This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Vintage year '56 Yep
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
As a Palace fan it has been frustrating that refs seem to have decided this season that nearly every foul on Zaha can go unpunished. They seem to have decided that he goes down easily for everything and so more and more teams have recognised they can just foul him in order to stop him. We haven't even played Burnley yet so that is a worry as he has become more prone to injuries. In the wider picture there seems to be less interference from VAR, but there were at least two clear penalties which they seemingly ignored; firstly on Friday a Leeds' player was clearly obstructed sending the player (I think it was Daniel James?) crashing to the ground; secondly Zouma clearly went through Ronaldo and was nowhere near the ball and yet VAR didn't intervene, a minute later it gives a penalty to West Ham. Had it not been Ronaldo would they have given it? As always the problem seems to be about consistency. One thing you could say on Saturday was that the referee was consistently poor. For example, it seems to be well-known that if you pull a player back when they are breaking away then it is a yellow card yet Liverpool did that repeatedly. Milner committed six fouls (that were given) and also blasted the ball at Gallagher from point blank range and yet he didn't even get a ticking off. Ward complains once and gets booked. I like the more free-flowing football and the fact that some of the stupid fouls like the ones Kane (and to be fair Ayew) is so good at winning are disappearing, but it seems referees are struggling to identify what is play acting and what are fouls. Nevertheless, if the new style of refereeing is going to continue then we need to stop complaining and follow suit and start doing what Liverpool did on Saturday and target the more creative players with constant subtle fouling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Yep, playing to the PL tune “ help the big clubs at all costs” media outlets like Sky/MOTD are there to dismiss these theories by not showing controversial incidents involving those clubs. Until there is a fan rebellion (never going to happen) it will not change. This new “rule” they are playing too, is nothing to do with free flowing football, it is so the interpretation can go in favour of certain clubs
|
|
|
James Milner seemed to have license to kick any Palace player within kicking distance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Why was the foul on Benteke not even mentioned? had we had the penalty and scored they would have played somewhat differently. The reason it was ignored by the ref was that it would've been a straight red for 'stopping a goal scoring chance'. Easier to just ignore. But how there was no VAR review is the question...
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'm loving the more lenient, less interventionist refereeing. If there is blame to be dished out regarding incorrect decisions, I’d allocate it in three places in order of importance: 1. The honesty of the players Players are highly competitive animals under enormous pressure to succeed, and will seek out any advantage until the rules are implemented in a way that prevents it. In the 80s hatchet men went through the back of forwards, so the tackle from behind was banned. In the 90s tough tacklers went over the top in midfield, so excessive force was banned. In the last ten years forwards have increasingly aimed to 'win' poxy, technically correct but morally dubious free kicks, a practise made even worse by the advent of VAR, because in super slow motion every contact loses context and looks worse. Now, hopefully, these threats to the spirit of the game are being addressed, just like serious foul play was. Take Sterlings dive in the Euros semi final. Outrageous. Our national team cheated their way past a more deserving opponent, yet his actions generated no serious condemnation from his cheerleaders at the BBC, particularly Shearer who, some ten or so years ago gave the greatest insight to the mind of a competitive player when he coined the phrase 'The forward has the right to go down in that situation'. It is hugely damaging to place winning at all costs above the credibility of the game itself. Once again, football needed saving from footballers. Or perhaps more accurately, the sport needed saving from the professional industry. If you paid money to watch a boxing match and one of them went over when he could have stayed up, you’d call it fraud, yet we have grown to accept it in football. Arseholes like Salah, Mane, Son, Vardy, Alli and particularly Kane throw themselves on the floor with absolutely no shame whatsoever at the slightest contact in the knowledge they will at best be rewarded and at worst not punished. And yes, Zaha goes in that category too. It kills the game, and threatens the whole point of even playing it. The solution? If in doubt, don’t give the foul. Players have proven they can’t be trusted, so don’t trust them. It's great that referees are giving less soft free-kicks. It instantly leads to far better games, and to football having a chance to once again be a sport rather than a fraud-show. If that means the odd foul in our favour being missed, it's a price worth paying. It would have been nice to get a penalty at Anfield, but it's far better that Zaha runs at full backs with the aim of beating them rather than of going to ground as soon as he feels contact. The shift in culture is noticeable already. Why did the ref not give the penalty at Liverpool? Because in normal time he didn’t see it clearly enough. Why did VAR not see the foul on Benteke? Christ knows. Same reason it didn’t see the very clear foul on Ronaldo at West Ham towards the end of the game. Perhaps they are so concerned with not killing the speed and emotion of the game that they are interfering less. Fine by me. I have no expectation whatsoever that every decision be correct, and the process for trying to achieve it is so awful that I’m far happier with the alternative. As far as I'm concerned, I hope the refs will keep up the (generally) good work. Edited by TheBigToePunt (20 Sep 2021 5.39pm) All well and good if they consistent and don’t show an obvious biased towards certain teams. If they can’t do this, then the game has gone I’m afraid
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I do, give everything to and nothing against the big clubs, unless already winning easily, so they can say they do get decisions against them. Yes, but why? Man Utd could have had several this weekend, yet got none and conceded one. Going back a while, we had loads, and some were generous. Back in 2005 we had loads too.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
1. The honesty of the players Edited by TheBigToePunt (20 Sep 2021 5.39pm) I have to say, reading this, I just thought "nail...head". I watch a lot of rugby when I'm not watching Palace and, I know everyone's sick of hearing it, but the fact is rugby proves that football players themselves go a long way to making referees better or worse, in this case worse. If you treat anyone with constant disrespect, try to con them on a more or less non-stop basis, and complain vociferously every time they make a decision you're pretty much guaranteed to get the worst performance possible out of them. That's basic common sense. If clubs want refereeing standards to improve, they might start by telling their own players to show refs some respect. Television doesn't help; yes referees make mistakes (and usually front up to them too, far more often than players take responsibility for their mistakes) but I'm not sure it's productive to view every error in slow motion and analyse it to the nth degree, particularly when the original decision was made from a single vantage point and often not a good one at that, and in real time. I don't think referees have gotten measurably worse in recent seasons. I think they're simply more exposed by being under the microscope now and working in a far less tolerant society in a game filled with millionaire prima donnas. The biggest problem, as I said, is the players. If you want better referees, act in ways that will bring out the best in them and make their jobs easier, not harder.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
All too often they find themselves in positions where they can do no right. The level of respect shown towards refs is near zero when compared to rugby for instance. I struggle to understand why anyone would even want the job. Maybe mic the refs up so we can hear what their decisions are and why then it could stop the dissent and trying to influence the officials easily which players do and must make the refs uncertain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I have to say, reading this, I just thought "nail...head". I watch a lot of rugby when I'm not watching Palace and, I know everyone's sick of hearing it, but the fact is rugby proves that football players themselves go a long way to making referees better or worse, in this case worse. If you treat anyone with constant disrespect, try to con them on a more or less non-stop basis, and complain vociferously every time they make a decision you're pretty much guaranteed to get the worst performance possible out of them. That's basic common sense. If clubs want refereeing standards to improve, they might start by telling their own players to show refs some respect. Lack of respect for officials is certainly very unhelpful to referees trying to do a good job. And I think some parents should shoulder some of the blame. I haven't watched a school game since I was of that age, but I gather that referees in those matches are routinely howled at, sworn at and even physically confronted by raging fathers (and mothers). Little wonder that by the time they're teenagers, so many boys have no respect for the officials. I've never checked this out, but someone once told me that the laws of rugby provide for badly behaved spectators to be dismissed from the surrounding area. I can't see that catching on in football! As for rugby's 10-yard (or is it metres?) law, the authorities will never have the guts to introduce it. But its effectiveness is illustrated by the fact that it so rarely has to be applied.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Lack of respect for officials is certainly very unhelpful to referees trying to do a good job. And I think some parents should shoulder some of the blame. I haven't watched a school game since I was of that age, but I gather that referees in those matches are routinely howled at, sworn at and even physically confronted by raging fathers (and mothers). Little wonder that by the time they're teenagers, so many boys have no respect for the officials. I've never checked this out, but someone once told me that the laws of rugby provide for badly behaved spectators to be dismissed from the surrounding area. I can't see that catching on in football! As for rugby's 10-yard (or is it metres?) law, the authorities will never have the guts to introduce it. But its effectiveness is illustrated by the fact that it so rarely has to be applied.
Alternatively, of course, football could introduce the sin-bin option for the 2nd such offence in the same game. Basically, once refs are able to punish players who try to intimidate, the practice of surrounding the ref will quickly disappear.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Lack of respect for officials is certainly very unhelpful to referees trying to do a good job. And I think some parents should shoulder some of the blame. I haven't watched a school game since I was of that age, but I gather that referees in those matches are routinely howled at, sworn at and even physically confronted by raging fathers (and mothers). Little wonder that by the time they're teenagers, so many boys have no respect for the officials. I've never checked this out, but someone once told me that the laws of rugby provide for badly behaved spectators to be dismissed from the surrounding area. I can't see that catching on in football! As for rugby's 10-yard (or is it metres?) law, the authorities will never have the guts to introduce it. But its effectiveness is illustrated by the fact that it so rarely has to be applied. FIFA introduced the 10 Yard rule in about 2000 but it only lasted a few seasons. Refs at the time said it had a positive effect but I can't remember it being applied very often.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.