You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58


Page 3 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Farawayeagle Flag Sydney 16 May 13 6.31am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.


Spending isn't working either. Small business which employs 7 million people here is bleeding to death. That damages both the tax base and jobs.

 


Founder Of The Crystal Palace Roller Coaster
Association

An Affiliate Of The Never A Dull Moment Club

R.I.P. DJ Hardline -- Gone Way Too Soon

GKAS Member 54

matt_himself Flag Matataland 16 May 13 6.37am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.


I am afraid that you, and the left, have failed to provide a credible and workable alternative to austerity.

We can't borrow more, we seemingly are stuck in a non-growth or low-growth cycle for at three more years and the hypocrisy of the state being largest employer in some parts of the country has been exposed as uneconomical and unproductive. Yet you suggest we someone find a Wonga.com to provide us with money we can't afford in order to prolong the factors that contributed to the shocking waste of public money promulgated by the state?

Mental.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 16 May 13 7.00am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 May 13 7.05am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.

It is working, hence our economy is growing, compare and contrast with France whose economy contracted in Q4 2012 & Q1 21013 and therefore are officially back in recession.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 16 May 13 7.51am

i can see nick's point of view, but sometimes the articles he references can be a bit spurious.

So a policeman has had a shltty weekend at work. Armed forces get it, nurses get it, in fact most front-line personnel get a few days like this.

What is galling, is that society's elite are still drinking their full from the public money trough.
In fact to call them 'elite' is to do real academics a great disservice.

Take this chancer, who apparently has more than enough money to retire at 60, after guzzling from the public coffers.


[Link]

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (16 May 2013 8.04am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 May 13 8.06am

Quote Forest Hillbilly at 16 May 2013 7.51am

i can see nick's point of view, but sometimes the articles he references can be a bit spurious.

So a policeman has had a shltty weekend at work. Armed forces get it, nurses get it, in fact most front-line personnel get a few days like this.

What is galling, is that society's elite are still drinking their full from the public money trough.
In fact to call them 'elite' is to do real academics a great disservice.

Take this chancer, who apparently has more than enough moeny to retire at 60, after guzzling from the public.


[Link]

Much of the time he doesn't express a view. He posts this stuff and when it gets rubbished, defaults by saying he was only trying to spark debate.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 16 May 13 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.

What is your solution?

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 16 May 13 11.41am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.

What is your solution?

The same as the solution to everything else, of course. The state!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 5.23pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 6.26am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2013 1.01am

This is just embarrassing from Gusset! Your cut and pastes are getting worse.

Oh and what is the solution to austerity then? Spend and borrow even more money we dont have? I see the socialist Hollande doing well with France's economy...


Get your head out of the sand. Austerity isn't working.

What is your solution?

A hypothetical idea-sorry if it is a bit simplistic...

Currently the rate of interest for the government to borrow on a 15 year loan is 2.43%. Therefore, it would cost the government £24.3 million a year in repayments if it borrowed £1bn.

In the north west, new homes for social housing cost about £120,000 to build. With £1bn you could build 8,330 houses.

If the rent for each house was set at about £5,500 a year (affordable) then the total income would be £45.8m per year, a surplus of £21.5m on the repayments. Over 15 years, this would amount to a surplus of around £322m.

Of course you have to take inflation into account, say 2% a year - the £1bn would devalue by 2% a year meaning after 15 years the original loan of £1bn would actually be worth about 30% less than it is today. So we would repay the equivalent of about £666m.

Of course people are needed to build the houses, this will take people off of benefits, If the average amount of benefits is £100 a week (jsa and housing benefit) it amounts to £5200 a year. If the same person were to earn an average wage of £22k a year building the houses, then they would pay around £3500 Tax and NI a year. So the public purse will make a gain of about £8700 a year from that person who is not receiving benefit and paying taxes.

Multiply this by the number of people taken off benefits to build the houses (say 500 for arguments sake) and you now have £4.35m a year into the public purse. Of course with more money, these people will buy more goods and services which means more tax paid.

Additionally, you would have companies supplying the goods and contracts to build the houses, their profits would increase with additional corporation tax to pay.

So not only do we get people off of benefits and into work, we save on benefits and generate more tax but we also go some way to solving the housing crisis, especially if this model is repeated around the country.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 5.30pm

Most would agree that we are in the proverbial because of the banking crisis and the fact that we, the taxpayer bailed them out.

Not so in Iceland. Rather than bailing the banks out, they arrested those responsible. Iceland invested in infrastructure and now happen to be doing rather well. No austerity there.

Obama reigned in his austerity measures and invested. The States are now turning the corner.

 

johnfirewall Flag 16 May 13 5.32pm

Sorry, who's living in those houses?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 5.33pm

Instead of bailing out banks, the government could bail out those in debt. The banks would get money from repaid loans and many people would have a bit of disposable income again which they would spend thus getting the economy going again.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 16 May 13 5.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.30pm

Most would agree that we are in the proverbial because of the banking crisis and the fact that we, the taxpayer bailed them out.

Not so in Iceland. Rather than bailing the banks out, they arrested those responsible. Iceland invested in infrastructure and now happen to be doing rather well. No austerity there.

Obama reigned in his austerity measures and invested. The States are now turning the corner.

France went socialist and taxed the rich etc, and are now enjoying the third dip of their triple-dip recession.

My point being just because an approach works (or fails) elsewhere doesn't mean the same would happen here

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 5.38pm

Quote johnfirewall at 16 May 2013 5.32pm

Sorry, who's living in those houses?


People currently on housing waiting lists! People who need to downsize because of having the gall to have a spare room.

We are going to need more housing stock for the millions of Romanians on their way.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 5.42pm

Quote npn at 16 May 2013 5.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.30pm

Most would agree that we are in the proverbial because of the banking crisis and the fact that we, the taxpayer bailed them out.

Not so in Iceland. Rather than bailing the banks out, they arrested those responsible. Iceland invested in infrastructure and now happen to be doing rather well. No austerity there.

Obama reigned in his austerity measures and invested. The States are now turning the corner.

France went socialist and taxed the rich etc, and are now enjoying the third dip of their triple-dip recession.

My point being just because an approach works (or fails) elsewhere doesn't mean the same would happen here


Can you give me an example where austerity has worked?

Greece, Spain and Portugal don't look too healthy do they?
In the UK, borrowing is going up, not down. People have committed suicide because they are at the end of their tether. The genuine needy are being penalised. Child poverty is rising. The IMF say austerity is the wrong route.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 May 13 5.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.42pm

Quote npn at 16 May 2013 5.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.30pm

Most would agree that we are in the proverbial because of the banking crisis and the fact that we, the taxpayer bailed them out.

Not so in Iceland. Rather than bailing the banks out, they arrested those responsible. Iceland invested in infrastructure and now happen to be doing rather well. No austerity there.

Obama reigned in his austerity measures and invested. The States are now turning the corner.

France went socialist and taxed the rich etc, and are now enjoying the third dip of their triple-dip recession.

My point being just because an approach works (or fails) elsewhere doesn't mean the same would happen here


Can you give me an example where austerity has worked?

Greece, Spain and Portugal don't look too healthy do they?
In the UK, borrowing is going up, not down. People have committed suicide because they are at the end of their tether. The genuine needy are being penalised. Child poverty is rising. The IMF say austerity is the wrong route.


Germany, UK, Austria, Belgium and Finland.

 

johnfirewall Flag 16 May 13 5.59pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.38pm

Quote johnfirewall at 16 May 2013 5.32pm

Sorry, who's living in those houses?


People currently on housing waiting lists! People who need to downsize because of having the gall to have a spare room.

We are going to need more housing stock for the millions of Romanians on their way.

And it's paid for by money the government give them?

Net result we're up a bit of tax minus that not declared or legally avoided by sub-contractors minus pay to housing assocition directors as neither the goverment nor council can actually administer these schemes directly.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 May 13 6.07pm

Quote johnfirewall at 16 May 2013 5.59pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.38pm

Quote johnfirewall at 16 May 2013 5.32pm

Sorry, who's living in those houses?


People currently on housing waiting lists! People who need to downsize because of having the gall to have a spare room.

We are going to need more housing stock for the millions of Romanians on their way.

And it's paid for by money the government give them?

Net result we're up a bit of tax minus that not declared or legally avoided by sub-contractors minus pay to housing assocition directors as neither the goverment nor council can actually administer these schemes directly.

Why not? They're the government, they can pass legislation...

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 17 May 13 5.46am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.33pm

Instead of bailing out banks, the government could bail out those in debt. The banks would get money from repaid loans and many people would have a bit of disposable income again which they would spend thus getting the economy going again.


Erm, inflation would rise ramatically, to the extent that you would need a wheelbarrow of cash to buy a loaf of bread.

Which lefty website did you get your 'idea' in the above post from?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 17 May 13 9.42am

Quote nickgusset at 16 May 2013 5.33pm

Instead of bailing out banks, the government could bail out those in debt. The banks would get money from repaid loans and many people would have a bit of disposable income again which they would spend thus getting the economy going again.

Tell you what Nick, before you go spouting ridiculous ideas, perhaps you should get a (very) basic book on economics. This would end in mayhem and probably a barter system since our money would be so worthless. Dimwitted.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Page 3 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Effects of Austerity Cuts part 58