You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Performance of the new government
November 21 2026 9.21pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Performance of the new government


Page 20 of 23 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 9.08am

Not bizarre at all.
They say they knew nothing about this until last week but published the letter yesterday.
Their letter also says that they will carry out a review as something went wrong in March.
They appear to blame the Treasury but the Treasury is made up of supposedly apolitical employees - forgive my cynicism!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Jul 24 9.25am

My take it's all politics by both parties.

Tories
Sunak held the election early knowing that there were a bunch of big decisions coming up that would impact the economy. If he had gone in November all those decisions would be out in the open and he would get pelters from Labour.

Going early meant he dumped the problem onto Labour.

Labour
They knew exactly what the Tories were up to and chose to turn a blind eye and not inform the voters that Labour's spending plans would be unrealistic.

It suits Labour to dump the problem back onto the Tories however they did not have to agree to the public sector pay rises. So much but not all of the so called black hole is actually a political decision by Labour.

As for the other stuff that Labour has since found again this is people playing politics. If government departments have been hiding the "truth" from the previous government then people should be sacked.

 


One more point

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 9.38am

Good post and I am in agreement.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 9.42am

The winter fuel issue from yesterday is going to really backfire on Labour.
I have just seen a clip of Starmer hand wringing about the state of pensioners and their lack of money, having to choose whether to turn the heat on in winter or buy stuff they need - from how long ago I can't say.
It makes it even worse and as some people have said, it is absolutely disgusting!
I get my pension in December and don't need the fuel allowance but those that do should get it and many of them won't.
If the opposition have anything about them, then this should be something that is reversed.
Interesting that she did it knowing there would be no more PMQ's for a few weeks.
She really is a piece of work!

Edited by The Dolphin (30 Jul 2024 9.45am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 9.46am

Found it - 2 months ago.
The bare faced cheek of it!
[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Jul 24 9.55am

On the Winter Fuel change I am actually in agreement with Labour I have never understood why it wasn't mean tested.

My older neighbours have done very nicely during and after COVID / cost of living crisis most tell me they use it for Christmas presents for the grand kids.

For me the only real question is where is the cut off point when people stop getting it. I will leave that to others to argue how poor pensioners really are. My own father complains he is a poor pensioner and then complains he pays too much tax. This contradictory statement seems quite common amongst pensioners.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 30 Jul 24 9.55am

'We cannot do what we cannot afford' - Rachel Reeves.

'We can afford whatever we can do' - John Maynard Keynes.

No prizes for guessing who is the better economist, Keynes is credited with the post war recovery based on labour thinking.

And they, Ms Reeves, really didn't have money, the NHS was started even though the North American loan was not certain.

Really tories and labour simply don't understand that wealthy people have money, and poor people don't.


 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 9.59am

Originally posted by Badger11

On the Winter Fuel change I am actually in agreement with Labour I have never understood why it wasn't mean tested.

My older neighbours have done very nicely during and after COVID / cost of living crisis most tell me they use it for Christmas presents for the grand kids.

For me the only real question is where is the cut off point when people stop getting it. I will leave that to others to argue how poor pensioners really are. My own father complains he is a poor pensioner and then complains he pays too much tax. This contradictory statement seems quite common amongst pensioners.

Means testing, I agree with.
They, however, intend to stop anyone not on benefits getting it.
So someone with just a pension will not receive it and that has to be wrong.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 30 Jul 24 10.09am

Originally posted by Badger11

On the Winter Fuel change I am actually in agreement with Labour I have never understood why it wasn't mean tested.

My older neighbours have done very nicely during and after COVID / cost of living crisis most tell me they use it for Christmas presents for the grand kids.

For me the only real question is where is the cut off point when people stop getting it. I will leave that to others to argue how poor pensioners really are. My own father complains he is a poor pensioner and then complains he pays too much tax. This contradictory statement seems quite common amongst pensioners.

Completely agree with this - there's a valid discussion around where the cut-off is, but it certainly should be means tested.

1 in 4 pensioners is a millionaire, and they are on average the wealthiest demographic in the country - the fact we spend so much on an untested benefit for them doesn't make any sense at all.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Jul 24 10.13am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Not bizarre at all.
They say they knew nothing about this until last week but published the letter yesterday.
Their letter also says that they will carry out a review as something went wrong in March.
They appear to blame the Treasury but the Treasury is made up of supposedly apolitical employees - forgive my cynicism!

I can’t see what point you are making here.

Unfunded commitments were made and not provided to the OBR.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Jul 24 10.29am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Completely agree with this - there's a valid discussion around where the cut-off is, but it certainly should be means tested.

1 in 4 pensioners is a millionaire, and they are on average the wealthiest demographic in the country - the fact we spend so much on an untested benefit for them doesn't make any sense at all.

That is only because of high house prices.
I have a problem with rewarding failure and penalising achievement and responsibility.

The socialist way.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 10.32am

So they say - totally unproven.
A BBC article describes as the bean counters getting their own back on the Tories.
[Link]
In the interests of fair play, when you read it, it backs up your argument.
I am afraid that I don't buy it all and so we will have to agree to disagree.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 10.36am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That is only because of high house prices.
I have a problem with rewarding failure and penalising achievement and responsibility.

The socialist way.

Agreed.
Come to Britain and Labour will look after you.
Don't want to work - Labour will look after you.
Public sector - Labour will not only look after you but will also shower you in above inflation pay rises every time you threaten to strike.
Work hard, own a house - sorry - you really shouldn't have done that, because Labour want it all, to give to undeserving rafts of society.
It sucks the life out of aspiration.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 30 Jul 24 10.36am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Completely agree with this - there's a valid discussion around where the cut-off is, but it certainly should be means tested.

1 in 4 pensioners is a millionaire, and they are on average the wealthiest demographic in the country - the fact we spend so much on an untested benefit for them doesn't make any sense at all.

No, many of the other 3 million pensioners live on their state pension only.

They will not qualify for pension credit it is set higher.

So they lose the fuel allowance altogether, the people who most need it.


 

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Jul 24 10.37am

I don't know why everyone is so worried!

Whilst millions of hard working British pesioners are at risk of getting pneumonia from the winter cold those lovely deserving migrants/illegal immigrants will be fine in their nice, warm, free hotel rooms!!

And at the end of the day, that is all that matters to the b*st*rds running this country!!

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 30 Jul 24 10.38am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That is only because of high house prices.
I have a problem with rewarding failure and penalising achievement and responsibility.

The socialist way.

Well yes, the explosion in house prices is exactly what's made this generation so wealthy (on average) - that's not remotely an argument in favour of maintaining benefits for them.

I find these lines about rewarding/punishing very silly - we have a progressive tax system; by definition it's going to 'reward failure' and 'penalise achievement' - unless you think we should start taxing low earners more?

I pay a large tax bill every year because I earn a good salary; not for a second do I view that as being punished or penalised. Equally, if I lost my job and started paying less tax, I would certainly not feel rewarded.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 30 Jul 24 10.41am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

So they say - totally unproven.
A BBC article describes as the bean counters getting their own back on the Tories.
[Link]
In the interests of fair play, when you read it, it backs up your argument.
I am afraid that I don't buy it all and so we will have to agree to disagree.

Beyond parody

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 30 Jul 24 10.54am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Completely agree with this - there's a valid discussion around where the cut-off is, but it certainly should be means tested.

1 in 4 pensioners is a millionaire, and they are on average the wealthiest demographic in the country - the fact we spend so much on an untested benefit for them doesn't make any sense at all.

let me introduce myself as one of the '3'...

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Eden Eagle Flag Kent 30 Jul 24 10.55am

When this Labour Government talks about a £20 billion “blackhole” in the funding and then consequently cuts winter fuel support for pensioners (those not in receipt of pension credit) please remember that the previous Government wasted over £400 billion on Covid measures/support.

Many of us on here pointed out the consequences of the lunacy of the Covid spending and it is now very clear that this madness of paying people to sit at home for 2 years, shutting down our economy and locking down the population will continue to have a massive financial impact for many generations to come.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Jul 24 11.01am

Originally posted by steeleye20

No, many of the other 3 million pensioners live on their state pension only.

They will not qualify for pension credit it is set higher.

So they lose the fuel allowance altogether, the people who most need it.


We agree Steeleye!


 

Page 20 of 23 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Performance of the new government