You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 23 of 27 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >
taylors lovechild Flag 17 Dec 19 7.16am

Meyer looks good when we're in possession, but he disappears when out of possession. Given we generally have less of the ball I imagine this is why he has struggled to break into the team. Personally I would play him on the left at Newcastle and Wilf on the right (if Andros is still out) and Ayew back in the middle. Tekkers did ok in the second half, but we missed Ayew's work ethic up top.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 17 Dec 19 2.38pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

I agree 100% of every thing you wrote, Benteke and the Dutch lad looked pathetic, even though it was possibly Benteke's best game for ages.
Also, I don't think Roy came out of this game smelling of roses.

A bit harsh on Reidewald. He had Dann as the left sided centre half who is slower than me and Wilf as his protection in front who hardly tracked back all evening.
And he has, as a defender, our best record this season minutes played / goals conceded. Just saying.
As for Big Ben there is a footballer in there somewhere. Just not quite sure where.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 17 Dec 19 3.55pm

Originally posted by RyWa

How Max doesn't get a start is beyond me.
The game changed the second he came on.
He links up so well with Wilf down the left and has done since he's been here.
We are a team that struggles for goals, largely in part from lack of creativity, he has bundles of it.
You could feel the buzz in ground whenever he got on the ball tonight.
He may not be great every game, but neither is Wilf, however I really belive he should be in the 11.
I also think Luka needs to be dropped for Mccarthy as he's had a shocker so far this year

Agree 100% with all sentiments expressed.
Only got to look at how good Brighton now are with Mooy. Creativity will get us goals.
Our captain is poor and plays suicide 'passes'
I'd drop him and Koyuate and play McCarthy and Meyer - it may take time but it will pay off with more goals, even if Zaha leaves.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 17 Dec 19 4.18pm

Meyer, is a talent, still young enough to develop further. He can influence games , as he did ,last night.
But as of yet, and this is his second season with Palace, he has rarely if ever been able to keep himself in the game when started.
Brighton ,had run themselves down a fair bit ,when he came on last night, and not for the first time when in that situation he performed as his natural talent allowed. He is a good player there is little doubt.
But for the minute at his best ,when used as an impact sub.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Dec 19 9.14pm

He did Ok when he came on but we got back into the game because Zaha pulled rabbit out of the hat from (an otherwise terrible) Luka's great ball. No other reason.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (20 Dec 2019 9.15pm)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Dec 19 1.25am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He did Ok when he came on but we got back into the game because Zaha pulled rabbit out of the hat from (an otherwise terrible) Luka's great ball. No other reason.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (20 Dec 2019 9.15pm)

I should stickclear of football management mate

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 21 Dec 19 7.37am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I should stickclear of football management mate

Careful DWR you know what triple Rs like.
He'll give it ya.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 12.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He did Ok when he came on but we got back into the game because Zaha pulled rabbit out of the hat from (an otherwise terrible) Luka's great ball. No other reason.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (20 Dec 2019 9.15pm)

But that's exactly how most teams score, Zaha isn't a magic wand he is part of our team, when Messi scores the winner in a dull game do their fans say it was because he pulled a rabbit out? ..Leicester City exactly the same with Vardy!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 12.30pm

Originally posted by RyWa

How Max doesn't get a start is beyond me.
The game changed the second he came on.
He links up so well with Wilf down the left and has done since he's been here.
We are a team that struggles for goals, largely in part from lack of creativity, he has bundles of it.
You could feel the buzz in ground whenever he got on the ball tonight.
He may not be great every game, but neither is Wilf, however I really belive he should be in the 11.
I also think Luka needs to be dropped for Mccarthy as he's had a shocker so far this year

This Brighton game was the first time he really made an impression that's why.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 21 Dec 19 12.45pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I should stickclear of football management mate

Just my opinion that Meyer did quite well when he came on but until Wilfs moment of individual brilliance we were beaten. Brighton then seemed to lose belief and we gained it, partcularly Benteke and Ayew.

Don’t think I’m any less (or more) qualified than anyone else on these boards to pass judgement but thanks for the insight anyway.

Football’s a simple game over thought by too many and I’d prefer to trust what I see. The points made above by others about Meyer’s contribution (or lack of) out of possession and his lack of energy / impact when starting are very fair IMO. He was played in an advance midfield position against Colchester and was rubbish.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 21 Dec 19 12.47pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

But that's exactly how most teams score, Zaha isn't a magic wand he is part of our team, when Messi scores the winner in a dull game do their fans say it was because he pulled a rabbit out? ..Leicester City exactly the same with Vardy!

I think he’s as close to a magic wand as any Palace team has had in my lifetime.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 12.58pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Just my opinion that Meyer did quite well when he came on but until Wilfs moment of individual brilliance we were beaten. Brighton then seemed to lose belief and we gained it, partcularly Benteke and Ayew.

Don’t think I’m any less (or more) qualified than anyone else on these boards to pass judgement but thanks for the insight anyway.

Football’s a simple game over thought by too many and I’d prefer to trust what I see. The points made above by others about Meyer’s contribution (or lack of) out of possession and his lack of energy / impact when starting are very fair IMO. He was played in an advance midfield position against Colchester and was rubbish.

Zaha allowed Phillips the opportunity to score the winner in that final against Watford, nothing has ever changed since ..Meyer is much much too weak when challenged on the ball, given space and room to move he is very able though, not many teams are going to allow him time, everything you say is correct.

 

mattteo Flag 26 Dec 19 5.23pm

What did you think of him today??

Problem is that he is really just 1 thing:attacking midfielder. He definitely isn't a right winger and can't really be an amazing central.midfielder.

He used to be a really good attacking midfielder in his youth in the Bundesliga, but then they pulled him down to central midfielder position and he lost his touch for goals or creating them.

He's been tried on several position since he arrived at Palace, but team doesn't really play with an attacking midfielder behind the main striker, so he's mostly forced on the wings. Shows touches of grandeur, but considering that he has the highest or second highest salary in the squad+ he could bring he club some money too if sold (I'd say he still has decent value in Germany and could bring in 10 million), would it be bad if he got sold in the winter?

I mean, with adequate replacement. A very similar attack minded player like Ryan Christie for example seems younger and in a much better mental and physical condition and would not cost more than 15 million, coming on a smaller salary than Meyer. What do you think? Would you still have patience with Max?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 26 Dec 19 5.33pm

Originally posted by mattteo

What did you think of him today??

Problem is that he is really just 1 thing:attacking midfielder. He definitely isn't a right winger and can't really be an amazing central.midfielder.

He used to be a really good attacking midfielder in his youth in the Bundesliga, but then they pulled him down to central midfielder position and he lost his touch for goals or creating them.

He's been tried on several position since he arrived at Palace, but team doesn't really play with an attacking midfielder behind the main striker, so he's mostly forced on the wings. Shows touches of grandeur, but considering that he has the highest or second highest salary in the squad+ he could bring he club some money too if sold (I'd say he still has decent value in Germany and could bring in 10 million), would it be bad if he got sold in the winter?

I mean, with adequate replacement. A very similar attack minded player like Ryan Christie for example seems younger and in a much better mental and physical condition and would not cost more than 15 million, coming on a smaller salary than Meyer. What do you think? Would you still have patience with Max?

I'll tell you what I like - always available, looks up and links play quickly. One of my favourite players as he can create something.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Dec 19 5.58pm

Agreed. I watch him on the pitch and always want the ball to him. The other players need to get faith (like in Zaha) and he will do really well.

Originally posted by chris123

I'll tell you what I like - always available, looks up and links play quickly. One of my favourite players as he can create something.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 26 Dec 19 6.03pm

He did quite well today, but he is not a winger and Ayew looked far more threatening when he moved out there. He still has to prove he's worth his wage if you ask me, but I think a big issue is he just doesn't fit our system. I wouldn't sell him in January though given Camarassa is surely leaving and we only have about 13 fit outfield players now.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 26 Dec 19 6.04pm

Always looking to pass the ball forward in the first half and does link up play well . Second half as the game became stretched he lost his way a bit which was surprising as when he comes on late in games he looks half decent .

The Jury's still out, we all want our players to do well but if what we are seeing now is it I would sell . Needs to improve

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 26 Dec 19 6.08pm

I really like Max and with a different manager, I think he would be an automatic starter. Roy likes his midfielders to be more defensive minded. With a run of games I really think he could offer us something different, and be an assister for us.

Roy sees it differently and you can't argue with him. Think he's been top class since he's been at palace, considering he's had nowhere near the budget that Pardew and Allardyce had.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Dec 19 6.16pm

Agreed! Love him. Alwasys looking to pass forward. He should be in every game, either as a starter or a sub.

Originally posted by sotac464

I really like Max and with a different manager, I think he would be an automatic starter. Roy likes his midfielders to be more defensive minded. With a run of games I really think he could offer us something different, and be an assister for us.

Roy sees it differently and you can't argue with him. Think he's been top class since he's been at palace, considering he's had nowhere near the budget that Pardew and Allardyce had.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 26 Dec 19 6.25pm

Best attacking performance for many months. Not a coincidence that Max started. He's a genuine game changer for us. He gives us that bit of quality in midfield to help unlock defences.

 

Page 23 of 27 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread