You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ayew and Benteke
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ayew and Benteke


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Sep 21 11.50am

Originally posted by palace99

Fair point re Ayew. I don't dislike Ayew but he is not a right sided player. Works hard and helps Ward but lacks pace and can't cross the ball.

Part of the problem is that PV seems a very cautious manager. He rarely changes the starting X1 and his subs are pretty predictable.

Last night Tekkers and Kouyate one for Edouard and Luka after c70 minutes were so predictable.

Ayew run himself into the ground. With 10 left i thought would he maybe go to 442 and push Macca on the right and bring on Olise to give us some pace upfront. Instead he goes for the predictable Jeff S option.

Wouldn't be surprised to see Ayew start this weekend although his confidence is getting lower by the game

Do many managers often change their starting 11's when doing well. Over the last couple of games PV has transitioned Luka and Eduard in, and I'm sure Olise will also come in when ready. Out of interest what changes to the starting 11 did you want?

For what its worth I think the subs were right (on paper). The game was starting to swing, and we couldn't really get the ball to stick up top. Plus they are a big side. So bring on some height and some fresh legs. Unfortunately Benteke didn't put a shift in, so we were basically down to 10 men.

Viera isn't stupid and would have seen what we saw. Will he trust that he can bring Benteke on for the last 15 to continue the good pressing work and help lead from the front? I doubt it.

(In the same way that after Jairo's shocker I doubt he'll get a look in for a while.)

 

beak Flag croydon 28 Sep 21 2.20pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Have you ever thought of telling PV that he doesn't know what he is doing?

PV inherited these two and they are not typical of the younger,eager players PV has brought in. A January spring clean looks inevitable.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Sep 21 2.39pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Have you ever thought of telling PV that he doesn't know what he is doing?

You don’t seem to realise that Vieira sees the players in training everyday, has played the game at the highest level and a proven winner. It’s pretty obvious that some on here are far more qualified and a better judge of players than him.

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Sep 21 2.42pm

I can’t be too harsh on Ayew as he’s a trier and he was not an expensive purchase.
However, I only think he warrants a place on the bench at best.
He doesn’t seem to know when to release the ball and frequently misses the opportunity to make telling passes to better placed teammates because of his head down approach.
With regard to Benteke it seems evident at this early stage he will not suit Vieira’s playing style.
He’s not mobile, does not press and lacks incisive movement around the box.
I would go as far to say that if Edouard was unavailable I would prefer Ayew in the centre forward role than Benteke.
I’m not suggesting Ayew is the better player or goalscorer, but at least he will hustle the defenders and run across the frontline.
Benteke’s immobile style of just waiting for the ball will not work in Vieira’s system in my view.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Sep 21 2.45pm

I thought Ayew had a reasonable game aside from the miss, but as a forward player that's ultimately what he'll be judged on. Most of his passes seemed to go sideways as well. It'll be interesting to see how long PV sticks with him if his attacking output doesn't improve. Bentenke and Kouyate were both benched after looking like weak links. PV seems like he'll give people chances and then it is down to them to take those chances.

Brighton had resorted to throwing balls up to their big men so I can kind of see why Bentenke was brought on. He is after all very good at defending corners (I think he cleared at least one) and we looked very short in comparison to Brighton's ugly giants. My god that man looks like he hasn't got the energy to run 20 feet without having a rest though. Edouard showed more pace and energy in 70 minutes than Tekkers has shown in his Palace career. I very much doubt he'll get back into the side for Leicester.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 28 Sep 21 3.01pm

Originally posted by Painter

You don’t seem to realise that Vieira sees the players in training everyday, has played the game at the highest level and a proven winner. It’s pretty obvious that some on here are far more qualified and a better judge of players than him.

I've never intruded into other posters' disagreements before and I doubt I ever will again. But for heaven's sake, if a fans' forum isn't at least partly to allow fans to criticise the manager or players, then there seems little point in at all. But when someone does that on here, there are almost always people wishing to attack them with sarcastic remarks, of which there have been a couple in this thread.

I'll now creep back into my hole, but please can't we all be tolerant of others' views?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Sep 21 3.42pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

In my opinion we new to offload both of them in the Jan window

Ayew; there is no position for Ayew, we don't play a Number 10, he cant play wide, doesn't have the pace and doesn't score enough goals as CF, no goals or assists in 20 matches, why Olise or Schlupp didn't come on sooner i don't understand.

Benteke; he clearly wont score enough goals, it will be our last chance to get some money back, he will have 18 months left and his contract wont be renewed. Edouard should have an extended run now to see what he can do, and Mateta as the substitute, so he can be properly assessed, also Street is going to be a very good CF

Your frustration could make you look very silly.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Sep 21 3.51pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I've never intruded into other posters' disagreements before and I doubt I ever will again. But for heaven's sake, if a fans' forum isn't at least partly to allow fans to criticise the manager or players, then there seems little point in at all. But when someone does that on here, there are almost always people wishing to attack them with sarcastic remarks, of which there have been a couple in this thread.

I'll now creep back into my hole, but please can't we all be tolerant of others' views?

Posters need to be aware of making themselves look very stupid and posters who moan immediately after an excellent performance need to keep away for their own sake, individual mistakes will always happen in football, we all need to think how our keeper felt last night instead of behaving like morons.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Sep 21 4.29pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Your frustration could make you look very silly.

Why because i have an opinion, that's all it is, like everybody else's, What summed Benteke up to me is we have a corner, Gallagher passes short to keep it in the corner, but sadly Benteke's first touch put it straight out of play,

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 28 Sep 21 4.33pm

Finding a forward who can perform consistently in this league is the Holy Grail for every football club. Budgetary limits means, unless we can grow our own like Wilf, we have to take a gamble on the unproven, unknown or unloved. Sorloth, Mateta, Edouard ? the search goes on. Ayew pissed me off last night when he missed and CB is a constant frustration but they are what we have. Hopefully Olise and Edouard can climb up the pecking order. Or failing that perhaps Textor has a few million stashed down the back of his sofa that he wouldnt mind spending on a proven striker.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 28 Sep 21 4.45pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Wow... Just wow...

So Benteke came on and did his job for the last 15 did he and the other 10 on the pitch sat back??... Literally hilarious.

He came on and did absolutely nothing. He provided no presence and didn't hold the ball up because as usual his touch let him down...
In a way I can live with that but what I can't live with is laziness... He was bone idle and disinterested when he came on.


Other then set up what should of been a goal. Grow up

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 28 Sep 21 4.54pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Posters need to be aware of making themselves look very stupid and posters who moan immediately after an excellent performance need to keep away for their own sake, individual mistakes will always happen in football, we all need to think how our keeper felt last night instead of behaving like morons.

it's hardly behaving like a moron to call out and want to bleat about two blinding failures in a game against our biggest rivals, is it? Yeah the performance was excellent in places, but we can still rue Ayew's miss and Guaita's miss-placed kick. That's human nature.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 28 Sep 21 5.47pm

Originally posted by rossboss29


Other then set up what should of been a goal. Grow up

Oh yes... He played a simple pass that I could of played, all is forgiven... He was amazing...

I'm not gonna congratulate a player for playing a simple pass... In the words of Roy Keane 'That's his job'..

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 28 Sep 21 6.28pm

Have been a big Benteke fan on HOL, but got to say he had an absolute shocker when he came on last night.

We needed to defend from the front and was not mobile enough to challenge for possession. The Weed defenders were breezing past him without him putting up any resistance. He had a couple of misguided headers which went nowhere near Palace players. He had that farcical short corner which held up for less than a second and he must have given ball away at least 5 times. Other than the ball to Ayew, which let’s be honest was a basic pass for a pro, he had a negative impact on the team. He’s dangerous when we cross the ball but we don’t do that. Expected more from a man trying to get his place back in the team.

