This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Yes she was. In a video of the arrest, one of the six officers dealing with her, is heard telling her: “You’ve said you’ve been engaging in prayer, which is the offense.” The police have now apologised to her and there will be no further action on the alleged offence. A judge in Birmingham had already dismissed the first case against her along with that of Father Sean Gough, a Wolverhampton priest also arrested for praying silently. Suella Braverman wrote to every police force in England and Wales to tell them that silent prayer was not a criminal offense. The woman involved in this is now, quite rightly, considering whether to sue the police for wrongful arrest and to seek compensation for the ordeal inflicted upon her. The charges were dropped. That one policeman made an erroneous remark might be unfortunate but it does nothing at all to change the facts. Facts which are routinely misrepresented by the religious and right wing press. Something you obviously consume far too much of. This was a publicity stunt by a well known activist. Nothing more, nothing less. She wanted to be arrested and charged. The police did all they could to avoid that and then let her off. Read this. It’s from somewhere usually more sympathetic to your views:- That you reference Braverman speaks volumes as she is wrong on almost everything but she isn’t on this. Silent Prayer is not a criminal offence. Nor is holding opinions. Breaking exclusion orders is though. If silently praying within an exclusion area is considered to be intimidatory then it becomes an offence.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
CNN has started to turn on 'woke'......Mmmm....How opportune the timing. It should be noted that the rich activist donors from a certain group who have started pulling funding from rich elite universities were perfectly content when progressive ideology was attacking 'white' people. Now they are learning that while they regard themselves as different the ideology they fostered doesn't. It's hard to portray yourself as a victim when you top the wealth leagues. Now all of a sudden they want to go back to merit based systems of education and move away from 'oppression/oppressed. I fully agree with them.....If they want to even attempt social cohesion....Did they let it go on too long...we will find out....but I'm well aware that this is happening only because its because the eye of Sauron was turned on them.....Not because of any sense of principle. I truly hope they learn this lesson. [Tweet Link]
Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Dec 2023 4.45am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The charges were dropped. That one policeman made an erroneous remark might be unfortunate but it does nothing at all to change the facts. Facts which are routinely misrepresented by the religious and right wing press. Something you obviously consume far too much of. This was a publicity stunt by a well known activist. Nothing more, nothing less. She wanted to be arrested and charged. The police did all they could to avoid that and then let her off. Read this. It’s from somewhere usually more sympathetic to your views:- That you reference Braverman speaks volumes as she is wrong on almost everything but she isn’t on this. Silent Prayer is not a criminal offence. Nor is holding opinions. Breaking exclusion orders is though. If silently praying within an exclusion area is considered to be intimidatory then it becomes an offence.
The charges were dropped because there was no offence. As with say, criminal neglect of gas appliance maintenance, they would have loved to take her to court but in an identical previous case she was found not guilty, the case dismissed. The six police officers – yes six, did all they would to arrest and falsely charge this woman – it’s like Germany in the 1930s. Braverman wrote to the police to tell them that silently praying or holding views that life should be protected is not a criminal offence (yet) and the police clearly thought overwise. (PS: I don’t read newspapers and am not active in any religion and oppose extreme, detrimental religions like Islam.)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The charges were dropped because there was no offence. As with say, criminal neglect of gas appliance maintenance, they would have loved to take her to court but in an identical previous case she was found not guilty, the case dismissed. The six police officers – yes six, did all they would to arrest and falsely charge this woman – it’s like Germany in the 1930s. Braverman wrote to the police to tell them that silently praying or holding views that life should be protected is not a criminal offence (yet) and the police clearly thought overwise. (PS: I don’t read newspapers and am not active in any religion and oppose extreme, detrimental religions like Islam.) The charges were dropped because it was not in anyone’s interest to proceed. Once she had been removed the task was complete. She now knows what will happen if she attempts the same stunt again. You obviously didn’t read the link I provided or you would not be persisting with these erroneous claims. The religious press and the right don’t rely on newspaper output. Their ideas, which you mirror, are all over the web. They all ignore the fact that there was an exclusion order in place prohibiting what she did, but only where she did it. Campaign against exclusion orders if you wish but whilst they exist they must be accepted and respected. Break them and you will be arrested. It’s not complicated.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The charges were dropped because it was not in anyone’s interest to proceed. Once she had been removed the task was complete. She now knows what will happen if she attempts the same stunt again. You obviously didn’t read the link I provided or you would not be persisting with these erroneous claims. The religious press and the right don’t rely on newspaper output. Their ideas, which you mirror, are all over the web. They all ignore the fact that there was an exclusion order in place prohibiting what she did, but only where she did it. Campaign against exclusion orders if you wish but whilst they exist they must be accepted and respected. Break them and you will be arrested. It’s not complicated. The charges were dropped because it was not in the interests of the police to proceed as they knew full well that she would be found not guilty as she was in a previous identical case. The police now know what will happen if they attempt such unlawful stunt arrests again. I largely ignore any links that you past – along with many of the posts themselves, as you persist in your Pravda-style misinformation. The extreme left wing views that you mirror are all over the web. Persist if you wish, but however much you deny the truth, the truth goes on existing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The charges were dropped because it was not in the interests of the police to proceed as they knew full well that she would be found not guilty as she was in a previous identical case. The police now know what will happen if they attempt such unlawful stunt arrests again. I largely ignore any links that you past – along with many of the posts themselves, as you persist in your Pravda-style misinformation. The extreme left wing views that you mirror are all over the web. Persist if you wish, but however much you deny the truth, the truth goes on existing. Spot on.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I see the 3 Ivy League Presidents are in real trouble after their disastrous appearance at congress. All 3 failed to condemn antisemitism adequately at their universities citing freedom of speech or rather whining "Well what can you do!". Of course all 3 have been active in banning and de platforming stuff they didn't like so showing themselves up to be hypocrites. One has resigned, one is stepping down, whilst the 3rd is clinging on. Have they had a change of heart? Not really but money talks and rich white people have been threatening to withdraw their donations. Freedom of speech at university should be for all. Edited by Badger11 (12 Dec 2023 8.15am) Until they go back to employing the people who believe in it as a principle and not just for what they believe in that won't happen. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Dec 2023 3.21pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The charges were dropped because it was not in the interests of the police to proceed as they knew full well that she would be found not guilty as she was in a previous identical case. The police now know what will happen if they attempt such unlawful stunt arrests again. I largely ignore any links that you past – along with many of the posts themselves, as you persist in your Pravda-style misinformation. The extreme left wing views that you mirror are all over the web. Persist if you wish, but however much you deny the truth, the truth goes on existing. You at least make me laugh. I am as far from being either extreme or left wing as any normal middle of the road citizen could be. The only resemblance to Pravda here comes from your blinkered posts which have not even considered the alternatives. If you don’t read information how will you learn anything? The internet searches on this return almost nothing other than identical propaganda from those who support the so called “pro-life” movement. It’s all distorted and twisted to present an entirely untrue picture. Something explained very well in the link. Here it is again. Kindly don’t respond until you have read it:- The title gives a flavour. There is indeed a lot more to be seen. Isabel Vaughan-Spruce is a well known “pro-life” activist who courts publicity for her stunts. She is supported by the “ADF” an American anti-abortion organisation which has been very successful in campaigning to get abortion banned in a variety of US states. They design her actions and provide the cameras to film them. She is deliberately trying to provoke being arrested. The police have no interest in seeing her either arrested or charged and only do so when left with no choice. Even when she was “cleared” the first time the CPS had dropped the charges on the basis it wasn’t worth a court’s time but she insisted on having her day in court. The magistrates let her off. It seems her argument that being silent isn’t praying caused sufficient doubt in their minds. On the second occasion the CPS also dropped the charges. Removing her was the desired outcome. Not giving her more publicity. The only apology that was made was for the time it took to deal with things, the CPS having rather more important things to do. However those charges remain on the book and should she attempt anything similar they may be resurrected. There is no doubt whatsoever that she, and the others doing similar stunts are not simply wanting to pray. They want to have the right to do so in places where others consider it undesirable. The same scenario has been engineered by the ADF many times in the USA. Just ask yourself, do we really want to follow the way the USA has gone over this issue? It seems to me that the ADF, which is a substantial and well funded organisation, is trying to find loopholes in the law and to then exploit them. Hence the “silently” ! That though does nothing to change the underlying intent of this. Which clearly conflicts with, and is intended to conflict with, the whole purpose of the exclusion zone being created. So I hope and trust that the terms of any exclusion order are reviewed and revised to ensure that this and any other loopholes are closed so it becomes watertight and impervious to the activities of those whose only intention is to avoid compliance. Read the link.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You at least make me laugh. I am as far from being either extreme or left wing as any normal middle of the road citizen could be. The only resemblance to Pravda here comes from your blinkered posts which have not even considered the alternatives. If you don’t read information how will you learn anything? The internet searches on this return almost nothing other than identical propaganda from those who support the so called “pro-life” movement. It’s all distorted and twisted to present an entirely untrue picture. Something explained very well in the link. Here it is again. Kindly don’t respond until you have read it:- The title gives a flavour. There is indeed a lot more to be seen. Isabel Vaughan-Spruce is a well known “pro-life” activist who courts publicity for her stunts. She is supported by the “ADF” an American anti-abortion organisation which has been very successful in campaigning to get abortion banned in a variety of US states. They design her actions and provide the cameras to film them. She is deliberately trying to provoke being arrested. The police have no interest in seeing her either arrested or charged and only do so when left with no choice. Even when she was “cleared” the first time the CPS had dropped the charges on the basis it wasn’t worth a court’s time but she insisted on having her day in court. The magistrates let her off. It seems her argument that being silent isn’t praying caused sufficient doubt in their minds. On the second occasion the CPS also dropped the charges. Removing her was the desired outcome. Not giving her more publicity. The only apology that was made was for the time it took to deal with things, the CPS having rather more important things to do. However those charges remain on the book and should she attempt anything similar they may be resurrected. There is no doubt whatsoever that she, and the others doing similar stunts are not simply wanting to pray. They want to have the right to do so in places where others consider it undesirable. The same scenario has been engineered by the ADF many times in the USA. Just ask yourself, do we really want to follow the way the USA has gone over this issue? It seems to me that the ADF, which is a substantial and well funded organisation, is trying to find loopholes in the law and to then exploit them. Hence the “silently” ! That though does nothing to change the underlying intent of this. Which clearly conflicts with, and is intended to conflict with, the whole purpose of the exclusion zone being created. So I hope and trust that the terms of any exclusion order are reviewed and revised to ensure that this and any other loopholes are closed so it becomes watertight and impervious to the activities of those whose only intention is to avoid compliance. Read the link. Why do you keep denying reality? The arresting officer said: “You’ve said you’ve been engaging in prayer, which is the offense.” He said her offence was engaging in prayer, she wasn’t even sure herself whether she was actually silently praying – when does a thought become a prayer? She had been to court previously on exactly the same charge and was found not guilty. The police apologised to her. The government wrote to the police to remind them that silent praying was not unlawful. Once again, your squid-ink waffle does not change reality. (PS: don’t presume to pompously tell me under what conditions I can reply to posts.)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Why do you keep denying reality? The arresting officer said: “You’ve said you’ve been engaging in prayer, which is the offense.” He said her offence was engaging in prayer, she wasn’t even sure herself whether she was actually silently praying – when does a thought become a prayer? She had been to court previously on exactly the same charge and was found not guilty. The police apologised to her. The government wrote to the police to remind them that silent praying was not unlawful. Once again, your squid-ink waffle does not change reality. (PS: don’t presume to pompously tell me under what conditions I can reply to posts.) How the Police behaved here was quite incredible....alien even.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Why do you keep denying reality? The arresting officer said: “You’ve said you’ve been engaging in prayer, which is the offense.” He said her offence was engaging in prayer, she wasn’t even sure herself whether she was actually silently praying – when does a thought become a prayer? She had been to court previously on exactly the same charge and was found not guilty. The police apologised to her. The government wrote to the police to remind them that silent praying was not unlawful. Once again, your squid-ink waffle does not change reality. (PS: don’t presume to pompously tell me under what conditions I can reply to posts.) The denial of reality is entirely yours. You will find the reality more extensively explained in the link I provided, which you conveniently ignore. Replying without considering the information it contains is just ignorance. Was that all the policeman said, or only the bit that was included in the propaganda video? It is, of course, true. She was arrested for praying, but what is being deliberately ignored is the context. She was behaving (in this instance praying) in a way and in a place where such behaviour is not allowed. She was free to behave like that in a million other places. Her freedom to do so was never impacted. She was just restricted from making a nuisance of herself in one specific location. It’s not difficult to understand. Only the wilfully blind and deaf refuse to see past the propaganda that’s being blown over them. The police apologised for the delay. Not for her arrest. Silent praying is not unlawful. Braverman writing to the police stating the obvious is just her playing to the crowd in her populist way. What’s unlawful is breaking exclusion orders. Those who believe propaganda are bound to remain uninformed.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The denial of reality is entirely yours. You will find the reality more extensively explained in the link I provided, which you conveniently ignore. Replying without considering the information it contains is just ignorance. Was that all the policeman said, or only the bit that was included in the propaganda video? It is, of course, true. She was arrested for praying, but what is being deliberately ignored is the context. She was behaving (in this instance praying) in a way and in a place where such behaviour is not allowed. She was free to behave like that in a million other places. Her freedom to do so was never impacted. She was just restricted from making a nuisance of herself in one specific location. It’s not difficult to understand. Only the wilfully blind and deaf refuse to see past the propaganda that’s being blown over them. The police apologised for the delay. Not for her arrest. Silent praying is not unlawful. Braverman writing to the police stating the obvious is just her playing to the crowd in her populist way. What’s unlawful is breaking exclusion orders. Those who believe propaganda are bound to remain uninformed. I’m not obliged to view links that you think I should view, insisting that I am is just coercive intimidation – the sort of thing that rogue landlords get up to. If you are keen on links here is one of the woman herself speaking about her arrest. She was charged with protesting by silently praying. As there was no measurable level of protest, intimidation or harassment, her ‘crime’ can have only been a thought crime. Only the wilfully blind and deaf refuse to see this. As Orwell said: We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
I’m not obliged to view links that you think I should view, insisting that I am is just coercive intimidation – the sort of thing that rogue landlords get up to. If you are keen on links here is one of the woman herself speaking about her arrest. She was charged with protesting by silently praying. As there was no measurable level of protest, intimidation or harassment, her ‘crime’ can have only been a thought crime. Only the wilfully blind and deaf refuse to see this. The courts of course found her not guilty as thought crime is (not yet) a crime. As Orwell said: We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I feel as though the above debate has been rumbling on forever Is it fair to say this woman was not arrested for praying in her head but for deliberately loitering within a space where it was not allowed? I remember the old 'no loitering' signs which police did enforce. She was surely arrested for her physical presence, not for her thoughts/prayers? I cannot remember the bible verse decreeing 'Thou shalt stand within 'x' distance of the abortion clinic when silently praying'. I might suggest there's an argument for saying that the law in this instance should be changed, whether that be the Orwellian nature of it or the ambiguity in enforcing it, dependant on your side of the fence, however the headline 'arrested for silently praying' is misleading. It's a bit like saying 'I've been arrested for tying my shoelaces' when standing for two hours, 101m from an ex partner I've been harassing, with a court order to stay 100m away in effect. That's all hypothetical of course I'm not in that situation... the court actually said 500m. You could get the impression that the regime want to essentially make it illegal to protest abortion.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I feel as though the above debate has been rumbling on forever Is it fair to say this woman was not arrested for praying in her head but for deliberately loitering within a space where it was not allowed? I remember the old 'no loitering' signs which police did enforce. She was surely arrested for her physical presence, not for her thoughts/prayers? I cannot remember the bible verse decreeing 'Thou shalt stand within 'x' distance of the abortion clinic when silently praying'. I might suggest there's an argument for saying that the law in this instance should be changed, whether that be the Orwellian nature of it or the ambiguity in enforcing it, dependant on your side of the fence, however the headline 'arrested for silently praying' is misleading. It's a bit like saying 'I've been arrested for tying my shoelaces' when standing for two hours, 101m from an ex partner I've been harassing, with a court order to stay 100m away in effect. That's all hypothetical of course I'm not in that situation... the court actually said 500m. The arresting officer said: “You’ve said you’ve been engaging in prayer, which is the offense.”
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You could get the impression that the regime want to essentially make it illegal to protest abortion. That would be my grievance, and what I would suggest this is actually about, not her praying. 'We don't want you disturbing that which we condone, for whatever reason or because it suits our narrative'. I do take umbrage at that, especially where there are probably plenty of other similar things/instances which suit the narrative so they're more hesitant about it as opposed to just nicking someone straight away.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
That would be my grievance, and what I would suggest this is actually about, not her praying. 'We don't want you disturbing that which we condone, for whatever reason or because it suits our narrative'. I do take umbrage at that, especially where there are probably plenty of other similar things/instances which suit the narrative so they're more hesitant about it as opposed to just nicking someone straight away. How many Muslims have been arrested for silently praying for the death of all Jews?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.