This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Progressives have always been fine with the racism they support. I don't have an issue with honesty, it's been the lying and double standards that's annoying. [Tweet Link]Chinese americans have been going nuts. Its about them consistently getting top school grades...... and then being passed-over for University places by, ahem, other more deserving ethnic minorities. The minorities that often get the crappy grades. It seems that There are heroic ethnic minorities....and then there are other minorities. Reminds me of the BBC.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The idea that the US military would take political sides is, hopefully, very far fetched for it would result in a complete disaster. I cannot imagine the very disciplined military not following the orders of their commanders or those commanders not following the instructions of their CIC. Unless, of course, that CIC exceeded their authority. Which regrettably now seems conceivable. I imagine that should any “activists” start to make trouble beyond the scope of local law and order to handle that the National Guard would be asked to assist and only in very extreme circumstances would it have to be elevated. Our resident know something (about everything) often pontificates about how the USA is bound to break up. He’s “been saying it for years”, and here it is again. It isn’t something much discussed here, but apparently is in the USA. So we know where this something comes from. Which given where much of the content comes from is unsurprising. So I thought I ought to take a look myself. There is a lot of discussion, that’s true. Not all of it believing it is either feasible or sensible. This was interesting:- As anyone who has been through a divorce knows the divorce itself is the simple bit. It’s the division of the assets, who has custody of the children, who has the dog and retains the house that’s the difficult stuff. Some can sort things out amicably but they are those who didn’t ought to be getting divorced in the first place. Those who really need to separate often need a Judge to order how things are settled. I don’t see a suitable Judge for the US states. In any case the individual states already possess quite a lot of independence so what would be the point. All pain and no gain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Clearly not, but so is a Raving Loony PM. Or have we already had one of them? Any split would cause such disruption as to soon change minds. There must be easier ways of allowing states more control over the social things that seem to concern people whilst still running the important things centrally. Thatcher was a strong advocate for subsidiarity and perhaps her attitude needs promoting in the USA. Raving lunacy might well be a prerequisite for anyone who actually wants the job.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The idea that the US military would take political sides is, hopefully, very far fetched for it would result in a complete disaster. Well it has happened already, 1861 and all that. I agree it would be a disaster the problem is that although the North won the actual issue of the war, states rights versus federal rights, is still simmering 150 years later. The actual argument that once a state had joined the union it could never leave was not won, it was a military solution that won. The lead up to the civil war was about 20 years with successive Presidents trying to put a sticking plaster over the issue until it came to a head. I don't see a split happening soon but if they keep getting divisive leaders they will start heading down the same path for Civil War 2 "The Payback". Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 8.23am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Well it has happened already, 1861 and all that. I agree it would be a disaster the problem is that although the North won the actual issue of the war, states rights versus federal rights, is still simmering 150 years later. The actual argument that once a state had joined the union it could never leave was not won, it was a military solution that won. The lead up to the civil war was about 20 years with successive Presidents trying to put a sticking plaster over the issue until it came to a head. I don't see a split happening soon but if they keep getting divisive leaders they will start heading down the same path for Civil War 2 "The Payback". Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 8.23am) Hopefully the fact that the military is more disciplined and the weapons more lethal would ensure this doesn’t happen. I cannot imagine one group of US military being prepared to fight another. Their loyalty is to the USA and its constitution. Not to factions.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The Supreme Court decision is still the law. The argument is about how the Court that made it was constituted and what changes need to be made to it so it is a better balanced institution. Nevertheless the decisions it makes are the law and must be respected . You will not find an argument from me to the contrary. I believe in dialogue and better arguments than force of any kind. So certainly don’t create wars. I have always avoided confrontation as being a pointless exercise. When faced with aggression I walk the other way to continue the argument verbally when the temper has cooled. You cannot do that though when someone tries to take what is yours. If you aren’t strong enough to resist alone, you ask friends to help. Trump may have a lot of friends but I suspect that at the higher intellectual levels he has many more enemies than friends. Having dimwits as friends isn’t a lot of use. President's have always appointed judges that they believe would favour their interests. Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren because he thought he was a safe pair of hands. Warren of course led the charge on civil rights. The current SC has made several rulings that have upset a great many but if you can step away from the emotion actually make sense. The job of the SC is to interpret the law and protect the constitution. However at what point does interpreting the law become making the law something that is not the role of the courts. If Congress wants to pass legislation it is free to do so if it hasn't done that then why should the SC decide to make law. The current SC has reversed some of these decisions because they have chosen to interpret their role in a narrower manner than previous courts. The current court is only reflecting what has largely been the case since the beginning. It was from the fifties until recently that the court acquired an activist role. Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 4.39pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
President's have always appointed judges that they believe would favour their interests. Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren because he thought he was a safe pair of hands. Warren of course led the charge on civil rights. The current SC has made several rulings that have upset a great many but if you can step away from the emotion actually make sense. The job of the SC is to interpret the law and protect the constitution. However at what point does interpreting the law become making the law something that is not the role of the courts. If Congress wants to pass legislation it is free to do so if it hasn't done that then why should the SC decide to make law. The current SC has reversed some of these decisions because they have chosen to interpret their role in a narrower manner than previous courts. The current court is only reflecting what has largely been the case since the beginning. It was from the fifties until recently that the court acquired an activist role. Edited by Badger11 (19 Dec 2023 4.39pm) That Presidents have always appointed SC Judges doesn’t make it wise. In fact it’s crazy in my opinion to allow it. The judiciary ought to be completely separate from politics. What decisions do you think make sense when stripped of their emotions? Reversing Roe v Wade hardly made sense other than as a gift to the so called “pro-life” lobby. The USSC seems to me to make a lot more law based on particular interpretations of an out of date constitution than is sensible. It’s no longer a system fit for purpose in a modern world. Congress can make new law but need the President on board and then run the risk of the SC declaring it unconstitutional. Not fit for purpose.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That Presidents have always appointed SC Judges doesn’t make it wise. In fact it’s crazy in my opinion to allow it. The judiciary ought to be completely separate from politics. What decisions do you think make sense when stripped of their emotions? Reversing Roe v Wade hardly made sense other than as a gift to the so called “pro-life” lobby. The USSC seems to me to make a lot more law based on particular interpretations of an out of date constitution than is sensible. It’s no longer a system fit for purpose in a modern world. Congress can make new law but need the President on board and then run the risk of the SC declaring it unconstitutional. Not fit for purpose. Then they should change the constitution. I don't disagree that the system is flawed but until they change it...
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Then they should change the constitution. I don't disagree that the system is flawed but until they change it... Have you ever talked to an American, especially one who is a hard-core conservative, about changing the constitution? They regard it as untouchable. Something akin to having been handed down by God. Their country would need to be in ruins before it would even be discussed. They are, I think, trapped in a vicious circle of inevitable decline.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.