You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman


Page 2 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 26 Jan 24 4.02pm

Our best recruitment was with Vieira. Doogie was one of those players like Danny Graham and Chung Yong Lee who look great in the second tier but get found out in the top tier, and he tends to pick players like that (Rakip, Sorloth, Hughes) - his overall record is mixed (Meyer!!!), more good than bad but nothing special - I think he did a better job as manager here than Sporting Director - Hodgson hasn't always been immediately on board with some of Doofie's signings and his diffidence has generally been vindicated.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Jan 24 4.59pm

I think DF is a good judge of a player.

If you look at what could be classified as his failures, they were largely low risk. Players like Banks, Plange, O'Brien, Rakip, Jach and others - bought cheap and if they made it, great. If they didn't, well try to get a fee for them and move on.

I think critisising Dougie for signing Meyer is totally unfair. Meyer came with a decent reputation and was hailed as something of a marquee signing at the time. His failure to live up to the hype was not down to Freedman.

Saying he was better as a manager...did he not recruit Jedinak and Bolasie as manager ?

Freedman has had to work within a tight budget. He's also not had the luxury of any meaningful incoming funds as we have hung onto our assets.

Overall, I think he's doing a good job.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Jan 24 5.16pm

There seems to be a significant discord between Freedman, Hodgson and Parish. Maybe Im wrong, but on our lack of funds surely it is crucial that every penny spent is going to directly enhance the first team, not be used to fund some sort of future hope signings that we seem to be seeing more and more of who hardly ever get on the pitch.

 

stevo Flag Reigate 27 Jan 24 10.42am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Freedman was made DOF on august 21st 2017, Sakho was signed 6 days later, so since then we have signed:
Sorloth 14m, Kouyate 8m, Sako 0, Guaita 0, Meyer 0, McCarthy 3m, Ayew 2.2m, Cahill 0, Eze 16m, Butland 1.1m, Ferguson 0, Clyne 0, Guehi 19m, Andersen 17m, Edouard 15m, Mateta 10m, Olise 8m, Hughes 6m, Plange 1m, Doucoure 21m, Ebowei 0, Johnstone 0, Richards 10m, Franca 17m, Lerma 0, Hendersen 18m, Holding 1.2m

In my opinion, overall an excellent selection of signings, I personally hold Freeman in the highest esteem as a Player, Manager and DOF for Crystal Palace

All figures supplied by transfermk

I was clearly referring to the strikers he’s signed with him being an ex striker. It’s weird who he’s brought in, in regards to strikers he’s been a massive failure since promotion.

How many more duffers will he bring in in the position he should have the most knowledge of??

Edited by stevo (27 Jan 2024 10.45am)

 


Slowly slowly catchy monkey

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Jan 24 1.52pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Our best recruitment was with Vieira. Doogie was one of those players like Danny Graham and Chung Yong Lee who look great in the second tier but get found out in the top tier, and he tends to pick players like that (Rakip, Sorloth, Hughes) - his overall record is mixed (Meyer!!!), more good than bad but nothing special - I think he did a better job as manager here than Sporting Director - Hodgson hasn't always been immediately on board with some of Doofie's signings and his diffidence has generally been vindicated.

I would have signed Meyer. Not now, in retrospect, but at the time. Looked a gift given his youth international pedigree. Didn't work sadly.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Jan 24 2.01pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I would have signed Meyer. Not now, in retrospect, but at the time. Looked a gift given his youth international pedigree. Didn't work sadly.

True, we nearly all had high hopes for him. I noticed Campana (sorry about the accent thing) ended up very good. Don't think that was Freedman but can't remember. Interesting contrast. Of the two, you'd think the one that would have worked out is Meyer. I believe Meyer plays quite low down these days whereas Campana made a bit of a decent career for himself with a few international call ups later on. I guess all signings are a bit of an unknown - there's no one who's only signed good players. I think even Brighton have signed a couple of duffers. And Chelsea and Man U spring to mind.

