You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 21 of 65 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Mar 19 8.24am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Roy is signed up for another season, which for me is absolutely fine. We badly need continuity and need to avoid the upheaval and time&energy lost when finding a new manager If Roy decides one more year will be enough for him we should be looking for an assistant this Summer who we think will be capable of taking over.

 

Only 10 a year!! Flag 06 Mar 19 12.03pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Roy is signed up for another season, which for me is absolutely fine. We badly need continuity and need to avoid the upheaval and time&energy lost when finding a new manager If Roy decides one more year will be enough for him we should be looking for an assistant this Summer who we think will be capable of taking over.


Always a bad idea, being a good assistant is completely different to being the main man. We should just be constantly monitoring good managers elsewhere who we can get at the time of Roy going.
I don't see anything wrong with Roy, he is old enough and wise (owl) enough to understand what is needed to stay in this division.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 06 Mar 19 12.19pm

At some time, next season or the season after,Roy will retire. This being Palace, we'll take a month or so to go through the recruitment process. The new manager will be new to the club and will take time to assess his new squad etc. etc. lining up the traditional poor start to the season, ready made excuses and expensive signings in January. You can keep a list of prospects as up to date as you like but things change rapidly for managers and you cannot be sure if your choice(s) will be released, want to come, want to negotiate special terms...

Just for once, why cant we try something a bit different? We'll know Roy's retirement date a season before he leaves. Why cant we get someone then, who knows he will take over in a year but until then work with Roy and the team?

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 06 Mar 19 12.36pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


He has an assistant,Ray Lewington

Ray Lewington's already failed as a manager at CPFC; he was a good coach then as well. I hope he'd continue to fill that role after Roy retires and I think he'd go on doing that longer without a role change.

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 06 Mar 19 2.09pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

At some time, next season or the season after,Roy will retire. This being Palace, we'll take a month or so to go through the recruitment process. The new manager will be new to the club and will take time to assess his new squad etc. etc. lining up the traditional poor start to the season, ready made excuses and expensive signings in January. You can keep a list of prospects as up to date as you like but things change rapidly for managers and you cannot be sure if your choice(s) will be released, want to come, want to negotiate special terms...

Just for once, why cant we try something a bit different? We'll know Roy's retirement date a season before he leaves. Why cant we get someone then, who knows he will take over in a year but until then work with Roy and the team?

Kinda like what's going on with the Irish international teams, in rugby once Schmidt is off Farrell will be taking over his roll and in Football Mick McCarthy is in there until after the qualifying stages then the u20s coach Stephen Kenny will be taking the position.

I like the idea of this but i can see flaws in it that would need to be worked out

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

KAOS Flag In a tree 06 Mar 19 3.23pm

I’ll be happy for Roy to stay next season. Yes, he can be frustrating, yes someone new could maybe get more out of certain players but at this stage of our ‘growth’ it’s key to maintain stability which is what Roy brings. If that means another season at the lower end of the table / but avoiding relegation then so be it … but I’ll take that and his years of experience and structured methods over the unknown.

If he manages to persuade the club and Wilf & AWB to stay another season, then he should be knighted!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 06 Mar 19 7.42pm

Originally posted by KAOS

I’ll be happy for Roy to stay next season. Yes, he can be frustrating, yes someone new could maybe get more out of certain players but at this stage of our ‘growth’ it’s key to maintain stability which is what Roy brings. If that means another season at the lower end of the table / but avoiding relegation then so be it … but I’ll take that and his years of experience and structured methods over the unknown.

If he manages to persuade the club and Wilf & AWB to stay another season, then he should be knighted!

You need to try harder to understand what he is achieving with all the players at his disposal.

Very bizarre.

He's been quite brilliant at everything he has done so far.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 06 Mar 19 7.53pm

Originally posted by Charles

Ray Lewington's already failed as a manager at CPFC; he was a good coach then as well. I hope he'd continue to fill that role after Roy retires and I think he'd go on doing that longer without a role change.

We might as well all give up then, that bloke at Man.U is as hopeless as he was at Cardiff, some people can actually learn from mistakes and learn under the guidance of great managers like Hodgson.

 

davehuggins Flag 06 Mar 19 8.01pm

If Roy stays it can only be good for us. He has done a brilliant job thus far. Long may he stay healthy and enjoy his work at Palace.

 

jeeagles Flag 06 Mar 19 8.39pm

Like me and the girl I'm dating. I think we both no we are alright but can't do better.

When I tell her I'm planning on ending things soon. She gets demotivated. Hopefully the same won't happen to the players.

 

doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 06 Mar 19 10.45pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Like me and the girl I'm dating. I think we both no we are alright but can't do better.

When I tell her I'm planning on ending things soon. She gets demotivated. Hopefully the same won't happen to the players.

You're a real bundle of fun

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Mar 19 11.23pm

Originally posted by doi209

You're a real bundle of fun

Classic!!!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Mar 19 1.20am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Like me and the girl I'm dating. I think we both no we are alright but can't do better.

When I tell her I'm planning on ending things soon. She gets demotivated. Hopefully the same won't happen to the players.

It has been written that his disaster at Liverpool was in fact due to the boards lack of funds and the fans hatred of someone not from within a bin ...Something you need to KNOW.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 07 Mar 19 7.45am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It has been written that his disaster at Liverpool was in fact due to the boards lack of funds and the fans hatred of someone not from within a bin ...Something you need to KNOW.

If it was lack of funds, it doesn't look good for us then

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 07 Mar 19 8.00am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It has been written that his disaster at Liverpool was in fact due to the boards lack of funds and the fans hatred of someone not from within a bin ...Something you need to KNOW.

Why rewrite history?

You can love him for being Palace's manager and he can still have been s***e elsewhere.

Sick of this nonsense. He did a terrible job at Liverpool and England, that's just a fact.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 07 Mar 19 8.16am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Why rewrite history?

You can love him for being Palace's manager and he can still have been s***e elsewhere.

Sick of this nonsense. He did a terrible job at Liverpool and England, that's just a fact.

I think Roy is very good at taking an average team and drilling them in training so that they know exactly what their job is and what to do in certain situations. This is ideal for teams like Palace, WBA and Fulham.

At international level he would not have enough time with the players to drill them daily as he does in club sessions. At a bigger club he has to deal with better players and bigger egos and they may not take to doing the same things in training each day.

 


One more point

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 07 Mar 19 8.22am

Originally posted by davehuggins

If Roy stays it can only be good for us. He has done a brilliant job thus far. Long may he stay healthy and enjoy his work at Palace.

Brilliant job: by what what standard? We need to better our standing last year for it to be considered a brilliant job.

I grant you that results are finally where they should be after half a season, but that's not a sign of brilliance.

If we beat Brighton on Saturday and Watford to get to the semi final I'll be on board the "Super Croydon Roy" bus.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 07 Mar 19 8.23am

Originally posted by Badger11

I think Roy is very good at taking an average team and drilling them in training so that they know exactly what their job is and what to do in certain situations. This is ideal for teams like Palace, WBA and Fulham.

At international level he would not have enough time with the players to drill them daily as he does in club sessions. At a bigger club he has to deal with better players and bigger egos and they may not take to doing the same things in training each day.

Yes, he's very good at making average players achieve the average.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Mar 19 8.37am

When you look at the size of the club and the size of investment only Watford are achieving more than us this season (and possibly Bournemouth by 1 point). I don't believe in everything Roy does, but with the fixtures remaining and our current form we could end up finishing with our best ever season in the PL, especially if we were to beat Watford in the cup. I don't really understand how anyone can question what Roy has achieved this season given what the club spent? Bar one season under Pardew we always have a better second half to the season, which is pretty much how our games tend to pan out too. Win the next two games and we should start laying the foundations on the Hodgson Stand

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Mar 19 8.59am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Why rewrite history?

You can love him for being Palace's manager and he can still have been s***e elsewhere.

Sick of this nonsense. He did a terrible job at Liverpool and England, that's just a fact.

One bad result with the England team when they failed to turn up, Hodgson like us had to watch them fail.

[Link]

Stop following all the sheep!

 

Page 21 of 65 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread