You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US politics
November 17 2026 9.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

US politics


Page 296 of 424 < 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 >
PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 18 Dec 23 9.53am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Progressives have always been fine with the racism they support.

I don't have an issue with honesty, it's been the lying and double standards that's annoying.

Chinese americans have been going nuts. Its about them consistently getting top school grades...... and then being passed-over for University places by, ahem, other more deserving ethnic minorities. The minorities that often get the crappy grades.

It seems that There are heroic ethnic minorities....and then there are other minorities. Reminds me of the BBC.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Dec 23 7.20pm

So once again our resident know it all is making silly assertions!

We don’t all “know this is a “kangaroo court”! I certainly don’t! Primarily though because it isn’t and could not be.

Even if the judicial and political systems in the USA are more entwined than we are used to, especially at Supreme Court level, Judges are still Judges whose loyalty is to the law. Every accused has the complete freedom to offer their defence which is properly considered, usually by an independent jury. So no kangaroos.

The assertion that these are political prosecutions arises from the propaganda being spread by Trump and his supporters in an effort to divert attention from the actual events. They claim there must be a coordinated campaign because there are so many happening at the same time. What they conveniently decide to ignore is that there are very good reasons for that, which have nothing to do with the Democrats. Trump managed to remain immune from prosecution for 4 years and to add to his problems interfered with the election process and the transfer of power. He then retained records he wasn’t entitled to. The reason they all arrived at once is solely down to Trump. Nothing to with the Democrats or anyone else.

It’s just the law running its course. Are ex-Presidents above the law? Not in my book!

Biden, from all I have read, has no reason at all to be concerned about any impact on him arising from his son’s activities. If there is, then he should face precisely the same due process as Trump.

I am sure there are many US voters who would like to see both Trump and Biden gone. However in the case of the Democrats and Biden only because of his age and not because of any worries about corruption.

Lawfare is an interesting term, now being made popular by a populist and his supporters in an effort to deflect attention away from the actual accusations. It’s been given a new meaning because it originally meant the use of the law by the wealthy and powerful to intimidate the weak and vulnerable. Something Trump has often done himself.

[Link]

The current use of the term arises from the right in the USA and it’s sad to see it being parroted here. It can only be because too much attention is being given to “alternative” news sources in the USA. Something supported by the frequent copy and paste of dubious videos and the frequent use of American spelling and vernacular.

This coming from someone who claims to be a proud Englishman, feels a little odd.

I had a disturbing conversation with some relatives of ours in California yesterday. They have always seemed objective and thoughtful with their politics. Whilst naturally conservative they supported Obama. So when they told me they were now supporting Trump I was shocked and even more so by the reasoning which repeated all the mantras being fed into the public consciousness by the right.

For them Trump’s legal problems are all political set ups. Biden is pursuing an open border policy. Etc etc. The kind of thing our resident expert on Trump propaganda repeats here regularly. What’s disturbing is that people like them believe it. There wasn’t a word of condemnation for the disgusting actions of Trump. Only sympathy for the way he is being “treated”. He is recreating himself as a martyr and people are believing it. I know memories are short but surely this is off the scale.

This cannot continue. There will need to be a rethink on how to halt this spiral down.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (18 Dec 2023 7.25pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Dec 23 7.39pm

When it comes to a throw down I don't rate the left's chances.

They tried to rainbow the military and suffer recruitment problems and they can have as many progressive generals as they like. The vast bulk of any military are right wing or right of centre and are never going to turn their guns on....well something like Maga. They would most likely stay out of any of it....Perhaps it would come down to state militias....the old Antifa v Proud Boy types.....modern day mods and rockers....where the mods are into bumming each other.

Low scale activist conflicts, in some states more than others, until agreements to legally secede.

Essentially the direction of travel into conflict suits the right....and those on the left who think there is a physical resolution or you can jail and force half of the country into lives they don't want then you are only playing into their hands....Eventually you create the radicalism by forcing people....Human nature.

Russell Brand is sensible on this kind of thing.....Let communities live how they want to live and stop fighting them and get on where you can. No one needs to be the other's bow. That means that America splits into two then that's what happens....they can make common defence agreements like Nato, but the current centre just isn't going to hold like this.

