You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf
November 16 2026 4.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 26 May 21 9.58am

if he stays on at Palace his heart isn't going to be in it, and he's a player who plays with heart. He doesn't want to look back on his career and wonder 'what if..', so I think it's about time he moved on in the quest of silverware or whatever it is he thinks he wants. He's been a very good servant to the club - can't begrudge him.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 26 May 21 12.14pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Here's a link;

[Link]

Personally I am sick and tired of Zaha’s moaning, sulking and general attitude - he clearly doesn’t want to be at Palace let him go.

If Spurs want him yeah OK £30M plus Ryan Sessagnon.

Then go and get Micheal Olise from Reading.

We’ll still have £20M left over.

COYP

I agree- we’ve indulged Wilf’s ego far too much imo and played him up front because he wants to improve his goal stats. Cant see Spurs or Everton or even Arsenal making the same concessions to keep him happy AND why should they! There are much better natural goal scorers with better top flight stats for that sort of money.

He’s a brilliant winger (unplayable on the right - at times) and that’s part of our problem really, we’re so desperate to keep him sweet we let him play where HE wants and not where is best for the TEAM.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 26 May 21 2.32pm

The Way I see it, we've made 10M profit on him already, so unless we get a decent fee so we get a decent chunk of it after ManU have taken their cut, he can stay with us for the remanider of his contract.

For us, now, A sulky Wilf is better than no Wilf at all.

Fwiw, I reckon he's playing with some kind of injury, which hasn't helped. We may see an invigorated, remotivated player under a new man next year.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 May 21 2.56pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

They were reputed to be offering him £200,000 per week last time but I'm not sure whether that's true or just media rubbish.

In any event who would he replace in the Everton side as I'm guessing that it wouldn't be Calvert-Lewin or Richarlison


Everton could well lose Richarlison to one of the BIGger clubs, so perhaps the click-baiters are putting 2 and 2 together and getting....?

 

Mstrobez Flag 26 May 21 3.04pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

I agree- we’ve indulged Wilf’s ego far too much imo and played him up front because he wants to improve his goal stats. Cant see Spurs or Everton or even Arsenal making the same concessions to keep him happy AND why should they! There are much better natural goal scorers with better top flight stats for that sort of money.

He’s a brilliant winger (unplayable on the right - at times) and that’s part of our problem really, we’re so desperate to keep him sweet we let him play where HE wants and not where is best for the TEAM.

Just wrong. The reason Wilf plays up front in a Roy 442 is to give him license to roam & not place the burden on him to track back.

in a Roy 442, out of possession, it's 2 banks of 4 and the wingers are expected to double up with the full backs. Whilst attacking, it would be less rigid & often Eze or Ayew would drift inside from the flanks to form a 3 up top, which would essentially allow Wilf to occupy pretty much any space across the front line (including the wing).

Whenever we went 433, it would effectively be a 451 out o possession - he'd play out wide and this would usually result in him having his moments in games (because he's a top player) but playing far too defensively for a player of his quality relative to our team.

I think Palace fans just like hammering people in all honesty. Roy has gone so hammering one of our greatest ever players & top scorer now seems to be the order of the day. It's quite pathetic, really.

We'd be nuts to actively try and push him out the door. And I don't think he'll be overly desperate to join Everton.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 May 2021 3.11pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

eaglesdare Flag 26 May 21 3.09pm

ship has sailed for wilf i think! he should have gone two seasons ago! or a least he should have left instead of wan bissaka!


Only arsenal seem to want to buy players of his age! prob get 25 mill for him.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 26 May 21 10.37pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Just wrong. The reason Wilf plays up front in a Roy 442 is to give him license to roam & not place the burden on him to track back.

in a Roy 442, out of possession, it's 2 banks of 4 and the wingers are expected to double up with the full backs. Whilst attacking, it would be less rigid & often Eze or Ayew would drift inside from the flanks to form a 3 up top, which would essentially allow Wilf to occupy pretty much any space across the front line (including the wing).

