You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 20 of 174 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Mar 23 10.42pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I won't speak on the vaccines for brevity's sake, as it's a different if related point.

Ok, I'll answer this debunked NHS point yet again....no doubt you will continue to state it but this point is so irritating it's worth it.

But before I do I'll say that looking at the statistics from when masks were first mandated they made no difference to the spread. So your suggestion that they 'delay the spread' doesn't relate to reality (no change there).

Anyway, the NHS was never going to be overwhelmed for covid provision.....No, what happened was that everything else practically stopped....which is some of the reason so many have and are dying later.

We built several new hospitals just for Covid. The amount of provision was based upon high numbers of severely ill that were never reached. Ok, lets imagine in an alternative universe these numbers were hit then guess what genius.

More hospitals and provision would have been provided....covid had an open cheque book in excess of its medical impact.

Let me state it again, just in case you weren't taking it in.

The NHS was never going to be 'overwhelmed' by this virus. The very word suggests something that is so annoyingly misleading it deserves the 'overwhelming' contempt I feel for it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 9.26pm)

The vaccines are an integral piece of this and cannot just be dismissed as unconnected.

You are again talking total bs when you claim that masks made no difference to the spread. No-one can possibly know that because we did wear masks, and we don't know what would have happened if we didn't. Even if it could be established that, with hindsight, it was found they made no difference, it was still the right thing to do to mandate them. We needed to take every available step, some would work, others, like the Nightingale Hospitals didn't and weren't needed. Perhaps because other measures, like masks, did work. We were in a crisis, surrounded by unknowns and had to adopt all available measures.

Smart-arses always know best, when what they think never has to be tested, and they are not under pressure to make decisions.

More smart-arse bs about the NHS never going to be overwhelmed. Now as well as being an expert on everything else, you know more than our Chief Scientific Officer and the senior management at the NHS? That risk existed. You don't construct and equip hospitals overnight. The world was scrambling for respirators and if the worst case scenario had been realised, we would have been overwhelmed. Money could not have solved that problem.

It was bad enough as it was, with so much elective surgery having to be delayed as wards were converted to accommodate Covid patients. I don't suppose you have any idea of just what it was like. Having to manage Covid and non_Covid patients in the same hospitals, dividing areas into Red and Green zones, staffing them separately and with large numbers of staff becoming ill, and off work themselves. Only when the vaccines arrived did things begin to ease, but the knock-on effects will be felt for years.

The idea that things would have been better if we had not locked down, and not worn masks, would be funny if it wasn't so embarrassingly pathetic.

Then you wonder why I got so angry with those who refused the vaccines and still do. I find this whole approach irresponsible and selfish.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 10.54pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

If wearing a mask is a "lie" why then does my wife, who is a nurse in our local hospital, wear one at all times when facing patients? Is she wasting her time, and our money? Or is she protecting herself, or her patient, from the possibility of a cough or a sneeze overloading the environment close to her? She knows it isn't perfect, but she and her colleagues all wear them without complaint, and they are all trained medical professionals. Are they fools? What do you know better, and what qualifications do you have that have enabled that knowledge?

If my wife, and those she is in contact with derive benefit, why won't others when in contact with other people? She isn't from a unique species.

Yes, she's wasting her time and our money. There is precious little benefit from surgical masks. Even surgeons don't necessarily wear them during invasive surgery. It is purely continued practice which was introduced over a hundred years ago.

You obviously didn't read the Cochrane review. Do you have them on your list of far right conspiracy theorists? You silly sausage.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 11.00pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Nonsense

There has been far more recent research

A large, randomized trial led by researchers at Stanford Medicine and Yale University has found that wearing a surgical face mask over the mouth and nose is an effective way to reduce the occurrence of COVID-19 in community settings.

2021

You don't trust Cochrane either??? It's a more recent, and worldwide review. Or have you not bothered to read it too?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 11.06pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Masks and hand sanitising were important steps to make in areas of highest concentration of persons.
The fact that quite a few people got 'exemption' cards for masks, and then went to highly-populated public areas kind of nullified a lot of the good that these measures were intended for.
Then going round supermarkets in family groups with the kids (who could carry and spread the virus whilst having no symptoms) and 'nana' only served to spread the virus further, especially to vulnerable people who needed to use supermarkets as a necessity.

It brought out a lot of the bad/selfish characteristics in people.

Hand washing probably did help contain the spread. Masks however, really didn't. As simple as that. Read the Cochrane review I posted or TeddyEagle's post.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 11.19pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Correct re. surgical, although it would of course stop some level of it eg. large droplets with lots of delicious virus. But to your point it wouldn't really make that much difference as they're so porus. Always made me laugh people walking about with cloth masks on. Absolutely useless.

However, there always seems to be a lot of confusion when this is discussed because for some reason people decide that because better quality masks don't stop all of the virus, then all masks are useless.

This is of course, nonsense.

It's more or less impossible to stop ANY of it getting out or through unless you do decide to go full specimen and wear and NBC suit as you describe.

But, something like an N95 mask, properly worn and sealed does provide a significant benefit to those around you if you have an infection, or if there are viral particles in the air. Why? Masks like that will lower the amount of viral load expelled or inhaled, which also means reduction in the liklihood of you or others catching something (depending on time spend in the vicinity of course, if you're stuck on a busy train for 2 hours then you're screwed either way) or at the very least getting a big hit of it and therefore getting more sick as a result (basically no/light symptoms vs. heavy symptoms).

The other thing people fail to take into account is the behavioural aspect of mask wearing combined with the actual mask wearing itself – it became a signal of caution and awareness that this thing was knocking about and to take a bit more care than usual. If they hadn't of been temporarily adopted then I'd assume infection rates would have been much higher – if we're referring to the latest global studies a lot of the numbers back this up.

This was covered ages ago in the old thread, but ultimately it's wrong to claim 'masks don't stop (all) of the virus therefore masks are pointless'.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (06 Mar 2023 6.23pm)

If you knew anything about how a N95 (or FFP3 in this country) work, you would relise that they do not protect anyone not wearing one. They are purely personal protection. To function correctly, they need a release valve to expel moisture as one exhales. Once they become damp, they are as useless against a virus as surgical masks.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 23 3.27am

N95 masks have repeatedly shown to be very effective in hospital settings. In multiple studies very few staff wearing them got covid despite being surrounded by it during that period. So it of course has it's uses and is more effective than some wish to paint.

The other side of the coin is that during a pandemic, all you can hope with masks is to slow infection. As has been said where something is everywhere, realistically it's unavoidable in the long run.

That about sums it up.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Mar 23 9.16am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3780148]

Yes, she's wasting her time and our money. There is precious little benefit from surgical masks. Even surgeons don't necessarily wear them during invasive surgery. It is purely continued practice which was introduced over a hundred years ago.

You obviously didn't read the Cochrane review. Do you have them on your list of far right conspiracy theorists? You silly sausage.

A surgeon who is infection free operating on an infection free patient will decide for themselves which is the safest way to proceed. There is no correlation with the steps taken to try to limit the spread of Covid.

I have read the Cochrane report. It will doubtless, along with many others, inform on best practice when making assessments on how to respond if another pandemic occurs. When responding to the Covid pandemic, with a nervous population expecting actions to reassure them, and evidence of mask wearing in Asia in particular as a response to other viruses, mandating their use, alongside social distancing and lockdowns made, and continues to make, perfect sense. It might not again, as the public are now more aware.

I wonder if you have read their report! Or whether you have only read the words you want to hear! This is the author's conclusion:-


"The high risk of bias in the trials, variation in outcome measurement, and relatively low adherence with the interventions during the studies hampers drawing firm conclusions. There were additional RCTs during the pandemic related to physical interventions but a relative paucity given the importance of the question of masking and its relative effectiveness and the concomitant measures of mask adherence which would be highly relevant to the measurement of effectiveness, especially in the elderly and in young children.

There is uncertainty about the effects of face masks. The low to moderate certainty of evidence means our confidence in the effect estimate is limited, and that the true effect may be different from the observed estimate of the effect. The pooled results of RCTs did not show a clear reduction in respiratory viral infection with the use of medical/surgical masks. There were no clear differences between the use of medical/surgical masks compared with N95/P2 respirators in healthcare workers when used in routine care to reduce respiratory viral infection. Hand hygiene is likely to modestly reduce the burden of respiratory illness, and although this effect was also present when ILI and laboratory&#8208;confirmed influenza were analysed separately, it was not found to be a significant difference for the latter two outcomes. Harms associated with physical interventions were under&#8208;investigated.

There is a need for large, well&#8208;designed RCTs addressing the effectiveness of many of these interventions in multiple settings and populations, as well as the impact of adherence on effectiveness, especially in those most at risk of ARIs."

In other words the jury is still out, especially on the impact in our own country. What is not in doubt was the need to use every potential tool in the box in a crisis. Not allowing despondency to set in is an important issue in health management.

The time for reflection and lesson learning comes later. Which is precisely why we are holding an enquiry and not rushing to judgement whenever something emerges which happens to confirm a deep-seated bias.


 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Mar 23 9.22am

Originally posted by footythoughts

N95 masks have repeatedly shown to be very effective in hospital settings. In multiple studies very few staff wearing them got covid despite being surrounded by it during that period. So it of course has it's uses and is more effective than some wish to paint.

The other side of the coin is that during a pandemic, all you can hope with masks is to slow infection. As has been said where something is everywhere, realistically it's unavoidable in the long run.

That about sums it up.

Trying to slow the infection until the vaccines were available was the aim. Flattening the curve, so the NHS could cope. Did it work? As we just about coped it seems so, but that doesn't stop some clinging to their beliefs that it was wrong. Lessons will be learned, but not from those with biases and agendas.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

eaglesdare Flag 07 Mar 23 9.45am

Imagine locking down the country over a silly flu with a 99.9 percent survival rate if the catch it. Scaring the life out of the vulnerable and eldery.

History will not look back in kind on these events. Especially those who discriminated against people who made informed decisions about thier body to not get the covid vax.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Mar 23 12.26pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Imagine locking down the country over a silly flu with a 99.9 percent survival rate if the catch it. Scaring the life out of the vulnerable and eldery.

History will not look back in kind on these events. Especially those who discriminated against people who made informed decisions about thier body to not get the covid vax.

The ignorance you regularly display on this subject is very unfortunate but, fortunately, not shared by many.

That you think Covid is just a "silly flu", or no worse than a cold, says enough really. You clearly haven't witnessed those really suffering from it, or now being affected by long-Covid.

History won't view people like you kindly. People who made misinformed, selfish decisions to refuse the vaccines and allow themselves to be unnecessarily exposed to infections themselves, and possibly giving them to others.

It's a credit to our tolerant society that we allowed such things to happen. That though does nothing to mitigate my disgust of them.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Mar 23 12.39pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The ignorance you regularly display on this subject is very unfortunate but, fortunately, not shared by many.

That you think Covid is just a "silly flu", or no worse than a cold, says enough really. You clearly haven't witnessed those really suffering from it, or now being affected by long-Covid.

History won't view people like you kindly. People who made misinformed, selfish decisions to refuse the vaccines and allow themselves to be unnecessarily exposed to infections themselves, and possibly giving them to others.

It's a credit to our tolerant society that we allowed such things to happen. That though does nothing to mitigate my disgust of them.

There are many reasons people don't get vaccinated beyond selfishness.

[Link]

 

eaglesdare Flag 07 Mar 23 12.55pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The ignorance you regularly display on this subject is very unfortunate but, fortunately, not shared by many.

That you think Covid is just a "silly flu", or no worse than a cold, says enough really. You clearly haven't witnessed those really suffering from it, or now being affected by long-Covid.

History won't view people like you kindly. People who made misinformed, selfish decisions to refuse the vaccines and allow themselves to be unnecessarily exposed to infections themselves, and possibly giving them to others.

It's a credit to our tolerant society that we allowed such things to happen. That though does nothing to mitigate my disgust of them.

I really did touch a nerve there didint I. I like many people looked at the scientific evidence presented or lack there of and made an informed decision to not be vaccinated. Many people looked at the same and decided to get vaccinated. Some people just blindly did as they were told like sheep to wear masks, get the clot shot and stay in their homes.

The only selfish people were the ones who made it all about them "oh you have to get the vax to save me" even tho it had little to no effect on transmissions.

All the while your lord and masters partied in thier offices creating fear from "new strains"

What are you on? your 4th 5th booster shot? you most likely still foolishly wear a mask out in the park on your own too! I laugh at you and all those other people!

 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 23 1.27pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Imagine locking down the country over a silly flu with a 99.9 percent survival rate if the catch it. Scaring the life out of the vulnerable and eldery.

History will not look back in kind on these events. Especially those who discriminated against people who made informed decisions about thier body to not get the covid vax.

Case by case really. The first lockdown was understandable as it was new territory and unknowns. Beyond that it was just more and more destructive to businesses, mental health, those with other health issues. I don't envy those having to make these decisions, but since they often didn't follow the restrictions themselves it further manages faith in them.

It was all a crap shoot. If something that comes along that's worse, understandably fewer will listen and the next time your 'informed decision' might get you killed because they're made in the moment not in hindsight. Life is full of unknowns and whether politician or man on the street, best judgement is often just a guess really. The retrospective back patting exercises are more ego based than anything anyone else cares about.


 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 23 1.33pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare


What are you on? your 4th 5th booster shot? you most likely still foolishly wear a mask out in the park on your own too! I laugh at you and all those other people!

If someones 80, it might be that it's not a bad idea to get boosters, it's not a concept that's unheard of. If your view is that people should make the decision they feel is right for them, it goes against your logic to laugh at someone making those choices.

 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 23 1.37pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Trying to slow the infection until the vaccines were available was the aim. Flattening the curve, so the NHS could cope. Did it work? As we just about coped it seems so, but that doesn't stop some clinging to their beliefs that it was wrong. Lessons will be learned, but not from those with biases and agendas.

It made sense to slow the spread at the beginning, most certainly. The repeated lockdowns though did some bundled with many negatives. We also have to factor in though that young people were largely unaffacted by Covid and yet the consequences are substantially long term more theirs to face. As such there are many considerations to be made beyond covid itself. We all have failings and a bias could be the 'i'm alright jack' angle , financially, so it pays to recognise that too. If you're a landlord you in a sense may benefit from others financial difficulties which puts you out of the loop of some peoples very real struggles in life. All perspectives matter not just the covidcentric one.


Edited by footythoughts (07 Mar 2023 1.39pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Mar 23 1.40pm

Originally posted by footythoughts

Case by case really. The first lockdown was understandable as it was new territory and unknowns. Beyond that it was just more and more destructive to businesses, mental health, those with other health issues. I don't envy those having to make these decisions, but since they often didn't follow the restrictions themselves it further manages faith in them.

It was all a crap shoot. If something that comes along that's worse, understandably fewer will listen and the next time your 'informed decision' might get you killed because they're made in the moment not in hindsight. Life is full of unknowns and whether politician or man on the street, best judgement is often just a guess really. The retrospective back patting exercises are more ego based than anything anyone else cares about.


I agree, somewhat that the first lockdown was something that had an argument.

As for unknowns and so on....Let's not forget that this isn't an unknown insomuch as new novel viruses have been turning up with human evolution since the start.

Let's also acknowledge that pandemic policy was already in place and had been devised over generations of experience of fighting pandemics of the past.

The Great Barrington declaration is an example of academics and health professionals having serious concerns over the divergent pathways that governments took from previous policy.

If you have never heard of the Great Barrington declaration you can take that as further evidence for the systematic suppression of alternative opinions and approaches that marked this extremely illiberal governance.

When it comes to your hindsight point. In fairness there were people on Hol stating the very same takes on this forum when these decisions were taken. So I think that is on a case by case basis.

And let's sod anyone's ego, the cost to this country and added cost to the future youth has been beyond many's comprehension.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Mar 2023 1.41pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

eaglesdare Flag 07 Mar 23 1.44pm

Originally posted by footythoughts

If someones 80, it might be that it's not a bad idea to get boosters, it's not a concept that's unheard of. If your view is that people should make the decision they feel is right for them, it goes against your logic to laugh at someone making those choices.

Yes that is my view. But do know what? after the last 3 years of s*** from covid zealots I will gladly laugh at them and look down on them now and give them a taste of thier own ridiculous medicine.

 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 23 1.56pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Yes that is my view. But do know what? after the last 3 years of s*** from covid zealots I will gladly laugh at them and look down on them now and give them a taste of thier own ridiculous medicine.

Point being I suppose that a great many people still getting vaccinated are likely ill or elderly rather than zealots. But yes I do appreciate the point that going all in on covid concerns is blinkered considering the knock on effect for other health conditions, businesses, the young.

The worldwide nature of covid was likely going to screw people over anyway, but the restrictions for thee be not for me attitudes of those in power will certainly ensure that people are much less likely to listen in future.

 

eaglesdare Flag 07 Mar 23 2.23pm

Originally posted by footythoughts

Point being I suppose that a great many people still getting vaccinated are likely ill or elderly rather than zealots. But yes I do appreciate the point that going all in on covid concerns is blinkered considering the knock on effect for other health conditions, businesses, the young.

The worldwide nature of covid was likely going to screw people over anyway, but the restrictions for thee be not for me attitudes of those in power will certainly ensure that people are much less likely to listen in future.

I dont mind people getting vaccinated. I fully support anyone who makes that decision its thier choice.

When I refer to "Covid Zealots" I refer to those who were mandating people to get the vax and discriminating against people who chose not to get it for thier own personal or medical reasons, forcing people to get it against thier will. And those who campaigned for lockdowns, face masks, covid certs etc...

I had to lie myself and get fake covid vaccine documents for work / travel. Somthing I never thought I would have to do in this world to survive.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 07 Mar 23 3.25pm

I think it's the impinging on people's individual choices.
If i were vaccinated I should have no say on what other people's choices are. That is a safety concern for the individual to manage.

What I found worrying, was the number of maskless groups of people wandering around supermarkets, encroaching on people's personal space restrictions and clearly putting those who felt more vulnerable (and had to do essential shopping) at increased risk of infection. Just one example.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Page 20 of 174 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy