cahill hasn't worn that well but he can do a job even if not every week.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 May 21 6.58pm


Mitchell did well today. Against some of the best attacking players on the planet. It could have been 7-0 on another day.

I reckon he has earned the shirt for next season.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 May 21 8.01pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio


Mitchell did well today. Against some of the best attacking players on the planet. It could have been 7-0 on another day.

I reckon he has earned the shirt for next season.


Agreed, although there are some on the match thread who thought he was rubbish today.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 23 May 21 10.12pm

Keep everyone except PVA, Hennessey and Wilf. And I'd take or leave McArthy too.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 May 21 10.38pm

It's a case of pragmatism versus wishful thinking.

For me we should let the following players contracts run out:
- Hennessey (no need for him as a no 3 keeper)
- Henderson (not really used him to date and good cover in U23s)
- Sakho (Hardly seen him this season)
- Wickham (seen even less of him)
- PvA (too inconsistent and fails in his defensive duties too often)
- Dann (too slow and past it for this league)
- Clyne (I actually prefer Ward who I think would be better in a system which wasn't so narrow)

Should try and retain the following:
- Benteke
- Schlupp
- Townsend
- Cahill
- Ward
- Woods

These players could be let go if we have satisfactory (younger) replacements:
- McCarthy
- Kelly
- McArthur

All the current U23s are still young enough to represent us at that level next season. It would be good if they can win the play-off tomorrow so they can pitch themselves against the big clubs next year.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 23 May 21 11.44pm

After the last couple of games, think it is time to say farewell to our wonderful right-back Joel Ward. His lack of pace cost us in every game. Wonder what Clyne is like now when he can not get into the side..?
Others to release: Sakho, McCarthy, Hennessey, Dann (been great for us), Tomkins (too injury prone), Wickham (obvious).

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 May 21 1.31am

Still think both Sakho and Wickham could be worth keeping, obviously with reduced terms or some creative pay as you play basis. Both quality on their day and if they get an injury-free run, would be like a couple of new 20mil + signings.

(I realise it's a big IF on the injury-free run.)

Edited by sprites (24 May 2021 1.32am)

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 24 May 21 2.29am

Wilf: We have to keep him, especially with Eze out.

Ayew: Don't see what he brings to our squad anymore, goodbye.

Hennesey: Third choice, no reason to keep him. Goodbye.

Sakho: Not unless he's willing to take a massive cut in wages. Goodbye.

Benteke: Not unless he's willing to take a massive cut in wages. Goodbye.

Schlupp: He's a bench player, not sure how much we want to pay him.

PVA: I like him, but as a bench player on reduced wages.

Cahill: A one year contract at most.

Ward: Bench player at best.

Townsend: Bench player at best.

McCarthy: I'd lean toward keeping him. He's similar to Luka, but better.

Kelly: We should be able to do better.

McArthur: Bench player at best.

Mateta: Keep.

Basically, we have a bunch of players who are either too old, or too injured to count on playing on every day. Roy never rotated players. Our new manager could get something out of players like Townsend, if he's on the bench most of the time, and starting here and there.

Benteke is another example. The guy was total sh-t for years, then when he's playing for a new contract, he looks great in a few games at the end of the season. This is another case where Roy f-ed up by not giving Mateta and/or Bats some starts so we could see if they would be adequate replacements for Benteke. But no, he stubbornly played Benteke every match. Now we don't now what Mateta and Bats can do, and we don't know if Benteke could be useful, or only motivated when playing for a new deal.

The disconnect between SP, DF, and Roy was cancerous to our squad this season. I mostly blame Roy for that, refusing to play anyone new.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

sprites Flag Auckland 24 May 21 4.15am

Wow. Lots to disagree with here. Where do I begin.

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Wilf: We have to keep him, especially with Eze out.

We really don't. He doesn't want to be here and his performances have shown that. If we can get anything in excess of 40 mil, I think we take it.

Ayew: Don't see what he brings to our squad anymore, goodbye.

Works his socks off. Chips in with goals. Covers wide positions, #10 and striker. Worth keeping for cover.

Hennesey: Third choice, no reason to keep him. Goodbye.

Agreed.

Sakho: Not unless he's willing to take a massive cut in wages. Goodbye.

Agreed. Although I'd be pushing the reduced terms, because when fit he's up there with our best.

Benteke: Not unless he's willing to take a massive cut in wages. Goodbye.

Madness. He's been in great form recently. Shows what he can do when we play to his strengths. Agreed that we need to try a different wage structure though (performance based.)

Schlupp: He's a bench player, not sure how much we want to pay him.

Not necessarily. Looked one of our more dangerous at times.

PVA: I like him, but as a bench player on reduced wages.

Agreed.

Cahill: A one year contract at most.

Agreed.

Ward: Bench player at best.

Agreed.

Townsend: Bench player at best.

Bit unfair - he's been our best player last couple of weeks.

McCarthy: I'd lean toward keeping him. He's similar to Luka, but better.

Nah, I'd get rid. Nowhere near as good as Luka.

Kelly: We should be able to do better.

Agreed.

McArthur: Bench player at best.

Rubbish. One of our most important players. Missed him.

