You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Is it racist to....
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is it racist to....


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 28 Nov 02 3.55pm

If a black bloke is a c***, it's alright to call him a black c*** IMO. My mate Chris is a c***, he's also 19 stone, I often call him a fat c***.

There's no difference whatsoever, it really depends on the recipient of the abuse (ie. is he a mate), and how he takes it. In other words, if you don't know them don't risk upsetting them.

 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 28 Nov 02 4.06pm

I agree with both of you, MU played the race card to good effect and Simmons ended up with the lifetime ban not the thug who attacked him. I was very close to the incident and MS certainly wasn't the only person who mentioned the ****'s nationality to detrimental effect that night. Political correctness saved Cantona's career.

However that doesn't alter the fact that calling someone a 'black ****' or a 'welsh ****' CAN be interpreted by the target as being every bit as offensive as throwing a banana (or a leak) on the pitch. Whatever the situation those comments can be construed as racial abuse.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 28 Nov 02 4.32pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 12:49pm

...of Saxon origin...

F*ckin' Saxon w*nkers... hate 'em.

Oh... sorry Pete...


 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

scout Flag East Dorset 28 Nov 02 4.39pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 2:51pm

Quote Selhurst Stallion at 28 Nov 2002 2:22pm

To me a racist is someone who would go to a football match, make monkey noises and throw a bananas on the pitch or someone who would stand on a street corner tormenting a person from a different culture even to the point of beating them up not a moron who can't think before he speaks.


That's the whole point of my argument! The actions you describe are 'racial abuse', but by categorising it 'racism', in today's general conception of what 'racism' is, you place my harmless little old lady from Stepney in the same category as the bloke throwing the bananas onto the football pitch!
My point is that in today’s terms, you are a considered racist if you merely dislike a group of people due to personal experience or otherwise and that's my beef! To force people to accept that their point of view is evil and wrong, is nothing less than mind-control! It's a person's right to like or dislike whatever they feel in life, and furthermore I believe EVERYONE on this planet is 'racist' to one extent or another, it's a natural human instinct to dislike or distrust one group or another, but racial hatred and racial abuse are a whole different ball game!


Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 2:53pm)


Very interesting thread, Pete. As much as I wouuld like to say that we should all love our neighbour as ourselves, in reality that doesn't happen. As you mentioned the Welsh, DH was born and bred in Wales (Welsh mother/Scots father) and he would consider the 'sheep shagging' comments to be racial abuse, but it really doesn't bother him and he certainly doesn't see it as hatred, and the Welsh definitely give back as good as they get to the English!
I liked your points, SelhurstStallion, about colour of skin though. If, for example, an idiot wanted to shout abuse at Roy Keane, they would call him an 'Irish ****'; whereas the same idiot would automatically refer to Ince by his skin colour, not the fact that he was English. That's how I define the difference between racial abuse and hatred, anyway.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 4.56pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 28 Nov 2002 4:32pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 12:49pm

...of Saxon origin...

F*ckin' Saxon w*nkers... hate 'em.

Oh... sorry Pete...



Yeah, Saxons are pasty-faced, loud-mouthed yobs! But having said that, I've got one or two saxon friends and they're alright they are!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 5.07pm


Quote scout
for example, an idiot wanted to shout abuse at Roy Keane, they would call him an 'Irish ****'; whereas the same idiot would automatically refer to Ince by his skin colour, not the fact that he was English. That's how I define the difference between racial abuse and hatred, anyway.

Well he'd look pretty silly as an Englishman shouting out 'You, you... English C**t!'
If the target was Viera, I bet you a pound to a penny he'd shout 'You French C**t!'

Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 5:16pm)

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 28 Nov 02 5.38pm

To distill it still further, what about calling someone a scouse, brummie, geordie or whatever kind of t***? Or the pejorative 'pikey'?

It's not possible to legislate how people think; old attitudes die hard and society as a whole can only come to terms with what some people deem unacceptable over a period of time. This country, in fact, has a pretty good track record in assimilating immigrants such as the Hugenots, East European Jews, Italians, Poles etc. The difference nowadays is that much of the immigration is non-white and is therefore preceived to be more of a cultural threat. Some have argued that many actually don't want to integrate, be that because they feel persecuted unless they live in close proximity to each other or because they wish to preserve their own native culture as much as possible. In general, society's attitude towards non-white immigrants has improved immensely since the 1970's, when the 'send 'em back' brigade were assured of a far wider audience than they would be now. In 2002, such attitudes are far more likely to distance someone who holds such views from society at large. Times change, and attitudes change with them.

Using the word 'racist' as glibly a it is used nowadays holds its own dangers, though. The MacPherson Report, commissioned after the Stephen Lawrence case, actually stated that if someone thinks you're a racist, then you are. How illogical is that? It seems to imply that any reference you make to someone based upon their ethnicity, good or bad, is somehow discriminatory. How stupid is that? It did, however, make the point that the Police are 'institutionally racist' which is pretty likely but I'd prefer to think of them as institutionally stupid, which I'm sure anyone who's had any dealings with them will testify.

We're a long way from a perfect society, where race, colour and creed should be irrelevant in one's opinion of another but we have come on immensely over the last thirty years in terms of attitude and tolerance. Unfortunately, there will always be people who are stupid, there will always be moronic w*nkers and I'm afraid they will always come in all colours.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

scout Flag East Dorset 28 Nov 02 5.47pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 5:07pm


Quote scout
for example, an idiot wanted to shout abuse at Roy Keane, they would call him an 'Irish ****'; whereas the same idiot would automatically refer to Ince by his skin colour, not the fact that he was English. That's how I define the difference between racial abuse and hatred, anyway.

Well he'd look pretty silly as an Englishman shouting out 'You, you... English C**t!'
If the target was Viera, I bet you a pound to a penny he'd shout 'You French C**t!'

Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 5:16pm)


Thanks Pete. That's assuming I was referring to an English idiot.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 5.53pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 28 Nov 2002 5:38pm

To distill it still further, what about calling someone a scouse, brummie, geordie or whatever kind of t***? Or the pejorative 'pikey'?

It's not possible to legislate how people think; old attitudes die hard and society as a whole can only come to terms with what some people deem unacceptable over a period of time. This country, in fact, has a pretty good track record in assimilating immigrants such as the Hugenots, East European Jews, Italians, Poles etc. The difference nowadays is that much of the immigration is non-white and is therefore preceived to be more of a cultural threat. Some have argued that many actually don't want to integrate, be that because they feel persecuted unless they live in close proximity to each other or because they wish to preserve their own native culture as much as possible. In general, society's attitude towards non-white immigrants has improved immensely since the 1970's, when the 'send 'em back' brigade were assured of a far wider audience than they would be now. In 2002, such attitudes are far more likely to distance someone who holds such views from society at large. Times change, and attitudes change with them.

Using the word 'racist' as glibly a it is used nowadays holds its own dangers, though. The MacPherson Report, commissioned after the Stephen Lawrence case, actually stated that if someone thinks you're a racist, then you are. How illogical is that? It seems to imply that any reference you make to someone based upon their ethnicity, good or bad, is somehow discriminatory. How stupid is that? It did, however, make the point that the Police are 'institutionally racist' which is pretty likely but I'd prefer to think of them as institutionally stupid, which I'm sure anyone who's had any dealings with them will testify.

We're a long way from a perfect society, where race, colour and creed should be irrelevant in one's opinion of another but we have come on immensely over the last thirty years in terms of attitude and tolerance. Unfortunately, there will always be people who are stupid, there will always be moronic w*nkers and I'm afraid they will always come in all colours.

Extremely good post, Although I don't see race and creed as being irrelevant at all, I don't want to be part of a coffee-coloured world of similar thinking automatons, I want to live in a world were different races and cultures thrive and enrich the world we live in.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 5.59pm

Quote scout at 28 Nov 2002 5:47pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 5:07pm


Quote scout
for example, an idiot wanted to shout abuse at Roy Keane, they would call him an 'Irish ****'; whereas the same idiot would automatically refer to Ince by his skin colour, not the fact that he was English. That's how I define the difference between racial abuse and hatred, anyway.

Well he'd look pretty silly as an Englishman shouting out 'You, you... English C**t!'
If the target was Viera, I bet you a pound to a penny he'd shout 'You French C**t!'

Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 5:16pm)


Thanks Pete. That's assuming I was referring to an English idiot.

You were scout me ole mucker, you were talking about Paul Ince, who's English, and an idiot.

Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 6:01pm)

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

scout Flag East Dorset 28 Nov 02 6.16pm

Pete, if you read my post again, I was referring to the idiot throwing the abuse, not Ince.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 6.34pm

Quote scout at 28 Nov 2002 6:16pm

Pete, if you read my post again, I was referring to the idiot throwing the abuse, not Ince.

Yeah I know Scout, I was jesting. I get your point though, I did initially jump to the wrong conclusion.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 28 Nov 02 6.35pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 28 Nov 2002 5:38pm

We're a long way from a perfect society, where race, colour and creed should be irrelevant in one's opinion of another but we have come on immensely over the last thirty years in terms of attitude and tolerance.


The 'perfect society' will never ever happen, it's not in our nature as a species to all get along.

By 'attitude and tolerance having come on immensely' I assume you are referring to the fact that due to political correctness being thrust upon us by the media over the last 30 years those opinions aren't voiced publicly any more. I don't believe that peoples attitudes have changed at all since the 70s, it's been suppressed but it's still there and currently growing due to the immigration system.

 

scout Flag East Dorset 28 Nov 02 6.43pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 6:34pm

Quote scout at 28 Nov 2002 6:16pm

Pete, if you read my post again, I was referring to the idiot throwing the abuse, not Ince.

Yeah I know Scout, I was jesting. I get your point though, I did initially jump to the wrong conclusion.


Tut!

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 28 Nov 02 7.01pm

end of the day, i i called you an f***ing stupid aussie, that would be racist. if not it would still be offending to another so that is just as bad.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Hazzacpfc Flag London 28 Nov 02 9.28pm

Mostly very good points here.

The main thing that sticks in my mind is that if someone abused a white player it would be about his country, or if he's English it would be "you northern/southern/etc", yet if someone shouted abuse at a black player it would be about his colour. That's more ignorant than anything.

I've never shouted at a black player and said "you black this or you black that", but I did call Mr Diving Roberts a Welsh tw*t a few times, which is just as bad.

I also have a dislike for the French and the Germans, on the grounds that they're all arrogant a*sholes; which isn't true. It's just the vast majority . Does that make me a racist? It all depends on your point of view.

The term racism at the moment covers everything from frothing at the mouth insanity, to HMHS's little old lady, to friendly football banter (or unfriendly in the case of Roberts). The situation is just ridiculous.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 29 Nov 02 9.27am

While this has been a pretty interesting thread, the one thing that has disappointed me is that there's been no counter-argument. As I see it, there's three camps on this battlefield. There's the camp that I'm in, which is people that are basically right wing (I'm not talking 'extreme' right-wing here) who believe it's time to stand up for England and the down-trodden English. There's the opposite camp of basically left-wing people and people of non-British decent that feel that the wishes and concerns of England's native populace is less important than the wishes and concerns of immigrant’s and minority groups and then there's the camp which is the middle ground. As I see it we've had one or two from my camp contribute to this thread, plenty from the middle ground and as I see it, only HMHS has had the balls to contribute to this argument from his camp, which is a sad state of affairs! This hasn't been a slanging match, it's been an orderly discussion, so where's the likes of Bexter now? Where's Cider-Eagle! If i'm the prosecution, where's the defence? I want to hear their take on all this.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

j2j007 Flag in a house, on top of a hill 29 Nov 02 11.32am

After reading all of this thread here are my views..... I think this country is being over populated with too many immigrants who see this country as an easy way to make money and not have to lift a finger, but does this make me a racist, or am I just one of millions who see the big picture and are worried for my children's future and England losing its own identity. I have black, Asian and Greek friends but that doesn't not stop my feeling animosity towards a group a black teenagers who I know are just out to cause trouble cause they know if anyone touches them they can just throw the racist card at them !

If I was out with my mates and we had an argument with a group of Black or Asian kids and one of them got a kicking it would be a racist attack even if no racist words were exchanged, if it was the other way around and I got a kicking it would be serious assault !!!!!

What does annoy me is when people call me a racist, im not a racist im just proud to be English- and it seems to me that this is a wrong thing to be in this day and age, proud of were you come from !!!!

I have a South African flag because my Fiance is South African and everytime I see it it reminds me how lucky I am to have found her !!!!
(a bit girly I know)

Edited by j2j007 (29 Nov 2002 11:37am)

 


I never laughed at Clowns when I was younger however in adulthood its a different story.............. Who's laughing now !!!!!

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 29 Nov 02 12.06pm

Quote j2j007 at 29 Nov 2002 11:32am

After reading all of this thread here are my views..... I think this country is being over populated with too many immigrants who see this country as an easy way to make money and not have to lift a finger, but does this make me a racist, or am I just one of millions who see the big picture and are worried for my children's future and England losing its own identity. I have black, Asian and Greek friends but that doesn't not stop my feeling animosity towards a group a black teenagers who I know are just out to cause trouble cause they know if anyone touches them they can just throw the racist card at them !

If I was out with my mates and we had an argument with a group of Black or Asian kids and one of them got a kicking it would be a racist attack even if no racist words were exchanged, if it was the other way around and I got a kicking it would be serious assault !!!!!

What does annoy me is when people call me a racist, im not a racist im just proud to be English- and it seems to me that this is a wrong thing to be in this day and age, proud of were you come from !!!!

I have a South African flag because my Fiance is South African and everytime I see it it reminds me how lucky I am to have found her !!!!
(a bit girly I know)

Edited by j2j007 (29 Nov 2002 11:37am)


Excellent post! In today's terms, you are a racist, you should ask yourself though; do you give a s***? I don't think you were wrong in anything you said and it's a perfect example of my whole argument, every bit as valid as my little old lady and like her; you are neither evil nor dangerous and you don't practise racist abuse, so what's the big problem? Why do you and your opinions have to be eradicated? You've seen the good and bad in people and you've made your own mind up, that's what is supposed to happen in a free country!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Nov 02 12.15pm

I would recommend anyone with an interest in this topic to get a copy of today's Times and read the article about how immigrants feel in other countries. I stick by my original point: this country, considering its size and population density, deals with non-white immigration far better than other, so-called 'civilised' nations. Having said that, I am of the opinion that allowing immigration to the degree that we do and promoting other cultures at the expense of our own Britishness in a sea of politically correct garbage is a recipe for disaster.

Read the Times article. It's excellent.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Is it racist to....