Qwijibo Bournemouth 07 Apr 14 11.25am |
|
|
Needs to get to the physical condition of Raheem Sterling. Proves you can be a youthful nippy winger amongst the big boys
|
silvertop Portishead 07 Apr 14 11.36am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Andy_G at 07 Apr 2014 11.19am
Good talent but way off the physical strength for Premier League at the moment. Whether he stays with us will depend on his wage demands, I think it's pretty clear that no big guns will be in for him yet. A good season with us in The prem would do him the world of good.
Is that because we haven't played him? Is TP playing a long game here? Depress his profile to reduce the number of summer takers to one i.e. CPFC?
[PS this is probably over-cynical/conspiracy theory/nonsense]
|
Mstrobez 07 Apr 14 11.45am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
We're the Arthur over ere!
|
silvertop Portishead 07 Apr 14 12.03pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Mstrobez at 07 Apr 2014 11.45am
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
To be fair to the negative posters, he was not signed on as an investment. You cannot apply the Joniesta argument for this one. The club paid £1m and a hefty wage bill for the privilege of having him on loan for only FOURTEEN games. We pay an additional £1m if we stay up; that's a lot if he is only considered good enough for 3 games. You do not pay those sorts of monies for a loanee unless he is capable of hitting the ground running from the off and carrying on that form to the end. While you may say he has repaid the money with the baggies game alone, it is not difficult to have some sympathy for those who think £2m plus a hefty wage for just one decent game - did we not deserve more?
For my part, I hope we get the points we need quickly so Ince can play the final 3/4 games with little risk to the club's future; that he shines bright; and we sign a superb player on a permanent basis who goes on to be a club legend.
|
paperhat croydon 07 Apr 14 12.43pm |
|
Quote silvertop at 07 Apr 2014 12.03pm
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Mstrobez at 07 Apr 2014 11.45am
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
To be fair to the negative posters, he was not signed on as an investment. You cannot apply the Joniesta argument for this one. The club paid £1m and a hefty wage bill for the privilege of having him on loan for only FOURTEEN games. We pay an additional £1m if we stay up; that's a lot if he is only considered good enough for 3 games. You do not pay those sorts of monies for a loanee unless he is capable of hitting the ground running from the off and carrying on that form to the end. While you may say he has repaid the money with the baggies game alone, it is not difficult to have some sympathy for those who think £2m plus a hefty wage for just one decent game - did we not deserve more?
For my part, I hope we get the points we need quickly so Ince can play the final 3/4 games with little risk to the club's future; that he shines bright; and we sign a superb player on a permanent basis who goes on to be a club legend.
may I ask, how do we know what we paid for Ince and what 'hefty' wage he's on?
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
Plane Bromley 07 Apr 14 1.16pm |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 05 Apr 2014 7.44pm
Quote miles18 at 05 Apr 2014 7.43pm
Quote TheLastDodo at 05 Apr 2014 7.40pm
s***. Just like his old man. He can fukc off at the season's end too. A pointless waste of space . Just like his old man. When the manager of the month came up.
How long before this troll gets banned? You're boring!
Yeah be he does have one of the more honest board names :-)
You get an understanding of why he is 'The last dildo'.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 07 Apr 14 1.21pm |
|
Quote Vaibow at 07 Apr 2014 12.29am
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
I thought it was great getting him and hoped he would be used as an impact sub - to step up and fight a relegation battle in a higher league is a big ask - but he had the hype to go with it.
It hasn't worked out, yet.. but let's be honest, look at Bolaise, KG, Gayle and even Williams at the start of this season - he needs game time.
It's a great learning curve though - hopefully he will learn to talk when spoken to and say what is required - he often spook highly of himself and told the 'lads he expects to be booed at swansea' no sh*t sherlock. He will hopefully learn to bulk up, earn his spot.
Having said that, he will probably go abroad
Maybe not for him, that he is NOT in the starting 11. However TP has him on the Bench. Its a team (squad) game. And since the January Transfer Window our team has improved. Give the lad a chance. Only been on the pitch 5 times FFS.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
paperhat croydon 07 Apr 14 1.22pm |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 07 Apr 2014 1.21pm
Quote Vaibow at 07 Apr 2014 12.29am
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
I thought it was great getting him and hoped he would be used as an impact sub - to step up and fight a relegation battle in a higher league is a big ask - but he had the hype to go with it.
It hasn't worked out, yet.. but let's be honest, look at Bolaise, KG, Gayle and even Williams at the start of this season - he needs game time.
It's a great learning curve though - hopefully he will learn to talk when spoken to and say what is required - he often spook highly of himself and told the 'lads he expects to be booed at swansea' no sh*t sherlock. He will hopefully learn to bulk up, earn his spot.
Having said that, he will probably go abroad
Maybe not for him, that he is NOT in the starting 11. However TP has him on the Bench. Its a team (squad) game. And since the January Transfer Window our team has improved. Give the lad a chance. Only been on the pitch 5 times FFS.
I think the question being asked is - If he's this good, homes comes he's only as good as a seat on the bench?
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
Plane Bromley 07 Apr 14 1.29pm |
|
Quote paperhat at 07 Apr 2014 12.43pm
Quote silvertop at 07 Apr 2014 12.03pm
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Mstrobez at 07 Apr 2014 11.45am
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
To be fair to the negative posters, he was not signed on as an investment. You cannot apply the Joniesta argument for this one. The club paid £1m and a hefty wage bill for the privilege of having him on loan for only FOURTEEN games. We pay an additional £1m if we stay up; that's a lot if he is only considered good enough for 3 games. You do not pay those sorts of monies for a loanee unless he is capable of hitting the ground running from the off and carrying on that form to the end. While you may say he has repaid the money with the baggies game alone, it is not difficult to have some sympathy for those who think £2m plus a hefty wage for just one decent game - did we not deserve more?
For my part, I hope we get the points we need quickly so Ince can play the final 3/4 games with little risk to the club's future; that he shines bright; and we sign a superb player on a permanent basis who goes on to be a club legend.
may I ask, how do we know what we paid for Ince and what 'hefty' wage he's on?
I'm not sure what silvertop is on about, he will be on the wage that was agreed in his contract with Blackpool, that's the rules. The rumours are that we paid a £1m loan fee and I've never heard anything about a additional £1m fee (paid to whom, I don't know)if we stay up. I did read that we are paying for his accommodation at Canary Wharf, which is fair enough.
|
Plane Bromley 07 Apr 14 1.32pm |
|
Quote paperhat at 07 Apr 2014 1.22pm
Quote alaneagle1 at 07 Apr 2014 1.21pm
Quote Vaibow at 07 Apr 2014 12.29am
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
I thought it was great getting him and hoped he would be used as an impact sub - to step up and fight a relegation battle in a higher league is a big ask - but he had the hype to go with it.
It hasn't worked out, yet.. but let's be honest, look at Bolaise, KG, Gayle and even Williams at the start of this season - he needs game time.
It's a great learning curve though - hopefully he will learn to talk when spoken to and say what is required - he often spook highly of himself and told the 'lads he expects to be booed at swansea' no sh*t sherlock. He will hopefully learn to bulk up, earn his spot.
Having said that, he will probably go abroad
Maybe not for him, that he is NOT in the starting 11. However TP has him on the Bench. Its a team (squad) game. And since the January Transfer Window our team has improved. Give the lad a chance. Only been on the pitch 5 times FFS.
I think the question being asked is - If he's this good, homes comes he's only as good as a seat on the bench?
Sorry to butt in a again. We need a squad of players to get us through to the end of the season, Ince is one of them.
|
silvertop Portishead 07 Apr 14 1.47pm |
|
Quote Plane at 07 Apr 2014 1.29pm
Quote paperhat at 07 Apr 2014 12.43pm
Quote silvertop at 07 Apr 2014 12.03pm
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Mstrobez at 07 Apr 2014 11.45am
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
To be fair to the negative posters, he was not signed on as an investment. You cannot apply the Joniesta argument for this one. The club paid £1m and a hefty wage bill for the privilege of having him on loan for only FOURTEEN games. We pay an additional £1m if we stay up; that's a lot if he is only considered good enough for 3 games. You do not pay those sorts of monies for a loanee unless he is capable of hitting the ground running from the off and carrying on that form to the end. While you may say he has repaid the money with the baggies game alone, it is not difficult to have some sympathy for those who think £2m plus a hefty wage for just one decent game - did we not deserve more?
For my part, I hope we get the points we need quickly so Ince can play the final 3/4 games with little risk to the club's future; that he shines bright; and we sign a superb player on a permanent basis who goes on to be a club legend.
may I ask, how do we know what we paid for Ince and what 'hefty' wage he's on?
I'm not sure what silvertop is on about, he will be on the wage that was agreed in his contract with Blackpool, that's the rules. The rumours are that we paid a £1m loan fee and I've never heard anything about a additional £1m fee (paid to whom, I don't know)if we stay up. I did read that we are paying for his accommodation at Canary Wharf, which is fair enough.
Have I accidentally walked into "Pedant's Corner"? Have you both missed the substantive point? Even if the additional £1m payment is wrong [sorry if so, I read that somewhere and accepted it as fact] paying a £1m premium for a loanee for only 14 games suggests that he should be of a standard to play all or the bulk of those 14 games - either starting or coming on as a scary impact sub. While I accept the need to rotate, that is not this manager's want. Had he been of the standard he was hyped up to be, he would have been one of those who play every week. He isn't; and hasn't been.
He has not been signed as one for the future [see the post I responded to] as he is only a loanee for less than half a season. Thus, comments like "give him a chance" are ones we can apply to Gayle and Joniesta; not Ince. Thus, people have a right to be disappointed.
However, if we took him on loan on the basis that he would either be sensational from day one or we would be better placed to pitch for him on a permanent deal while in situ, then the deal doesn't have the appearance of a flop.
|
TheLastDodo Rye 07 Apr 14 1.54pm |
|
Quote skatman at 05 Apr 2014 7.45pm
Quote TheLastDodo at 05 Apr 2014 7.40pm
s***. Just like his old man. He can fukc off at the season's end too. A pointless waste of space . Just like his old man. When the manager of the month came up.
You're in a good mood today aren't ya?
All you've done is av a moan like some some east end cockney apples and pears geeza.
Chill out mush.
In retrospect, I was probably a tad harsh. Just don't like anything to do with the name 'Ince' really. Don't trust it.
|
Plane Bromley 07 Apr 14 1.59pm |
|
Quote silvertop at 07 Apr 2014 1.47pm
Quote Plane at 07 Apr 2014 1.29pm
Quote paperhat at 07 Apr 2014 12.43pm
Quote silvertop at 07 Apr 2014 12.03pm
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Tom Ince' by Hambo
Quote Mstrobez at 07 Apr 2014 11.45am
He's started 3 games, one of which he was extremely impressive, how can anyone say whether or not he is ready etc? You don't know?
People are quick to right off players on this site - I spent the majority of the season backing Puncheon saying although a little frustrating at times, he has more quality then a lot of players in the squad, look at him now?
Tom Ince could be huge and you cannot judge someone on the base of 3 games.
Give the guy a chance ffs!
To be fair to the negative posters, he was not signed on as an investment. You cannot apply the Joniesta argument for this one. The club paid £1m and a hefty wage bill for the privilege of having him on loan for only FOURTEEN games. We pay an additional £1m if we stay up; that's a lot if he is only considered good enough for 3 games. You do not pay those sorts of monies for a loanee unless he is capable of hitting the ground running from the off and carrying on that form to the end. While you may say he has repaid the money with the baggies game alone, it is not difficult to have some sympathy for those who think £2m plus a hefty wage for just one decent game - did we not deserve more?
For my part, I hope we get the points we need quickly so Ince can play the final 3/4 games with little risk to the club's future; that he shines bright; and we sign a superb player on a permanent basis who goes on to be a club legend.
may I ask, how do we know what we paid for Ince and what 'hefty' wage he's on?
I'm not sure what silvertop is on about, he will be on the wage that was agreed in his contract with Blackpool, that's the rules. The rumours are that we paid a £1m loan fee and I've never heard anything about a additional £1m fee (paid to whom, I don't know)if we stay up. I did read that we are paying for his accommodation at Canary Wharf, which is fair enough.
Have I accidentally walked into "Pedant's Corner"? Have you both missed the substantive point? Even if the additional £1m payment is wrong [sorry if so, I read that somewhere and accepted it as fact] paying a £1m premium for a loanee for only 14 games suggests that he should be of a standard to play all or the bulk of those 14 games - either starting or coming on as a scary impact sub. While I accept the need to rotate, that is not this manager's want. Had he been of the standard he was hyped up to be, he would have been one of those who play every week. He isn't; and hasn't been.
He has not been signed as one for the future [see the post I responded to] as he is only a loanee for less than half a season. Thus, comments like "give him a chance" are ones we can apply to Gayle and Joniesta; not Ince. Thus, people have a right to be disappointed.
However, if we took him on loan on the basis that he would either be sensational from day one or we would be better placed to pitch for him on a permanent deal while in situ, then the deal doesn't have the appearance of a flop.
No but your facts are incorrect as I've pointed out which doesn't really substantiate your argument, as I said in a post above, it's a squad game and he has regularly featured in the squad, so he fulfilled the signing criteria.
IMO if he was to sign a contract with us next year, I'd like to see him here, a good prospect.
|
JonnyTheEagle Croydon 07 Apr 14 1.59pm |
|
|
I think that he might be better suited to next season when we can perhaps start off the season a bit more adventurous in style. Thing is, him being largely on the bench lately is doing us no harm whatsoever with our chances of signing him permanently.
I would think other potential suitors are now looking and thinking he's not good enough to start for us and perhaps losing interest as a result. If we're selling this loan move to Ince in the right way (e.g. to acclimatize him), then hopefully he'll have that in mind if we do decide to make a move with a permanent switch in the summer.
And as said by others, if that £1m has actually given us a chance to decide to miss out on an over-hyped player (if that what is deemed the case by the management come season end) then surely that is better than paying £10m-odd for a flop?
|
Mapletree Croydon 07 Apr 14 1.59pm |
|
Quote TheLastDodo at 07 Apr 2014 1.54pm
Quote skatman at 05 Apr 2014 7.45pm
Quote TheLastDodo at 05 Apr 2014 7.40pm
s***. Just like his old man. He can fukc off at the season's end too. A pointless waste of space . Just like his old man. When the manager of the month came up.
You're in a good mood today aren't ya?
All you've done is av a moan like some some east end cockney apples and pears geeza.
Chill out mush.
In retrospect, I was probably a tad harsh. Just don't like anything to do with the name 'Ince' really. Don't trust it.
Yeh, Tom came in on a princely sum but has failed to convince. He is too powderpuff and each time he gets tackled it makes me whince. Need to feed him up on spuds and mince.
|
TheLastDodo Rye 07 Apr 14 2.03pm |
|
Quote Mapletree at 07 Apr 2014 1.59pm
Quote TheLastDodo at 07 Apr 2014 1.54pm
Quote skatman at 05 Apr 2014 7.45pm
Quote TheLastDodo at 05 Apr 2014 7.40pm
s***. Just like his old man. He can fukc off at the season's end too. A pointless waste of space . Just like his old man. When the manager of the month came up.
You're in a good mood today aren't ya?
All you've done is av a moan like some some east end cockney apples and pears geeza.
Chill out mush.
In retrospect, I was probably a tad harsh. Just don't like anything to do with the name 'Ince' really. Don't trust it.
Yeh, Tom came in on a princely sum but has failed to convince. He is too powderpuff and each time he gets tackled it makes me whince. Need to feed him up on spuds and mince.
I was as pleased as punch as any Palace fan when we signed him but at the same time there was always this niggling little doubt. I think it's called Paul.
|
sxp55 South Norwood 07 Apr 14 2.05pm |
|
|
if we stay up one could argue that his performance against west brom was worth the 1m fee alone
@sxp55555
|
Plane Bromley 07 Apr 14 2.06pm |
|
Quote JonnyTheEagle at 07 Apr 2014 1.59pm
I think that he might be better suited to next season when we can perhaps start off the season a bit more adventurous in style. Thing is, him being largely on the bench lately is doing us no harm whatsoever with our chances of signing him permanently.
I would think other potential suitors are now looking and thinking he's not good enough to start for us and perhaps losing interest as a result. If we're selling this loan move to Ince in the right way (e.g. to acclimatize him), then hopefully he'll have that in mind if we do decide to make a move with a permanent switch in the summer.
And as said by others, if that £1m has actually given us a chance to decide to miss out on an over-hyped player (if that what is deemed the case by the management come season end) then surely that is better than paying £10m-odd for a flop?
Good post especially the bit in bold. Good business acumen from us 
|
TheLastDodo Rye 07 Apr 14 2.14pm |
|
Quote sxp55 at 07 Apr 2014 2.05pm
if we stay up one could argue that his performance against west brom was worth the 1m fee alone
But one could also say.... 'wadda waste!'
Edited by TheLastDodo (07 Apr 2014 2.15pm)
|
Harry Beever Newbury 07 Apr 14 2.16pm |
|
|
Is it just a coincidence that Puncheon's form and effort has picked up massively since Ince's arrival? With the goals he's scoring at the moment that would be worth the money even if Ince doesn't play for us again.
|