You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zaha


Page 2 of 57 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Elpis Flag In a pub 15 May 23 9.17pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

It was intended to be harsh! I thought I was being nice

I’ve perhaps over egged my assertion that JWP’s general footballing ability is not aligned to his world class dead ball specialism. I do sincerely maintain however that outside of that, I don’t rate him highly and certainly wouldn’t desire his acquisition on that basis alone. I do however think he is quite similar to Hughes in some ways! Easy to underestimate his general tidiness on the ball and tenacity in midfield!


I would agree always thought WP as average at best . Saints forum over the years would back you up on that

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 15 May 23 9.25pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

It was intended to be harsh! I thought I was being nice

I’ve perhaps over egged my assertion that JWP’s general footballing ability is not aligned to his world class dead ball specialism. I do sincerely maintain however that outside of that, I don’t rate him highly and certainly wouldn’t desire his acquisition on that basis alone. I do however think he is quite similar to Hughes in some ways! Easy to underestimate his general tidiness on the ball and tenacity in midfield!

Academic. Neither he nor maddison will come to us.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 15 May 23 10.13pm

Originally posted by Charlie B

Does anyone else think that maybe other clubs are casting a doubting eye over Wilf now? The injuries are adding up. Also, if he is now injury prone, should we be offering him £200k a week on a 4 year contract as reported

No, we should be letting him go with a thank you for your service.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 15 May 23 11.19pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Wilf 130, Luka 75, McArthur, 55, Tomkins 50, Lokonga 52, Butland 35, Clyne 30, Ferguson 29, Ward 35 total 491k GBP per week.

I would offer Ward a one year extension

I would cap any contract offer for Wilf to one year and £100k/wk absolute max.
I would try it at £80k/wk to kick off.
I would keep Wardy one more year then let the rest on your list go

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 May 23 6.51am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I would cap any contract offer for Wilf to one year and £100k/wk absolute max.
I would try it at £80k/wk to kick off.
I would keep Wardy one more year then let the rest on your list go

Add to that, prolong the contracts of Eze and Olise and Guehi. And if they are ever allowed to leave, make the buyers pay what they are worth to us.

 

PJEagle Flag London 16 May 23 11.12am

Originally posted by silvertop

Academic. Neither he nor maddison will come to us.

If Leicester are relegated, they'll have to sell Madison. It would convince me that we had more money than sense if Palacee put a bid in for him

 

The Dolphin Flag 16 May 23 11.59am

Madison - not for me - Emperors clothes!

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 16 May 23 1.55pm

It was tough to see Wilf on the ground just in front feeling his hamstring. Realised it was season over, but when somebody said we may never see him in a Palace shirt again that seemed very sad. On balance he has given far more joy than angst. A shame his effort just before half time was off target, it would have been a fitting goal to depart on.
Offering 4years x £200k a week, if indeed that is the case, is total madness. Balancing what he has given, what he is worth and what we can afford, I think 2years at around £100k would be right. If there are some imaginative add ons then fair enough. This probably wont be enough and it will seem the end of an era when he goes. Thanks for the good times.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 16 May 23 2.18pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Add to that, prolong the contracts of Eze and Olise and Guehi. And if they are ever allowed to leave, make the buyers pay what they are worth to us.

Of the 3 Eze has 2 years left, so he would be my focus.
Guehi and Olise have 3 left so no need to worry - yet.

Regarding Wilf, i think he wants to go. However, if i was the club i'd offer him a 1 year contract with a 2nd year that is triggered if he plays say 30 league games.

In terms of the package i would make it very 'add on' heavy.

So to get say £150k a week i'd offer £75k a week basic plus a starting league bonus of say £75k a game and £100k a goal and maybe a win bonus.

if he plays 30 games and scores 10 goals that's a total payment of over £7m for the year.

If that is not enough for him, it's a thank you and goodbye from me.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 May 23 5.25pm

Originally posted by palace99

In terms of the package i would make it very 'add on' heavy.

So to get say £150k a week i'd offer £75k a week basic plus a starting league bonus of say £75k a game and £100k a goal and maybe a win bonus.

That's a recipe for disaster as he would never pass the ball to a team mate and risk losing £100,000 and he would prefer to try for goal himself even if someone else is better placed.

Anyway why would he accept such a package when other teams are likely to offer more with the prospect of European football thrown in

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 16 May 23 11.29pm

Maybe a wishful thinking but i think if Zaha leaves, that seems to be lose-lose situation.

For Zaha, i do not predict he will get any offer more than his current salary from a European spot team and even if that happens, he may be mostly sidelined.

For Palace, Zaha is still a power and game changer. We may smell relegation battle again and he will be important asset and also can move us to higher spot if 6-week mindset continues.

I would keep him for the same salary for 2+1 kind of contract and add-on such as FA Cup final, top-10 type of stuff. If he won’t be happy with this or he really has a good option outside, nothing to do. Long term 200k/week is high odd bet.

Edited by blackheatheagle (16 May 2023 11.32pm)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 17 May 23 6.22am

Time to wave goodbye.

Hasn't been very good for a while now.
Massive wages.
Makes it all about himself.
Injury prone.
Unfortunately no other top 6 club will play him regularly.

Could be a limp end to a decent career for our Wilf. Probably somewhere like Monaco is his best bet.

 

TrickyboyVn Flag Ho Chi Minh City 17 May 23 6.38am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I would cap any contract offer for Wilf to one year and £100k/wk absolute max.
I would try it at £80k/wk to kick off.

Pretty much spot on but definitely try the 80k first.
Time to clear some past favorites and build up the future ones.

Thanks Wilf ...

 

taylors lovechild Flag 17 May 23 7.21am

Wilf isn't going to accept less that his current deal. He needs a rest to fully recover as I think he's tried to come back too soon a couple of times this season. Personally I think he'll end up at Arsenal. They're (apparently) going to be paying Saka 300k per week for his new deal and need a stronger squad for the CL, so a two-year deal of 150k per week would likely be no problem for them. They get a proven PL player who is a fan of the club and who has a strong will to win and high work ethic, no fee and I would imagine straightforward negotiations. He's better than Nelson and can play across the front line. With Arsenal likely to play 50+ games across all the competitions he may not start regularly but he'd probably still play 20+ games and I think he would be a very tidy player for them as he is still strong and powerful.

I really can't see him staying and the only thing I hope is that he says his goodbyes when we play Forest and we are clear that we are now moving on for better or worse. He is the most important player we've had in the past 30 years and whatever people's views are of him now he has had a massive hand in our longest run in the top flight (and getting here in the first place of course!)

 

becky Flag over the moon 17 May 23 9.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's a recipe for disaster as he would never pass the ball to a team mate and risk losing £100,000 and he would prefer to try for goal himself even if someone else is better placed.

Anyway why would he accept such a package when other teams are likely to offer more with the prospect of European football thrown in


We don't seem to have been seeing queues round the block for him so far, even at the peak of his prowess, and with these injuries seeming to show that his career is beginning to take it's toll on his body, I doubt there will be.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

palace99 Flag New Mills 17 May 23 9.49am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's a recipe for disaster as he would never pass the ball to a team mate and risk losing £100,000 and he would prefer to try for goal himself even if someone else is better placed.

Anyway why would he accept such a package when other teams are likely to offer more with the prospect of European football thrown in

Have you seen how contracts work? This is an extreme example but many players have goals scored bonuses. Vinny Jones had £5k 25 years ago so god knows that the amounts are now. Again 25 odd years ago McGoldrick earned an extra £100k for scoring 10 goals one season with us.
There will be players in the Prem today on massive goal bonuses - if you think not you are very naive

 

eaglesdare Flag 17 May 23 11.18am

200k a week on a 4 year deal offered.

A replacement will be 30-40 million on 120k plus a week.

I think it's a good deal for all parties.

 

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 17 May 23 11.30am

Let Zaha go he is getting older and more injurys, always looks miserable and never scores a lot off goals, build new team without Zaha

 

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 17 May 23 11.32am

Originally posted by Far away fan

Let Zaha go he is getting older and more injurys, always looks miserable and never scores a lot off goals, build new team without Zaha

200k a week a joke

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 May 23 11.46am

Originally posted by palace99


There will be players in the Prem today on massive goal bonuses - if you think not you are very naive

Are you saying that my comment was wrong and that with a hefty goal bonus at stake Zaha would be a good team player and pass the ball to anyone in a better position to score.

if you do then you are very naive

 

Page 2 of 57 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha