This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
With his 5 PL appearances? He's in a squad with players like Harvey Elliot, Noni Madueke & Rico Lewis - Wharton has got one of the least impressive CVs of the entire squad, never mind being miles above the standard. He didn't even make the squad initially, he was in the U20s... he only got moved up to U21 because Mainoo was bumped up to the seniors! I think Wharton is a superb prospect, but he's exactly where he should be with U21 national team. He's integral to our team. Chelsea and Man Utd have cover, we don't. He has only five appearances because that's how long he's been here. The reason is, he gets injured for the U21s, like Olise did for France U21s and we're playing Hughes. I'm frankly surprised that anyone buys into this rubbish. No one watches the U21s. We can't afford to get relegated because we think U21s is important - which no one else other than propaganda nen for the FA are going to say.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
He's integral to our team. Chelsea and Man Utd have cover, we don't. He has only five appearances because that's how long he's been here. The reason is, he gets injured for the U21s, like Olise did for France U21s and we're playing Hughes. I'm frankly surprised that anyone buys into this rubbish. No one watches the U21s. We can't afford to get relegated because we think U21s is important - which no one else other than propaganda nen for the FA are going to say. We've had a fair number of players get injured training, it doesn't just happen during games or international duty. He is more likely to progress with the England setup if he plays for the U21 and that will only increase his value
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
We've had a fair number of players get injured training, it doesn't just happen during games or international duty. He is more likely to progress with the England setup if he plays for the U21 and that will only increase his value Exacly this. I'd expect Wharton will be excited, and will help cement that coming to us was good for progression. Would he have got called up if Chelsea had bought him and loaned him back? This (hopefully) will be Henderson's last tournament with England. England need another DCM. Another 6 months of PL experience and some England U21's and I reckon that spot will be his
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
He's integral to our team. Chelsea and Man Utd have cover, we don't. He has only five appearances because that's how long he's been here. The reason is, he gets injured for the U21s, like Olise did for France U21s and we're playing Hughes. I'm frankly surprised that anyone buys into this rubbish. No one watches the U21s. We can't afford to get relegated because we think U21s is important - which no one else other than propaganda nen for the FA are going to say. I mentioned those other players in response to your suggestion that Wharton is miles above that standard, which he clearly isn't. We're not going to get relegated because Wharton plays a game for the U21s. That you don't watch it or find it important doesn't mean that's true of everyone else. I'd also imagine it's a source of pride for Wharton himself, and if we as his club were to prevent him from playing, I can't imagine that would be a very popular decision... neither with Wharton himself nor with other talented kids who might be considering joining us in the future.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I mentioned those other players in response to your suggestion that Wharton is miles above that standard, which he clearly isn't. We're not going to get relegated because Wharton plays a game for the U21s. That you don't watch it or find it important doesn't mean that's true of everyone else. I'd also imagine it's a source of pride for Wharton himself, and if we as his club were to prevent him from playing, I can't imagine that would be a very popular decision... neither with Wharton himself nor with other talented kids who might be considering joining us in the future. It's still missing the point that in our position, at this stage of the season, we can't afford an injury to him in a needless U21S game. It's just the reality of where we are. If he's in a team with a much bigger squad then fair enough. He's in our first eleven - not underage, or coming on as a sub. And our cover for him is not at a similar standard, or anywhere near.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
It's still missing the point that in our position, at this stage of the season, we can't afford an injury to him in a needless U21S game. It's just the reality of where we are. If he's in a team with a much bigger squad then fair enough. He's in our first eleven - not underage, or coming on as a sub. And our cover for him is not at a similar standard, or anywhere near. I don't know if it is - you can get us at 30/1 to go down now... it's really rather unlikely at this stage. Even if it were, we won't get anywhere dictating to talented players whether they're allowed to represent their country - I think that's quite clearly a bad idea.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don't know if it is - you can get us at 30/1 to go down now... it's really rather unlikely at this stage. Even if it were, we won't get anywhere dictating to talented players whether they're allowed to represent their country - I think that's quite clearly a bad idea. Totally agree. It’s a pretty negative selling point to a future signing - if you’re good enough to represent your country well forget it as we won’t let you play.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DenTyler
Is it just me or does anybody else find it madness that they shoe horn in international friendlies just as teams are in the meat of the season. Half the players are fighting for titles or champions league and some fighting for there league survival. We’ve now likely lost our best keeper. Genius. You couldn’t make this s*** up Why not play qualifiers at the end of a season when there is no tournament, like a mini qualifying tournament. We would all be interested then. The season could finish earlier as we wouldn’t have to stop in sept, oct, nov and march for pointless games. Meaning players would actually get a break before back to training pre season. Total waste of time. They may as well have finished the season 2 weeks earlier and then they could play some meaningful warm up games before the euros
|
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
Totally agree. It’s a pretty negative selling point to a future signing - if you’re good enough to represent your country well forget it as we won’t let you play. It's one or two matches whilst our squad is depleted and we need all hands on deck. It's not a policy that I'm asking us to take up in future. In this case, club comes first. As it clearly has for many of the players in teams above us for even the full England squad - let alone U21s.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Been saying this for a while. 3 or 4 breaks before Christmas completely mucking up the domestic season. They don't have to reduce the games just reduce the breaks. Let them have time off around Jan and Feb to coincide with AFCON. Yep ,with players of all nationalities playing all over the world the international calendar needs to be the same for everyone . Would make complete sense to have a winter break from league matches to allow for all the international comps and then again in the summer .
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Back to the drawing board. The season stop-starts and the matches too. We would also like to know what version of the handball and off-side laws are current. The more they mess, the worse it is. You can be offside when the ball is played and score - you're not interfering with play. Hand ball is for when a big team is going to need a penalty.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Munoz off injured
|
|
|
Im watching the Wales game but have just seen the goals from the England game at HT . Pickford being Pickford again , how many chances is this idiot going to get ?
|
|
|
Munoz suspected hamstring injury so I understand. How many more of these feckin injuries do we have to put up with?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Munoz off injured Right now he's probably the one player we don't want injured in our new system. Can you imagine Clyne filling in? If he played like Munoz he'd be dead by half-time. If Munoz is out I wonder if we might be better going back to 433, as Mitchell is not exactly excelling as a wingback.
|
|
|
Unbelievable that injuries have yet again come from International matches or training for them, Guehi, Olise, Johnstone, Munoz. What the hell is going on ?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.