Let the left live their neo commie fantasies and let the right live their libertarian one.....and let them both police those systems and throw out the fifth columnists who like to pretend they stand for you while tearing you down.

Been saying it for years.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Dec 2023 8.33pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Dec 23 9.48pm

The idea that the US military would take political sides is, hopefully, very far fetched for it would result in a complete disaster. I cannot imagine the very disciplined military not following the orders of their commanders or those commanders not following the instructions of their CIC. Unless, of course, that CIC exceeded their authority. Which regrettably now seems conceivable. I imagine that should any “activists” start to make trouble beyond the scope of local law and order to handle that the National Guard would be asked to assist and only in very extreme circumstances would it have to be elevated.

Our resident know something (about everything) often pontificates about how the USA is bound to break up. He’s “been saying it for years”, and here it is again. It isn’t something much discussed here, but apparently is in the USA. So we know where this something comes from. Which given where much of the content comes from is unsurprising. So I thought I ought to take a look myself.

There is a lot of discussion, that’s true. Not all of it believing it is either feasible or sensible. This was interesting:-

[Link]

As anyone who has been through a divorce knows the divorce itself is the simple bit. It’s the division of the assets, who has custody of the children, who has the dog and retains the house that’s the difficult stuff. Some can sort things out amicably but they are those who didn’t ought to be getting divorced in the first place. Those who really need to separate often need a Judge to order how things are settled. I don’t see a suitable Judge for the US states. In any case the individual states already possess quite a lot of independence so what would be the point. All pain and no gain.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Dec 23 10.03pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The idea that the US military would take political sides is, hopefully, very far fetched for it would result in a complete disaster. I cannot imagine the very disciplined military not following the orders of their commanders or those commanders not following the instructions of their CIC. Unless, of course, that CIC exceeded their authority. Which regrettably now seems conceivable. I imagine that should any “activists” start to make trouble beyond the scope of local law and order to handle that the National Guard would be asked to assist and only in very extreme circumstances would it have to be elevated.

Our resident know something (about everything) often pontificates about how the USA is bound to break up. He’s “been saying it for years”, and here it is again. It isn’t something much discussed here, but apparently is in the USA. So we know where this something comes from. Which given where much of the content comes from is unsurprising. So I thought I ought to take a look myself.

There is a lot of discussion, that’s true. Not all of it believing it is either feasible or sensible. This was interesting:-

[Link]

As anyone who has been through a divorce knows the divorce itself is the simple bit. It’s the division of the assets, who has custody of the children, who has the dog and retains the house that’s the difficult stuff. Some can sort things out amicably but they are those who didn’t ought to be getting divorced in the first place. Those who really need to separate often need a Judge to order how things are settled. I don’t see a suitable Judge for the US states. In any case the individual states already possess quite a lot of independence so what would be the point. All pain and no gain.


It's not inconceivable though.

[Link]


 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Dec 23 10.25pm

We will see.

After this election next year, whoever wins, there are going to be an awfully large number of very angry people. That doesn't just go away.

There is no unifying figure in American politics, the political distance between the two parties is too large for that. They don't share the same values.

There is no 'convincing'.....They can no more be convinced than you or I can be convinced....that's just a demeaning way of thinking of political oppositions.

I predict that this election leads to significant forms of disruption and increasing separation and loss of influence between the president and the opposite party's states.

It's all steps along the way.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Dec 23 10.37pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


It's not inconceivable though.

[Link]


Clearly not, but so is a Raving Loony PM. Or have we already had one of them?

Any split would cause such disruption as to soon change minds.

There must be easier ways of allowing states more control over the social things that seem to concern people whilst still running the important things centrally. Thatcher was a strong advocate for subsidiarity and perhaps her attitude needs promoting in the USA.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 19 Dec 23 12.09am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Clearly not, but so is a Raving Loony PM. Or have we already had one of them?

Any split would cause such disruption as to soon change minds.

There must be easier ways of allowing states more control over the social things that seem to concern people whilst still running the important things centrally. Thatcher was a strong advocate for subsidiarity and perhaps her attitude needs promoting in the USA.

Raving lunacy might well be a prerequisite for anyone who actually wants the job.
Different parts of America give the impression of not necessarily wanting independence for themselves but rather from the way things are done and in other states. Gavin Newsom is being touted as a likely candidate but many Americans look at California with horror.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Dec 23 12.14am

Guy thinks you can stick Trump in jail....who half the country will vote for and then....'let's give states more social freedom' is going to smooth over the edges.

Don't see it myself but we will see I guess....because if Trump wins, he's coming for his enemies and if he loses they are going to destroy him.

Intelligent people wouldn't be doing any of this and would argue against it but unfortunately things have gone over that Rubicon in America and few people are interested in compromises.

Like I said, there is no unifying figure that the other side respects anymore.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Dec 2023 12.18am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 23 8.22am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The idea that the US military would take political sides is, hopefully, very far fetched for it would result in a complete disaster.

Well it has happened already, 1861 and all that. I agree it would be a disaster the problem is that although the North won the actual issue of the war, states rights versus federal rights, is still simmering 150 years later.

The actual argument that once a state had joined the union it could never leave was not won, it was a military solution that won.

The lead up to the civil war was about 20 years with successive Presidents trying to put a sticking plaster over the issue until it came to a head.

I don't see a split happening soon but if they keep getting divisive leaders they will start heading down the same path for Civil War 2 "The Payback".

Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 8.23am)

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 8.37am

If the rule of law is going to be maintained then even if 99% of the people vote for someone if they are given jail time they must serve it! You cannot ever put somebody above the law. You invite dictatorship should you do so.

The consequences would be extremely difficult but they must be faced, because not to do would be worse. It’s another example of drawing a line and sticking to it.

That anyone talks of Trump having “enemies”, and not political opponents, and that he will be “coming for them” confirms just how important it is that this cannot be allowed to happen. Trump tried to usurp the democratic process the last time. To use this kind of language points up he still hasn’t finished. Can we really take the risk of what a second Trump term might bring in its wake?

I don’t though see a unifying candidate on the horizon, although I am prepared to be surprised. The problem is that the divide is too deep. Particularly so on the Trump side of the Republican Party. I think it is perfectly possible for traditional Republicans and most Democrats to be able to work together and find common ground. Not so with the hardliners for whom their way is the only way. With those people dominating the Party and regarding the traditionals with almost as much distain as the Democrats it’s going to need to wait until after the Trump era for common sense to stand a chance of rising again.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 8.43am

Originally posted by Badger11

Well it has happened already, 1861 and all that. I agree it would be a disaster the problem is that although the North won the actual issue of the war, states rights versus federal rights, is still simmering 150 years later.

The actual argument that once a state had joined the union it could never leave was not won, it was a military solution that won.

The lead up to the civil war was about 20 years with successive Presidents trying to put a sticking plaster over the issue until it came to a head.

I don't see a split happening soon but if they keep getting divisive leaders they will start heading down the same path for Civil War 2 "The Payback".

Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 8.23am)

Hopefully the fact that the military is more disciplined and the weapons more lethal would ensure this doesn’t happen. I cannot imagine one group of US military being prepared to fight another. Their loyalty is to the USA and its constitution. Not to factions.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Dec 23 9.56am

'Law'....notice when it's laws that they don't agree with...like the supreme court abortion decision, suddenly this attitude changes.

No acceptance of 'evolving' then, things are only allowed to evolve how they want them to.

Total façade.

People like our Corny friend create war and then point at others.

There is a lot of money behind Trump....You put him in jail and what comes next isn't a gruff 90s Democrat.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Dec 2023 10.18am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 3.24pm

The Supreme Court decision is still the law. The argument is about how the Court that made it was constituted and what changes need to be made to it so it is a better balanced institution. Nevertheless the decisions it makes are the law and must be respected . You will not find an argument from me to the contrary.

I believe in dialogue and better arguments than force of any kind. So certainly don’t create wars. I have always avoided confrontation as being a pointless exercise. When faced with aggression I walk the other way to continue the argument verbally when the temper has cooled. You cannot do that though when someone tries to take what is yours. If you aren’t strong enough to resist alone, you ask friends to help.

Trump may have a lot of friends but I suspect that at the higher intellectual levels he has many more enemies than friends. Having dimwits as friends isn’t a lot of use.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Dec 23 4.19pm

I can only hope that there are some American independents who might read that insulting description of Trump supporters between now and the election and understand just the level of contempt Democrat supporters have for their opposition.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 23 4.38pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The Supreme Court decision is still the law. The argument is about how the Court that made it was constituted and what changes need to be made to it so it is a better balanced institution. Nevertheless the decisions it makes are the law and must be respected . You will not find an argument from me to the contrary.

I believe in dialogue and better arguments than force of any kind. So certainly don’t create wars. I have always avoided confrontation as being a pointless exercise. When faced with aggression I walk the other way to continue the argument verbally when the temper has cooled. You cannot do that though when someone tries to take what is yours. If you aren’t strong enough to resist alone, you ask friends to help.

Trump may have a lot of friends but I suspect that at the higher intellectual levels he has many more enemies than friends. Having dimwits as friends isn’t a lot of use.

President's have always appointed judges that they believe would favour their interests. Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren because he thought he was a safe pair of hands. Warren of course led the charge on civil rights.

The current SC has made several rulings that have upset a great many but if you can step away from the emotion actually make sense.

The job of the SC is to interpret the law and protect the constitution. However at what point does interpreting the law become making the law something that is not the role of the courts.

If Congress wants to pass legislation it is free to do so if it hasn't done that then why should the SC decide to make law. The current SC has reversed some of these decisions because they have chosen to interpret their role in a narrower manner than previous courts.

The current court is only reflecting what has largely been the case since the beginning. It was from the fifties until recently that the court acquired an activist role.

Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 4.39pm)

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 7.27pm

American independents are not Trump supporters. They are independent! They aren’t half-wits. It’s those who see him as a saviour without any faults, or are prepared to ignore them who are. They fully deserve the contempt of everyone who values democracy.

That they will have to make a choice means some will vote for Trump, probably after biting their tongue very hard. I trust it won’t be too many but capturing these people is why I remain convinced that Biden will not be the candidate. It will be someone younger, more energetic and quite possibly female.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 7.40pm

Originally posted by Badger11

President's have always appointed judges that they believe would favour their interests. Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren because he thought he was a safe pair of hands. Warren of course led the charge on civil rights.

The current SC has made several rulings that have upset a great many but if you can step away from the emotion actually make sense.

The job of the SC is to interpret the law and protect the constitution. However at what point does interpreting the law become making the law something that is not the role of the courts.

If Congress wants to pass legislation it is free to do so if it hasn't done that then why should the SC decide to make law. The current SC has reversed some of these decisions because they have chosen to interpret their role in a narrower manner than previous courts.

The current court is only reflecting what has largely been the case since the beginning. It was from the fifties until recently that the court acquired an activist role.

Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 4.39pm)

That Presidents have always appointed SC Judges doesn’t make it wise. In fact it’s crazy in my opinion to allow it. The judiciary ought to be completely separate from politics.

What decisions do you think make sense when stripped of their emotions? Reversing Roe v Wade hardly made sense other than as a gift to the so called “pro-life” lobby.

The USSC seems to me to make a lot more law based on particular interpretations of an out of date constitution than is sensible. It’s no longer a system fit for purpose in a modern world. Congress can make new law but need the President on board and then run the risk of the SC declaring it unconstitutional. Not fit for purpose.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 23 8.01pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That Presidents have always appointed SC Judges doesn’t make it wise. In fact it’s crazy in my opinion to allow it. The judiciary ought to be completely separate from politics.

What decisions do you think make sense when stripped of their emotions? Reversing Roe v Wade hardly made sense other than as a gift to the so called “pro-life” lobby.

The USSC seems to me to make a lot more law based on particular interpretations of an out of date constitution than is sensible. It’s no longer a system fit for purpose in a modern world. Congress can make new law but need the President on board and then run the risk of the SC declaring it unconstitutional. Not fit for purpose.

Then they should change the constitution. I don't disagree that the system is flawed but until they change it...

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 19 Dec 23 8.42pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Then they should change the constitution. I don't disagree that the system is flawed but until they change it...

Have you ever talked to an American, especially one who is a hard-core conservative, about changing the constitution? They regard it as untouchable. Something akin to having been handed down by God.

Their country would need to be in ruins before it would even be discussed. They are, I think, trapped in a vicious circle of inevitable decline.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 296 of 424 < 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US politics