This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Lessons learnt?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
PatrickA London 27 Dec 22 9.16am |
|
|
In a post match interview Vieira said he may have to reconsider how we set up. This sounds as if lessons are being learnt. However, he made similar noises after the Everton game but in subsequent games has still persisted with only one defensive midfielder with players shoehorned into roles that don’t suit them.
I raised the issue some months ago as to whether it was possible to include Zaha, Eze and Olise all in the same team on a regular basis in a tough competitive Premier League. Even though they are all very talented, I remain unconvinced. It’s difficult to have three players who don’t contribute out of possession , particularly when you only play with one defensive midfield player. There also has to be a question mark about using Zaha regularly as a centre forward even if he is our most likely goal scorer. It’s not playing to his strengths as he spends his whole game chasing lost causes or trying to battle physical centre halves . I wonder if part of the reason that Zaha is used up front is because Vieira is of the view that it will allow him a system to also to accommodate Eze and Olise in the team.
After Bournemouth we have a really tough run of games coming up and I really hope that lessons have been learnt with a more suitable playing system which allows us first to compete in the midfield to get a foothold in games. We all hoped McArthur would be fit for the second half of the season, but this looks more and more unlikely. The noises about signings in January don’t sound too promising so Vieira may well have to look at existing resources to resolve the problems in midfield and restore a proper balance in the team. For me this would mean Edouard up front , Zaha restored to the left of a front three and a more defensive midfielder introduced at the expense of either Eze or Olise.
|
Dubai Eagle 27 Dec 22 10.45am |
|
|
In the post game interview against Everton, about the 3rd question to be asked of PV was - Would you consider playing with 2 defensive midfielders? The answer was a clear no -
The interview is still available on Palace TV -
Maybe this is one of the things he is now considering - If not then ...............
|
Osvaldo Epsom 27 Dec 22 11.20am |
|
|
agree with all that has been said. Our manager is a bit like Southgate, reacts too late to introduce substitutions. Players have got to act more responsibly and not be careless with tackles. After such a long break, you would think they would have come out and given the fans something to shout about, the opposite, it was dreadful. Pay good money to watch highly paid rubbish. In the January window we must get a couple of strikers, even if it means going into the Championship or Morocco - Rashid Harkouk! Clearly we need Wan Bisaka asap. This is a poor team that has good individual players who are not playing to their full potential. The team does need a complete overall. Hopefully, Bournemouth have a bad day on Saturday! I am truly concerned because with performances like this, the Championship is beckoning!
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 27 Dec 22 11.40am |
|
|
We will see how much the gaffer has learnt when he puts out his chosen 11 with Bournemouth as opposition. I would like to see: Guieta Clyne - Andersen - Guehi - Riedewald Luka - Doucoure - Hughes (beef up the midfield) Olise - Edouard/Mateta - Zaha
PS! Anyone know what has happened to keeper Johnstone?
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 27 Dec 22 12.29pm |
|
|
For balance yesterday's line up was the one that dominated West Ham apart from Tomkins for Guehi who is able to carry the ball forward and pass well with both feet. I think Silva mentioned Tomkins was targeted in his post match.
|
Uphill Bedford 27 Dec 22 12.58pm |
|
|
Amidst the justified moans and groans a few on here have pointed out what we have known all season
1. We can't pass the ball 2. We have no cohesion 3. The manager is slow to react with fresh subs (ala Southgate & Hodgson) and then brings on the wrong ones! 4. A midfield 'general' who can hold the ball until he sees a pass (like Bannon, Shelvey, etc) is our most desperate need - just watch Olise, Eze, Zaha and Edouard go if they received some service !
I would add that no homework was done on Mitrovic, he is a sly often dirty player and reaped his reward against a gullible Tomkins.
|
aashman12 27 Dec 22 1.06pm |
|
Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
Ayew better than Eze or Olise??.. Wow... I'm lost for words at that...
Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (27 Dec 2022 12.57am)
Performance wise he has been. What's ezes best 90 mins for us?
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 27 Dec 22 2.05pm |
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
I wouldn’t disagree with any of this, but worth noting that the only difference between the starting XI yesterday and the team who beat West Ham 2-1, and more than matched them for 90 minutes, was Tomkins replacing Guehi. Is Tomkins that bad? Fulham that good? Or did we just look rusty and half asleep for the whole game
..Tomkins is nowhere near match fit and we lost Mitchell after 34 mins making us a player short, how many times have we watched us start as we did against Fulham and then after about half an hour start to slowly improve and then have a real good go in the second half?
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 27 Dec 22 2.09pm |
|
|
Agree, Ayew is the sort of player we very badly need on the pitch especially now, do not and never will understand the shit some fans fire at him.
He created our best moment at Forest and was very unlucky not to score yesterday!
Edited by Tickled pink (27 Dec 2022 2.12pm)
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 27 Dec 22 2.32pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Amidst the justified moans and groans a few on here have pointed out what we have known all season
1. We can't pass the ball 2. We have no cohesion 3. The manager is slow to react with fresh subs (ala Southgate & Hodgson) and then brings on the wrong ones! 4. A midfield 'general' who can hold the ball until he sees a pass (like Bannon, Shelvey, etc) is our most desperate need - just watch Olise, Eze, Zaha and Edouard go if they received some service !
I would add that no homework was done on Mitrovic, he is a sly often dirty player and reaped his reward against a gullible Tomkins.
No amount of homework can help a team like ours when reduced to ten and Fulham to some degree made us play the way we did.
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Dec 22 2.45pm |
|
|
I would have been fuming after yesterday's game at that performance in isolation. But it followed the pre World Cup match at Forest that was well below standard too. So there appears to be little that has been learned in between those games.
Another shocker at Bournemouth and we will have a real problem.
We lack strength in depth. For example our centre backs have no genuine competition for their places. Instead we wheel Tompkins out for the occasional cameo and unsurprisingly he struggles.
Midfield is a shambles with no balance to it.
Up front it would appear that Vieira has lost faith in both Edouard and Mateta.
As I mentioned on another thread, it's a worry that Parish seems to think this squad needs little help in the second half of the season.
Saturday's game has grown in importance now.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
aashman12 27 Dec 22 4.28pm |
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
We will see how much the gaffer has learnt when he puts out his chosen 11 with Bournemouth as opposition. I would like to see: Guieta Clyne - Andersen - Guehi - Riedewald Luka - Doucoure - Hughes (beef up the midfield) Olise - Edouard/Mateta - Zaha
PS! Anyone know what has happened to keeper Johnstone?
Out injured for 2 months with a coccyx issue
|
Mapletree Croydon 27 Dec 22 4.32pm |
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
We will see how much the gaffer has learnt when he puts out his chosen 11 with Bournemouth as opposition. I would like to see: Guieta Clyne - Andersen - Guehi - Riedewald Luka - Doucoure - Hughes (beef up the midfield) Olise - Edouard/Mateta - Zaha
PS! Anyone know what has happened to keeper Johnstone?
Hughes to beef up the midfield. Hmmmmm
|
Eaglecoops CR3 27 Dec 22 6.14pm |
|
|
More of a thin frying steak I reckon but he deserves a chance, he can’t be less effective than Schlupp, Eze and Olise were yesterday. Of course we all know Eze/Olise can be superb and Schlupp can be a very effective impact player, but only in front of an effective defensive midfield.
I would be tempted to go 4-4-1-1 next game.
Guaita Ward, Anderson, Guehi, Riedewald Ayew, Hughes, Doucoure, Zaha Eze Edouard
Eze needs to be the link up player, Ayew and Zaha providing the width and Doucoure/Hughes holding.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 27 Dec 22 6.35pm |
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Agree, Ayew is the sort of player we very badly need on the pitch especially now, do not and never will understand the shit some fans fire at him.
He created our best moment at Forest and was very unlucky not to score yesterday!
How many times did he lost the ball or passed to a Fulham player_ I lost count and if we need him on the pitch, we ARE in trouble.
Edited by Tickled pink (27 Dec 2022 2.12pm)
|
Eaglecoops CR3 27 Dec 22 6.53pm |
|
|
I’m no Ayew fan, but he does get stuck in and until Olise can put in the same effort and defensive work then Ayew edges it on the right, certainly for the first 60 minutes.
If you could morph the best attributes of Ayew and Olise you would have a very good player.
|
cROYdonrogers Leamington Spa 27 Dec 22 8.53pm |
|
|
And yet despite the way we set up BBC report we’ve set a record-2 consecutive games without a shot on target.Apology s*** with adding links. Think I know where this could soon end up but don’t want to be the shot messenger. A great shame really cos I like him.
|
auk 28 Dec 22 12.45am |
|
|
The trouble is that our recruiter-in-chief’s wife is a former ballet dancer, so her influence has resulted in Palace buying artiste-players of undoubted balance, poise and grace but short on grit, tenacity and determination.
Gallagher brought all these latter attributes plus skill, bravery, fantastic powers of acceleration and a great sense of the team being more important than the individual.
In the window, we need to sign players who can get us out of a scrape when we’re chasing the game in front of a hostile crowd on a cold afternoon in midwinter.
The blueprint was set by the do-or-die attitude of Morocco in the World Cup tournament in Qatar.
COYP.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 28 Dec 22 7.11am |
|
|
We need some muscle in the middle of the park, to put some tackles in and leave a mark on the opposition. We are too nice and get rolled over far too easy. It’s really odd because PV was that sort of player.
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 28 Dec 22 9.36am |
|
|
Could someone explain to me what or style is, all i can see is passing it back and forward among the back four until we either kick it out of play or lose possession in our own half.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|