This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
They're a joke of a protest movement with blood on their hands.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
They're a joke of a protest movement with blood on their hands. Is it even a movement, it seems more like a hashtag that people use. Movements tend to have leaders, staff, volunteers, infrastructure etc. Its more like a protest catch phrase.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
They're a joke of a protest movement with blood on their hands. And so have US police departments by not holding officers accountable for excessive force and violation, and creating an environment and situation that massively favours police officers when facing disciplinary proceedings. As long as the police investigate themselves and have friendly prosecutors and close ranks, the police will always be 'above the law'.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
And so have US police departments by not holding officers accountable for excessive force and violation, and creating an environment and situation that massively favours police officers when facing disciplinary proceedings. As long as the police investigate themselves and have friendly prosecutors and close ranks, the police will always be 'above the law'. Surely by now the "innocent Blacks" should have learnt their lesson and realised that the police ARE the law so will be protected by their own kind. It is pretty obvious by what we see ourselves on the news that the police NEED to be heavy handed out there and we should not be swayed by the poor little darlings families who say the shot person only had a book in their hand when shot by the police when in fact it WAS a gun as the police have stated. You must remember that the police have their own body cameras these days and the film is used in courts. It is all very sad when these people get shot but they must learn by the recent episodes that they must obey the law even if they are living in poverty which really is no excuse to carry a gun.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by susmik
Surely by now the "innocent Blacks" should have learnt their lesson and realised that the police ARE the law so will be protected by their own kind. It is pretty obvious by what we see ourselves on the news that the police NEED to be heavy handed out there and we should not be swayed by the poor little darlings families who say the shot person only had a book in their hand when shot by the police when in fact it WAS a gun as the police have stated. You must remember that the police have their own body cameras these days and the film is used in courts. It is all very sad when these people get shot but they must learn by the recent episodes that they must obey the law even if they are living in poverty which really is no excuse to carry a gun. Interestingly in areas where body cameras have been deployed, incidents of complaints against the police dropped around 80%, and incidents of brutality by the police dropped 60%. Problem is, and this is a key issue, its not a race thing. It just stands out as a race thing, because the Black Civil Rights movement is very powerful. The problem is that a surprisingly high number of Americans are being shot by the police, notably poor people it seems. What is disturbing is how when this is shown not to be a specifically racial issue, its deemed 'not a problem'. As if killing an equal proportion of unarmed white innocent people as black would justify killing unarmed innocent people. The problem isn't with racism in the Police. Its with Policing in the US, and the fact that oversight, accountability, financing, training and professional standards vary from 'good' to comical. Ok, its two incident, and its off John Oliver, so its limp wristed liberalism. But an account of officers who shot and killed someone, whilst still under investigation for a questionable shooting and an officer who got a job as an officer, after resigning rather than take a DUI test when drugs and booze were found in his car, at a different police force. Then when investigations are issued, they're typically in house, and prosecuted locally (where the police officers and prosecutors are closely involved). Policing in the US is a lottery.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by susmik
Surely by now the "innocent Blacks" should have learnt their lesson and realised that the police ARE the law so will be protected by their own kind. It is pretty obvious by what we see ourselves on the news that the police NEED to be heavy handed out there and we should not be swayed by the poor little darlings families who say the shot person only had a book in their hand when shot by the police when in fact it WAS a gun as the police have stated. You must remember that the police have their own body cameras these days and the film is used in courts. It is all very sad when these people get shot but they must learn by the recent episodes that they must obey the law even if they are living in poverty which really is no excuse to carry a gun. Not all police forces have body cameras. In fact very few do, and those that have trialled them, seem to want them. However the police unions and federations seem to be against them, along with political interests (it costs money). As for the gun. Its the US. Ownership of guns is not by default illegal. Having a gun doesn't make you a criminal by default.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
As for the gun. Its the US. Ownership of guns is not by default illegal. Having a gun doesn't make you a criminal by default.
Tamir Rice was sitting in a park, on his own, holding a toy gun. The police rolled right up to him in a cruiser and shot him within 2 seconds of coming to a stop. He never pointed the gun at the officer. This was in Ohio - an open-carry state - where Rice, even if he was carrying a real gun, was not breaking any law. This not only goes to show the terrible job the police do in many of these shooting situations, it also highlights the lunacy of open carry and how such a privilege is for whites only. Edited by Ray in Houston (04 Oct 2016 6.13pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Tamir Rice was sitting in a park, on his own, holding a toy gun. The police rolled right up to him in a cruiser and shot him within 2 seconds of coming to a stop. He never pointed the gun at the officer. This was in Ohio - an open-carry state - where Rice, even if he was carrying a real gun, was not breaking any law. This not only goes to show the terrible job the police do in many of these shooting situations, it also highlights the lunacy of open carry and how such a privilege is for whites only. Edited by Ray in Houston (04 Oct 2016 6.13pm) The police weren't told it was a toy gun, or that Tamir Rice was a juvenile. They turned up and this guy reaches for a gun (all sides agree this). Officer fires 2 shots. All evidence (cctv and the dispatchers failure to pass on relevant information) was put before a grand jury who decided not to prosecute. Although I admit that's not as catchy as "White cop kills black child"
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
The police weren't told it was a toy gun, or that Tamir Rice was a juvenile. They turned up and this guy reaches for a gun (all sides agree this). Officer fires 2 shots. All evidence (cctv and the dispatchers failure to pass on relevant information) was put before a grand jury who decided not to prosecute. Although I admit that's not as catchy as "White cop kills black child" Imitation fire arm, not a toy. The officer shot a 12 year old kid, holding a imitation gun, within 2 seconds of getting out of the car. If you think that's acceptable approach to policing and procedure - I don't think the police officer broke the law, but f**k me that some very shoddy procedure and process, to get straight out the car, and shoot. No attempt to contain the suspect, call in back up and control the situation. Ascertain the actual threat. Rather than Roy Rogers in like its some kind of action movie. That's the problem. Poor discipline, poor training The issue with the US is that there is this whole if you can legally defend it, its right and that feeds into the whole problem. I notice you left out the bit about the emotional stability of the shooting officer, who resigned rather than being recorded as unfit for duty, as a police officer in Independence. Or that his partner had a previous settled claim of excessive force against a woman. The shooting, from a legal position of criminal, is reasonable, but that's a long way from being acceptable, which was also the view of many expert witnesses. Whilst the two officers did not commit a criminal offence the County settled a lawsuit for 6m from the family (knowing that on a balance of evidence rather than reasonable doubt the county police department would not win the case - due to the greater scope of the offence). I don't think the officers are to guilty beyond reasonable doubt, but that the police department, its recruitment policies, its handling of shootings, training, its processes and procedures - particually with the handling of internal investigations of its own officers - were responsible for creating situations like this. And that's the problem in a nut shell.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Imitation fire arm, not a toy. The officer shot a 12 year old kid, holding a imitation gun, within 2 seconds of getting out of the car. If you think that's acceptable approach to policing and procedure - I don't think the police officer broke the law, but f**k me that some very shoddy procedure and process, to get straight out the car, and shoot. No attempt to contain the suspect, call in back up and control the situation. Ascertain the actual threat. Rather than Roy Rogers in like its some kind of action movie. That's the problem. Poor discipline, poor training The issue with the US is that there is this whole if you can legally defend it, its right and that feeds into the whole problem. I notice you left out the bit about the emotional stability of the shooting officer, who resigned rather than being recorded as unfit for duty, as a police officer in Independence. Or that his partner had a previous settled claim of excessive force against a woman. The shooting, from a legal position of criminal, is reasonable, but that's a long way from being acceptable, which was also the view of many expert witnesses. Whilst the two officers did not commit a criminal offence the County settled a lawsuit for 6m from the family (knowing that on a balance of evidence rather than reasonable doubt the county police department would not win the case - due to the greater scope of the offence). I don't think the officers are to guilty beyond reasonable doubt, but that the police department, its recruitment policies, its handling of shootings, training, its processes and procedures - particually with the handling of internal investigations of its own officers - were responsible for creating situations like this. And that's the problem in a nut shell. If I was a copper and I'm told there's a man with a gun (info the police dispatcher passed on) and as soon as I get out my car this dude goes for the gun, I'm gonna shoot him. I'm not going to try and Freddie Gray's family got a settlement before it went to court. People think the reason the city settled because it stopped riots which would have cost the city more. I remember thinking it would impact on the trial of the officers if the city has already paid out
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
If I was a copper and I'm told there's a man with a gun (info the police dispatcher passed on) and as soon as I get out my car this dude goes for the gun, I'm gonna shoot him. I'm not going to try and Which is why you shouldn't be a copper or police man without extensive training. You cannot operate and perform the role of a police officer whilst acting in the same way as an ordinary member of the public. Police officers have to be able to remain calm and in control, in dangerous situations. Which is, why like soldiers, they under go extensive specialised training in how to deal with specific situations most people will not encounter. I don't doubt the officer acted 'within the law'. The question is a) is this kind of police response acceptable. b) would this be acceptable if it was a different neighbourhood (such as a nice middle class area). Personally, I think we all know that if the police rolled out and shot down a nice kid from a nice middle class family with an airsoft pistol in the same circumstances, they'd be hell to pay. Originally posted by 7mins
Freddie Gray's family got a settlement before it went to court. People think the reason the city settled because it stopped riots which would have cost the city more. I remember thinking it would impact on the trial of the officers if the city has already paid out They settled because they knew they'd probably lose the case. They employed an officer whos previous employers had listed as unfit for duty, emotional unstable and a potential danger to life - and recorded that on his file - He'd only avoided being sacked (which would have made him unemployable) by resigning, and then Cleveland police never run a background check when recruiting him. Suggesting either they knew, and didn't care, or were negligent. There is no way they could have won a civil case. The officers managed to avoid charges really on a reasonable doubt basis. In civil court, on balance of probability, with a prior on one cop of excessive force against a woman, they were going be found culpable - which would have exposed their internal procedures, processes and training etc, opening them up for more law suits, possibly even a class action law suit if they were found to be negligent in their training, oversight, recruitment and protocol. That's why they settled for 6m.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
They settled because they knew they'd probably lose the case. They employed an officer whos previous employers had listed as unfit for duty, emotional unstable and a potential danger to life - and recorded that on his file - He'd only avoided being sacked (which would have made him unemployable) by resigning, and then Cleveland police never run a background check when recruiting him. Suggesting either they knew, and didn't care, or were negligent. There is no way they could have won a civil case. The officers managed to avoid charges really on a reasonable doubt basis. In civil court, on balance of probability, with a prior on one cop of excessive force against a woman, they were going be found culpable - which would have exposed their internal procedures, processes and training etc, opening them up for more law suits, possibly even a class action law suit if they were found to be negligent in their training, oversight, recruitment and protocol. That's why they settled for 6m. I disagree. If I copper shot a middle class kid there wouldn't be hell to pay. I would guess there would be no riots, no revenge shootings, no attacks on white people. If a copper is faced with a guy reaching for a gun, how does he "contain the situation"? Also is it fair to bring up a coppers past, but when Trayvon/Stirling/Browns past are brought up, BLM say it has zero relevance?
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
I disagree. If I copper shot a middle class kid there wouldn't be hell to pay. I would guess there would be no riots, no revenge shootings, no attacks on white people. If a copper is faced with a guy reaching for a gun, how does he "contain the situation"? Also is it fair to bring up a coppers past, but when Trayvon/Stirling/Browns past are brought up, BLM say it has zero relevance? any officer in a major city is trained on this very thing. tamir rice was shot by a rookie cop. it's pretty simple - you drive up and assess the situation. you don't drive up to 2 inches from the person when no one is around at all. get a safety distance to announce your presence. turn on your lights and siren. first order of business is to defuse when no one is in immiment danger.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
I disagree. If I copper shot a middle class kid there wouldn't be hell to pay. I would guess there would be no riots, no revenge shootings, no attacks on white people.
Your commentary and forthright views are shared by millions of Americans, all destined to vote for Donald Trump in next month's US Presidential election.
"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers" |
|
|
Originally posted by soulboy
Your commentary and forthright views are shared by millions of Americans, all destined to vote for Donald Trump in next month's US Presidential election. Cheap. What would you have done?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
I disagree. If I copper shot a middle class kid there wouldn't be hell to pay. I would guess there would be no riots, no revenge shootings, no attacks on white people. If a copper is faced with a guy reaching for a gun, how does he "contain the situation"? Also is it fair to bring up a coppers past, but when Trayvon/Stirling/Browns past are brought up, BLM say it has zero relevance? Bollocks - He'd be logging evidence if he was lucky, unless he had a very solid defence, and it would go to independent oversight, because the parents lawyer would force the issue. Chances are he'd lose his job and the degree to which the force closed ranks would be much lower, because the kids parents could afford to good lawyer. Justice costs in this world. Coppers Past - Yes, because a police officer is a representative of the state with the authority to utilise force. As such, their past is important - And very relivent when your previous employer, also a police department, was discharging you for being emotionally unstable. When employing anyone, their past and their suitability to the job, and their capacity is a vital factor in determining their employment. Being a police officer isn't just a job. I'm not saying BLM are automatically correct. However, and it seem to bear saying over and over again, there is a massive problem with police and police shootings (both of officers and civilians) in the US, which the police have virtually no accountability for. Of course, sometimes a police officer is going to have to make a call, and sometimes shoot. And the only way to determine whether that shooting was justified is to have a clear process of investigation and accountability - not just for the officer but also for the police department (in fact especially the department). Otherwise you end up with a situation where community trust and engagement with the police becomes stretched to the point of violence. The US doesn't even keep records of the number of civilans shot by the police each year.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
any officer in a major city is trained on this very thing. tamir rice was shot by a rookie cop. it's pretty simple - you drive up and assess the situation. you don't drive up to 2 inches from the person when no one is around at all. get a safety distance to announce your presence. turn on your lights and siren. first order of business is to defuse when no one is in immiment danger. What he said. Assess and respond to the situation in a manner that reduces the necessity for confrontation.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Tried a line of communication. Plus I'd have also kept in contact with the handler, and established everything they had to say. It worth noting that the dispatcher did not pass on the information that a) the caller reported it was a juvenile b) that the witness believed the gun to be a fake. Its also pretty important to not that the kid has been pointing the gun at people, but no shots have been fired, reports made of threatening behaviour or crimes committed. Its also important to note that the police report from the deputy chief did state that the child did not threaten the officers verbally, or physically. So the problem, I would say isn't with the officer per se, but the failure of the police department, which arguably also put an officer into potentially dangerous situation, which they arguably had a reasonable chance of getting shot (if we accept the counter argument).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Tried a line of communication. Plus I'd have also kept in contact with the handler, and established everything they had to say. It worth noting that the dispatcher did not pass on the information that a) the caller reported it was a juvenile b) that the witness believed the gun to be a fake. Its also pretty important to not that the kid has been pointing the gun at people, but no shots have been fired, reports made of threatening behaviour or crimes committed. Its also important to note that the police report from the deputy chief did state that the child did not threaten the officers verbally, or physically. So the problem, I would say isn't with the officer per se, but the failure of the police department, which arguably also put an officer into potentially dangerous situation, which they arguably had a reasonable chance of getting shot (if we accept the counter argument). Bulls***. You're a police officer arriving at a report of a man with a gun, he reaches for his gun, and you honestly think I'm gonna believe you're gonna strike up a conversation???? "I can't explain why officer Jamie died chief, suspect opened fire, and Jamie returned with small talk, but it didn't seem to work... it's a real head scratcher "
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.