This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I forgot about Plange!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
Both Edouard and Meteta are not premiership standard strikers and should be replaced . Out of the two , if we had to keep one it would be Edouard . How would you define premiership standard? We aren't in the market for a Haaland or Kane.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
How would you define premiership standard? We aren't in the market for a Haaland or Kane. I didn't get this comment either. You could argue a number of teams aren't PL standard but their Modus Operandi is to muddle through and survive. The two mentioned have the potential to have a decent career in the top league IMO.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
My view is that there may be a possible misconception that the CF needs to be our main goal getter. In many ways the output of our strikers simply matches the trends in the modern game. The CF is no longer there just to score goals and there is a firm trend to inverted wingers being the main supply line. Second point is our CFs scored 15 goals between them last season. To what extent does it matter that those goals were shared between 3 players? 15 goals is a decent return and not far short of 20 which is probably the optimum for a club of our size/ranking. General thought is though that the problems lie in how well our forward line combines to create the right number and type of chances. We often looked dominant and/or pretty last season without actually creating that much. Perfectly happy here to run with Olise Mateta/Edouard Zaha next season with the two inverted wingers combining to be our most likely source of goals with the central forward creating space and chipping in. To make this happen it would help to have a RB who can overlap on the right as Mitchell has on the left to allow Olise to cut in to even more effect. Good post.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Nothing like a good debate, so here's hoping I can start one: There’s been talk on this site that we need to upgrade our strikers. But is there actually a need and if so, how great is it? We simply don’t have the kind of money that would enable us to buy a proven 15 goal a season PL striker (never mind a 20 goal a season one). We are shopping in the lower leagues and less fashionable clubs overseas. In last summer’s transfer window, there was talk of our getting Adam Armstrong from Blackburn. Southampton outbid us (£15.93m according to Transfermarkt - the figures quoted below are also from that site) and he’s basically been a nonentity there (3 goals and 3 assists in the PL). He spent most of the second half of the season on the bench. Mitrovic at Fulham has scored some 70 goals over his last 2 Championship seasons but managed just 14 in his last 2 Premier league ones. Basically, the gulf between the Championship and the Premier League can be massive for central strikers. We bought Edouard and Mateta from other countries’ leagues for £14.69m and £9.9m respectively. They’ve scored 11 PL goals between them at the rate of a goal every 247 minutes. That equates to 14 goals over a full season which for a team like Palace is an OK return. Both players are 24 and IMHO will improve as they gain more PL experience (Mateta has already improved significantly since those early days under Hodgson). I’m happy for us to keep them both and see what they can do next year and so for me, at least, there’s no urgent need to upgrade our strikers. Over to you all! IMO we do not need another striker, I believe Mateta will continue to improve, his running off the ball is very good. Eduoard I still believe we have a very good player there, personally I think he is a fox in the box.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
Both Edouard and Meteta are not premiership standard strikers and should be replaced . Out of the two , if we had to keep one it would be Edouard . I think they are both PL standard given the right service. Mateta running off the ball is very good. If you have an odd £100m flying around perhaps we can improve. Edited by Spiderman (27 May 2022 5.10pm) Edited by Spiderman (27 May 2022 5.11pm)
|
|
|
how many years have we said " we need to give the strikers the right service " and they will be top strikers , never happens .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Hi OP , I do agree with you on the Mateta not being good enough but i do think Edouard is ! I also think he did a good job filling in for Wilf when he was injured/banned . We also have a striker from Derby on the way Plange i think his name is we bought him and loaned him back in the last window . Dont know much about him though . Totally agree I thought that when he played there , I still would like to see them both play together but we wont play 4 up front sadly , getting a prem striker ask the other 15 clubs that we match with , thats there dream to so we get lucky every now and then with a 20+ striker , I would love Wilf with 11 Matata 15 Edouard 15 Olise 10 thats 51 with them 4 so 20+ striker not a must but it does help
|
|
|
Originally posted by mtp1958
Totally agree I thought that when he played there , I still would like to see them both play together but we wont play 4 up front sadly , getting a prem striker ask the other 15 clubs that we match with , thats there dream to so we get lucky every now and then with a 20+ striker , I would love Wilf with 11 Matata 15 Edouard 15 Olise 10 thats 51 with them 4 so 20+ striker not a must but it does help
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Quite agree - think a "holistic" approach is most informative. Looking at last season I'd have said that the hole in our side was the comparative paucity of goals from the right - where we had Ayew stationed for much of the time - and not centrally. It also shouldn't be forgotten that Gallagher got 8 goals playing in an advanced central position - frequently in areas where you'd expect the CF to be. I haven't done it but I imagine the "wagon wheel" of our goals would show a significant imbalance to the left and centre. If we can improve our output from the right then theoretically we should be more productive. But then of course we'll need to replace - presumably - the goals from a late arriving mid in the box. An additional thought here is that improving the range of areas we threaten from also improves our likely goal output. It was still the case - in my head anyway - that we became too easy to defend against when it was Zaha on the left and Ayew on the right just because the the likely threat was too easy to predict. Add an Olise on the left and then it becomes a much trickier defence to organise as you cannot immediately double mark down one side.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
I am in full agreement. I genuinely believe that Christian Eriksen could be the answer. Clearly you're not joking, but why would Brentford release him? He played a huge role in their success; he'll be expensive; and his defending skills are modest. He must love playing with his Danish teammates and manager. For personal reasons I would LOVE to see him in our squad – he's my wife's favorite player, by far – but it doesn't seem remotely possible.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
Clearly you're not joking, but why would Brentford release him? He played a huge role in their success; he'll be expensive; and his defending skills are modest. He must love playing with his Danish teammates and manager. For personal reasons I would LOVE to see him in our squad – he's my wife's favorite player, by far – but it doesn't seem remotely possible. It was a 6 month contract with a year's option I think. But truthfully I'd have Eze over a 29 year old Eriksen every day of the week.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
It was a 6 month contract with a year's option I think and he's likely a free agent. But truthfully I'd have Eze over a 29 year old Eriksen every day of the week.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
how many years have we said " we need to give the strikers the right service " and they will be top strikers , never happens . Haha, probably because we have never given them the service! Having said that, both Edouard and Mateta have had one on ones and fluffed their lines this season and to me that is the acid test for a top striker as they should bury those 9/10 times. Edouard for me lack’s confidence as he had no problem burying it in the SPL but looks nervous when he gets an opportunity here.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.