This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I suppose, if you think about it, Derry may have said: why loan an Arsenal player who's hardly played and not been great - instead of using say Ozoh. He may also have said: why pay 10.5 mil for pretty raw talent, again not exactly massively featured instead of promoting from within? And I guess they are genuine questions. If either does not play well, or isn't used, then these questions will come up again. It's not like our signings have played much more than our own academy players. I guess Derry could have thought this was a poor message for the club to give to promising youngsters in the area. Good post. If Derry had indeed said the things you mooted, then he's an idiot. "Derry may have said: why loan an Arsenal player who's hardly played and not been great - instead of using say Ozoh" Answer: Because one has around 100 games of top-flight experience (Anderlecht AND Arsenal) under his belt and, other than a recent loss of form, HAS been very good throughout most of his career. We KNOW what Lokonga is capable of at top level, even if he's not been able to show it in the past few months. We have NO IDEA what Ozoh is capable of at this level and while he should be given a chance to show us, he's best being brought along slowly. There's simply a word of difference between the two in the here and how. "He may also have said: why pay 10.5 mil for pretty raw talent, again not exactly massively featured instead of promoting from within?" Answer: This makes Derry the man who, at Brighton a year ago, said "let's not sign Caceido. I don't trust our scouts." That would have worked out well, wouldn't it? Besides which, Ahamada is young and developing, but he's NOT a raw talent. He has at least some experience of playing regularly in a top European league.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Good post. If Derry had indeed said the things you mooted, then he's an idiot. "Derry may have said: why loan an Arsenal player who's hardly played and not been great - instead of using say Ozoh" Answer: Because one has around 100 games of top-flight experience (Anderlecht AND Arsenal) under his belt and, other than a recent loss of form, HAS been very good throughout most of his career. We KNOW what Lokonga is capable of at top level, even if he's not been able to show it in the past few months. We have NO IDEA what Ozoh is capable of at this level and while he should be given a chance to show us, he's best being brought along slowly. There's simply a word of difference between the two in the here and how. "He may also have said: why pay 10.5 mil for pretty raw talent, again not exactly massively featured instead of promoting from within?" Answer: This makes Derry the man who, at Brighton a year ago, said "let's not sign Caceido. I don't trust our scouts." That would have worked out well, wouldn't it? Besides which, Ahamada is young and developing, but he's NOT a raw talent. He has at least some experience of playing regularly in a top European league. I understand what you say Syd, but did he actually say anything.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I understand what you say Syd, but did he actually say anything. I was merely playing devil's advocate. Anything literally could have happened. Just pure supposition.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
It's interesting because there's clearly a story here. Parish is rightly big on promoting from within, and I believe when PV was hired having an existing member of the club coaching team was more or less imposed on him so I don't imagine if Derry was fired, it would have been done without a good reason. And if he left voluntarily because he has a manager's job or something else lined up, you'd usually say that; "one of our coaches is moving up the career ladder" is broadly good publicity. So you have to think there's an "adverse" story somewhere in here somewhere. Plus, as I said, Derry has a history of being a man who does things his own way. TBH, on a personal level I'll miss him because I like continuity in the club and I always liked Derry as a player. But I'm inclined to think from a pure coaching standpoint, it's no great loss. And I presume that's how PV feels too, as we haven't had the obligatory press release thanking Derry for his services, and noting how much he'd contributed to the club. Possibly even, we've weeded out a bad apple. What I do think is, as I've said before, things were going stale. We've looked out of sorts for some weeks now. We needed a shake-up and some refreshing...needed it badly...and two new players and presumably a new voice in the coaching team if Derry is going to be replaced is in my view, a good start and no bad thing. I'll be interested to see if we push on and show a little more life over the next few weeks. Is looking like a fall out but who knows? Interesting point on the coaching side - I've no idea who's any good or what we need. I expect PV has contacts.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
It's interesting because there's clearly a story here. Parish is rightly big on promoting from within, and I believe when PV was hired having an existing member of the club coaching team was more or less imposed on him so I don't imagine if Derry was fired, it would have been done without a good reason. And if he left voluntarily because he has a manager's job or something else lined up, you'd usually say that; "one of our coaches is moving up the career ladder" is broadly good publicity. So you have to think there's an "adverse" story somewhere in here somewhere. Plus, as I said, Derry has a history of being a man who does things his own way. TBH, on a personal level I'll miss him because I like continuity in the club and I always liked Derry as a player. But I'm inclined to think from a pure coaching standpoint, it's no great loss. And I presume that's how PV feels too, as we haven't had the obligatory press release thanking Derry for his services, and noting how much he'd contributed to the club. Possibly even, we've weeded out a bad apple. What I do think is, as I've said before, things were going stale. We've looked out of sorts for some weeks now. We needed a shake-up and some refreshing...needed it badly...and two new players and presumably a new voice in the coaching team if Derry is going to be replaced is in my view, a good start and no bad thing. I'll be interested to see if we push on and show a little more life over the next few weeks. So Derry leaving will make for a refreshing makeover. Got it. Must have been Derry who choose the 4-3-3 system with players not compatible for it, Schlupp as a central midfielder and the useless Eze as who knows what. Still, look on the bright side, the new players might give PV the opportunity to play his preferred system correctly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
If I remember correctly when Vieira joined Derry was the under 21 manager and McCarthy took the under 18s. Maybe that is the issue, he felt he didn't have a proper role or wasn't listen to?
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
So Derry leaving will make for a refreshing makeover. Got it. Must have been Derry who choose the 4-3-3 system with players not compatible for it, Schlupp as a central midfielder and the useless Eze as who knows what. Still, look on the bright side, the new players might give PV the opportunity to play his preferred system correctly. I didn't say that specifically. What I said (in another thread if not this one) was that the combination of two new players and a new coach may well freshen up the room. And beyond that, even if PV himself ultimately chooses the formations, etc., sometimes having a new member of the team brings in fresh ideas, a new head for PV to pick and bounce ideas off, and a new perspective to listen to. It all contributes to the greater good in one way or another. I'm not saying Derry's departure alone amounts to a makeover, but we've been a team in need of reinvigoration for most of this season and to my mind, any change no matter how small is probably a step in the right direction. In a game of fine margins, something we all acknowledge, don't underestimate how much something might matter.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
On another thread somebody mentioned a hope that McArthur stays on as a coach with his playing days drawing to a close. I would imagine that thought has crossed the minds of many of us on here. It certainly has mine. It's a great shout. Does anyone know if JM is doing his badges?
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I would imagine that thought has crossed the minds of many of us on here. It certainly has mine. It's a great shout. Does anyone know if JM is doing his badges? Badges, badges. He no need no stinkin' badges.
|
|
|
Has Derry definitely left?
|
|
|
Potential litigation = No statement. The murky world of Constructive Dismissal will be on our leaders mind, if of course there has been a rift.
|
|
|
A lot of speculation and no cold facts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
A lot of speculation and no cold facts. This is Hol after all...
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
Badges, badges. He no need no stinkin' badges. Ahh, The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, a classic scene
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
I am also of the opinion that McCarthur will make an excellent manager when he hangs up his boots.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.