You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > carabao cup team for wednesday
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

carabao cup team for wednesday


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 07 Nov 22 6.18pm

Originally posted by cryrst

ZDS

i did say a proper cup, however, that was a great day out

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 07 Nov 22 7.17pm

Originally posted by palace99

i did say a proper cup, however, that was a great day out

When Geoff went up to lift the ZDS Cup I was there..!

COYP

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Nov 22 9.30pm

Originally posted by palace99

i did say a proper cup, however, that was a great day out

There were only 3 to play for

 

CPFC Dartford Flag Dartford 07 Nov 22 9.48pm

Only 2 games until the World Cup, I would start exactly the same team that started against West Ham. I would love to win even the league cup

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Nov 22 9.55pm

Originally posted by The groover

Since most of the top sides rest their first team its a really good shout.

As has been said shame those running the game had that lobotomy!

I'd rather have a bottle in front of me than a frontal lobotomy!

I'd play whoever can afford to play (which in my very humble opinion should be all of them). Understand and accept those suggesting a second XI however I'd like to see something like:

GK: Johnstone

RB: Ward
CB: Andersen
CB: Guehi
LB: Mitchell or maybe Clyne... probably Clyne

DM: Luka
CM: Doucoure
CAM: Ebz

RW: Ebiowei
ST: Mateta
LW: Zaha

I think that'd be a fair shout with a few subs thrown in for the non-regulars (Tommo, Jairo, Hughes et al)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

viveasheagle Flag perth 08 Nov 22 6.06am

I think as a club the first priority is the league. We are on a good run with an important game on Saturday and if win against Forest it will go along way to making sure we remain in the league for another year. I think if we were drawn at home to Newcastle on Tuesday and had say Forest at home on Sunday we could have put out a near full strength team but with the travel and short turn around we need to rest our first eleven

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Nov 22 7.49am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

When Geoff went up to lift the ZDS Cup I was there..!

COYP

Ahh, the memories, one of the best bits was when Southall refused to go up and get his loser’s medal and what was that funny tournament at Wembley where you only played 45mins, only Palace fans there

851A3F27-EF3C-4E2B-97EA-0C7920406E96.jpeg Attachment: 851A3F27-EF3C-4E2B-97EA-0C7920406E96.jpeg (2,756.70Kb)

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

crystal-purley Flag Purley 08 Nov 22 8.12am

Originally posted by cryrst

ZDS


You know that that is never allowed. My highlight was Neville Southall sitting in the goal while the rest of the team were inside.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

crystal-purley Flag Purley 08 Nov 22 8.24am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Ahh, the memories, one of the best bits was when Southall refused to go up and get his loser’s medal and what was that funny tournament at Wembley where you only played 45mins, only Palace fans there

That would be the Full Members cup or trophy, we were knocked out by Forest. We just got in to the tournament ahead of Millwall.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Nov 22 9.06am

Originally posted by crystal-purley

That would be the Full Members cup or trophy, we were knocked out by Forest. We just got in to the tournament ahead of Millwall.

Thanks, all i can remember from that is that Wembley was divided up in little sections for each set of supporters

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

YT Flag Oxford 08 Nov 22 9.27am

Originally posted by crystal-purley

That would be the Full Members cup or trophy, we were knocked out by Forest. We just got in to the tournament ahead of Millwall.

Not correct, I'm afraid. It was the 'Mercantile Credit' tournament. The matches were shorter than 45 minutes, Millwall DID qualify and if I recall correctly we lost our one and only game on penalties after a 0-0 - I think to Sheffield Wednesday.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 08 Nov 22 9.29am

Also ... the ZDS was in fact the Full Members' Cup (just like the Carabao Cup is the League Cup).

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Nov 22 9.51am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I'd play whoever can afford to play (which in my very humble opinion should be all of them). Understand and accept those suggesting a second XI however I'd like to see something like:

GK: Johnstone

RB: Ward
CB: Andersen
CB: Guehi
LB: Mitchell or maybe Clyne... probably Clyne

DM: Luka
CM: Doucoure
CAM: Ebz

RW: Ebiowei
ST: Mateta
LW: Zaha

I think that'd be a fair shout with a few subs thrown in for the non-regulars (Tommo, Jairo, Hughes et al)

Do you think that Patrick would risk Doucoure as he won't have fully recovered from his injuries

 

TheFish Flag 08 Nov 22 11.19am

Alright lads, Geordie in peace here,

Eddie says he's going to take the cups seriously so while there may be a couple of changes (Wilson looks like he'll miss out due to illness) but it should still be a strong side.

We've a few key players who're likely off to the World Cup; Bruno, Wilson, Trippier e.g. so I do wonder if they'll be protected?

Will Vieira ring the changes or will he name the usual first 11? How many of your lads are off to Qatar?

For any of you heading up for the match tomorrow, I've got plenty of pub recommendations. There are no 'away' pubs and you'll be welcomed in all of the 100 or so pubs within walking distance of the ground. Probably won't get in the Strawberry because it'll be packed. Rosies, Tilleys, Town Wall, the Forth, all en route from the train station. Mile Castle is huge and kind of on your way. If you're driving up I'd recommend parking at the Metro Centre and getting the short train across. Free, CCTV-ed parking in a shopping centre with all the food options you'd expect from something like that.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 08 Nov 22 11.35am

Welcome Fish - & for those travelling up, many thanks for the heads up on beer, food & parking -

On the cup side - we are sitting in the League with 19 points from 13 games & given that we had played so many of the bigger teams I think overall we are pleased if not a tad surprised to find ourselves with so many points, also we have an away game against forest at the weekend where we would hope to get something, so to be going into the WC break with 20 / 22 points we would be pretty pleased with ourselves & I dont think our desire to go further in the cup will be allowed to interfere with the League prospects -

This factor I believe will shape our team selection -Obvs I am not PV so its only my opinion -

I expect to see a few big names in our team but several others rested & the balance made up of some periphery players & academy hopefuls - that dosent mean we will just roll over but ultimately I think Newcastle will prove too strong for us on a cold wet windy night up North.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 08 Nov 22 1.24pm

I’ve been to quite a few away matches this season, but can’t make tomorrow’s game. I understand the need to rotate/rest players - but after Saturday, there is a 6 week break coming up! Also, remember the fans who are making the effort to travel and support the team from the stands. I know they would appreciate PV putting out a strong team. It makes the journey worthwhile!

 

mileend Flag East London 08 Nov 22 1.38pm

To answer your question about Qatar the answer is not many and the few who might make the trip are, with one exception, not likely to play a great part in it

Jordan Ayew for Ghana - a player that divides Palace fans on whether he should ever be allowed on the pitch which is unfair but when a forward players role seems to have morphed into working hard defensively or coming on late in the game to draw a foul or two (which he is uncannily good at) then you have to wonder and it's right that his position has been taken by Olise. For balance it is right to say he is capable of some sublime skill every other season or so and the mystery of why it occurs so infrequently is likely never to be solved.

Marc Guehi - definitely one of the most talented English Centre Backs and one of the transformative players since Vieira's arrival that has given us a different style and a better team. Would be no surprise to seem him on the plane and could become a mainstay in future England teams. But I don't think anyone is expecting him to be a likely starter at the World Cup.

Joachim Andersen - the other half of the first choice centre back pairing - long pass a speciality - and a likely starter for Denmark.

Tyrick Mitchell - Palace fans are rightly proud that we have another academy player making the grade in the Premier League. But previously making the England squad was a bit of a surprise even one weakened by withdrawals. He didn't do too bad but it is not an experience that has made him kick on. If anything the opposite happened and he's not been as effective or confident in the early part of the season - though some more promising signs he is coming back to his previous level. But with the Chilwell injury it's possible he could be in the frame. Though at this time I am not sure he should be.

Now who have I missed?

 

TheFish Flag 08 Nov 22 1.52pm

Originally posted by mileend

To answer your question about Qatar the answer is not many and the few who might make the trip are, with one exception, not likely to play a great part in it

Jordan Ayew for Ghana - a player that divides Palace fans on whether he should ever be allowed on the pitch which is unfair but when a forward players role seems to have morphed into working hard defensively or coming on late in the game to draw a foul or two (which he is uncannily good at) then you have to wonder and it's right that his position has been taken by Olise. For balance it is right to say he is capable of some sublime skill every other season or so and the mystery of why it occurs so infrequently is likely never to be solved.

Marc Guehi - definitely one of the most talented English Centre Backs and one of the transformative players since Vieira's arrival that has given us a different style and a better team. Would be no surprise to seem him on the plane and could become a mainstay in future England teams. But I don't think anyone is expecting him to be a likely starter at the World Cup.

Joachim Andersen - the other half of the first choice centre back pairing - long pass a speciality - and a likely starter for Denmark.

Tyrick Mitchell - Palace fans are rightly proud that we have another academy player making the grade in the Premier League. But previously making the England squad was a bit of a surprise even one weakened by withdrawals. He didn't do too bad but it is not an experience that has made him kick on. If anything the opposite happened and he's not been as effective or confident in the early part of the season - though some more promising signs he is coming back to his previous level. But with the Chilwell injury it's possible he could be in the frame. Though at this time I am not sure he should be.

Now who have I missed?

Could you see Vieira leaving those players out of the Cup game?

It's a shame some of the players you have that give me sleepless nights aren't going to be rested, mind you. If Zaha, Eze could be rested, that'd be swell.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Nov 22 1.59pm

Originally posted by mileend

To answer your question about Qatar the answer is not many and the few who might make the trip are, with one exception, not likely to play a great part in it

Jordan Ayew for Ghana -

Marc Guehi - d

Joachim Andersen -

Tyrick Mitchell -

Now who have I missed?


Theoretically there's Chris Richards for the USMNT if he recovers sufficiently. They might take him if he could be available for the KO stage should the Americans get through.

As for tomorrow night. It was noticeable that PV used only ONE sub on Sunday, Luka coming on for Cheick. Playing Sunday-Wednesday-Saturday is a tough ask so whilst PV has said he will put out a strong team, reading between the lines of his pre-match press conference, I think several of the team who started on Sunday will be rested. We might see some of the youngsters on the bench, but the only one with a chance of starting IMO is Ebiowei in place of Olise (who on Sunday completed, I believe, his very first full PL game. He's either been subbed or was a sub in all his previous PL appearances). I expect to see Tomkins, Hughes, Luka, Riedewald and Mateta starting as well.

Edited by doombear (08 Nov 2022 1.59pm)

 

mileend Flag East London 08 Nov 22 2.17pm

Vieira said today he is taking the game seriously and wants to compete

Sounds like a reasonable side, not a team with lots of U21s in to get experience, but with key players rested for the Forest game.

Better judges than me have given some likely line ups in this thread

He will probably leave out Zaha and Andersen. Mateta and Tomkins to come in. Probably swap Clyne for Ward. Doucoure is not likely to be risked in midfield so Miliojevic will get some more game time. Ayew for Olise likely.

We could hold our own for periods but will need a bit of luck to get through this one. Newcastle clear favourites.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > carabao cup team for wednesday