This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Would you say that if she were Black and or a Democrat? I doubt it. In fact, I'm sure neither you or Wisbech would. Of course I would. Break in to a high security establishment full of armed guards in a country where shooting is standard, what do you get. I wouldn’t have done it. Not a ‘jolly outing’. Many of those inside were very scared for their lives. Unlike you, I have no hang ups about colour. I will sack you no matter what you look like.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Was she armed? No How can you possibly suggest that she deserved to be shot dead? In your sinister world, it seems that only Black people and Democrats can be victims of unjust killing, and only if the Black people are killed by White people. Everyone else is just collateral. You are seeing things in my comments that are not there. I haven’t said she deserved to be shot dead! What I said is the simple truth. She had neither a right nor a legitimate reason to be where she was, doing what she was doing. The mob she was engaged with were trying to subvert the democratic process, using violence and threats of violence to achieve their aims. They must have anticipated their actions would be resisted for such things cannot be allowed to succeed. She put herself in that situation. Nobody forced her. She was unlucky. No-one deserves to be unlucky. She could though have avoided that bad luck by not behaving so stupidly in the first place.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Like everything with this version of the left, the control of language is what matters to them, not what an objective truth is.....they are only interested in their own narratives. Look at what actually happens. A white person dies, nothing. A non white person dies, the media never stops with it....claims of racism, whether true or untrue are neither here nor there they make as much political capital as possible out of it. Once again, I have to challenge the nonsense that what happened on January six was an attempt at overthrowing an election. Errrr....to do that requires a coup, that requires guns...you know actually firing and killing people... and the coordinated taking over of power centres around a country to replace the power brokers. To achieve it you need the military to turn onto your side. It can't be done without a military and all these lies are nothing but pure political capital. The US state continues to this day to keep its own citizens in solitary confinement based upon lies. That form of political persecution used to be what non western countries did, one's we would call banana republics. They are the people who actually murdered people that day with a bullet and then whitewashed the incompetent cop. Go watch the actual video of her death. Anyone objective who does that can see the horrible difference between a narrative and what actually happened. I also hear there is also a claim from video footage that Police were responsible for a woman dying outside....but I don't know, it's just a claim at this stage. Instead these are the people who chose to lie about a cop, who died of a heart attack after the event as having been killed by the event.....something they have and had no proof of. A fantasy of lies, built and maintained by liars. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Jan 2023 10.51pm) Not heard of the Velvet Revolution then?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Not heard of the Velvet Revolution then? The communist government after the collapse of other Warsaw Pact governments? Without that collapse it would have been the same story as all the other communist uprisings. They chose to not turn their guns on their people. That's what it takes and you know that very well. That's very very rare and your chosen side would have shot every single one of them if they seriously thought their power was threatened. It all comes down to who the men with guns decide to back....and while the military are majority right wing, they are still deluded enough to believe that these leaders are worth protecting. Welcome in recession and cold war with a child sniffing zombie. Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Jan 2023 12.10am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Like everything with this version of the left, the control of language is what matters to them, not what an objective truth is.....they are only interested in their own narratives. Look at what actually happens. A white person dies, nothing. A non white person dies, the media never stops with it....claims of racism, whether true or untrue are neither here nor there they make as much political capital as possible out of it. Once again, I have to challenge the nonsense that what happened on January six was an attempt at overthrowing an election. Errrr....to do that requires a coup, that requires guns...you know actually firing and killing people... and the coordinated taking over of power centres around a country to replace the power brokers. To achieve it you need the military to turn onto your side. It can't be done without a military and all these lies are nothing but pure political capital. The US state continues to this day to keep its own citizens in solitary confinement based upon lies. That form of political persecution used to be what non western countries did, one's we would call banana republics. They are the people who actually murdered people that day with a bullet and then whitewashed the incompetent cop. Go watch the actual video of her death. Anyone objective who does that can see the horrible difference between a narrative and what actually happened. I also hear there is also a claim from video footage that Police were responsible for a woman dying outside....but I don't know, it's just a claim at this stage. Instead these are the people who chose to lie about a cop, who died of a heart attack after the event as having been killed by the event.....something they have and had no proof of. A fantasy of lies, built and maintained by liars.
How sad it is to see the level of indoctrination that occurs when someone becomes obsessed with believing the nonsense to be found in some US right wing podcasts. Most people in the UK, whether they be right leaning, left leaning or, like me, in the centre, would, in my opinion, completely reject the narrative above. This has nothing whatsoever to do with the skin colour of the person involved and to try to claim it has is a barely disguised conspiracy theory of the worst kind. Just because the attempt at an insurrection was foolish and bound to fail doesn't mean it wasn't an attempt. It was stoked by a foolish POTUS. Whether he and his cabal seriously thought it could succeed is open to question but those involved did. The state did what it had to do, which was to ensure the attempt failed in the safest way possible, given the resources available and the time those responsible for decision-making had to react. No-one was murdered. To suggest they were is an outrageous slur on those charged with trying to resist the mob and protect the people's elected representatives. Videos show just a few moments and not the whole picture. They always need to be set in their context. The individual involved may well have panicked under threats and pressure. I haven't read the investigation, but no-body could be adequately prepared and trained for such an event. It was certainly unfortunate but it wasn't murder. Anyone deliberately placing themselves into a situation like that risks what happened to Bobbitt. The blame, and the blood, lies squarely and only, on the hands of those who incited the mob to do what they did. Which is what, in due time, and following due process, will be established. If the Police have failed in their duty they will undoubtably be investigated and held to account. That's what responsible societies do.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
How sad it is to see the level of indoctrination that occurs when someone becomes obsessed with believing the nonsense to be found in some US right wing podcasts. Most people in the UK, whether they be right leaning, left leaning or, like me, in the centre, would, in my opinion, completely reject the narrative above. This has nothing whatsoever to do with the skin colour of the person involved and to try to claim it has is a barely disguised conspiracy theory of the worst kind. Just because the attempt at an insurrection was foolish and bound to fail doesn't mean it wasn't an attempt. It was stoked by a foolish POTUS. Whether he and his cabal seriously thought it could succeed is open to question but those involved did. The state did what it had to do, which was to ensure the attempt failed in the safest way possible, given the resources available and the time those responsible for decision-making had to react. No-one was murdered. To suggest they were is an outrageous slur on those charged with trying to resist the mob and protect the people's elected representatives. Videos show just a few moments and not the whole picture. They always need to be set in their context. The individual involved may well have panicked under threats and pressure. I haven't read the investigation, but no-body could be adequately prepared and trained for such an event. It was certainly unfortunate but it wasn't murder. Anyone deliberately placing themselves into a situation like that risks what happened to Bobbitt. The blame, and the blood, lies squarely and only, on the hands of those who incited the mob to do what they did. Which is what, in due time, and following due process, will be established. If the Police have failed in their duty they will undoubtably be investigated and held to account. That's what responsible societies do. I wouldn't hold your breath. Responsibility for Capitol policing lies with Congress there were sufficient warnings about the riot yet between Congress and the Police seniors they managed not to have enough officers on patrol that day. I think both police and politicians are far more interested in going after the rioters then examining why this was a failure in leadership and oversight.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I wouldn't hold your breath. Responsibility for Capitol policing lies with Congress there were sufficient warnings about the riot yet between Congress and the Police seniors they managed not to have enough officers on patrol that day. I think both police and politicians are far more interested in going after the rioters then examining why this was a failure in leadership and oversight. There is already a Congressional enquiry underway which, with the House now under Republican control, will likely shift its emphasis and try to allocate blame to anyone but Trump. So blaming the Capitol police looks a very likely scenario to me.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There is already a Congressional enquiry underway which, with the House now under Republican control, will likely shift its emphasis and try to allocate blame to anyone but Trump. So blaming the Capitol police looks a very likely scenario to me. Exactly blame the police and not the politicians. I believe the committee that oversees Capitol policing is cross party so it's in both parties interests to look for blame elsewhere. I maybe wrong on this point but I thought in the aftermath the (now sacked) police chief did say he had asked for extra resources and had been ignored.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly blame the police and not the politicians. I believe the committee that oversees Capitol policing is cross party so it's in both parties interests to look for blame elsewhere. I maybe wrong on this point but I thought in the aftermath the (now sacked) police chief did say he had asked for extra resources and had been ignored. Some people want a two headed coin in every discussion. If the woman killed was unlucky so was George Floyd based on the same logic. What a load of manure is spouted by the usual suspects. Edited by HKOwen (30 Jan 2023 12.07pm)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I wouldn't hold your breath. Responsibility for Capitol policing lies with Congress there were sufficient warnings about the riot yet between Congress and the Police seniors they managed not to have enough officers on patrol that day. I think both police and politicians are far more interested in going after the rioters then examining why this was a failure in leadership and oversight. Agree
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly blame the police and not the politicians. I believe the committee that oversees Capitol policing is cross party so it's in both parties interests to look for blame elsewhere. I maybe wrong on this point but I thought in the aftermath the (now sacked) police chief did say he had asked for extra resources and had been ignored. The only politician deserving of blame is the one who incited the mob. The others were terrified, confused and relying on their security. Whether new arrangements have now been introduced as a consequence of what was learned I don't know, but I would hope so. Equally, whether any individual officer failed to do their duty is something an investigation will reveal. I believe there are several underway, not just the Congressional one, which will indeed see political point scoring. It might be cross-party, but it will now be chaired and dominated by the Republicans. Thankfully the Democrats made some telling points in their interim report and handed their file to the Justice Department.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Some people want a two headed coin in every discussion. If the woman killed was unlucky so was George Floyd based on the same logic. What a load of manure is spouted by the usual suspects. Edited by HKOwen (30 Jan 2023 12.07pm) Did George Floyd attack a heavily armed centre of government in order to 'get at' the politicians behind a locked door then? I must have missed that. What I have seen from Ashli Babbitt is that she was in the company of a large group of rioters that mobbed three security officers. One punched out the windows to the left and right of an officer. She was at the very front of the crowd spurring them on. For some reason the security officers, who had been incredibly patient, moved out of the way. The mob then set about smashing through the doors towards the politicians, despite the obviously armed officer on the other side. I also note that a 'Tactical Officer' pointed his rifle at the person that shot Ms Babbitt but then appears to have decided he had the right to act as he did. Now, in the UK I don't think she would have been shot, although perhaps she would had she been smashing down the doors of the Houses of Parliament. Different rules apply when the special services are involved. But in the USA putting herself on the front line like that was sheer madness. On the other hand Floyd was, well, driving. And a very unconcerned looking officer appears to have chosen to kneel on his neck to the point where he died. To me, that is really a little different. But hey, I guess others see that somewhat differently for some reason.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Some people want a two headed coin in every discussion. If the woman killed was unlucky so was George Floyd based on the same logic. What a load of manure is spouted by the usual suspects. Edited by HKOwen (30 Jan 2023 12.07pm) Completely different set of circumstances, but Floyd was indeed unlucky to have been handled by those particular officers. Other, better trained, officers may well have avoided the outcome that befell him. The same applies to Babbitt. The judgement being made is on the behaviour of the officer(s) in each case. Was what they did wilful or were they, and those they were charged with protecting, under threat? The answers seem clear enough to me.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Did George Floyd attack a heavily armed centre of government in order to 'get at' the politicians behind a locked door then? I must have missed that. What I have seen from Ashli Babbitt is that she was in the company of a large group of rioters that mobbed three security officers. One punched out the windows to the left and right of an officer. She was at the very front of the crowd spurring them on. For some reason the security officers, who had been incredibly patient, moved out of the way. The mob then set about smashing through the doors towards the politicians, despite the obviously armed officer on the other side. I also note that a 'Tactical Officer' pointed his rifle at the person that shot Ms Babbitt but then appears to have decided he had the right to act as he did. Now, in the UK I don't think she would have been shot, although perhaps she would had she been smashing down the doors of the Houses of Parliament. Different rules apply when the special services are involved. But in the USA putting herself on the front line like that was sheer madness. But hey, I guess others see that somewhat differently for some reason. Incorrect surprisingly.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The police were called because Floyd passed a fake note to the store. Your argument is that the woman killed in Washington had contributed to her demise by her actions, by the same measure do did Floyd. I don't expect anything other than hypocrisy and self serving narrative in reply, typical cake and eating it. In fact Floyd did not know it was a fake note according to the cashier to whom he passed it. So no, Floyd didn't knowingly contribute to his demise. And since when did passing a forged note result in a death sentence. How you can conflate that with being in a riot mob facing one of the most highly armed places in the US is just bizarre. Absolutely no comparison. And by the way in the US the death penalty can be imposed on defendants convicted of capital offenses including treason or the kidnapping of a Congressman.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Incorrect surprisingly. OK, sitting in a parked car.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
In fact Floyd did not know it was a fake note according to the cashier to whom he passed it. So no, Floyd didn't knowingly contribute to his demise. And since when did passing a forged note result in a death sentence. How you can conflate that with being in a riot mob facing one of the most highly armed places in the US is just bizarre. Absolutely no comparison. And by the way in the US the death penalty can be imposed on defendants convicted of capital offenses including treason or the kidnapping of a Congressman. I suspect she didn't want her store trashed....you know, by your oppressed social justice friends. How on earth would she know? What we do know however is that Floyd was a career criminal who was on overdose levels of fentanyl. The medical examiner concluded that George Floyd likely died of a fentanyl overdose. The autopsy revealed no physical evidence suggesting that Floyd died of asphyxiation but hey you know, just like your political brethren, the actual objective truth of a matter isn't important. Those in power on the left have their narratives and they will stick to them and it's rather obvious why. I bet all those people who lost property in the rioting and suffered attacks off the back of this event must really love you lot.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I suspect she didn't want her store trashed....you know, by your oppressed social justice friends. How on earth would she know? What we do know however is that Floyd was a career criminal who was on overdose levels of fentanyl. The medical examiner concluded that George Floyd likely died of a fentanyl overdose. The autopsy revealed no physical evidence suggesting that Floyd died of asphyxiation but hey you know, just like your political brethren, the actual objective truth of a matter isn't important. Those in power on the left have their narratives and they will stick to them and it's rather obvious why. I bet all those people who lost property in the rioting and suffered attacks off the back of this event must really love you lot.
Hmm. You believe you are so well informed? The store assistant was a he and he knew George well. Felt sorry for him apparently. And as for the other nonsense, maybe read the autopsies: The Hennepin County medical examiner's office ruled Floyd's death was a homicide caused by "cardiopulmonary arrest" complicated by "restraint, and neck compression" while he was being subdued by police. Medical Examiner Andrew Baker testified that the way officers held Floyd down and compressed his neck while restraining him "was just more than Mr. Floyd could take," given the condition of his heart. Similarly, an independent autopsy commissioned by Floyd's family ruled "asphyxiation from sustained pressure was the cause" of Floyd's death.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.