Whenever we went 433, it would effectively be a 451 out o possession - he'd play out wide and this would usually result in him having his moments in games (because he's a top player) but playing far too defensively for a player of his quality relative to our team.

I think Palace fans just like hammering people in all honesty. Roy has gone so hammering one of our greatest ever players & top scorer now seems to be the order of the day. It's quite pathetic, really.

We'd be nuts to actively try and push him out the door. And I don't think he'll be overly desperate to join Everton.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 May 2021 3.11pm)

Yeah that’ll be it Mstrobez - I love hammering the most talented player I’ve ever seen in a palace shirt. Nothing to do with a fair or balanced assessment of his overall performance and body language backed up by his open expression of a continued desire for bigger and better things. Nobody’s pushing out - he wants to go!
I think we should give him what he wants and get the best deal we can.

I just happen to hold a different opinion to yours - on this issue anyway.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 26 May 21 11.02pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

The Way I see it, we've made 10M profit on him already, so unless we get a decent fee so we get a decent chunk of it after ManU have taken their cut, he can stay with us for the remanider of his contract.

For us, now, A sulky Wilf is better than no Wilf at all.

Fwiw, I reckon he's playing with some kind of injury, which hasn't helped. We may see an invigorated, remotivated player under a new man next year.

Disagree entirely.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 26 May 21 11.04pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

who was our most influential attacking player then? not eze he spent half his season earning his stripes.

Exactly. And even with less game time, Eze got most palace fans twice as excited as Wilf did. He started well, but for the last 2/3 of the season, I'd say Eze, Benteke and even Townsend were more influential.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 27 May 21 12.24am

He should move in but no one here believes a decent side will come in for him at 40 million. That tells its own story. I think we may still have him next season but he isn’t irreplaceable and he isn’t entitled to play 90 minutes if he is playing badly.

There were a number of games where he should have been subbed but wasn’t because he might just have that moment of genius and score. If he’s been subbed or, God forbid, benched for a game it might have done him some good.

Next season could be a nightmare if we don’t sort the rest of the team out. Worst case scenario for him would be keeping him in the hope he can keep us up.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 May 21 12.53am

Originally posted by Elphers40

Yeah that’ll be it Mstrobez - I love hammering the most talented player I’ve ever seen in a palace shirt. Nothing to do with a fair or balanced assessment of his overall performance and body language backed up by his open expression of a continued desire for bigger and better things. Nobody’s pushing out - he wants to go!
I think we should give him what he wants and get the best deal we can.

I just happen to hold a different opinion to yours - on this issue anyway.

Great post.

 

CT Charlie Flag 27 May 21 2.00am

The original post asked why another team would want him, based on what we've seen lately.

My opinion is that Happy Wilf is still a force to be reckoned with, by any team in the League. Frustrated Wilf is not very effective. If he can be surrounded by players who'll create space for him, pass the ball where he needs it to be, and finish the opportunities he creates for him, he still has 3-5 more years of top-level play.

I'd love to see a new manager at Palace who can re-shape the offense – by finding the right players and by coaching them to create opportunities – to reward Wilf's talent. But it's more likely that we'll sell him for what we can get, and start anew.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 May 21 7.47am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Just wrong. The reason Wilf plays up front in a Roy 442 is to give him license to roam & not place the burden on him to track back.

in a Roy 442, out of possession, it's 2 banks of 4 and the wingers are expected to double up with the full backs. Whilst attacking, it would be less rigid & often Eze or Ayew would drift inside from the flanks to form a 3 up top, which would essentially allow Wilf to occupy pretty much any space across the front line (including the wing).

Whenever we went 433, it would effectively be a 451 out o possession - he'd play out wide and this would usually result in him having his moments in games (because he's a top player) but playing far too defensively for a player of his quality relative to our team.

I think Palace fans just like hammering people in all honesty. Roy has gone so hammering one of our greatest ever players & top scorer now seems to be the order of the day. It's quite pathetic, really.

We'd be nuts to actively try and push him out the door. And I don't think he'll be overly desperate to join Everton.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 May 2021 3.11pm)

No one is pushing him out the door. He submitted a transfer request for his own reasons, remember?

 

Mstrobez Flag 27 May 21 8.25am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No one is pushing him out the door. He submitted a transfer request for his own reasons, remember?

If Wilf wants to go and another club are prepared to take him for the right price then we should let him go. But there are plenty who are calling for him to go regardless.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

TheBigToePunt Flag 27 May 21 11.18am

The Zaha conundrum hasn't really changed, and probably won't: His value to us remains higher than the fee anyone will pay.

It's not madness to entertain the idea of selling Zaha for a sum that will enable us to strengthen the team, or at least prevent it from being weaker, and his desire to leave is a factor, but I do feel there is a slightly childish tone in a good few posts advocating his sale. If you've got to the point that you're checking whether his celebrations when someone else scores are sufficient for your tastes then you've probably gone too far.

The fact is that even at his (alleged) sulkiest and most disinterested, he has been our top scorer and most likely source of points through goals, chances created and defenders occupied. Again.

Even if we all agree (and I don't really) that his performances have declined, that, along with his increasing age and reducing contract length, simply means that the fee we could get reduces too. That leads him back to where he started - his value to us is greater than the fee we would get, even if both have reduced in line with each other.

It remains very, very risky to take the money and lose the player. £40m (if we can even get that post-covid) can disappear like a puff of smoke in this league. West Ham spent nearly that on Haller. Newcastle spent it on Joelinton. Even if you come down a step to around £25m - £30m you are not getting Zaha quality very often. Ayoze Perez, Pablo Fornals and Alex Iwobi for instance are all decent, but cost the bulk of the sum we'd get for Zaha without touching the sides of his influence.

Do not underestimate how hard it would be to replace even a half-steam Zaha, which is the most important part of any prospective deal.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (27 May 2021 11.25am)

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 27 May 21 1.45pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

Yeah that’ll be it Mstrobez - I love hammering the most talented player I’ve ever seen in a palace shirt. Nothing to do with a fair or balanced assessment of his overall performance and body language backed up by his open expression of a continued desire for bigger and better things. Nobody’s pushing out - he wants to go!
I think we should give him what he wants and get the best deal we can.

I just happen to hold a different opinion to yours - on this issue anyway.



I completely agreee with you. I agreed with your original post. There is nothing wrong with fans criticising our players and managers etc.

Wilf is a brilliant player on his day but has always had an attitude which has held him back. Like you I think his strength is as a winger. yes he has scored goals this season as a striker but he also missed a lot of chances. If he was not one of our own or was called Benteke he would be slated.

Personally I think he will stay as none of top sides want or need him. He is still worth more to us as a side than we will get as a transfer fee unless we can get some good young (possibly untested)players in exchange. I think only Chelsea (from their loan army)or Arsenal (who need to reduce squad) have the ability to do this.

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 28 May 21 9.49am

I almost feel quite bad for Wilf, wages aside, he's probably harming his career by staying with us (which due to the contract he signed is out of his control). Once his contract expires, he'll be at an age where he'll be undesriable as a winger to the top clubs he beleives he should be playing for.

He is more than capable of playing for a top European side, whether that be in the UEFA cup or Champions League and and player of his stature would want that as an immediade goal. However, bearing in mind some of the players he currently play with that are way below his level, but I don't think any of the top 4 in the Premiership could give him regular football.

I don't get the "whinging" thing, personally and as a PAlace fan, it's completely irrelevant to his performance. Any other player would be commended for passion and personally, I'd rather have 11 players who care and show emotion in the shirt, than 11 that quietly fade away when the game isn't going their way.

