You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone Release Clause
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sam Johnstone Release Clause


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
becky Flag over the moon 22 Jun 23 6.43am

Originally posted by doombear

Maybe I'm a bit thick but I'm never clear on which of the two parties would insist on a release clause in a contract.

For example,

If a player coming to a club like Palace but wanting to have the option of going to a bigger club if an approach were to come might they insist on one so that if a bid came in from one of the Big 6 meeting that sum, they can be off?

On the other hand, a club might be scared stiff of losing a player so that in return for giving that player a nice fat pay rise they insist on a mega release clause so as to fend off bids, but if another club was desperate enough to trigger the release - more fool them (think Chelsea, Fernandes and Benfica)

So, do we think Johnstone asked for the release clause or Palace?

Don't know who asked for it, but it would, to me, make sense for the keeper to want one.

Generally, (as I think with Johnstone) they are one of 3+ keepers on the books with no option of playing elsewhere, unlike an outfield player who can be called on to cover another position.

This means they could (and I think Palace have had keepers that did) spend their whole time with a club pushing to even get a reserve team game, let alone a 1st team team one, so it would make more sense for them to be able to 'get out' if an offer came to get actual match time else where.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Jun 23 7.55am

Originally posted by becky

Don't know who asked for it, but it would, to me, make sense for the keeper to want one.

Generally, (as I think with Johnstone) they are one of 3+ keepers on the books with no option of playing elsewhere, unlike an outfield player who can be called on to cover another position.

This means they could (and I think Palace have had keepers that did) spend their whole time with a club pushing to even get a reserve team game, let alone a 1st team team one, so it would make more sense for them to be able to 'get out' if an offer came to get actual match time else where.


Thanks Becky. That makes sense.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 22 Jun 23 10.32am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It has always been one of life's great mysteries to me as to why any ambitious footballer would want to join Everton.

If I were Parish, I'd write up a new contract for Johnson before he gets lured by a club that might actually win something.

[Link]

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 22 Jun 23 11.08am

Originally posted by doombear

Maybe I'm a bit thick but I'm never clear on which of the two parties would insist on a release clause in a contract.

For example,

If a player coming to a club like Palace but wanting to have the option of going to a bigger club if an approach were to come might they insist on one so that if a bid came in from one of the Big 6 meeting that sum, they can be off?

On the other hand, a club might be scared stiff of losing a player so that in return for giving that player a nice fat pay rise they insist on a mega release clause so as to fend off bids, but if another club was desperate enough to trigger the release - more fool them (think Chelsea, Fernandes and Benfica)

So, do we think Johnstone asked for the release clause or Palace?

Really deepens on the size of hte release clause.

In this case it will be of Johnstons doing. Its pretty modest, and so gives him a reasonably low get out if either big club comes or an another prem club.

Harland also had a clause that became active after something like 2 seasons as Dortmund. Essentially I'll commit to you for 2 years, but I'm not going to give you the power to hold other suiters to ransom. The talk is that he has the same at City.

IF Kane had done the same he would have had his move by now.

The Villa chairman spoke about it quite a lot when City triggered Grealish's. They put it in at 100m to be fair to all sides. If Jack was performing at an incredibly high level there was always an option to buy, but Villa were protected as it would be the highest ever fee for a British player. And it made it easy to be clear on their stance....trigger the cause or don't bid.

The silly ones that Barca and co put in, I'm not sure. More for the headlines? Because in reality they can sell for whatever they want.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Jun 23 12.07pm

The release clause will definitely be due to Johnstone's side - probably his agent suggesting or insisting on it.

Johnstone clearly ran down his contract to get a big pay rise, but also wants 1st team football.

With 2 decent goalies already at Palace this was never guaranteed.

So agree to the move but ensure there is a get out,if required. The amount seems fair for both sides.

Don't forget WBA played hardball the previous summer when they received a few bids for Johnstone, and i suspect he was keen on a move then back to the Prem.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 22 Jun 23 12.27pm

A release clause is never advantageous to a club.

The only reason to have one is to be a more attractive move for a player.

Therefore the pressure for release clauses, whether they are proposed as an idea by the club or the player's side, ultimately emanates from the player's side.

A billion pound release clause is still less advantageous to the selling club than a theoretically infinite price that it could insist upon if it chose to.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jun 23 12.29pm

In my opinion, Johnstone played a large part in our improvement. I don't like to complain about Guaita - great servant, but feel Johnstone did better. He seemed to improve the whole team. I know he made the one big mistake but De Gea made a few and he's still a good keeper. I'd pick Johnstone over Guaita personally.

 


Red and Blue Army!

VinceHilaire Flag London 22 Jun 23 1.08pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

In my opinion, Johnstone played a large part in our improvement. I don't like to complain about Guaita - great servant, but feel Johnstone did better. He seemed to improve the whole team. I know he made the one big mistake but De Gea made a few and he's still a good keeper. I'd pick Johnstone over Guaita personally.

Agreed - funny enough, Johnstone reminds me of Nigel Martyn. He was an outstanding goalkeeper for us.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jun 23 1.30pm

Originally posted by VinceHilaire

Agreed - funny enough, Johnstone reminds me of Nigel Martyn. He was an outstanding goalkeeper for us.

I hadn't thought about Martyn but the main thing I prefer about Johnstone is that he seems more composed, and seems to command his area, better than Guaita. We've never really been too bad with goalies - even our worst were largely acceptable, and would have a decent point if they blamed it on who was in front of them.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Jun 23 1.33pm

Agree on Johnstone.

Not for me to say and quite easily an awful, subjective view on things but I think even beyond his goalkeeping abilities he looks to have inspired confidence at the back and in the team.

I love Vinnie, I really do, but he is a stay at home, non-vocal, shot-stopping goalkeeper who lacks a commanding presence, particularly in aerial scenarios.

The defence looks more settled for me with Johnstone behind them.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 22 Jun 23 1.41pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Agree on Johnstone.

Not for me to say and quite easily an awful, subjective view on things but I think even beyond his goalkeeping abilities he looks to have inspired confidence at the back and in the team.

I love Vinnie, I really do, but he is a stay at home, non-vocal, shot-stopping goalkeeper who lacks a commanding presence, particularly in aerial scenarios.

The defence looks more settled for me with Johnstone behind them.

Johnstone had far weaker opponents than Vinny faced.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Jun 23 1.58pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Johnstone had far weaker opponents than Vinny faced.

Agreed , Johnson had a torrid first half at Leeds, did well , most other games it was standard stuff. Haven’t seen him with a top side having him busy all afternoon..
He appears competent , but better than Vinnie is not based on to much yet.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Jun 23 2.27pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Johnstone had far weaker opponents than Vinny faced.

Guaita has played near on 150 games for us and Johnstone around 10 so I'm not sure what that statement achieves?

VG may well be a better 'shot-stopper' than Johnstone, that's debatable however very possible, but I'd argue immediately SJ looked more confident (presence), comfortable in the air and better with his feet than Guaita has over the long course of time he's been between our sticks.

Quality of opponent, manager of course and even players in front of them may well factor into considerations, and I did insist it was only my personal opinion, however for me Johnstone looks more suited to our current identity if not just an improvement. Does not detract from my adoration, gratitude and respect for VG nonetheless.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Jun 23 3.18pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Guaita has played near on 150 games for us and Johnstone around 10 so I'm not sure what that statement achieves?

VG may well be a better 'shot-stopper' than Johnstone, that's debatable however very possible, but I'd argue immediately SJ looked more confident (presence), comfortable in the air and better with his feet than Guaita has over the long course of time he's been between our sticks.

Quality of opponent, manager of course and even players in front of them may well factor into considerations, and I did insist it was only my personal opinion, however for me Johnstone looks more suited to our current identity if not just an improvement. Does not detract from my adoration, gratitude and respect for VG nonetheless.

It is all just opinion. But how lucky are we to choose between what now appears to be two very decent keepers. Both free transfers , Dougie Parish Pat on back?

Edited by Putitout (22 Jun 2023 3.22pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Jun 23 3.33pm

Originally posted by Putitout

It is all just opinion. But how lucky are we to choose between what now appears to be two very decent keepers. Both free transfers , Dougie Parish Pat on back?

Edited by Putitout (22 Jun 2023 3.22pm)

Absolutely, agree 100%.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jun 23 3.45pm

Originally posted by becky

Don't know who asked for it, but it would, to me, make sense for the keeper to want one.

Generally, (as I think with Johnstone) they are one of 3+ keepers on the books with no option of playing elsewhere, unlike an outfield player who can be called on to cover another position.

This means they could (and I think Palace have had keepers that did) spend their whole time with a club pushing to even get a reserve team game, let alone a 1st team team one, so it would make more sense for them to be able to 'get out' if an offer came to get actual match time else where.

Plus the fact, as he was on a free and had, in the not too distant past, been in the England squad, I suspect he would have upper hand in negotiations

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jun 23 4.10pm

We have to keep the likes of Johnstone if we are to sustain or improve our status.

He is the future.

We have sold Wan Bissaka which was disappointing, but the club has no need to sell unless deemed necessary in order to better spend the money elsewhere.

We should sell when we want to sell.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Jun 23 6.56pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

A release clause is never advantageous to a club.

The only reason to have one is to be a more attractive move for a player.

Therefore the pressure for release clauses, whether they are proposed as an idea by the club or the player's side, ultimately emanates from the player's side.

A billion pound release clause is still less advantageous to the selling club than a theoretically infinite price that it could insist upon if it chose to.

As he was a free transfer having a release clause of £10m is advantageous to us. It stops him pushing for a move to get higher wages elsewhere, but at a smaller transfer fee, say £4mm

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jun 23 7.01pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

We have to keep the likes of Johnstone if we are to sustain or improve our status.

He is the future.

We have sold Wan Bissaka which was disappointing, but the club has no need to sell unless deemed necessary in order to better spend the money elsewhere.

We should sell when we want to sell.

Completely agree, there's a few years of Johnstone yet. Could be England's no. 1.

 


Red and Blue Army!

esox lucius Flag Deal 22 Jun 23 10.05pm

Firstly Everton have got to sell Pickford for any realistic chance of Johnstone going there. Johnstone has only recently become a number one keeper, I can’t imagine he wants to take a step back and start warming the bench again as Pickford’s understudy.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone Release Clause