You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Jun 22 6.20pm

Originally posted by Badger11

According to Alex Salmon the Scots do not owe us anything regarding the national debt. Well if the SNP walk away without paying their fair share of the bill good luck to them getting finance in the international money markets, nobody likes a welcher.

Russia got away with it after the revolution.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Jun 22 6.34pm

Referendums are bitter divisive and have long-lasting consequences eg Brexit, Scots will not be looking forward to this.

A vote cast for the SNP at an election should be a vote for independence it is the people's choice.

Definitely not the Supreme Court, the tory geriatrica.

Some of their decisions are even worse than the USA model.

Recent voting in Scotland shows increased support for the SNP after a long stint, and the demise of tory support now in a very poor third place, and even they rebelled against Johnson.

To continue inflicting policies from Westminster that are clearly not in the interests and not wanted by the other countries is rather like the end of empire.

And frankly, with Johnsons desperate administration, it's good riddance.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jun 22 7.25pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Russia got away with it after the revolution.

In exchange for large tracts of land and resources.

Ireland would be the go to example really. Incredibly poor until perhaps the 90s. So about 70-80 years after independence. Modern times are quicker of course. I'd give Scotland maybe 50 years before it can stand on its own two feet.
The other countries to look at are former Soviet satellites. Some are ok for some people, most have much decaying infrastructure and little cash to go round. Some aren't worth mentioning as they've gone back.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 29 Jun 22 7.26pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Referendums are bitter divisive and have long-lasting consequences eg Brexit, Scots will not be looking forward to this.

A vote cast for the SNP at an election should be a vote for independence it is the people's choice.

Definitely not the Supreme Court, the tory geriatrica.

Some of their decisions are even worse than the USA model.

Recent voting in Scotland shows increased support for the SNP after a long stint, and the demise of tory support now in a very poor third place, and even they rebelled against Johnson.

To continue inflicting policies from Westminster that are clearly not in the interests and not wanted by the other countries is rather like the end of empire.

And frankly, with Johnsons desperate administration, it's good riddance.

Presumably you are stating what you would like to be the case, because the actual case is completely the opposite. Constitutional matters affecting the UK are solely the remit of the UK parliament. And before you start having a go, I'm completely ambivalent regarding Scottish independence.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 7.30pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Therein lies the problem. Scotland could vote out in a protest vote over the current situation, rather than any long term reality for their own country.
The kind of independence the SNP want would probably take 50-100 years before establishing much - depends on how much they get subsidised by UK and EU.
Major issues: North Sea Oil, Military and defence - particularly RAF and Navy, the EU and immigration, exports, imports. Not quite as straight forward as colouring book geographers in the SNP would like. And there will certainly be boundary issues too. I'm guessing they want Berwick back - they all want their kilts and eat it.

They do have wind-and not just Teddys defending bungles kind!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Jun 22 8.02pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

They do have wind-and not just Teddys defending bungles kind!

Got a load today after yesterday's session on chocolate and marshmallow porter. If there was a turbine around it'd be a blur.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 8.03pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Got a load today after yesterday's session on chocolate and marshmallow porter. If there was a turbine around it'd be a blur.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 29 Jun 22 8.15pm

For me as a son of a Scots Dad and London mum, born in Sydenham but raised in Scotland I never wanted independence. However, the country changed after Thatcher. She made socialism a dirty word. She once said there’s no such thing as society only the individual. I thought I might never see a Labour government again. I even accepted the New Labour BS to get rid of the tories only to be disappointed by what Blair had to offer.

But all of that pales into insignificance compared with what we now have. Brexit made me sad not because we were leaving the EU but because we were leaving over issues like immigration. Farage came to a Scotland and we sent him packing. How any country could allow itself then to be run by a clown like Boris and a bunch of privileged Etonians is beyond me. I fear for the future of this great country.

Brexit was an emotional vote. No right thinking person could believe we’d be better off financially in their lifetime by leaving the EU but that didn’t stop people voting for it. The independence referendum will be the same this time. I don’t expect to be better off financially but if we gain independence I will be living in a country where the majority share my values rather than in one I no longer recognise. I will vote for independence knowing we will suffer financially and I’ll vote Labour at our first Scottish general election.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 8.18pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

For me as a son of a Scots Dad and London mum, born in Sydenham but raised in Scotland I never wanted independence. However, the country changed after Thatcher. She made socialism a dirty word. She once said there’s no such thing as society only the individual. I thought I might never see a Labour government again. I even accepted the New Labour BS to get rid of the tories only to be disappointed by what Blair had to offer.

But all of that pales into insignificance compared with what we now have. Brexit made me sad not because we were leaving the EU but because we were leaving over issues like immigration. Farage came to a Scotland and we sent him packing. How any country could allow itself then to be run by a clown like Boris and a bunch of privileged Etonians is beyond me. I fear for the future of this great country.

Brexit was an emotional vote. No right thinking person could believe we’d be better off financially in their lifetime by leaving the EU but that didn’t stop people voting for it. The independence referendum will be the same this time. I don’t expect to be better off financially but if we gain independence I will be living in a country where the majority share my values rather than in one I no longer recognise. I will vote for independence knowing we will suffer financially and I’ll vote Labour at our first Scottish general election.

Great post- I hope you follow the Hibs to mate!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Jun 22 8.41pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

For me as a son of a Scots Dad and London mum, born in Sydenham but raised in Scotland I never wanted independence. However, the country changed after Thatcher. She made socialism a dirty word. She once said there’s no such thing as society only the individual. I thought I might never see a Labour government again. I even accepted the New Labour BS to get rid of the tories only to be disappointed by what Blair had to offer.

But all of that pales into insignificance compared with what we now have. Brexit made me sad not because we were leaving the EU but because we were leaving over issues like immigration. Farage came to a Scotland and we sent him packing. How any country could allow itself then to be run by a clown like Boris and a bunch of privileged Etonians is beyond me. I fear for the future of this great country.

Brexit was an emotional vote. No right thinking person could believe we’d be better off financially in their lifetime by leaving the EU but that didn’t stop people voting for it. The independence referendum will be the same this time. I don’t expect to be better off financially but if we gain independence I will be living in a country where the majority share my values rather than in one I no longer recognise. I will vote for independence knowing we will suffer financially and I’ll vote Labour at our first Scottish general election.

Thanks for your post.

Economies recover, adapt, I don't think it is a given that Scotland will be worse off in the long term, you should prosper.

People have to realise there are consequences for brexit and disregarding the Scottish voters.

To be honest I can't think of a single reason for anyone to be attached to us.

I had better not say that too loud or Patel will send the police to arrest me.

That's just how bonkers Johnson and co. are.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 29 Jun 22 8.51pm

Originally posted by Matov


If Scotland does vote to leave then I suspect it will potentially be far worse than that. That sectarian stuff will really come into play up there in a BIG way. Will be bloody nasty.

and Ulster is also vulnerable to blowing up. Its a demographic tinder box. Constant political deadlock.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

becky Flag over the moon 29 Jun 22 9.51pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Thanks for your post.

Economies recover, adapt, I don't think it is a given that Scotland will be worse off in the long term, you should prosper.

People have to realise there are consequences for brexit and disregarding the Scottish voters.

To be honest I can't think of a single reason for anyone to be attached to us.

I had better not say that too loud or Patel will send the police to arrest me.

That's just how bonkers Johnson and co. are.

Haven't they still got to decide on a Scottish currency and set up a central bank for that?

I believe they were very firmly told they couldn't use the curent one.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 29 Jun 22 9.52pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Thanks for your post.

Economies recover, adapt, I don't think it is a given that Scotland will be worse off in the long term, you should prosper.

People have to realise there are consequences for brexit and disregarding the Scottish voters.

To be honest I can't think of a single reason for anyone to be attached to us.

I had better not say that too loud or Patel will send the police to arrest me.

That's just how bonkers Johnson and co. are.

If you hand yourself in Steeleye we promise to go easy on you!

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 29 Jun 22 10.57pm

Originally posted by Matov

I see our favourite Krankie is shooting her mouth off again.

I smell a rat. She knows it will get knocked back by our legal system (referendums require an act of Parliament) but can then proclaim that they are stymied by it. Already voicing off that if it is given the thumbs down then the SNP will only campaign on Independence come the next election.

Because let's be honest, what else can they campaign on? The increase in drug deaths under their malign rule?

Jeez please don't mention the 'R' word you'll have some of those loons in the SW of England spewing in their organic cerial

 


Pro USA & Israel

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 29 Jun 22 11.02pm

[ [/quote=croydon proud;3728868]
Great post- I hope you follow the Hibs to mate!

Thanks. As it happens I’ve been known to spend the odd couple of hours at Easter road!


Edited by Palacesince64 (29 Jun 2022 11.06pm)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 30 Jun 22 9.12am

Originally posted by becky

Haven't they still got to decide on a Scottish currency and set up a central bank for that?

I believe they were very firmly told they couldn't use the curent one.

Scotland could continue using the pound but would still be subject to the same interest rate changes which rather weakens the case.

Independence isn't as appealing as she claims.

[Link]


The situation may change when the Queen is no longer with us.

The SNP do well in the absence of any opposition; both Labour and the Tories are so weak. The Tories did surprisingly well under Ruth Davidson but since she's gone a lot of people would have to think to be able to name the leader of either party.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Jun 22 10.33am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Scotland could continue using the pound but would still be subject to the same interest rate changes which rather weakens the case.

Independence isn't as appealing as she claims.

[Link]


The situation may change when the Queen is no longer with us.

The SNP do well in the absence of any opposition; both Labour and the Tories are so weak. The Tories did surprisingly well under Ruth Davidson but since she's gone a lot of people would have to think to be able to name the leader of either party.

This is what the SNP wants. The BOE would effectively run the Scottish economy if it is boom all hail the SNP if bust blame the English. There would have to be an agreed transition but I think Westminster is correct to say no to the SNP over the pound.

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 30 Jun 22 12.58pm

Originally posted by Badger11

This is what the SNP wants. The BOE would effectively run the Scottish economy if it is boom all hail the SNP if bust blame the English. There would have to be an agreed transition but I think Westminster is correct to say no to the SNP over the pound.

I'm sure someone more knowledgeable will correct this but I don't think there is any way of stopping Scotland using the pound (or the dollar).

 

Matov Flag 30 Jun 22 1.43pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

I'm sure someone more knowledgeable will correct this but I don't think there is any way of stopping Scotland using the pound (or the dollar).


They can but given their EU ambitions, they have to establish a central bank because they will need to adopt the Euro.

And I suspect that using the pound without the approval of the RUK government would struggle big time to both attract inward investment (which would have to be in sterling) and raise money to fund their varied schemes. I would guess such a move would see almost all major banks pulling out of Scotland outside of some elements of retail banking. And I think, and happy to corrected on this, there could be some issues concerning people's registered addresses which could mean they struggle to open, and even possibly maintain sterling current accounts.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 30 Jun 22 10.48pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Russia got away with it after the revolution.

McBender.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scottish Indy Ref October 2023.