If we got £40m for him this summer, it would be good business, but we've become so reliant on him that we don't see that there might be someone available to replace him.

 


La la la your mum

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 28 May 21 9.59am

Originally posted by madcap_v2

I almost feel quite bad for Wilf, wages aside, he's probably harming his career by staying with us (which due to the contract he signed is out of his control). Once his contract expires, he'll be at an age where he'll be undesriable as a winger to the top clubs he beleives he should be playing for.

He is more than capable of playing for a top European side, whether that be in the UEFA cup or Champions League and and player of his stature would want that as an immediade goal. However, bearing in mind some of the players he currently play with that are way below his level, but I don't think any of the top 4 in the Premiership could give him regular football.

I don't get the "whinging" thing, personally and as a PAlace fan, it's completely irrelevant to his performance. Any other player would be commended for passion and personally, I'd rather have 11 players who care and show emotion in the shirt, than 11 that quietly fade away when the game isn't going their way.

If we got £40m for him this summer, it would be good business, but we've become so reliant on him that we don't see that there might be someone available to replace him.

I dont go along with that at all. I dont think Wilf is demonstrating passion at all - its frustration at himself and his team mates and its getting the better of him. His goal record this season may still get him his move. But by his own admission his usual attributes of dribbling, going past player isnt there this season. I respect Wilf as our greatest ever player and dont think negatively of him wanting to better himself elsewhere but bottom line is he signed the contract and a no club has met Palaces valuation of him to date. I love Wilf but I would rather we protect the club than facilitate a player career path. All Palace have done is ask him to adhere to the terms of his contract. The remuneration terms of the contract are reportedly pretty good.. so it is difficult to feel sorry for him being kept prisoner at Palace. Although like I said i have sympathy for his own personal ambitions. He should be frustrated at the agents hes sacked more than Parish and co.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 May 21 10.11am

Originally posted by madcap_v2

I almost feel quite bad for Wilf, wages aside, he's probably harming his career by staying with us (which due to the contract he signed is out of his control). Once his contract expires, he'll be at an age where he'll be undesirable as a winger to the top clubs he believes he should be playing for.

He is more than capable of playing for a top European side, whether that be in the UEFA cup or Champions League and and player of his stature would want that as an immediate goal.

You say that you feel sorry for him wages aside but his wage demands are a limiting factor in who would sign him.

He earns £130,000 per week and it was rumoured a year ago that he was looking for £200,000 per week to move.

That is the same as what Harry Kane and Mo Salah earn and with the best will in the world Zaha isn't in their league.

Added to that is the fact that many of the sort of top European clubs that he wants to join are haemorrhaging money and selling off their players to make ends meet so I doubt whether he has much chance of the move that he wants at the wage level that he wants.

If he genuinely wishes to test himself at the highest level he could always reduce his wage demands to take account of the new Covid level financial circumstances that many of the clubs find themselves but how likely is that?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 May 21 10.50am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You say that you feel sorry for him wages aside but his wage demands are a limiting factor in who would sign him.

He earns £130,000 per week and it was rumoured a year ago that he was looking for £200,000 per week to move.

That is the same as what Harry Kane and Mo Salah earn and with the best will in the world Zaha isn't in their league.

Added to that is the fact that many of the sort of top European clubs that he wants to join are haemorrhaging money and selling off their players to make ends meet so I doubt whether he has much chance of the move that he wants at the wage level that he wants.

If he genuinely wishes to test himself at the highest level he could always reduce his wage demands to take account of the new Covid level financial circumstances that many of the clubs find themselves but how likely is that?


I agree with the first part of your post as well ME but this last paragraph is the crux of the matter. In short:

How much is he prepared to reduce his wage demands in order to get the kind of move he wants? That will determine how much he really wants top table football.

The only club involved in Europe that might come for him (IMO) is Spurs (and they'll be playing in the new third tier competition, but that's better than nothing I suppose). That would test his allegiance to Arsenal!

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf