This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
She could make amends by paying all the tax she has avoided by her 'non-dom' status. Fat chance, more likely they will head for the USA. Next time you hear of a desperate young mother trying to feed 2 kids on £30 a fortnight think of these two parasites playing the system. If this continues as I think it will, we are looking at civil unrest similar to the austerity riots in 2011. This is supposed to be the 5th richest country yet the tories are returning to Charles Dickens 'hard times'. And it makes just about the same economic sense, none whatsoever. Should we keep on borrowing then to finance the public needs and it looks as if you would like civil unrest.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
I can hardly believe that intelligent people can write the ignorant claptrap that appears above. I'm talking not about opinions - everyone is entitled to their own - but about facts, which some of you are either unaware of, or choose to ignore because they don't suit your agenda. One poster suggests that the Sunaks have "got caught". The fact is that Mrs Sunak has been found to be abiding by the tax rules of this country. Another says that the rest of us "have to pay their (i.e., the Sunaks' Then we have the assertion that "basically the rich pay no tax". Finally, someone talks about "the Chancellor's tax-dodging". Really? Do you know something nobody else does? But it's not just on here that this rubbish is uttered. Last night I heard a respected phone-in host, twice in the space of ten minutes, talking about the Sunaks "wriggling out" of paying their due tax. Another, even more respected, referred to the "scheme" Mrs Sunak has employed to minimise her tax: it's not a scheme, it's a rule which has been in place since 1799. As I say, all these comments ignore the facts. But for what it's worth, I share the opinion of many that this non-dom rule should at the very least be closely looked at and made fit for purpose. Rishi Sunak is the chancellor. That is what makes this tastes bad. He’s deciding what tax people pay. Then there’s the green card during his first 18 months as chancellor. Hmmm.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What are you Wittering on about? Are referring to the change of font? typical immigrant laziness. Next we'll find you living off State pensions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The biggest problem I see with this is not whether Mrs Sunak broke any laws. She clearly didn't. She is a very lucky and ridiculously wealthy lady, who is an Indian citizen being paid dividends on investments in India. Why should she pay tax here, just because she is married to a Brit and is currently resident here? The problem I see is having a very wealthy man as Chancellor at this time, when wealth taxes ought to be part of the upcoming new measures I see on the horizon. On the basis that Turkeys don't vote for Christmas, I see this as a difficulty. ‘She is currently resident here’. That’s bull. This is without doubt her base for family life. She is resident here but benefits from rules designed for the rich to avoid tax. Now consider the system in the USA The United States taxes all U.S. persons on their worldwide income. A U.S. person is a citizen, green card holder (who is a legal resident but not necessarily present in the United States), and residents. A resident is anyone who spends more than 183 days a year in the United States. If you’re living and working outside the United States, and qualify for the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion, you can earn up to $102,100 in salary during 2017 free of Federal income tax. If your salary is more than the FEIE, you will pay US tax on the excess. Also, the FEIE only applies to your salary. You will pay US tax on capital gains, dividends, rents, royalties, and passive income no matter where you live.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The biggest problem I see with this is not whether Mrs Sunak broke any laws. She clearly didn't. She is a very lucky and ridiculously wealthy lady, who is an Indian citizen being paid dividends on investments in India. Why should she pay tax here, just because she is married to a Brit and is currently resident here? The problem I see is having a very wealthy man as Chancellor at this time, when wealth taxes ought to be part of the upcoming new measures I see on the horizon. On the basis that Turkeys don't vote for Christmas, I see this as a difficulty. Inheritance tax is going to rocket. Just watch. Could backfire of course. Lots of avoidance.
COYP |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The biggest problem I see with this is not whether Mrs Sunak broke any laws. She clearly didn't. She is a very lucky and ridiculously wealthy lady, who is an Indian citizen being paid dividends on investments in India. Why should she pay tax here, just because she is married to a Brit and is currently resident here? The problem I see is having a very wealthy man as Chancellor at this time, when wealth taxes ought to be part of the upcoming new measures I see on the horizon. On the basis that Turkeys don't vote for Christmas, I see this as a difficulty. Her company gained lucrative government contracts worth 50 million. Something tells me that isn't a co-incidence. Once that money is out of the country it's outside of scrutiny. MPs and their cronies use techniques such as this to kick their misdeeds and backhanders into the long grass and out of sight. They are stealing the life blood of this country and making us look like mugs. It's grotesque and makes a mockery of the working man. Edited by BlueJay (11 Apr 2022 12.12am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Her net worth is several hundred million. It's reported that she may have saved up to £20 million on her UK tax bill by being a non dom, which ironically also costs her £30,000 a year (non dom status). I'm not sure why we should be thanking her for picking our pocket to the tune of millions by paying the least amount possible, or comparing her favorably to normal people saying their taxes (which will be a radically higher percentage of their earnings than she has paid here).
She hasn't picked your pocket. That is just you, as usual, twisting the truth. She may have been avoiding tax by using legal methods, but she has not been stolen single penny from you. Any remittance that she pays is likely more than the average outraged idiot pays. Nobody else really cares. It is irrelevant how much she earns if she is obeying the rules. If the tax laws are offensive, take it up with Parliament, not the chancellor of the Exchequer's wife.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
How respectful of the average hardworking British taxpayer. Edited by BlueJay (11 Apr 2022 1.46am) No, "not the average hardworking British taxpayer", "the average outraged idiot". If you're going to quote me, try to get it right. Idiot.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
|
|
|
To be clear, Murthy is not tax resident in India either. If she were she’d be subject to Indian tax on worldwide earnings.
|
|
|
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
If the government has not amended the rules to ensure that they are fit for purpose / consider the modern world then they are the ones that should take a look at what they are doing & cant complain if people take advantage of them - They intentionally haven't done so, to benefit themselves and people like them.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.