You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite (not best) 11 since you've been going
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Favourite (not best) 11 since you've been going


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
georgey wood Flag South London and Proud 08 Oct 22 12.47pm

My first game was 1985 so only picking players I’ve seen live.

Favourite team: 442

Speroni

Butterfield, Thorne, Delaney, Hill

Zaha, Gray, Hughes, Salako

Bright, Murray

Subs: AJ, Clinton, Jedi, Ward, Mcarthur

Best team: 442

Martyn

AWB, Cahill, Thorn, Cole

Zaha, Gray, Lombardo, Salako

Wright, Bright

Subs: Murray, AJ, Jansen, Moore, AWB

 

stancummins Flag 08 Oct 22 1.19pm

mine would be

Jackson

3 centre halfs

Young
Cannon
Craig Moore

2 wingbacks

Sansom
Humphrey

Midfield

Don Rodgers
Zaha
GeoffThomas

Forwards

Wright
Bright

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Oct 22 2.08pm

This line-up is probably influenced by my early days down the Palace as a young man. System = 4-3-3

Keeper: Burridge

Defence: (Doris) Hinchelwood - Cannon - Guehi - Sansom

Midfield: Murphy - Jedinak - Thomas

Attack: Hilaire - Johnson - Rogers

Manager: Coppell

Subs: Speroni - Ward - MacArthur - Elwiss - Whittle

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Oct 22 2.42pm

Not necessarily the best XI of my era (last 33 years), but the most memorable for me...

Speroni

AWB Delaney Young Gordon

Puncheon Jedi Eze

Wilf AJ Bolasie

I will always have a soft spot for Bruce Dyer, but he never replied to my letter when I was a kid, so he misses out. Clinton would definitely be on the bench with Salad, Jolly Roger and Cocoa Pops. As good as they were, some players like Scott Dann were just too boring to stick in the memory.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 08 Oct 22 4.28pm

As I said in my original post there was bound to be names that other posters put up that I hadn't thought of.

I can't believe I had to leave out Ambrose, Michael Hughes and Cabaye.

Peter Taylor might even had made my side, but his management spell has tarnished his reputation for me unfortunately (and probably unfairly).

 

Runningman Flag Keston 08 Oct 22 5.55pm

Originally posted by stancummins

mine would be

Jackson

3 centre halfs

Young
Cannon
Craig Moore

2 wingbacks

Sansom
Humphrey

Midfield

Don Rodgers
Zaha
GeoffThomas

Forwards

Wright
Bright

I wondered when Craig Moore would get a mention. Absolute quality !

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 08 Oct 22 6.41pm

Cant believe how tough this question is but here goes , from 1968

Jacko
Saul Cannon Delaney Sansom
Jedi

Taylor Murphy Sasa Bolasie

AJ

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 08 Oct 22 7.55pm

This is so tough...Going since 1979. Here goes:

Gk - Martyn

LB - Sansom
CB - Cannon
CB - Thorne
RB - Doris

RM - Hilaire
CM - Gerry Francis
CM - Thomas
LW - Zaha

CF - Wright
CF - AJ

Subs: Speroni, Lombardo, AWB, Fan Zhayi, Ambrose, Jansen, Mabbutt, Salako, Jedi, Murray

Could pick 20 more easily!

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

Plaistow Eagle Flag 09 Oct 22 1.54pm

Martyn
Clyne
Gilbert
Southgate
Sansom
Thomas
Murphy
Cabye
Bolasie
Wright
Zaha

That should do the job..!!

COYP

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 09 Oct 22 4.27pm

Budgie
Ward. Cannon. Popovic. Cole

Hughes. Jedi

Kemp
Taylor. Murray. Morrison

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 09 Oct 22 8.26pm

Martyn Hinshelwood P Sansom Murphy Cannon Gilbert Thomas Zaha Johnson Bright Rogers

Subs Berridge Clyne Nicholas Lombardo Freedman Hilaire

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Oct 22 9.05pm

Speroni
Ward
Delaney
Dann
Sansom
MacArthur
Jedinak
Zaha
Bolasie
AJ
Murray

I can't pick Ian Wright. Grateful for what he did but can't stand him.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 10 Oct 22 10.24am

'A' team
Nigel Martyn
Damien Delaney
Mel Blyth
Ashley Cole
Jedi
Wilf
Attilio Lombardo
AJ
Yohan Cabaye
Glenn Murray
Yannick Bolasie

'B' team
John Jackson
Andy Thorn
Billy Gilbert
Roger Hynd
Michael Hughes
James McArthur
Simon Rodger
Colin Taylor
Matt Jansen
Don Rogers
Rachid Harkouk

Can't believe some names left out, but these are my favourites rather than 'best'.

Honourable mentions to John Salako, Geoff Thomas, Ian Wright, Gerry Queen, John McCormick, Dave Swindlehurst, Alan Whittle, Ninja, Dooogie, Mark Bright, Wardy, Peter Taylor, Jim Cannon, Vince Hilaire, Craig Moore, Jason Puncheon and many of the current team.

Great thread, very difficult choices....


Edited by Sansbup (10 Oct 2022 10.29am)

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 10 Oct 22 11.37am

My favourites since I've been going in 1993

Speroni
Ward
Eric Young
Southgate
Gordon
Routledge
Lombardo
Curcic
Zaha
AJ
Freedman

 


La la la your mum

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 10 Oct 22 12.11pm

Martyn

Shaw
Ninja
Andersen
Humprey

Lombardo
Gray
Cabaye

Zaha
Wright
Bolasie

 

edskan Flag 11 Oct 22 7.58am

Martyn
Gordon
Ninja
Southgate
AWB
Lombardo
Hopkin
Ambrose
Wilf
Murray
Johnson

Subs:Rodger,Roberts, Shaw, Armstrong, Jedinak, Guiata

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 11 Oct 22 1.42pm

Martyn

Pemberton Young Thorn Gordon

Zaha Gray Curcic

Freedman

Wright Armstrong


Subs:
Austin
Linighan
Bolasie
Houghton

 

RickEveleigh Flag Little Kimble, nr Aylesbury 12 Oct 22 10.19am

Originally posted by Palace 1979

This is so tough...Going since 1979. Here goes:

Gk - Martyn

LB - Sansom
CB - Cannon
CB - Thorne
RB - Doris

RM - Hilaire
CM - Gerry Francis
CM - Thomas
LW - Zaha

CF - Wright
CF - AJ

Subs: Speroni, Lombardo, AWB, Fan Zhayi, Ambrose, Jansen, Mabbutt, Salako, Jedi, Murray

Could pick 20 more easily!

Similar era to you (first game 1977), started my list but it's sooo difficult. Can I play Wilf, Vince, Yannick & Salako in the same team? No? Ah. Haven't been much over the last 25 years so my team is heavily early 80s/early 90s biased.

Budgie
Pembo Cannon Guehi Sansom
Salako Thomas Gray Zaha
Wright Bright

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Oct 22 11.09am

Nice to see Jerry Murphy mentioned Class, i always thought Simon Osborn was underrated, Stan Cummins, Ian Evans, Mike Elwiss, Kevin Mabbutt, Rachid Harkouk, Matt Jansen, Dave Madden, were players i look back with fondness, i think the most important player we had at the time was Mickey Droy, who did a fantastic job, my all-time favorite was Andy Gray.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Oct 22 12.34pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Nice to see Jerry Murphy mentioned Class, i always thought Simon Osborn was underrated, Stan Cummins, Ian Evans, Mike Elwiss, Kevin Mabbutt, Rachid Harkouk, Matt Jansen, Dave Madden, were players i look back with fondness, i think the most important player we had at the time was Mickey Droy, who did a fantastic job, my all-time favorite was Andy Gray.

I loved Micky Droy, he was massive, nothing used to get passed him, if he didn’t tackle them he just fell on them or took them out

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite (not best) 11 since you've been going