This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Which leader could? We will have to agree to disagree on basing our military involvement, economic downgrading and possible deaths upon 'what ifs'. Like my point earlier Hrolf, what you are essentially saying here is our state's position. But our state told us lies on Iraq, Libya and Syria just to name three recent wars....they fecked it up in all those countries. The media was full of commentary on all of those wars none of which ended up as the result or reality. None of these feckers are honest, Putin or Biden or Sunak or any of them. They all lie and paint themselves as the saints and their opposition as sinners. No, they are all pawns playing their own power games and selective morality is their calling card. Why would you ever echo their position and opinions now? Especially when this particular war affects us both economically and in risk of death. I think our leaders have taken us down several bad directions all of which are worsening our lives. But as they control the megaphone and there is no one effectively challenging them. The public just resorts to the 'go along to get along' that is effectively universal majority human behaviour. To quote: 'The whole system revolves around the idea that the majority can be made to believe anything so long as it is repeated loudly and often and it works.' (Edward Snowdon)
I have no faith or trust in our leaders. They probably judge their adversaries by their own standards, and are right to do so. Put simply. Putin cannot be trusted. We won't negotiate with anyone until we have a strong position. You either negotiate when you are about to lose or win. That is how it works.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I have no faith or trust in our leaders. They probably judge their adversaries by their own standards, and are right to do so. Put simply. Putin cannot be trusted. We won't negotiate with anyone until we have a strong position. You either negotiate when you are about to lose or win. That is how it works. That's was Hitler's position in 44/45....it didn't work out very well. I know I'm not going to change your mind on this and so regard this as not me arguing with you but just me putting my points across to a warrior who has spent time in the forum's trenches with me. I say how about not putting ourselves into this corner in the first place and negotiating a deal back in March instead of stopping one....Which leads to Russia deciding to annex south and east Ukraine.....once again, an escalation begets an escalation. Now we are forced to push them out of Ukraine with all the expense and risk of doing that.....and I don't need to tell you the risk of humiliating Russia. If people support this they also have to support the cost that comes from it. I don't.....I will moan like feck about the cost of living and I will have that leg to stand on because I never supported this nor lockdowns. Anyone who did has to accept that they supported those consequences. However, I still don't think many people are joining the dots on this....they think this war and the economy are separate things just as with covid. With Putin I can only say that judgements should be evidence based. Putin was talking about war over Ukraine for over a decade Hrolf, you should go watch the Oliver Stone interview from years ago. This was well known to those tracking it. Putin has been Russian leader for over twenty years, he offered help to the west over 9/11 and wasn't anti western until we started bombing the Serbs. In my view the west completely fecked up that relationship....one that I view more important than China as they are actually European.....Now we have created a Russia/China power block against us. Not exactly what I'd call the smartest outcome. There is no upside to this....imagine if Nato/Ukraine win....just how long do you think our own gas pipelines would last Hrolf. The problem with escalation is that the other guy gets to move as well and when you're fighting nuclear states there is no real prospect of a total win.....anyone who doesn't think this ends in a deal that Russia can live with just isn't being realistic. I come from a military family, like many use to, but I've rather that my risk of death was traded for something that benefited me or my country in some tangible way. All this is fighting for is for pride parades in Kiev and lower living standards.....Not for me.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
[Tweet Link]
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
[Tweet Link]Indeed. But why is this not mainstream news? It really was going to happen, even if Russia didn't invade Ukraine. Nobody believes Fox media, it's tv's equivalent to The Sun. But how come the Guardian or The Times, for example, don't report this? And why don't people ask themselves why they don't hear or read about this on MSM? Maybe it's just another inconvenient truth to the Putin/Russia haters.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Rather weird logic by Putin. If Ukraine wanted to be part of Russia, they could have agreed that around a table without a shot being fired. If you say so. I suspect you don't understand the Russian mentality, nor the history of how power has been grasped over generations. I didn't say that Ukrainians were crying out for Russians to take over, simply that Putin didn't believe they would die to repel them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
If you say so. I suspect you don't understand the Russian mentality, nor the history of how power has been grasped over generations. I didn't say that Ukrainians were crying out for Russians to take over, simply that Putin didn't believe they would die to repel them. That is certainly possible. How wrong he was.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
That's was Hitler's position in 44/45....it didn't work out very well. I know I'm not going to change your mind on this and so regard this as not me arguing with you but just me putting my points across to a warrior who has spent time in the forum's trenches with me. I say how about not putting ourselves into this corner in the first place and negotiating a deal back in March instead of stopping one....Which leads to Russia deciding to annex south and east Ukraine.....once again, an escalation begets an escalation. Now we are forced to push them out of Ukraine with all the expense and risk of doing that.....and I don't need to tell you the risk of humiliating Russia. If people support this they also have to support the cost that comes from it. I don't.....I will moan like feck about the cost of living and I will have that leg to stand on because I never supported this nor lockdowns. Anyone who did has to accept that they supported those consequences. However, I still don't think many people are joining the dots on this....they think this war and the economy are separate things just as with covid. With Putin I can only say that judgements should be evidence based. Putin was talking about war over Ukraine for over a decade Hrolf, you should go watch the Oliver Stone interview from years ago. This was well known to those tracking it. Putin has been Russian leader for over twenty years, he offered help to the west over 9/11 and wasn't anti western until we started bombing the Serbs. In my view the west completely fecked up that relationship....one that I view more important than China as they are actually European.....Now we have created a Russia/China power block against us. Not exactly what I'd call the smartest outcome. There is no upside to this....imagine if Nato/Ukraine win....just how long do you think our own gas pipelines would last Hrolf. The problem with escalation is that the other guy gets to move as well and when you're fighting nuclear states there is no real prospect of a total win.....anyone who doesn't think this ends in a deal that Russia can live with just isn't being realistic. I come from a military family, like many use to, but I've rather that my risk of death was traded for something that benefited me or my country in some tangible way. All this is fighting for is for pride parades in Kiev and lower living standards.....Not for me.
I understand your desire to avoid escalation. I can only see that happening when Putin realises that the West is not going to just let him destroy Ukraine without massive losses. Showing weakness has a very poor success rate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That is certainly possible. How wrong he was. Ukraine use enforced conscription. Let's not forget that they banned men from leaving the country back at the start of the war. Along with all the other stuff they banned. In the south and east Ukrainian areas that they still occupy that would have meant forcing pro Russians to fight as well. It's not really as romantic a situation when people learn that not all Ukrainians hate Russians....the western media feed the Polish western Ukrainian view of this war when it shouldn't be forgotten that at least half of the south and east of the country rebelled and fought in a civil war once that 2014 coup happened.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I understand your desire to avoid escalation. I can only see that happening when Putin realises that the West is not going to just let him destroy Ukraine without massive losses. Showing weakness has a very poor success rate. Well, that's exactly how Putin is going to see it as well. I just hope that some kind of settlement is reached sooner rather than later.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
If you say so. I suspect you don't understand the Russian mentality, nor the history of how power has been grasped over generations. I didn't say that Ukrainians were crying out for Russians to take over, simply that Putin didn't believe they would die to repel them. There is a lot of background on how it all came about. There was an important article back at the start of the war that detailed how Putin was receiving inaccurate information from his intelligence services about the Ukrainian army.....Essentially while Kherson was willing not to fight most cities in Ukraine fell in line with Keiv. Kherson being in the south of course....again, the difference between the east/south of Ukraine and the west/centre is vitally important to understanding the real picture of that country. What we in the west are presented with is a very curated picture that only shows the anti Russian perspective. Once again, I have to stress that people in the south and east felt so strongly against what was happening that military units were prepared to fight and die against the very people we think represent what Ukraine is. Yet that's just completely ignored.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I'm surprised this hasn't been bumped earlier. Lots of sabre-rattling by USA, Russia, China and Balkan states. Lots of countries aligning themselves to one side or tother.
Ironically It's very Soviet. Just hope we get away from this without the virtue signalling morons blowing us up.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
At the start of this there were Russian refugees fleeing Ukrainian units in the Donbass, so point taken. But the idea that you can invade a whole country Ukraine because of this, labelling Ukrainians who probably haven't a clue about the Donbass, as fascists and traitors etc. that you are somehow liberating them as brothers I mean has Russia got dementia. I'll just blow up your appartment block so you see our point of view. You sense Russians want this over yet have no idea that they themselves must end it.
I suspect you may be right however I'd suggest they are struggling to identify a way out that saves face both domestically and (to now a very limited extent) internationally as opposed to knowing the responsibility lies with themselves. Just my take not any strong assertion of that being truth. A lot of what Putin says seems to be a diverting of attention to the West which may be some sort of attempt to find wiggle room for out however his insistence on a narrative to justify the invasion seems at best weak if not bizarre. Problem is now that an attritional stalemate has been reached and he still needs to create the guise of domestic support even if it becomes implausible to retain. I suspect Russians are being told that they support the 'special military operation' more than actually holding that sentiment themselves. As to whether or not that tactic still works I have no idea (or if it really has done previously). I still also suspect he thought it'd be a rollover and he could just dress it up as he wishes with the West unwilling to risk a very dangerous confrontation over Ukraine. It has not played out that way unfortunately (for him of course) and I now think he and his cronies are still plotting, probably day by day, how best to resolve all this madness. My primary fear still lies with something going abruptly wrong, or someone makes an incontrovertibly wrong, provocative and/or disastrous move that see warheads fly. Expecting Russia to recant and withdraw immediately seems delusional but equally I don't think they really intend to push this much farther. The best I am hoping for is any small or even medium sized crumb they can paint up as 'mission accomplished' and pave the way for an end to emerge. We shall see I suppose.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I'm surprised this hasn't been bumped earlier. Lots of sabre-rattling by USA, Russia, China and Balkan states. Lots of countries aligning themselves to one side or tother. I honestly thought that read squirt results after love island.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.