This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
With all sorts of partisan nonsense flying around let's keep things accurate ...accidentally fired rockets at their own hospital. If deliberate the Israelis would be the first to claim it and shout it from the rooftops. Currently they claim to have and have released audio to support the misfire/accident theory. It doesn't make it any better, but an accident is not the same as a deliberate act of self-destruction, massacring ones own population holed up in a hospital, which is what you're inferring. Killing civilians is something that Israel, on the whole, does by accident and that Hamas, on the whole, does on purpose.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
With all sorts of partisan nonsense flying around let's keep things accurate ...accidentally fired rockets at their own hospital. If deliberate the Israelis would be the first to claim it and shout it from the rooftops. Currently they claim to have and have released audio to support the misfire/accident theory. It doesn't make it any better, but an accident is not the same as a deliberate act of self-destruction, massacring ones own population holed up in a hospital, which is what you're inferring. I think you may be missing a point…Hamas were very quick to say Israel had hit the hospital when they knew that it was an accident from their side. Might have been best to keep quiet for a bit.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Money sure, but I do think there's more importance than you're suggesting in having a strong ally in that region. I'd certainly have expected the US to distance itself from Israel over the last few decades if that wasn't the case. I agree with you that there are clear negatives but the positives must outweigh them in this case. I'm not seeing that myself. In my view money and a rather extreme over representative presence in powerful positions might have far more to do with that. It's far more trouble than any worth otherwise.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
They could knock up that audio easily. Personally I don't think it matters that much. People will believe whatever side they support. The middle east is extremely angry and the truth of it is secondly. I don't offer an opinion, it could be all of the above there's no way to be certain at this point. As soon as they go into Gaza with tanks Hezbollah will invade from the north....Maybe Egypt get involved, Jordan?....It's a frigging nightmare. I'll say it again just hope the Samson option isn't real. This is true, and it did cross my mind. But if they could doctor it they'd have made it so it came across as a deliberate act. It could also be rehashed old audio. But... I'm inclined to lean towards their version of events more now leaders appear to be convinced enough to declare it likely. But let's see. I also agree that in terms of who did it, it doesn't really matter that much, what matters is both sides are at the same s*** and have been for eons. I do think you're a bit paranoid re. nuclear, both on this and Ukraine. The chance of that being used is very very small. Agreed that the last thing this conflict needs is Lebanon getting drawn in. Hopefully this is what the US is communicating and as a result a full scale ground offensive simply won't materialise.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
I think you may be missing a point…Hamas were very quick to say Israel had hit the hospital when they knew that it was an accident from their side. Might have been best to keep quiet for a bit. Nope 'When they knew that it was an accident' I mean, do you know that in the immediate aftermath they knew this for certain? Unless their commanders were the ones firing the rocket I think it unlikely. They undoubtably know it by now. Or maybe those that did fire it off are still denying it to save their own skin? My take would be that considering how fast they rushed to claim the strike, and the complete chaos and confusion of the situation, the higher ups would not have known either way, and just gone hard on it immediately to try and gain an advantage. It pays to be the first mover in communications. Also highly unlikely they'd have expected it to be their own side... I can see why they'd want to pounce on it straight away. If it's proven (or at least made it hard to think otherwise)to have been them, I wouldn't want to be the person that fired the trigger. Don't think they'll be around for long. Despite all that, Hamas will never admit to it. In the same way I'd think it would be very hard for the Israelis to do so if they were responsible. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Oct 2023 6.18pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Killing civilians is something that Israel, on the whole, does by accident and that Hamas, on the whole, does on purpose. The history of this conflict completely contradicts this assertion. It's just not the case. Both sides are and have been guilty of it. By accident or otherwise.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
The history of this conflict completely contradicts this assertion. It's just not the case. Both sides are and have been guilty of it. By accident or otherwise. So what were the events of last Saturday - more Hamas 'accidents'?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
I would contend that I am not so much pro-Israel or anti-Palestine. I am pro-west (in a cultural/Liberal/democracy sense), pro-enlightenment and pro-human. Israel is just a better steward of these lands than any arab or muslim country would be. The saying, "if the arabs put down their weapons there would be peace, and if the jews put down their weapons there would be genocide" is just simply true. This is the world we live in. A world of historical consequences ranging from the end of the Ottoman Empire at WWI, the end of WWII, the holocaust and so forth. The Arabs look at Palestine a hundred years ago when the Ottomans owned it and see no Jewish ownership....then they look at now. I'm not sure how you square that circle....As they say a castle cannot brook a rival castle in the same land. One side has to win over the other. I fully agree, the Jews (most of which are mixed European) run that land far better than the Arabs....the reasons for which are many and varied. Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
Just as an individual can do whatever he wants until he intrudes on the rights or interests of others, countries should be left alone as long as they mind their own business. Now that would that be nice. But as we know it doesn't work like that. Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
But states are often run by leaders who achieve and maintain power by violating the rights of others. Maybe there is a practical or utilitarian case for applying the principle of sovereign equality to a state like North Korea and declaring Kim Jung Un the ultimate representative of the people he imprisons and starves, but there certainly isn’t a straightforward deontological case for it. In the area of geopolitics, we often find ourselves falling back to utilitarianism, and dispensing with talk of rights all together. All states are inherently suspect as moral entities, with some being better or worse than others. And individuals generally have zero control over what policies their governments adopt, making the doctrine of collective responsibility just as pernicious here as it is in the frameworks of wokes and Marxists. That brings us to the Israeli-Palestinian dispute. Some will talk of the “right” of Israel to defend itself, or the “right” of Palestinian self-determination. But Israel’s right to defend itself means killing a lot of innocent people. And the Palestinian right to self-determination is just a fancy way of saying men with guns telling other people what to do because of where they happen to live, which given the record of Arabs I’m sure they would screw up much more than most other states have. Well said. Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
With utilitarianism, we might at least hope to make some progress, unlike what tends to happen when we engage in endless debates about who has the right to do what. All reasonable people agree that Hamas is a bad actor, and both sides would be better off if they no longer had power. The problem is that they hide among civilians, and there’s no way to eliminate them without causing a lot of pain to innocent third parties. There’s also the question of what comes afterwards, and who exactly ends up governing Gaza. It's no different to the Vietcong and the North Vietnamize. I can't imagine any of them are pro Israeli, but probably most of them are pro peace....everyone's caught up within the maelstrom going on around them. Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
The recent attack has in any event shown that the status quo is untenable, by making it impossible to deny the ultimate ambitions of Hamas, while reminding us that their capabilities are likely to only increase over time. Israel has tried the path of seeking to ensure that Gazans suffer as little as possible for the actions of their government, based on the theory that they are not responsible for what Hamas does. This moral intuition is correct, but it does not give guidance regarding how to go forward. That doesn’t necessarily mean that Israel should accept casualties that high. But what is missing from current discussions is that getting rid of Hamas has potentially massive benefits down the line for future generations of Israelis and Palestinians alike. It's intractable.....just hold onto your hat. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Oct 2023 6.25pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This is true, and it did cross my mind. But if they could doctor it they'd have made it so it came across as a deliberate act. It could also be rehashed old audio. But... I'm inclined to lean towards their version of events more now leaders appear to be convinced enough to declare it likely. But let's see. I also agree that in terms of who did it, it doesn't really matter that much, what matters is both sides are at the same s*** and have been for eons. I do think you're a bit paranoid re. nuclear, both on this and Ukraine. The chance of that being used is very very small. Agreed that the last thing this conflict needs is Lebanon getting drawn in. Hopefully this is what the US is communicating and as a result a full scale ground offensive simply won't materialise. Let's hope for that outcome.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
I think you may be missing a point…Hamas were very quick to say Israel had hit the hospital when they knew that it was an accident from their side. Might have been best to keep quiet for a bit. Haters ofIsrael were also very quick to believe Hamas weren’t they! Both sides using propaganda so best wait until facts are known before condemning.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
So what were the events of last Saturday - more Hamas 'accidents'? Er Rather obviously not? Not sure what your point is, other than the inability to contribute in a balanced way because you’ve picked a side. Both sides have committed atrocities of varying scales in recent and historical times throughout the lengthy run of this conflict. To simply dismiss that and frame Israel as good and Palestinians as evil is absolutely ridiculous. And demonstrably untrue. Edited by SW19 CPFC (18 Oct 2023 6.47pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Fortunately, neither of us have to make such enormous life and death decisions. It's easy to be an armchair lefty, but the reality is that the responsibility for a nation's security sometimes means that you have to take drastic action when outcomes can only be speculated about and are not in history books. There will never be peace on this Earth while humans occupy it. LOLE Hyperbolic much? I think you need to do some detailed reading about how WWII ended. I have no issue with drastic action, none at all, so long as it’s proportionate and protective of civilian lives wherever possible. Clearly you do not agree with that view? Hamas attacks, Dresden and the depth and intensity of the ongoing Israeli response are neither proportionate or protective. As for peace - what are you trying to come across as there, some sort of preacher? An enlightened lecturer in the profound? Pfft One can accept the folly and inevitability of war and still criticise how others choose to engage in it. The two things are not incompatible - otherwise you’re saying unless you’re some sort of peace loving hippy you can’t pass comment. Bit odd
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
One of my formative memories growing up was coming home early from high school on 9/11 (due to early dismissal) and watching the Palestinians on the West Bank celebrate the murder of 2300 Americans on the news channels with my father. I didn't know much about the world back then other than NFL stats and players, but I saw 10-15 year old kids celebrating like they had won the world cup....over the murder of innocents. There are people and cultures who revel in war crimes—and who do not hide these crimes or their celebration of them but, rather, proudly broadcast their savagery for all the world to see. Islamist death cults such as Hamas and ISIS are modern examples of this. Conversely, there are people and cultures who have given us the concept of a war crime as a sacred prohibition—and as a safeguard in the ongoing project of maintaining the moral progress of civilization. One point to concede, and this will absorb all the nuance and nonsense that is now percolating in the brains of annoying leftists: It is, of course, true that we in the West have been on the wrong side of these dichotomies in the past. Most Western armies, including Israel’s, have at one time or another been guilty of war crimes. And if you go back far enough, all of human conflict was just a litany of war crimes. And you don’t have to go back all that far, in fact, to find large pockets of Western culture that were morally indistinguishable from what we now see in much of the Muslim world. If you have any doubt about this, study the photos of white mobs celebrating the lynching's that occurred in the American South in the first half of the 20th century: where seemingly whole towns—thousands of men, women and children—turned out as though for a carnival to watch some young man or woman be tortured to death and then strung up on a tree or lamppost for all to see. Seeing the pictures of these people in their Sunday best, having arranged themselves for a postcard photo under a dangling, and lacerated, and often partially cremated person, is one thing, but realize that these genteel people—who considered themselves good Christians—often took souvenirs of the body home to show their friends—teeth, ears, fingers, knee caps, internal organs—and sometimes displayed them in their places of business.
Absolutely agree re moral difference. However it doesn’t simply erase either sides crimes and atrocities either. Hamas might be the worst of it now but you should read up on the history of this conflict before tying yourself in knots. Specifically regarding Palestinian terrorist factions AND Zionist ones. It might iron you out a little. Also your point about how removing Hamas will solve all the ills in this conflict? It should be done, but your suggestion, especially as an American, that this will create some sort of resolution is pure fantasy and history clearly shows why.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
There is a picture going around of the crater and damage it caused. People talk about the hospital explosion story being a loss for the media, and it certainly is, but what a win for prediction markets. Pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli accounts both made plausible sounding arguments. (Though anyone with brain cells should have noted this was likely Hamas propaganda) With the prediction markets only one side was willing to risk their own money, and they were right. Leftists hate betting and prediction markets, like all markets. Even though they provide truth and knowledge, because they involve money they must be evil. Good way also for them to never have to be proven wrong about anything, which leftists always are.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Absolutely agree re moral difference. However it doesn’t simply erase either sides crimes and atrocities either. Hamas might be the worst of it now but you should read up on the history of this conflict before tying yourself in knots. Specifically regarding Palestinian terrorist factions AND Zionist ones. It might iron you out a little. Also your point about how removing Hamas will solve all the ills in this conflict? It should be done, but your suggestion, especially as an American, that this will create some sort of resolution is pure fantasy and history clearly shows why. You misread me my friend. A good act does not wash out the bad nor a bad act the good. Israeli settlers in the west bank do not help Israel's situation or cause, in fact they harm it immensely. Zionist terrorism from the past is wrong, but lets live in the year we are living in. I do not believe in utopia, only tradeoffs and difficult choices. I have no love of Zionism as a construct or political theory, but what's done is done and Israel is here to stay and should be supported by the west given the alternatives. I don't have a one-sized fits all solution to sectarian conflicts in the middle-east. Its not lost on me that America made a mess about Iraq. The best we can do have is get back to thawing ties between Israel and her Arab neighbors via the Abraham accords. The biggest fallout from this is KSA suspending the normalization of relations with Israel. Of course the suspension of normalizing relations only benefits the one country, one country who benefits from this violence and conflict - the mullahs' in Iran. Israel and KSA normalizing relations would have isolated Iran and her proxies. We are living through interesting times.
|
|
|
The most powerful man in the world. And he can't even get fuel supplies to keep hospitals going. -.-'
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.