This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
How very naive if you think this wasn't for a pay day. It's not the least naive. I listened to his testimony. It's my conclusion as a result. If you heard it to, and believe that getting something out of it was his motive, then you are very cynical. He freely admits his faults, and that he was both involved and stupid. That's the point. It's not the individuals who are caught up in it. It's a self-perpetuating culture that needs to change, Most people seem to get it. The only place I read from anyone who doesn't yet is here. What does that say about this place?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Hilarious. The old reclaiming gambit. What about the anti Semitism? Are you trying to ignore that by any chance? I would, you have already made a complete fool of yourself this week. always good for a free laugh
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It's not the least naive. I listened to his testimony. It's my conclusion as a result. If you heard it to, and believe that getting something out of it was his motive, then you are very cynical. He freely admits his faults, and that he was both involved and stupid. That's the point. It's not the individuals who are caught up in it. It's a self-perpetuating culture that needs to change, Most people seem to get it. The only place I read from anyone who doesn't yet is here. What does that say about this place? So you conclude it isn't for money! Why is he doing it then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Rafiq is allowed to reclaim the term if he wants to. It’s exactly the same as black people reclaiming the N word. Edited by DanH (18 Nov 2021 8.07pm) exactly the same.... yeah mate , sure. Show us the country named after that N word ? i feel sorry for you.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Let me make it plain, I don't put you in that category. There are though some, perhaps just a small number, who attitudes, and sometimes the links they provide, lead to the inescapable conclusion that "extreme-right" is the most accurate way to describe them. They would, of course, deny it. No-one believes they are extreme, especially when there are views held by people even more extreme than them. Views that are borderline certifiable. Tbh I'm not at all bothered but appreciate your statement.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
exactly the same.... yeah mate , sure. Show us the country named after that N word ? i feel sorry for you. Really thick aren’t you?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Hilarious. The old reclaiming gambit. What about the anti Semitism? Are you trying to ignore that by any chance? I would, you have already made a complete fool of yourself this week. Two wrongs don’t make a right do they? He’s used awful language in the past which doesn’t do him any favours whatsoever but it doesn’t make his case or testimony against Yorkshire any less valid. Cute how you think I’m the foolish one here. You’ve made a tit of yourself over and over again and have no self-awareness of it despite multiple people telling you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Tbh I'm not at all bothered but appreciate your statement. I think you have hit on what is a problem. There is at least one poster here who believes that the views he expresses were mainstream "conservatism" just a few decades ago, and that the "extreme-right" then were much further to the right. I don't believe that is remotely true. Mainstream "conservatism" for most of my life was centre-right. It had a social conscience and a heart. It occupied the middle ground and held power. Thatcher started the drift to the right, Major tried to steady the ship but when Blair stole the middle ground from them, out they went. When Labour lost their way again, Cameron moved back to the middle, partly because a coalition forced him to. Then came wishy-washy May and now the populist buffoon, Johnson. The extreme-right of today, both here and in the USA from where many of their ideas originate, are on a completely different level to anything I have witnessed before. Even Powell, who many regard as a prophetic hero, was moderate by comparison. So the problem is both perception and definition. No-one likes being described as an extremist. It has bad connotations. However, when views are expressed which are on the outer edge of that which is thought of as right, and when those who hold them start to disdain the major right-wing party, which is widely considered to be pretty hard-right itself, then using an "extreme" description seems appropriate. Of course, there are some who are even more extreme. There always are, but that doesn't mean these people aren't either. Just not quite so extreme.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think you have hit on what is a problem. There is at least one poster here who believes that the views he expresses were mainstream "conservatism" just a few decades ago, and that the "extreme-right" then were much further to the right. I don't believe that is remotely true. Mainstream "conservatism" for most of my life was centre-right. It had a social conscience and a heart. It occupied the middle ground and held power. Thatcher started the drift to the right, Major tried to steady the ship but when Blair stole the middle ground from them, out they went. When Labour lost their way again, Cameron moved back to the middle, partly because a coalition forced him to. Then came wishy-washy May and now the populist buffoon, Johnson. The extreme-right of today, both here and in the USA from where many of their ideas originate, are on a completely different level to anything I have witnessed before. Even Powell, who many regard as a prophetic hero, was moderate by comparison. So the problem is both perception and definition. No-one likes being described as an extremist. It has bad connotations. However, when views are expressed which are on the outer edge of that which is thought of as right, and when those who hold them start to disdain the major right-wing party, which is widely considered to be pretty hard-right itself, then using an "extreme" description seems appropriate. Of course, there are some who are even more extreme. There always are, but that doesn't mean these people aren't either. Just not quite so extreme.
It can be noted that Powell was greatly admired both within his party and outside it. He had a strong mutual regard with Michael Foot throughout their parliamentary careers working together against the common market. Among the politically notable of the time to attend his funeral service were Dennis Thatcher, John Major, Tony Benn, Michael Portillo, Alan Clark, the former speaker of the house of commons, Ann Widdecombe, John Biffen, Michael Mates, Alan Duncan, and David Trimble and a reasonably long list of lords. I'm curious as to why you consider his ideas as moderate compared to those who you would call 'extreme' now. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Nov 2021 12.52am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It can be noted that Powell was greatly admired both within his party and outside it. He had a strong mutual regard with Michael Foot throughout their parliamentary careers working together against the common market. Among the politically notable of the time to attend his funeral service were Dennis Thatcher, John Major, Tony Benn, Michael Portillo, Alan Clark, the former speaker of the house of commons, Ann Widdecombe, John Biffen, Michael Mates, Alan Duncan, and David Trimble and a reasonably long list of lords. I'm curious as to why you consider his ideas as moderate compared to those who you would call 'extreme' now.
Partly for the reasons you identify. He was admired as a deep thinking, honest and decent man even by those who found many of his policies distasteful. Today's extreme-right don't enjoy support from mainstream politicians. It's a long time ago and not fresh in my mind, but I seem to remember him holding quite socially liberal attitudes, alongside his better known anti-immigration ones. So he was a complex man with a variety of views that meant he didn't easily fit a pigeonhole. Whilst echoes of some of his views are certainly to be heard in the voices of today's extreme-right, not the others. Moderate is probably a somewhat misleading word, given its political connotations. Measured maybe?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think you have hit on what is a problem. There is at least one poster here who believes that the views he expresses were mainstream "conservatism" just a few decades ago, and that the "extreme-right" then were much further to the right. I don't believe that is remotely true. Mainstream "conservatism" for most of my life was centre-right. It had a social conscience and a heart. It occupied the middle ground and held power. Thatcher started the drift to the right, Major tried to steady the ship but when Blair stole the middle ground from them, out they went. When Labour lost their way again, Cameron moved back to the middle, partly because a coalition forced him to. Then came wishy-washy May and now the populist buffoon, Johnson. The extreme-right of today, both here and in the USA from where many of their ideas originate, are on a completely different level to anything I have witnessed before. Even Powell, who many regard as a prophetic hero, was moderate by comparison. So the problem is both perception and definition. No-one likes being described as an extremist. It has bad connotations. However, when views are expressed which are on the outer edge of that which is thought of as right, and when those who hold them start to disdain the major right-wing party, which is widely considered to be pretty hard-right itself, then using an "extreme" description seems appropriate. Of course, there are some who are even more extreme. There always are, but that doesn't mean these people aren't either. Just not quite so extreme. This from from someone who says people are racists because he believe that they think racist thoughts!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Does the picture, if genuine, not suggest that if he was called a P*** he accepted as banter from friends/teammates? I have seen the photo in question - it could easily have been photoshopped but I hope not because it makes his naming of people look pretty stupid - even though one or two of them should be ashamed of themselves in any event.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
In football the pre match kneeling has played a useful role drawing attention to racism. It has had its issues relating to the political movement BLM but overall it is a constant reminder to leave racism behind. LRB. it has even had its acceptable humor when Benteke forgot the kneeling, instead haring of down the wing, before tip toeing back in embarrassment!!! Don't you mean 'ambling at a leisurely pace' ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
I have seen the photo in question - it could easily have been photoshopped but I hope not because it makes his naming of people look pretty stupid - even though one or two of them should be ashamed of themselves in any event. Here's another - it is, apparently, an indoor cricket team -
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
He has now apologised for a meme he posted with a racial slur towards African people, this was 4 years ago. Edited by Spiderman (19 Nov 2021 8.29am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Two wrongs don’t make a right do they? He’s used awful language in the past which doesn’t do him any favours whatsoever but it doesn’t make his case or testimony against Yorkshire any less valid. Cute how you think I’m the foolish one here. You’ve made a tit of yourself over and over again and have no self-awareness of it despite multiple people telling you. Your first paragraph is correct but it makes him a hypocrite doesn’t it? (See my last post)
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Two wrongs don’t make a right do they? He’s used awful language in the past which doesn’t do him any favours whatsoever but it doesn’t make his case or testimony against Yorkshire any less valid. Cute how you think I’m the foolish one here. You’ve made a tit of yourself over and over again and have no self-awareness of it despite multiple people telling you. You are missing the point as usual. He has been exposed as a total hypocrite and moreover, it brings into question if any wrongs were done to him at all, since he might well have been a willing participant in that kind of environment. Face it. He has made you look utterly stupid. Something that seems to be quite easy to achieve lately.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.