 


Red and Blue Army!

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Jan 24 2.54pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

True, we nearly all had high hopes for him. I noticed Campana (sorry about the accent thing) ended up very good. Don't think that was Freedman but can't remember. Interesting contrast. Of the two, you'd think the one that would have worked out is Meyer. I believe Meyer plays quite low down these days whereas Campana made a bit of a decent career for himself with a few international call ups later on. I guess all signings are a bit of an unknown - there's no one who's only signed good players. I think even Brighton have signed a couple of duffers. And Chelsea and Man U spring to mind.

Momeyballs favours a set team and continuity. The latter teams you mention have never learned that but opt for throwing endless eye watering levels of cash at the squad. Constant rotation and poor results. Man City and Liverpool keep a more set team and only tinker (albeit when they buy £££). The outcome is as seen.

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 27 Jan 24 3.14pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Momeyballs favours a set team and continuity. The latter teams you mention have never learned that but opt for throwing endless eye watering levels of cash at the squad. Constant rotation and poor results. Man City and Liverpool keep a more set team and only tinker (albeit when they buy £££). The outcome is as seen.

Meyer is gradually rebuilding his career after a couple of years in the wilderness. Still only 28 he was Lucerne’s top scorer last year and the highest scoring midfielder in Switzerland. Roy did not want him so only played him occasionally and usually as a sub in a defensive left sided midfield role when the team was losing. Sounds familiar? Roy’s regular tactic to prove to SP and DF that a player hid did not approve of is c**p. He didn’t succeed with Sorloth but is trying it again with Mateta, Ahamada etc.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Mar 24 11.14am

It’s being reported today that Manchester United that Manchester United will make an official approach this week for Freedman.
This would be in addition to their recruitment of Dan Ashworth.
If Freedman does go it will be interesting to see who replaces him.
He really runs the football side of things at the club.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Mar 24 11.21am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Freedman to Utd?' by becky

This was mentioned last week but has exploded today on an awful lot of click-bait sites. Sir JR/Ineos want Dougie to be head of recruitment at Utd & according to reports PDQ. Will Dougie jump ship again, how long is there on his contract? Thoughts? [Link]

Sorry, just seen there is another thread on this subject, that'll teach me not to look properly. Mods please delete or merge.

Edited by eagleman13 (05 Mar 2024 11.23am)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 05 Mar 24 11.35am

Originally posted by PatrickA

It’s being reported today that Manchester United that Manchester United will make an official approach this week for Freedman.
This would be in addition to their recruitment of Dan Ashworth.
If Freedman does go it will be interesting to see who replaces him.
He really runs the football side of things at the club.

Can’t really blame him if he goes. It’s hard to turn down a gig at Man Utd. He’s had a tough time at Palace recruiting player that Roy never used and rarely seeing his efforts come to fruition and even worse, leave and do well elsewhere. Sorloth is a prime example. Rarely played for us and never looked like a striker but scoring goals for fun before he came and since he left.

Dougie has struggled to win over the fans who remember how he deserted us as a manager but for me he has done well. We have an academy filled with promising youngsters and by all accounts he played a huge part in persuading Glasner to come to us. Given Glasner’s history of falling out with owners over recruitment his apparent good relationship with Dougie is important. I hope he sees the opportunity to finally see his efforts bear fruit with a coaching team who he can work closely with to build an exciting young team.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Mar 24 11.38am

Originally posted by PatrickA

It’s being reported today that Manchester United that Manchester United will make an official approach this week for Freedman.
This would be in addition to their recruitment of Dan Ashworth.
If Freedman does go it will be interesting to see who replaces him.
He really runs the football side of things at the club.

I think it would be a massive loss for the club, lets hope Glasner knows someone, because i fear it could be Mark Bright, disaster.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

gmostone Flag 05 Mar 24 12.41pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Freedman to Utd?' by becky

Maybe his family are under threat again…

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 Mar 24 12.48pm

I'm not surprised that Dougie's work is again under the spotlight at Man U. He's done a brilliant job for us with the limited funds at his disposal.

We all know that money talks, but I for one hope he would prefer to be part of our re-structuring. Ollie has certainly said positive things about him in his first few weeks with us.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Mar 24 12.53pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think it would be a massive loss for the club, lets hope Glasner knows someone, because i fear it could be Mark Bright, disaster.

If you want to be scared: Roy.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Mar 24 12.57pm

I refuse to believe that there is any truth in this.

I still stand by the fact that apart from Franca, DF hasn't signed anyone that wasn't already pretty well know.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 05 Mar 24 1.06pm

If Dougie goes to Man U do you think there is a chance he might target Edouard as his first big name transfer?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Mar 24 1.10pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

If Dougie goes to Man U do you think there is a chance he might target Edouard as his first big name transfer?

Undercover agent, I like it!

Watching Rashford and others shuffle around the pitch with disinterest for them, I don't think Edouard would be too out of place there actually!

Edited by Nicholas91 (05 Mar 2024 1.10pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Mar 24 1.12pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I refuse to believe that there is any truth in this.

I still stand by the fact that apart from Franca, DF hasn't signed anyone that wasn't already pretty well know.


And yet, none of the bigger clubs (or our rivals) went for Olise, Eze, Doucoure, Guehi, Andersen, so what stopped these other clubs from signing these players?

If rumours are true, Wharton chose us ahead of Chelsea because of the young talent we'd previously brought in and successfully used.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Mar 24 2.01pm

Originally posted by doombear


And yet, none of the bigger clubs (or our rivals) went for Olise, Eze, Doucoure, Guehi, Andersen, so what stopped these other clubs from signing these players?

If rumours are true, Wharton chose us ahead of Chelsea because of the young talent we'd previously brought in and successfully used.

The arguments why are there from both buying club and player perspectives.

1) Why take a risk when you have the money to buy a complete player who can fit straight into the first team.
2) Why buy a player who is one level down in ability from what you currently have? Doucoure was a solid defensive midfielder who we did well to identify. Andersen had a great season at Fulham but before that he was pretty average and on a par with numerous other centre half’s.
3) There is of course a maximum number of players you can have. In Guehi’s case everyone (fans included) could see he was an excellent player however Chelsea had no room for him. You could see Chalobah moving on for the same reason.
4) Why go to a club when you’re likely to finish out on loan at some obscure club and disappear into the ether. You can bet your life this is Dougies big selling point whenever he speaks to players. Come and play for us or sit on the bench at a club that might win a trophy.
5) on many occasions career progression goes better starting at a smaller club and building a reputation. Zaha couldn’t make the step up, who is to say Wharton would. It goes back to the point that when you have billions to spend why take risks (unless of course you are Todd Bohely who buys anyone who scores two games on the spin).
6) Eze and Olise both won awards for best player etc etc and were tipped for bright futures. I think we quite simply took the chance of paying fairly substantial fees (for us) and trusting they would come good (which they have). All the top teams will be interested in them now we have turned them into seasoned top tier players.

Dougie has done ok, but I agree with the OP on the centre forward position. It’s the ones that got away that irritate the most. We could have signed Mitrovic, Watkins and Toney and at the time we were connected to them with more than a passing interest and yet they transferred elsewhere for small sums (by centre forward standards anyway).Bamford, Batshuayi, Sorloth, Edouard and Mateta tick the just about PL standard box, but literally only just and in a league that has at any time say 40 plus centre forwards all of ours since Murray would have appeared in the lower mid to bottom quartile performance wise (except perhaps Benteke’s first season for us).

It will be interesting to see how effective Mateta is under Glasner, I think Edouard doesn’t have the determination to make it at this level. I would guess he might be moved on in the summer.

 

Page 2 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman