You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.


Page 23 of 140 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Oct 23 4.10pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

It is not an exaggeration to say that people who are pro-Palestine, in any political sense, are pro-Hamas.

Hamas is the elected government of the currently prominent chunk of Palestine.

Yes it is. It is like saying I am ad item with the Tories who are elected but not by me.

Equating the 2 serves only to assuage your conscience and allows you to support Israel without reservation and irrespective of what they do.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Oct 23 4.26pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

We are lucky to have a Hamas missile expert to guide us on this. BY the way, if the missile was fired by Islamic State in Palestine do they use the same missile as Hamas, expert advice please.

The post incident photos show no crater but a fast huge fire such as might be caused by rocket propellant igniting.

I am not a missile expert like some here but I know enough chemistry to understand what happens when you mix sugar and fertiliser

Edited by HKOwen (18 Oct 2023 11.27am)

Like I said I haven't a clue but Israel and the US know with some certainty. Trouble is both present such endless mis-info that nobody believes them, least of all the Islamic world.

Have an independent review by experts from eg Malaysia under UN auspices and perhaps it will serve as a colossal own goal for Jihadi Palestinians.

The only reasons they might not open their doors is the protection of secrets, or it will open the floodgates to further outside intervention for any future events. Actually I can quite understand the last one. However, based on pretty much every Israeli I have met, there will also be a strong helping of outsider hatred spiced up with a heavy dose of bloody minded arrogance and obstinacy.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Oct 23 4.33pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

Something about the whole “Gazans don’t support Hamas” thing doesn’t make much sense.

We’ve seen thousands of Palestinians are willing to die fighting for Hamas.

In Gaza, though, they live among the people. Why don’t we ever hear of people giving their lives to take them out?

The Catholic community in Northern Ireland didn't against the IRA and the protestant community didn't against the UVF/UDA.

Also, to say that the only innocent Palestinian is one who has taken up arms against Hamas is absurd. What of those who can't?

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 18 Oct 23 4.33pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I predict this post will not age well.

Looks like it aged perfectly well. Sorry the only monsters here are Hamas and their sympathizers.

Incompetent, maliciously motivated, and mentally ill people have arisen to key positions across all of the institutions and as a result things are breaking down left and right.

Astounding media screw up.

It was just an Islamic Jihad rocket that fell in a parking rocket.

The media flamed a global hysteria by uncritically laundering Hamas propaganda?

If the media didn’t do due diligence on a story of this magnitude, they can’t be trusted for anything.

The Middle East started protesting because they thought Israel had bombed the hospital parking lot.

Now that it’s likely to have been Islamists, nobody expects a wave of indignation against them.

There’s no winning over Arab public opinion as long as it’s this tribal.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 18 Oct 23 4.35pm

Originally posted by silvertop

The Catholic community in Northern Ireland didn't against the IRA and the protestant community didn't against the UVF/UDA.

Also, to say that the only innocent Palestinian is one who has taken up arms against Hamas is absurd. What of those who can't?

I think a better equivocation would be tribal support for Al Qaeda in the FATA. They may not be AQ, but they aid and abet AQ (see them as a their allies).

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Oct 23 4.54pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I predict this post will not age well.

Mmmm

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 18 Oct 23 5.00pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

Looks like it aged perfectly well. Sorry the only monsters here are Hamas and their sympathizers.

Incompetent, maliciously motivated, and mentally ill people have arisen to key positions across all of the institutions and as a result things are breaking down left and right.

Astounding media screw up.

It was just an Islamic Jihad rocket that fell in a parking rocket.

The media flamed a global hysteria by uncritically laundering Hamas propaganda?

If the media didn’t do due diligence on a story of this magnitude, they can’t be trusted for anything.

The Middle East started protesting because they thought Israel had bombed the hospital parking lot.

Now that it’s likely to have been Islamists, nobody expects a wave of indignation against them.

There’s no winning over Arab public opinion as long as it’s this tribal.

I mean I was talking about ageing for more than an hour - there is still nothing definitive to say what happened.

Why are you so convinced the Israeli version of events is true?

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 18 Oct 23 5.00pm

The United States can of course afford to fight with one hand tied behind its back. None of these places actually matter to the USA, and terrorism has always been such a small risk that one can treat it as a completely fake problem. It is actually an interesting moral question whether it would be worth forcing third world nations to accept Western institutions at the point of a gun, which would clearly be better for them in the long run, but the point is moot if we’re not willing to use the means to do so.

The delusion of neocons and counter-insurgency types was that this could be accomplished just by spending a lot of money rather than utilizing the kinds of tactics that Western leaders deployed when they used to actually win their wars.

Israel is a different story though. Its opponents pose an existential threat to its way of life. Despite this, the country has been remarkably restrained. All of the Palestinian civilians killed in the last fifty years don’t even come close to the number of lives lost in the US/coalition war on ISIS, much less the Second World War. This is primarily due to Israel facing a lot more scrutiny than most other nations would under similar circumstances.

That being said, Israel does not strike me as suicidal. The recent attack by Hamas has shocked the current conflict out of the now default war of choice framework and made it clearly a war of necessity. I expect Israel to do whatever it takes to at the very least either dismantle Hamas or establish a buffer zone between itself and the people of Gaza. If it does not, the problem will fester, and the Israelis will find themselves in the exact same position a few years down the line. It would be nice to believe that the Palestinian conflict could be solved by the stronger side being more accommodating towards its enemy. But there is little in the history of warfare, and certainly nothing in the doctrine of Hamas, to suggest this is a viable path forward. The choice faced by Israel is a tragic one, no matter how much in denial those currently calling for restraint are about this fact.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 18 Oct 23 5.12pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I mean I was talking about ageing for more than an hour - there is still nothing definitive to say what happened.

Why are you so convinced the Israeli version of events is true?

There are multiple vectors of intelligences and resources indicating that this was a faulty rocket launch, which is common, by PIJ a Hamas aligned insurgent group.

I just want to know what exact piece of evidence are the holdouts still waiting for? There's video, ELINT evidence, geolocation evidence, aftermath photos in daylight, audio recordings, and independent Pentagon confirmation. We're past the point of healthy skepticism.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Oct 23 5.14pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

The United States can of course afford to fight with one hand tied behind its back. None of these places actually matter to the USA, and terrorism has always been such a small risk that one can treat it as a completely fake problem. It is actually an interesting moral question whether it would be worth forcing third world nations to accept Western institutions at the point of a gun, which would clearly be better for them in the long run, but the point is moot if we’re not willing to use the means to do so.

The delusion of neocons and counter-insurgency types was that this could be accomplished just by spending a lot of money rather than utilizing the kinds of tactics that Western leaders deployed when they used to actually win their wars.

Israel is a different story though. Its opponents pose an existential threat to its way of life. Despite this, the country has been remarkably restrained. All of the Palestinian civilians killed in the last fifty years don’t even come close to the number of lives lost in the US/coalition war on ISIS, much less the Second World War. This is primarily due to Israel facing a lot more scrutiny than most other nations would under similar circumstances.

That being said, Israel does not strike me as suicidal. The recent attack by Hamas has shocked the current conflict out of the now default war of choice framework and made it clearly a war of necessity. I expect Israel to do whatever it takes to at the very least either dismantle Hamas or establish a buffer zone between itself and the people of Gaza. If it does not, the problem will fester, and the Israelis will find themselves in the exact same position a few years down the line. It would be nice to believe that the Palestinian conflict could be solved by the stronger side being more accommodating towards its enemy. But there is little in the history of warfare, and certainly nothing in the doctrine of Hamas, to suggest this is a viable path forward. The choice faced by Israel is a tragic one, no matter how much in denial those currently calling for restraint are about this fact.

The only reason America give a damn about Israel is because they are an Israel first government and have been incrementally for many decades now.

They pass laws to ban anything anti Israeli....it's a joke....they don't ban anything anti Iranian yet they are both semites. Israeli lobbies fund US politicians and interfere with the selection of respective ones.....something I regard as an unacceptable use of foreign influence.

What other reason would there be to risk a nuclear war? Why else would America care more about the fate of Israel compared to the fate of Yeman?

All this stuff about Israel being the US's greatest ally? What exactly are the US getting out of it? What do Israel do for the US other than giving it huge problems and taking money from it?

The US has been compromised out of its own interests and is being run into the ground by ideologs seemingly obsessed with getting into as many wars as possible.

None of this helps the common man and woman in America....that's meant to be the job of government.


Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Oct 2023 5.35pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Oct 23 5.17pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

There are multiple vectors of intelligences and resources indicating that this was a faulty rocket launch, which is common, by PIJ a Hamas aligned insurgent group.

I just want to know what exact piece of evidence are the holdouts still waiting for? There's video, ELINT evidence, geolocation evidence, aftermath photos in daylight, audio recordings, and independent Pentagon confirmation. We're past the point of healthy skepticism.

At this point, yep, it's certainly leaning towards Israels account being more likely to be true than not. Can't disagree there when Biden is being advised to publicly state as much.

As to your earlier posts – the monsters lie on both sides, not just one. This conflict has been going on far too long for there to be a 'good' side and a 'bad' one. They both bomb civilians. They both have/had terrorist factions in the past. They've both committed atrocities.

If you have a bias for one or the other 'side' (in your case Israel) then that's obviously fine, but state it clearly so the points you're making are put more into context.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Oct 23 5.27pm

Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye

The United States can of course afford to fight with one hand tied behind its back. None of these places actually matter to the USA, and terrorism has always been such a small risk that one can treat it as a completely fake problem. It is actually an interesting moral question whether it would be worth forcing third world nations to accept Western institutions at the point of a gun, which would clearly be better for them in the long run, but the point is moot if we’re not willing to use the means to do so.

The delusion of neocons and counter-insurgency types was that this could be accomplished just by spending a lot of money rather than utilizing the kinds of tactics that Western leaders deployed when they used to actually win their wars.

Israel is a different story though. Its opponents pose an existential threat to its way of life. Despite this, the country has been remarkably restrained. All of the Palestinian civilians killed in the last fifty years don’t even come close to the number of lives lost in the US/coalition war on ISIS, much less the Second World War. This is primarily due to Israel facing a lot more scrutiny than most other nations would under similar circumstances.

That being said, Israel does not strike me as suicidal. The recent attack by Hamas has shocked the current conflict out of the now default war of choice framework and made it clearly a war of necessity. I expect Israel to do whatever it takes to at the very least either dismantle Hamas or establish a buffer zone between itself and the people of Gaza. If it does not, the problem will fester, and the Israelis will find themselves in the exact same position a few years down the line. It would be nice to believe that the Palestinian conflict could be solved by the stronger side being more accommodating towards its enemy. But there is little in the history of warfare, and certainly nothing in the doctrine of Hamas, to suggest this is a viable path forward. The choice faced by Israel is a tragic one, no matter how much in denial those currently calling for restraint are about this fact.

As an American I think you might need to re-evaluate how significant your involvement with Israel and the region actually is not to your own country's influence, perception, power and economy, but also Globally. It certainly isn't a minor or insignificant issue. As you will find out over the next 50 years.

Also – you could swap Israel/Zionists and Palestine/Hamas around in your last paragraph and write it in response to where this conflict at pretty much any time between 1920-1950. Back then Palestinians were the stronger side.

Forget, choose to ignore or remain ignorant to the history of this conflict at your peril.

This is all one long disastrous chain of cause and effect.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 18 Oct 23 5.33pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Why do you think it appears highly likely? What’s that based on?

Numerous news reports.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Oct 23 5.37pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The only reason America give a damn about Israel is because they are an Israel first government and have been incrementally for many decades now.

They pass laws to ban anything anti Israeli....it's a joke....they don't ban anything anti Iranian yet they are both semites. Israeli lobbies fund US politicians and interfere with the selection of respective ones.....something I regard as an unacceptable use of foreign influence.

What other reason would there be to risk a nuclear war? Why else would America care more about the fate of Israel compared to the fate of Yeman?

All this stuff about Israel being the US's greatest ally? What exactly are the US getting out of it? What do Israel do for the US other than giving it huge problems and taking money from it?

The US has been compromised out of its own interests and is being run into the ground by ideologs seemingly obsessed with getting into as many wars as possible.

None of this helps the common man and woman in America....that's meant to the job of government.


Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Oct 2023 5.19pm)

Isn't it also to do with having a strong western proxy presence in the region against China and Russias allies such as Iran, Syria etc. Political posturing. Much like supporting Ukraine.

Israel don't have to do much for the US other than provide a very clear stance of western/US support which then by extension exerts some level of influence and leverage against Russian/Chinese influence in the region, as well as nearby Arab countries at a more local level.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Oct 23 5.46pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Isn't it also to do with having a strong western proxy presence in the region against China and Russias allies such as Iran, Syria etc. Political posturing. Much like supporting Ukraine.

Israel don't have to do much for the US other than provide a very clear stance of western/US support which then by extension exerts some level of influence and leverage against Russian/Chinese influence in the region, as well as nearby Arab countries at a more local level.

It's been going on long before these became factors.

You know the main reason is down to money and which groups with it will bat for their own side.

The trouble caused by being seen as Israeli first far outweigh any balancing act in the region. In fact it's a reality that Israel make it far harder for America to have better relations in the Arab world.

It's one of the reasons (though not the only one) why the Arab countries are siding with BRICs.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Oct 2023 5.47pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Oct 23 5.47pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Numerous news reports.

Including the BBC!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Oct 23 5.53pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Now appears highly likely that Hamas fired rockets at their own hospital. What lovely people some on here support.

With all sorts of partisan nonsense flying around let's keep things accurate

...accidentally fired rockets at their own hospital. If deliberate the Israelis would be the first to claim it and shout it from the rooftops. Currently they claim to have and have released audio to support the misfire/accident theory.

It doesn't make it any better, but an accident is not the same as a deliberate act of self-destruction, massacring ones own population holed up in a hospital, which is what you're inferring.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Oct 23 5.59pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's been going on long before these became factors.

You know the main reason is down to money and which groups with it will bat for their own side.

The trouble caused by being seen as Israeli first far outweigh any balancing act in the region. In fact it's a reality that Israel make it far harder for America to have better relations in the Arab world.

It's one of the reasons (though not the only one) why the Arab countries are siding with BRICs.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Oct 2023 5.47pm)

Money sure, but I do think there's more importance than you're suggesting in having a strong ally in that region. I'd certainly have expected the US to distance itself from Israel over the last few decades if that wasn't the case.

I agree with you that there are clear negatives but the positives must outweigh them in this case.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 18 Oct 23 6.00pm

I would contend that I am not so much pro-Israel or anti-Palestine. I am pro-west (in a cultural/Liberal/democracy sense), pro-enlightenment and pro-human. Israel is just a better steward of these lands than any arab or muslim country would be. The saying, "if the arabs put down their weapons there would be peace, and if the jews put down their weapons there would be genocide" is just simply true. This is the world we live in. A world of historical consequences ranging from the end of the Ottoman Empire at WWI, the end of WWII, the holocaust and so forth.

Just as an individual can do whatever he wants until he intrudes on the rights or interests of others, countries should be left alone as long as they mind their own business. But states are often run by leaders who achieve and maintain power by violating the rights of others. Maybe there is a practical or utilitarian case for applying the principle of sovereign equality to a state like North Korea and declaring Kim Jung Un the ultimate representative of the people he imprisons and starves, but there certainly isn’t a straightforward deontological case for it.

In the area of geopolitics, we often find ourselves falling back to utilitarianism, and dispensing with talk of rights all together. All states are inherently suspect as moral entities, with some being better or worse than others. And individuals generally have zero control over what policies their governments adopt, making the doctrine of collective responsibility just as pernicious here as it is in the frameworks of wokes and Marxists.

That brings us to the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. Some will talk of the “right” of Israel to defend itself, or the “right” of Palestinian self-determination. But Israel’s right to defend itself means killing a lot of innocent people. And the Palestinian right to self-determination is just a fancy way of saying men with guns telling other people what to do because of where they happen to live, which given the record of Arabs I’m sure they would screw up much more than most other states have.

With utilitarianism, we might at least hope to make some progress, unlike what tends to happen when we engage in endless debates about who has the right to do what.

All reasonable people agree that Hamas is a bad actor, and both sides would be better off if they no longer had power. The problem is that they hide among civilians, and there’s no way to eliminate them without causing a lot of pain to innocent third parties. There’s also the question of what comes afterwards, and who exactly ends up governing Gaza.

The recent attack has in any event shown that the status quo is untenable, by making it impossible to deny the ultimate ambitions of Hamas, while reminding us that their capabilities are likely to only increase over time. Israel has tried the path of seeking to ensure that Gazans suffer as little as possible for the actions of their government, based on the theory that they are not responsible for what Hamas does. This moral intuition is correct, but it does not give guidance regarding how to go forward.

That doesn’t necessarily mean that Israel should accept casualties that high. But what is missing from current discussions is that getting rid of Hamas has potentially massive benefits down the line for future generations of Israelis and Palestinians alike.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Oct 23 6.04pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

With all sorts of partisan nonsense flying around let's keep things accurate

...accidentally fired rockets at their own hospital. If deliberate the Israelis would be the first to claim it and shout it from the rooftops. Currently they claim to have and have released audio to support the misfire/accident theory.

It doesn't make it any better, but an accident is not the same as a deliberate act of self-destruction, massacring ones own population holed up in a hospital, which is what you're inferring.

They could knock up that audio easily.

Personally I don't think it matters that much. People will believe whatever side they support. The middle east is extremely angry and the truth of it is secondly.

I don't offer an opinion, it could be all of the above there's no way to be certain at this point.

As soon as they go into Gaza with tanks Hezbollah will invade from the north....Maybe Egypt get involved, Jordan?....It's a frigging nightmare.

I'll say it again just hope the Samson option isn't real.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 23 of 140 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.