You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tim Martin
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tim Martin


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 9.08am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Of course industry wants cheap labour from abroad. This is how they keep their costs low by ensuring that they can pay peanuts.
The immigration policy that you support makes most people poorer. It's that simple.

I think the media reporting on the shortages in hospitably sector is quite disgraceful.

The last unemployment figures I saw were 4.8% that is a lot. In the next month we have thousands of school leavers about to start looking for work and 2m people still on furlough until September.

The media is still buying into we need to import cheap foreign labour to help our companies who pay Mcjob wages, No we bloody well don't.

Why is the media not mentioning any of this? It is possible that by October unemployment will be rising not falling although I hope not.

Tim Martin maybe a Brexiteer but I can't stand him or his pubs he and Starbucks et al should be told loud and clear start recruiting locally and pay better wages.

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Jun 21 9.14am

Originally posted by Badger11

I think the media reporting on the shortages in hospitably sector is quite disgraceful.

The last unemployment figures I saw were 4.8% that is a lot. In the next month we have thousands of school leavers about to start looking for work and 2m people still on furlough until September.

The media is still buying into we need to import cheap foreign labour to help our companies who pay Mcjob wages, No we bloody well don't.

Why is the media not mentioning any of this? It is possible that by October unemployment will be rising not falling although I hope not.

Tim Martin maybe a Brexiteer but I can't stand him or his pubs he and Starbucks et al should be told loud and clear start recruiting locally and pay better wages.

Couple of years ago, my son was desperately trying to find work, he had just left Uni. As he was over 21, I believe the minimum wage is slightly higher than for Under 21s. He applied at our local chip pie, who had been advertising for weeks, he was flexible as to how many hours and when he could work, they were keen until he said he was over 21, never heard again. The same applied when he applied to Sports Direct.
So it is not always that kids don’t want to work.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Jun 21 9.42am

Originally posted by croydon proud

This staunch brexiteer and wetherspoons boss has called for easier immigration rules as he can"t get enough staff for his pubs and it must be eating away at his profits.He was the most on screen industry boss during the brexit vote, the one i remember anyway, now he wants to make it easy for Johnny foreigner to come over to our great country, does he not want to employ our great british workforce?If he uses the "workshy"excuse, we should pack him off to eastern europe to be with his pals.


Pre 2004 there were no Eastern European workers and 30% more pubs yet they were all staffed.

It’s a fallacy that the country require an endless stream of cheap labour.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Jun 21 9.47am

Originally posted by DanH

A lot of the practices that go on on the farms are pretty disgraceful though and they don’t want British labour as they don’t live on site. When on site they deduct a ‘rent’ from their wage which pushes the labour costs down even further. A lot of this practice is hand forced as the farms are locked in to low prices by the big supermarkets who have massive control over the prices they pay. The whole supply chain is pretty screwed, the margins are so low all the way through until the big supermarkets ensure they get their share.

They don’t want British workers as British workers generally demand to be paid a fair wage.

Low wages are a direct result of open immigration. The left never mention this which is a shame, as it’s the working man who has been f@cked by this.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 10.01am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Couple of years ago, my son was desperately trying to find work, he had just left Uni. As he was over 21, I believe the minimum wage is slightly higher than for Under 21s. He applied at our local chip pie, who had been advertising for weeks, he was flexible as to how many hours and when he could work, they were keen until he said he was over 21, never heard again. The same applied when he applied to Sports Direct.
So it is not always that kids don’t want to work.

Agreed which is why it is even more disgraceful that the hospitality sector is not being criticised by the media. They and the tourist sector have had billions in taxpayers monies and all they do is bitch and moan. They need to be brought to account by the media.

If we need IT workers, chemists, NHS workers etc. now fine bring them in but we do not need unskilled labour.

Edited by Badger11 (04 Jun 2021 10.02am)

 


One more point

Orange1290 Flag 04 Jun 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Pre 2004 there were no Eastern European workers and 30% more pubs yet they were all staffed.

It’s a fallacy that the country require an endless stream of cheap labour.

Pre 2004 there were around 1.5 million EU citizens living and working in the UK. After 2004 the numbers increased but to claim there were 'no eastern European citizens' within that 1.5 million is incorrect. Many were already working on farms in the UK but EU membership made the opportunity to work in other EU countries easier for those who weren't ready before 2004.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Orange1290 Flag 04 Jun 21 10.05am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

They don’t want British workers as British workers generally demand to be paid a fair wage.

Low wages are a direct result of open immigration. The left never mention this which is a shame, as it’s the working man who has been f@cked by this.


Or maybe British workers demand to be overpaid and under productive. Even France has had higher productivity than the UK for years.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Orange1290 Flag 04 Jun 21 10.09am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed which is why it is even more disgraceful that the hospitality sector is not being criticised by the media. They and the tourist sector have had billions in taxpayers monies and all they do is bitch and moan. They need to be brought to account by the media.

If we need IT workers, chemists, NHS workers etc. now fine bring them in but we do not need unskilled labour.

Edited by Badger11 (04 Jun 2021 10.02am)

There are plenty of very skilled IT workers, chemists, health workers etc within the EU. However, they will in the vast majority of cases be snapped up by other EU countries as they can offer very good salaries and there will be no red tape, paper work, visas etc, just get a flight, drive a car or get a train and tomorrow you can start your new job within a choice of 26 other countries outside of your own. It works very well, I should know having done exactly that in 7 different EU countries. It opens up fantastic opportunities and made very, very easy for the EU citizen.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Jun 21 10.13am

Originally posted by Orange1290

Pre 2004 there were around 1.5 million EU citizens living and working in the UK. After 2004 the numbers increased but to claim there were 'no eastern European citizens' within that 1.5 million is incorrect. Many were already working on farms in the UK but EU membership made the opportunity to work in other EU countries easier for those who weren't ready before 2004.

Read my post again.

I did not say EU workers, I said Eastern European workers, who were not allowed to come until 2004.

Many who were here before then would have been illegal.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

corkery Flag Cork City 04 Jun 21 10.33am

Wetherspoons is a terrible pub. It's like a Ryanair version of a pub.

 


We'll never die

Orange1290 Flag 04 Jun 21 10.36am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Read my post again.

I did not say EU workers, I said Eastern European workers, who were not allowed to come until 2004.

Many who were here before then would have been illegal.


Of course they were 'allowed' to come, they just applied for a visa pre 2004 in the same way as UK citizens had to apply for a visa to travel to a variety of Easter European countries. I worked in Croatia and Hungary between 1997 and 2000. To state there were no 'Eastern' European workers in the UK pre 2004 is incorrect.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 04 Jun 21 10.43am

Originally posted by Orange1290


Of course they were 'allowed' to come, they just applied for a visa pre 2004 in the same way as UK citizens had to apply for a visa to travel to a variety of Easter European countries. I worked in Croatia and Hungary between 1997 and 2000. To state there were no 'Eastern' European workers in the UK pre 2004 is incorrect.


Getting back on subject.

Pubs managed just fine before the arrival of Eastern European workers.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Jun 21 10.52am

Originally posted by Orange1290


Of course they were 'allowed' to come, they just applied for a visa pre 2004 in the same way as UK citizens had to apply for a visa to travel to a variety of Easter European countries. I worked in Croatia and Hungary between 1997 and 2000. To state there were no 'Eastern' European workers in the UK pre 2004 is incorrect.

If they were coming to work, they would have needed to qualify for a work permit and visa

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 10.55am

Originally posted by Orange1290


Or maybe British workers demand to be overpaid and under productive. Even France has had higher productivity than the UK for years.

I am not saying your wrong but you should always take productivity numbers with a pinch of salt. Countries use different methodology for calculating productivity and whilst i agree that the UK is lagging behind I do raise an eyebrow when you see some of the countries that are supposedly more productive than us.

But back to your point you are knocking British workers when you should be knocking the companies who are not giving them a chance.

Edited by Badger11 (04 Jun 2021 10.56am)

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 11.02am

Originally posted by Orange1290

There are plenty of very skilled IT workers, chemists, health workers etc within the EU. However, they will in the vast majority of cases be snapped up by other EU countries as they can offer very good salaries and there will be no red tape, paper work, visas etc, just get a flight, drive a car or get a train and tomorrow you can start your new job within a choice of 26 other countries outside of your own. It works very well, I should know having done exactly that in 7 different EU countries. It opens up fantastic opportunities and made very, very easy for the EU citizen.

I agree but I never said we had to recruit from the EU that is the whole point of the new immigration rules as long as you are qualified you can come from anywhere.

As regarding how attractive the EU versus the UK well 5.5 million EU citizens have obtained settled status in the UK so we are not that unattractive.

It's about companies offering an attractive package if a company wants to bring in say German workers they are already on a decent wage so you would have to offer more.

Anyway this is nothing to do with importing cheap unskilled labour.

 


One more point

DanH Flag SW2 04 Jun 21 12.27pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

They don’t want British workers as British workers generally demand to be paid a fair wage.

Low wages are a direct result of open immigration. The left never mention this which is a shame, as it’s the working man who has been f@cked by this.

Low wages are a combination of a number of things. Labour supply being just one of them. The demand for cheap goods in an economy where consumption is high is far greater. We have become accustomed to paying extremely cheap prices for goods (especially agricultural goods) which means that these have to be produced extremely cheaply. This means low wages and low standards.

Rising inequality also suggests that company profits are not filtering their way through to rising wages, rather being distributed as dividends to shareholders/directors. A lot of businesses will seek to pay the minimum that the market (or NMW legislation) will allow to maximise profit margins rather than pass these on to staff.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 12.42pm

Originally posted by DanH

Low wages are a combination of a number of things. Labour supply being just one of them. The demand for cheap goods in an economy where consumption is high is far greater. We have become accustomed to paying extremely cheap prices for goods (especially agricultural goods) which means that these have to be produced extremely cheaply. This means low wages and low standards.

Rising inequality also suggests that company profits are not filtering their way through to rising wages, rather being distributed as dividends to shareholders/directors. A lot of businesses will seek to pay the minimum that the market (or NMW legislation) will allow to maximise profit margins rather than pass these on to staff.


True but if recruitment becomes a problem due to low wages then they will have to cut their dividends in order to fund a pay rise if they want the company to be successful.

I don't disagree with your assessment but Andrew Carnegie who was notorious for paying slave wages complained bitterly that his new immigrant workers were quick to realise that they were being under paid.

In short if companies can get away with it they will, look at Uber.

Edited by Badger11 (04 Jun 2021 12.43pm)

 


One more point

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 04 Jun 21 12.47pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

FWIW my son and his girlfriend tried desperately to get farm work last year, when, allegedly there was a shortage. Most didn’t reply to them, whilst others insisted they live on site, in caravans, and would have accommodation costs deducted at source. Why?
Maybe this is why we are still getting plane loads of workers from EU and Ukraine coming over, as even these conditions are better than they have at home?


I remember mate you talking about it last year, thing is, our great british farmers, the best in the world we are constantly told, have to be held to account then, why aren"t they employing local home born people to work? We are told to buy british all the time, and the british symbol, but if our great british farmers aren"t employing british people, maybe we should be holding them to account, and buying anything but british?

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 04 Jun 21 12.50pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think the media reporting on the shortages in hospitably sector is quite disgraceful.

The last unemployment figures I saw were 4.8% that is a lot. In the next month we have thousands of school leavers about to start looking for work and 2m people still on furlough until September.

The media is still buying into we need to import cheap foreign labour to help our companies who pay Mcjob wages, No we bloody well don't.

Why is the media not mentioning any of this? It is possible that by October unemployment will be rising not falling although I hope not.

Tim Martin maybe a Brexiteer but I can't stand him or his pubs he and Starbucks et al should be told loud and clear start recruiting locally and pay better wages.


Glad you didn"t mention lidl Badger, although a different business, German owned, and pays its staff over £10 an hour, the best in the business, fair play!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 21 12.53pm

Originally posted by croydon proud


Glad you didn"t mention lidl Badger, although a different business, German owned, and pays its staff over £10 an hour, the best in the business, fair play!

good for them.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tim Martin