Re Ayew, we all know his limitations. He’s a useful squad player but will soon be replaced by Olise/Eze. Good dribbler but doesn’t add much else. His miss wasn’t as bad as people are making out, he still had the keeper to beat who was well positioned.

Edited by Goal Machine (28 Sep 2021 6.30pm)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 28 Sep 21 6.45pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Ayew..........His miss wasn’t as bad as people are making out, he still had the keeper to beat who was well positioned.

Edited by Goal Machine (28 Sep 2021 6.30pm)

Might have missed it, but haven't seen anyone else make this point Goal Machine,although I think you're right about still having the keeper to beat. I was furious with him, but it wasn't as straightforward a chance as some choose to believe.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Sep 21 6.50pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

You're like a broken record.

I think most agree that Ayew is playing out of position. The Manager is selecting him because he thinks he's currently the best man for the job. Olise only recently returned from injury and is unproven at this level. PV is breaking him in gently - I realise from reading your posts that this is a concept that you find difficult to grasp.

As for Benteke, look at it this way. We spent big on Edouard. We potentially have spent big on Mateta, although I doubt we will see him signed permanently. We don't have unlimited funds. So re-signing Benteke made absolute sense.

Edouard started last night and looks set to get a run in the team. Mateta is assessed, as are all the players, on a daily basis. If he's not getting game time there is a reason for it. As for Rob Street, I think he's a big, bustling grafter but I don't think he's even remotely close to a first team spot. And I'll go on record now and say that I don't think he'll make it at Palace although I hope I'm proven wrong.

I suspect that PV has identified RB as a weak link in his plans. Ayew does a lot of work to help Ward, which at this time Olise will not do. Yes he missed a sitter and I said at the time, “that was the game”.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Sep 21 6.51pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Might have missed it, but haven't seen anyone else make this point Goal Machine,although I think you're right about still having the keeper to beat. I was furious with him, but it wasn't as straightforward a chance as some choose to believe.

Should have at least made the goalkeeper make a save

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Sep 21 6.52pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Have been a big Benteke fan on HOL, but got to say he had an absolute shocker when he came on last night.

We needed to defend from the front and was not mobile enough to challenge for possession. The Weed defenders were breezing past him without him putting up any resistance. He had a couple of misguided headers which went nowhere near Palace players. He had that farcical short corner which held up for less than a second and he must have given ball away at least 5 times. Other than the ball to Ayew, which let’s be honest was a basic pass for a pro, he had a negative impact on the team. He’s dangerous when we cross the ball but we don’t do that. Expected more from a man trying to get his place back in the team.

Re Ayew, we all know his limitations. He’s a useful squad player but will soon be replaced by Olise/Eze. Good dribbler but doesn’t add much else. His miss wasn’t as bad as people are making out, he still had the keeper to beat who was well positioned.

Edited by Goal Machine (28 Sep 2021 6.30pm)

I agree with most of this. Personally I would have given Mateta a run out, as he is more mobile and would have pressed more

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Sep 21 6.52pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Might have missed it, but haven't seen anyone else make this point Goal Machine,although I think you're right about still having the keeper to beat. I was furious with him, but it wasn't as straightforward a chance as some choose to believe.

Positionally it wasn't too dissimilar to the goal he scored against the Spam where he calmly chipped the keeper. Seems to me he has lost a little bit of confidence in front of goal and is trying too hard to make amends. He has goals in him, we've seen that, and once he gets on the scoresheet I think he'll go on a run.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 28 Sep 21 7.23pm

Second the broken record comment. It’s beyond boring now. They have their limitations, but they’re palace abs they’re what we’ve got. Benteke should’ve had an assist which is more than EO achieved.

Lanzo and others hate Benteke and want him gone. Others think he’s worth having in the squad.

Shall we all move on?

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ayew and Benteke