Mateta: Keep.

For what?

Basically, we have a bunch of players who are either too old, or too injured to count on playing on every day. Roy never rotated players. Our new manager could get something out of players like Townsend, if he's on the bench most of the time, and starting here and there.

Benteke is another example. The guy was total sh-t for years, then when he's playing for a new contract, he looks great in a few games at the end of the season. This is another case where Roy f-ed up by not giving Mateta and/or Bats some starts so we could see if they would be adequate replacements for Benteke. But no, he stubbornly played Benteke every match. Now we don't now what Mateta and Bats can do, and we don't know if Benteke could be useful, or only motivated when playing for a new deal.

The playing for a new contract thing is rubbish. And it's getting boring. Players don't do that. We've made it up.

The disconnect between SP, DF, and Roy was cancerous to our squad this season. I mostly blame Roy for that, refusing to play anyone new.


Edited by sprites (24 May 2021 4.17am)

Edited by sprites (24 May 2021 4.17am)

 

EddieMac Flag 24 May 21 6.53am

Originally posted by sprites

Still think both Sakho and Wickham could be worth keeping, obviously with reduced terms or some creative pay as you play basis. Both quality on their day and if they get an injury-free run, would be like a couple of new 20mil + signings.

(I realise it's a big IF on the injury-free run.)

Edited by sprites (24 May 2021 1.32am)

I have read some bizarre statements on here all season but this has got to top them all.

Keep Sakho and Wickham hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahanananha

Edited by EddieMac (24 May 2021 6.55am)

 

EddieMac Flag 24 May 21 7.12am

Out:

Clyne: Will be let go and rightly so.

Hennessy: I’m sure he will get an offer from the Championship.

Sakho: He has been as good as gone since the start of the year.

Wickham: Please god get rid of him.

PVA: His mind has been made up to leave and he won’t be short of decent offers.

Bats: Obviously going as only on loan.

Scott Dann: He looks finished so there is no way he should be offered a new deal.

McCarthy: The injuries this season should have pushed the club to move him on.

Stay:

Benteke: After his end to the season I will be surprised if he is not offered a new deal but problem is now he will have offers elsewhere to compete with ours.

Cahill: Has shown enough this year to be offered a 1 year deal.

Ward: He has his faults stays injury free but and decent this season and at 31 I think I will be offered a new deal.


We have a major puzzle ahead this summer and I think a lot of the contract issues will be decided on wether we have other players lined up.

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 May 21 8.34am

It’s been reported that Ferguson has a long term injury now.
Puts Ward in a strong negotiating position for a new deal.
There must be doubt about offering Clyne another contract with his injury record.
Could mean we also need to be looking at a right back to the other positions on the shopping list.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 May 21 8.47am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Out:

Clyne: Will be let go and rightly so.

Hennessy: I’m sure he will get an offer from the Championship.

Sakho: He has been as good as gone since the start of the year.

Wickham: Please god get rid of him.

PVA: His mind has been made up to leave and he won’t be short of decent offers.

Bats: Obviously going as only on loan.

Scott Dann: He looks finished so there is no way he should be offered a new deal.

McCarthy: The injuries this season should have pushed the club to move him on.

Stay:

Benteke: After his end to the season I will be surprised if he is not offered a new deal but problem is now he will have offers elsewhere to compete with ours.

Cahill: Has shown enough this year to be offered a 1 year deal.

Ward: He has his faults stays injury free but and decent this season and at 31 I think I will be offered a new deal.


We have a major puzzle ahead this summer and I think a lot of the contract issues will be decided on wether we have other players lined up.

Only one of these I would change is Cahill. I know he's ( like all of our CB's ) had injury problems this season, but I think he's underperformed and not worth another expensive contract.

I think we need to sign at least 2 CB's in the summer.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 21 8.53am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Only one of these I would change is Cahill. I know he's ( like all of our CB's ) had injury problems this season, but I think he's underperformed and not worth another expensive contract.

I think we need to sign at least 2 CB's in the summer.

I am in total agreement and had this conversation only last night.
He will be 36 this year and his performances have waned over the season.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 May 21 8.58am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Only one of these I would change is Cahill. I know he's ( like all of our CB's ) had injury problems this season, but I think he's underperformed and not worth another expensive contract.

I think we need to sign at least 2 CB's in the summer.

Agreed. He is one of the main reasons we sit so deep, he's slow. I noticed a few times when he has failed to react quick enough to block, and turns his back resulting in opposition goals. I was surprised when he came in, I thought we should have been looking for younger players then; now the CB area is desperate for an overhaul.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (24 May 2021 8.59am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 21 9.09am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Agreed. He is one of the main reasons we sit so deep, he's slow. I noticed a few times when he has failed to react quick enough to block, and turns his back resulting in opposition goals. I was surprised when he came in, I thought we should have been looking for younger players then; now the CB area is desperate for an overhaul.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (24 May 2021 8.59am)

I concur with these sentiments whilst adding that sitting deep is not solely due to Cahill's deficiencies in the twilight of his career.
Central defence is definitely an area which needs strengthening.

Edited by Willo (24 May 2021 9.09am)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Which players to keep...in your opinion ?